Difference between 2.5 hour run and 3.0

My longest run is 2h45 (18 miles or so)
The longest I run in a day is 2h50 (20 miles) split into somehting like 1h50/2h00 in the morning & then whatever during lunch time to make it to 2h50.
Other than that very very few 2H+ runs… However I try to run at least 5/sometimes 7 times per week. so I can spend time on the bike…
Run frequency is very important…

Cheers,
Fred

It appears that most advocates of running by time are faster runners. My first running coach was like that. Her plan called for the longest run to be 2.5 hours. The major difference was that she could finish a marathon in 2.5 hours, whereas I would be around 16-17 miles. Major difference IMO. If I had limited myself to the 2.5 hours as suggested I would have been woefully unprepared for those last 9-10 miles. My first 20 mile run was much more difficult mentally than it was physically. I did a progression of longer runs leading up to it and my body had adapted to the stress. The fast people seem to have the same physical stress when running a 20 in 2.5 hours as a slower person has doing the same distance in 3+ hours, but they equate a 3+ hours run with how they would feel if they ran that long rather than how they feel after doing the same mileage.

FWIW, the whole thing about not running over distance in training for a marathon may not be accurate IMO. In my area there are people regularly running in excess of 200 mpw. One of these guys set the course record in a local marathon last year and only going 26.2 must have seemed like a warmup run for him.

Doing an IM marathon is different than a stand alone race from what’s been said. IMO you should do several runs in the 20-22mile range regardless of how long they take. I know the more 20+ mile runs I’ve done, the easier they get, both physically and mentally. The body will adapt, just as it does for people like DK, and RAAM riders.

I ran the marathon at IMFL in 4:12, so about the same pace as you Kittycat. I did a longest run of 20 miles in training, which took me about 3 hours, and it was more of a psychological help than anything. Knowing I could do it. Just take it easy and stop halfway and stretch a bit.

Agree, personally I’d hate to face an IM run knowing my longest training run was less than 15 miles.

I appreciate what all of you are saying.
But man, i’m now so confused over all of this.

Think i’m starting to freak out a little bit…as i already feel behind in my long run, only up to 13 miles at this point–only halfway there!!! :frowning:

crap!

It seems to me that getting up to 13 miles is a lot harder than getting from 13 miles to a full marathon in a race. By the time you can run 13, you are already running long enough that your body is used to running after using up all the stored energy in your legs. So your body is using the systems it will be using on race day. Plus, if you decide to run 20 in training, that’s only 50% more than what you are already running, which really isn’t that much of a jump.

But, what’s really important is to get your bike mileage in. If you are whipped after the bike, you are going to have a lot of problems with the run no matter how much or how little running you have done. If you can finish your bike without too much effort, your running will be a lot better.

Don’t stress! Just plan it out so that you increase the distance a little each week, peaking out at 20 miles. I’ll PM my schedule (which worked well for IMFL).

KC,

I’ll put some more perspective to Rich’s advice for ya - I used his plans last year for IMLP and Kona.

On relatively “low” average weekly run volume (~28 mpw for the whole year, biggest run week was 50m), and longest run of about 2:33 (which for me was 22m), I knocked off a 3:24 run at LP and 3:29 at Kona.

(And no, I don’t have a running background or some massive base from prior years.)

I was sorely tempted to go the extra 4m on that 22m run so I could have done my first-ever marathon.
(I was feeling quite good, and zipping along comfortably, having built up from ~2hrs then ~2:12 in prior weeks)
But - I also had read numerous times here and elsewhere that more than 2:30 dramatically increases the recovery cost, w/ little to no adt’l trainning benefit, so I smartened up and “just” did the 22/2.5hrs.

