Right now I have 3 bike setups that all have different computers and features (Road, Tri, TT). All of them currently are running front-fork mounted speed sensors, which will not work on the trainer, so I usually end up on the rollers for my indoor training. Rollers are great for a lot of things, but riding for hours at a time isn’t one of them. Only one has cadence, and that is definitely a sticking point for me.
So, I would like some input on rear-wheel sensor capable wireless computers with wireless cadence. Major points for anything that will mount on the stem. If not, I will figure out a way, but not having to hack this would be preferable.
I currently have a Polar 200CAD that works alright (very finicky about magnet position and distance), but only runs on the front wheel. It’s also difficult to replace the batteries in the speed/cadence units. On the plus side, it has HR. I think I will keep this computer and move it to my road bike. I usually don’t ride it on the trainer anyway. So basically I need 2 new computers or 1 new computer and an extra mount kit.
So far on my list are the:
Cateye CD300DW (single transmitter)
Vetta VL110 T2X (single transmitter)
SigmaSport Topline BC 1606L
VDO C3 DS Wireless
I know the Cateye works from the off-side rear stay, but I don’t have any documentation on the Sigma. Does anyone else know of other computers that have these functions? Multi-bike kits are a plus too.
I had the cateye you mention and liked it, but the wireless sensor broke when I was dismounting with shoes on pedals…keep that in mind.
Have you considered the step up to the garmin forerunner 305? It is more expensive of course, but it has all the tri features you want and it has the option of adding the wireless speed/cadence unit. You can get the whole package for a reasonable price on ebay and then you can have all your training/log info on one machine. I like it at least…unless you are a pure roadie. Polar also has some nice wireless computers, although I haven’t researched all the features/models.
Before I got half way through I was going to also recommend the Garmin edge 305 that I will be using this year, but it will be of no value on the trainer. My wife has been using the Cateye 300dw for about a year and a half with no problems. All I can tell you is that she really likes it. No real experiences with other rr wheel wireless.
Thanks to both of you for the Garmin recommendation. I really do love the unit and will probably purchase one for my primary road bike in the future because I never ride it on the trainer (who wants to ride a trainer without aerobars?) What I am looking for now is just rear-wheel-located speed/cadence for my Tri and TT bikes for indoor (as well as outdoor) training.
I have read up on everything I can find about the various units. It looks to me like the Sigma is fork-mount only from their online manual, but there are no distance-from-headunit specifications that I can find.
So far the Cateye seems to be in the lead, though I don’t know if it is stem-mountable. This really is a must for me, as my aerobars are mounted very narrow. I can also get a full unit + additional bike kit for $150 or so, which isn’t terrible.
Does anyone have additional information about the Garmin GSC10 Speed/Cadence pickup?
I’ve seen several places refer to this as a Speed AND Cadence pickup, but they are not very clear. Can this additional unit be used to access the speed functions on an indoor trainer?
The garmin GSC 10 is what you want. For 40 bucks on ebay you can get more than one and spend less than the whole cateye computer…assuming you have the garmin (I got the impression you already have the garmin, so I’d just stick with it)
No, don’t have a Garmin yet, but I would be willing to put down the $300 total for two bike setups and a head unit. I just read the manual and Garmin seems to think it will do speed and cadence, so that’s a good sign. This would probably be double the cost of the CatEye setup, so I will have to weigh it all carefully.
The Garmin speed and cadence unit always transmits cadence and the speed unit is used when there is no GPS signal. For using on the trainer you just turn off the GPS (under settings, general) and it works like any wireless bike computer. But of course you have all the other Garmin benefits when using it outside with the GPS turned back on.
I REALLY like the sound of the Garmin, but monetarily it’s hard to justify. I finally found that the VDO C3 double wireless can do everything I want (stem mountable, rear-wheel speed pickup), and it’s pretty cheap. I could get three of these for the price of one Garmin and not really feel like I was losing out in functionality. The truth is that I usually just go out and hammer the same 2-3 courses and I already know where the time checks are and the speeds I need to maintain to hit them depending on wind conditions.
It pains me to say it, but the Garmin would probably just be another 2 watts worth of drag that I don’t need.
Thanks for the input everyone, I definitely understand how awesome the Garmin is now.
Yes it will. The Garmin Edge 305 (with cadence) picks up it’s cadence from the wireless sensor on the chainstay and it’s speed from the GPS as it’s primary default. But, if it can’t find satellites after a little bit, it will give up and pick up speed from the chainstay sensor instead.
I can’t give you specifics about the unit you’re looking at, but I can tell you that I have a Cateye on my road bike which is mounted on my stem. The mount has a soft curved bottom and goes on with a pretty much infinitely adjustable cable ties. Assuming they use the same (or similar) mount for all their units, mounting on a stem shouldn’t be a problem.
Edit: My apologies, I completely blew it on the above post. The mount I was looking at when I wrote this was actually my Garmin Edge mount - not the Cateye. The Cateye mount doesn’t mount with cable ties. I’m not sure if the band is log enough to go around a stem or not. It looks like it probably is, but I can’t be sure without taking it off. Sorry about that.
Interesting, that. Back to the manual downloading I guess. That is actually the cheapest option I have found, with a single head unit at around $100, and additional bike mounts only $50.
If the stem mount is all that is holding you up, why not just use something like the Profile computer mount. If it is a really tight cockpit I have also set up using the BLT Space Shuttle.
I just quickly took off my Cateye mount and looked at it. Yes, the integrated band is long enough to go around a typical stem, but it isn’t rotate-able, so the computer would be sideways if it were on the stem. Again, this is a wired Cateye Astrale (about a month old), so I’m not certain it has the same mount as the model you’re looking at. But it’s likely close.
For what it’s worth, this exercise has made me appricate the mount that comes with the Garmin Edge. It’s a great little feat of engineering that is rotate-able 270 degrees and adjustable to virtually any bar diameter. Nice little mount they’ve come up with.
I run a front bottle and am VERY aero-weenied out, so running a computer out on the bars somewhere is both difficult to deal with (because of the bottle), and costly because it’s out in the wind (because of the way it’s mounted).
Geez, I’m a picky bastard it seems.
Pretty sure the Cateye DW model doesn’t mount on the stem.
Basically I am down to two models that meet all the specs, the Garmin Edge 305 and the VDO C3.
Assuming I didn’t miss something, you could go for the Garmin Forerunner 305 (there’s a bike mount on the way), the screen isn’t as big as the Edge and you can’t look at as much data at once but you can run with it…
I am wearing mine on the bike a lot these days and might give up on my regular computer soon.
I get massive shoulder aches with anything more than a lightweight watch on my arm. I can’t even wear several different HRMs that are on the market. Broke both of my collar bones earlier in my life and now I have some trouble with fatigue in those areas.
I get massive shoulder aches with anything more than a lightweight watch on my arm. I can’t even wear several different HRMs that are on the market. Broke both of my collar bones earlier in my life and now I have some trouble with fatigue in those areas.
Geez, and I was going to offer to sell you this rolex…
Seriously, wearing a heavy watch hurts but you can do tris?
Yeah, I don’t understand it either. I get a lot of aches in what feels like the center of my clavicle. Most of them are on the left which has been broken 4 times, but sometimes on the right which was only broken twice. No issues from cycling or swimming, just running with additional weight on my arms (mp3 player, heavy watch, etc.)