Cycling Categories v's IM Bike Performance

After reading the post on the USCF cat’s, it got me wondering what level of IM bike performance we could expect from each respective cycling category, i.e. Would Norman Stadler beat most Cat 1 racers? And for those who race both IM’s and bike races, what kind of time does a typical Cat 1,2,3,4 cyclist achieve in an IM bike leg? Just curious.

Thanks,

Alan

IMHO not comparable, different events (rr/tt/crits v sprint/oly/half/im) in each sport require different physical make up to be really competitive, let alone the fundamental difference in the sports themselves (road racing with no running v tri where a run is required )
.

The local sprint tri hotshots would place pretty poorly in a stand alone TT against USCF racers… And when it came time to wind it up for a road race sprint (let alone a crit final lap), most of them would be so far back in the dust it wouldn’t even be funny, even in a cat 4 race.

Yes, if one didn’t change his/her training - but if a sprint tri hotshot (or IM-distance stud) focused on cycling alone, I would bet they could hold their own. Maybe not win, but put out a respectable performance.

Really? Sprint dudes who can average 27 mph or so really wouldn’t rate? I thought I saw something with the Cat listings that 27 mph for a 20km TT got you into the Cat 3 range? (maybe it’s on the Fiesta Island series site?). I know when I rode a 1:04 at Mrs. T’s a few years back, that while I got destroyed by many in that race (triathlon), I could pretty much hold me on (during a time trial) vs. some of my roadie pals (although they were mostly Cat 5, a couple were Cat 4’s).

Does somebody have a breakdown on this?

Just as the argument of Normann vs. Lance/Tyler, riding in an IM is quite a different beast. There just aren’t TT’s that are typically that long.

Yes, 27 would get a decent top 20 or so cat 3 around here, but in the 1’s and 2’s it would be… There’s some really fast 4’s as well. Just saying that the top speeds I see in the tri races in this area wouldn’t make it in the TT’s.

A good triathlete cyclist can do just fine up to about Cat 3 (at least around here). We have lots of triathletes that road race, and they do fine. Mostly mid-pack fodder though as we (or at least I) can’t sprint worth a damn, and that is where it is at in road racing. Can have a 90 min to 2 hour road race, finish 8 secs behind the leader, and get 12th place out of 30. Bummer. That’s OK - like flip turns, breastroke and butterfly at Masters swimming, it makes you better in cycling overall and able to recover fast from hills, surges, etc.

Cat 1/2 is another thing entirely as team tactics are paramount in addition to overall cycling “skills”. Again, Norman can cycle 27 mph for 112 miles (!), but not be able to hit 35 mph over and over, then sprint to 42 mph and loose. Who knows - very different skill sets. Maybe he could.

Chris Lieto finished 9th GC at Tour de Utah; Normann put a few minutes into him at Kona.

A triathlete generally has the skills to do well at stage races, where it’s based on time differentials rather than placings. TT’s and hillclimbs are what tend to win those races (gee, where have we seen THAT before?).