You wanna get more bang for your buck on the long run? Run it harder.
You can nicely increase the training stress of the workout w/o extending it, by working in some faster segments.

i see what you’re saying. but you’re covering a hell of alot more mileage in 2:33 than i am. if you can rip out 26.2 in those times, you’re a much faster/better runner than i am.

if it takes me 4:15 or 4:30; then a 2.5 hour run is only half way there. you, on the other hand are 75% or more there.

hmmm…

I run 18 miles in 2.5 hrs, you run 15 miles. All our bodies really know is that we each ran 2.5hrs. Running longer than 2.5hrs significantly increases the recovery cost of the run session, inserting a great deal of unpredictability into your training week, particularly if that run is done the day following a long ride and at the start of another training week.

A bigger and safer bang for your buck is to add a little harder work to existing runs, including your long run, and to run more frequently. Advice framed within the context of a standalone marathon should be immediately discounted. You’re not training for a marathon, you’re training for an Ironman. You have a LOT more going on than the typical marathon athlete. One delta I see between quality coaches and self-coached athletes is that while the athlete is concerned with the details of individual training sessions, the coach is much more concerned with how Monday flows into Tues into Wed and so on through the week, through the month, through the season. I believe you’re looking at the tree, not the forest :slight_smile:

Will running 3hrs and successfully integrating that into your training week improve your chances of a good run on race day? I suppose. However, at some point I think you will realize that 2.5hrs “is good enough.” If you listen to people with a coached data sample of > 1, VERY few of these people are prescribing runs longer than 2.5hrs and most are using creative ways to accomplish much the same thing in less stressful and risky ways.


i can run 60 minutes repeatedly, but put it to 70 and the ITB acts up, etc etc etc

I know it’s taboo, but you might try the run/walk method. Maybe start with a 3’ on / 2’ off and work up to a 9’ on / 1’ off.

That’s what I do when I want to increase my long run (and I throw the 10% rule out the window), and I’m also creaky once past 60’.

Joanne–I am a MUCH slower runner than you and the longest training runs I do prior to an IM are 2.5 hours. I did so some trail races prior to IM Brasil that look longer than 2.5 hours, but they were pretty hilly so there was walking involved.

I’d listen to what Rich says.

clm

Hi Kittycat

Rich Strauss has excellent credentials for giving advice. I would put a lot of faith in his advice. (certainly ahead of my own advice) but here goes anyway…

One of my main rules for training is to avoid injury. Long runs are high risk injury wise, so like Rich (and others with tons of experience like Dev Paul) say, cap your long runs at 2.5 hours. Yes the run at an IM is going to take you a lot longer than that, but one of the most important things you can do is get to the start line without any nagging injuries. By nature, most of us in this sport are people who like to push ourselves hard in training and racing. We often feel that we are not doing as much as we should be. I think one of the best things a good coach does for people like us is to tell us not to do too much.

Good luck with your training and racing. I look forward to reading your race report.

“difference between 2.5 hour run and 3.0”

30 minutes, why so much discussion???

Your approach to running seems to be “one size fits all” irrespective of the pace a person can maintain. Interesting. Do you also tell people to not do a ride longer than 5 hours or a swim longer than an hour? So what if those times would leave a person significantly short of preparing for the DISTANCE to be raced?

Why is that people can train over-distance for the swim and the bike - and even the run for a HIM - but when it comes to training for a marathon all of a sudden going that distance puts too much of a strain on the body? It’s a total wonder how the ultra runners ever get through a 100 mile race when people would be telling them to never run more than 2.5 hours. The body will adapt to longer mileage running just the same as it does to swimming longer than race distance or biking 120+ miles.

KC, I remember just a few years ago when I first started running how far even a 5K seemed. Now that I’ve done a few marathons just doing a 3 mile run doesn’t even seem to get me warmed up. The more mileage you get on your legs, the easier it will become. Now that you’re up to 13 miles, the 3-5 mile runs likely seem easy. When you get up to 15-18 miles, the 10-12 milers will seem easy. Your body will need to go the DISTANCE during the race. If you only train by time you could be training your body to only keep going for a certain time and the DISTANCE after that may be very painful.

