“One size fits all”
Dude, this is a post on an internet forum. I didn’t intend to explain how I do business across the board. KC asked a simple question and I gave a simple answer, as clearly as I could.
Over the years I’ve coached all manner of IM athletes: fast, slow, young, old, very old, skinny, fat, very fat, healthy, broke, semi-broke, mostly broke, you name it I’ve seen. All different and all handled a different way. But I’ve had pretty good results with that 2.5hr cap, as well as a focus on LOTS of other things, so…there you go. I’m hesitant to tell you that I don’t even prescribe many 2.5hr runs these days, more like lots and lots of 1:45-2hrs runs, some pretty tough, racked up over months. My mantra is that we can talk about all the neat and sexy ways to get faster and stronger on the run, but if we injury you, all the hard work is erased instantly. Success in the first year or two is often just showing up, everyday, every week, for months. Save the sexier/harder stuff for the off-season or year 2+.
Overdistance on the bike
Risk of injury through sitting on the bike longer is virtually zero. However, I have years of my own power data that show a steadily increasing FTP and decreasing bike splits under a short-ish/hard paradigm and flat FTP and flat splits under a Steady/over distance protocol. I’ve done multiple high triple digit days back to back and I got pretty good at sitting on a bike for a long time. Can’t say it made me faster. This observation is reflected in the histories people come to me with. 2yrs ago, you’d see 5-7hr rides from me. I’ve evolved, no more, but my people are working VERY hard for 4-5hrs with great results.
Ultra-marathoners
Different sport, different requirements, I don’t know anything about it other than it’s not an Ironman, they’re not also cycling and swimming, and I don’t want to do it
But I don’t think you’ll find too many professional Ironman coaches who prefer to have their athletes think in terms of distance rather than time.
In the end, I’m not interested in figuring out what works for a few sometimes, or for everyone all the time, but rather what works most of the time for most people and filling in the gaps with education and experience.