DIY replacing older threaded fork with unthreaded

Because of: 1. the economy and 2: a newer, lighter, more expensive bike won’t help me, I continue to do tris and time trials on my 1989 Klein Quantum. I had already replaced / upgraded everything on it, except the fork and headset. And, because I like the flexibility of unthreaded forks for different stems / angles / spacers, I decided to replace my threaded Klein steel fork with a 1" carbon fiber fork with aluminum steerer and FSA headset. As a side benefit, my Campy Chorus headset had pitted bearings that had to be replaced anyways. Note: This does not apply to a carbon steerer.

Here is what I did. Note: I have a bike stand. This job is a lot harder without one.

  1. Measure the current height of the top of the handlebar / base bar from the floor.
  2. Remove the current stem
  3. Unbolt the two headset nuts. There are special thin wrenches for this if you keep the old headset. If not, two pairs of channel lock pliers work fine.
  4. Unbolt the front caliper
  5. Remove the front wheel
  6. Remove the fork
  7. With a long punch (I used a 8" 1/2" diameter brass punch used by auto mechanics), punch the cups of the headset out by inserting the punch inside the head tube.
  8. Clean the inside of the head tube
  9. Install the new headset according to their directions. In my case, I tapped the new headset in with a rubber or plastic mallet. Do not use a steel hammer unless you tap on wood!
  10. Slide the fork into the headset and head tube
  11. Install the front wheel and lock
  12. Take bike off stand and place on ground
  13. Slide the new stem in place
  14. Slide the stem up and down so that the height where the handlebar contacts the stem, i.e., where the top of the handlebar would be, is the same height as in step 1. Lightly tighten the stem.
  15. Double check step 14.
  16. Triple check step 14.
  17. Mark the top of the stem. I used red.
  18. Recommended: Add 10 - 20mm of 1" spacers to provide flexibility later on.
  19. Mark the top of the spacer on the tube with a different marker. I used black.
  20. Tighten the stem, attach the handle bar / base bar, install the front caliper.
  21. Take the bike for a ride and see if you like the stem height.
  22. Put bike back on bike stand
  23. Remove handlebar / base bar
  24. Remove front caliper
  25. Remove front wheel.
  26. Loosen stem and remove. Hold onto tube so fork doesn’t fall out suddenly
  27. With a tubing cutter, cut tube 3mm below top mark (black)
  28. With a file or dremel tool, gently deburr the outside and inside of the tube.
  29. Clean metal filings out of tube.
  30. Install fork and hold in place
  31. Install front caliper
  32. Install front wheel
  33. Take bike off bike stand and put on floor
  34. Install a combination of spacers that you think will work to get the stem in place.
  35. Slide stem on
  36. If top of stem is below red mark, remove stem and add enough spacers so that top of stem is at red mark
    Note: I prefer to use as few spacers as possible, mainly for aesthetics
  37. Install star nut into top of tube. I used a small punch to keep it going in straight. This is a bit of a challenge. If you destroy the star nut, you can get a replacement at your LBS.
  38. Install spacers so that top of top spacer is 3 mm over top of tube. Top spacer must be 5mm or higher.
  39. Install cap and screw into star nut and tighten to headset torque spec. Note: The star nut just holds the stem in place until the stem is tightened and does not support any weight.
  40. Tighten stem to spec. I torqued stem to steering tube with 104 in-lbs and stem to handlebar with 87 in-lbs.

Done. Total time about 2 hours.

#9 - I fashioned myself a headset press with about a foot of 1/2" threaded rod, a couple of large nuts (locking for one end, regular for the “free” end), and a bunch of washers to form 2 stacks that taper from a little wider than the nuts to a little wider than the headset cups (for either 1" or 1-1/8"). Total cost at the hardware store was easily less than $10. Put several wraps of duct tape on the middle of the rod to “fill” the inner diam of the steerer and keep the rod well-centered/straight, and then just a couple crescent wrenches to operate. It’s already paid for itself several times over compared to getting cups pressed at a shop, and I think it does a smoother, less potentially damaging job than pounding the cups in w/ a mallet.

Why are you complicating things? Pull out the old. If you want to do it right - have an LBS face and ream the frame as well as face the fork. I would also have the LBS press in the cups and head race. DO NOT MARK ANYTHING - and DO NOT CUT ANYTHING. Install the HS top race and what ever spacers you feel you may want. If you have about 4" or so extra out the top cut that off. Then get it as tight as reasonable and fit the spacers and what not (while riding the bike). When you feel you are close cut the steer tube with about 2" extra out the top of the stem and leave it for a while. After a few weeks or riding and figuring out where you want the stem to sit cut off the extra from the top of the steer tube.