What would be helpful is if you could find out what other IM marathoners who ran around 4:30 did for training.

The longest training run I’ve ever done specifically for IM was 2:30. My two IM run splits are 4:17 and 3:52.

Hi Kitty,
I think Rich nailed it. Just to add to what he said, I have a RW from 1993 where they profiled Mark Allen. The gist of the article was how does someone who balances 4 sports (S/B/R and weights) manage to run faster in an IM at age 35 than 99% of all marathon runners who “only” run. I’ll never forget The Grip’s response. He said every Sunday he went out and ran 3 hours by himself at what he called an even pace. He stressed that he didn’t feel as if he derived any physical benefit from this workout rather he contested that, for him, it was purely mental training because he proved to himself on a weekly basis that when his body was fatigued and he wanted to stop his mind could “will” his body to keep going.

I’d listen to Rich…he knows a thing or two about a thing or two.

“One size fits all”
Dude, this is a post on an internet forum. I didn’t intend to explain how I do business across the board. KC asked a simple question and I gave a simple answer, as clearly as I could.

Over the years I’ve coached all manner of IM athletes: fast, slow, young, old, very old, skinny, fat, very fat, healthy, broke, semi-broke, mostly broke, you name it I’ve seen. All different and all handled a different way. But I’ve had pretty good results with that 2.5hr cap, as well as a focus on LOTS of other things, so…there you go. I’m hesitant to tell you that I don’t even prescribe many 2.5hr runs these days, more like lots and lots of 1:45-2hrs runs, some pretty tough, racked up over months. My mantra is that we can talk about all the neat and sexy ways to get faster and stronger on the run, but if we injury you, all the hard work is erased instantly. Success in the first year or two is often just showing up, everyday, every week, for months. Save the sexier/harder stuff for the off-season or year 2+.

Overdistance on the bike
Risk of injury through sitting on the bike longer is virtually zero. However, I have years of my own power data that show a steadily increasing FTP and decreasing bike splits under a short-ish/hard paradigm and flat FTP and flat splits under a Steady/over distance protocol. I’ve done multiple high triple digit days back to back and I got pretty good at sitting on a bike for a long time. Can’t say it made me faster. This observation is reflected in the histories people come to me with. 2yrs ago, you’d see 5-7hr rides from me. I’ve evolved, no more, but my people are working VERY hard for 4-5hrs with great results.

Ultra-marathoners
Different sport, different requirements, I don’t know anything about it other than it’s not an Ironman, they’re not also cycling and swimming, and I don’t want to do it :slight_smile: But I don’t think you’ll find too many professional Ironman coaches who prefer to have their athletes think in terms of distance rather than time.

In the end, I’m not interested in figuring out what works for a few sometimes, or for everyone all the time, but rather what works most of the time for most people and filling in the gaps with education and experience.


ok, Rich, at this point i’m just going to listen to you and unplug from this as otherwise i’ll just continue to feel uneasy (ie, the paradox of choice would apply for me in this thread!).

in the past i learned to “just trust the plan”, and leave it at that. so, this is what i’m going to do here and trust what you say. my long run will not exceed 2.5 hours; and i’ll focus on frequency as you’ve suggested.

clm, thanks for your post, that helps me with perspective on this topic and gives me even more reassurance that this is the right approach and it will work for me.

lastly, Rich, i agree about big picture, and thinking about how the days flow into one another. thanks for mentioning that philosophy, it really registers.

Hey Kittycat, FWIW, I like the idea of getting in a few 3 hour runs, but what works really well for me is to do 2:30 early sunday morning usually about 18 miles, then in the evening, I do another 30 minutes, the thing is, I feel so loose and warm after that morning run that I find myself going pretty fast on the second run, it seems to be really effective for me, you could try something like that. Also, I pretty much do all my long runs like that weather its 1.5,2.0,2.5, or 3.0 hours, I cut the am run short my 30 mins and do more of a tempo run that evening.