You need more than 4k/week in drills alone. In the offseason last year I tried to swim about 10,000 - 12,000 total yards/week. About 40% of those yards are dedicated to drilling, 1 entire session is technique. I swim with a masters team and each workout has a purpose. Last year my fastest OLY time was 32 minutes, this it was 24. Around here that is pretty much the front of the pack. I only wish I could get that kind of return on my running!! I can’t even do flip turns and the only other stroke I know is backstroke and its bad…real bad. Point being it doesn’t take much to be an effective swimmer in triathlon. But money is no substitute for actually swimming. Suck it up and get in the pool.
I second what STP said - your pull is really wide. Instead of simply putting your hand in the water and pulling directly through you want to make a “Z” with your hands in that your hand comes into the midline of your body (but not across it) and then goes back out along your hip. An old coach had us keep our thumbs sticking out in practice so that we could feel our hip on the final part of our stroke. This is actually the most powerful part of the pull and with as wide as your stroke is you’re missing a lot of power. Not so easy to explain over the internet but check out the youtube video and see if you can get an elite swimmer in your pool or coach to work with you a little bit on firming up your pull.
Also, though it’s tough to tell from the video, it looks like your wrists are breaking on the pull. By that I mean, your wrists should never bend during the pull and yours appear that they are (but the video is bad so not sure).
Lastly, don’t worry about what your arms are doing outside of the water. When your arms are up in the air they are doing nothing to help propel you forward. Focus on what they are doing when you’re in the water!
Personally, I’d steer clear of USAT certified coaches that claim to be swim coaches. I’ve talked with numerous USAT coaches through the years and the one thing that sticks out in my mind is that being USAT certified is no guarantee that they have a clue how to coach triathletes much less fix swim strokes.
I’d look at the USS swimming US Masters homepages to find a swim coach. Unless the USAT coach was a former swim coach, I’d personally run (fast) in the opposite direction.
The other thing I’ve noticed about triathletes, they think one swim lesson cures all. Swimming is not like a bike fit, toss them up change a few things and tighten the screws to hold the bars, seat and seatpost in place. Swimming is dynamic and takes a bit of time (not to mention lots of work)
You need more than 4k/week in drills alone. In the offseason last year I tried to swim about 10,000 - 12,000 total yards/week. About 40% of those yards are dedicated to drilling, 1 entire session is technique. I swim with a masters team and each workout has a purpose. Last year my fastest OLY time was 32 minutes, this it was 24. Around here that is pretty much the front of the pack. I only wish I could get that kind of return on my running!! I can’t even do flip turns and the only other stroke I know is backstroke and its bad…real bad. Point being it doesn’t take much to be an effective swimmer in triathlon. But money is no substitute for actually swimming. Suck it up and get in the pool.
No, I meant 4 TIMES per week, not 4K! 4 workouts x 3500y = 14K yards (though I average more like 8-10K/wk because of various traffic, work, etc., issues).
it looks like your wrists are breaking on the pull.
One much more so then the other. I think L is worse then right, but I’ll wait until I get the dvd in the mail.
Also, though it’s tough to tell from the video, it looks like your wrists are breaking on the pull. By that I mean, your wrists should never bend during the pull and yours appear that they are (but the video is bad so not sure).
Good eye. Yes, they break, starting about 1/3 of the way through the pull. My guess is that’s my subconscious attempt at holding more water or tricking myself into feeling that my elbow hasn’t dropped.
That’s pretty cool from you sharing your video here, be patient and listen to good certified coaches and you’ll be swimming fast in no time ![]()
Looks like many people are missing the point here…
Any decent swim coach knows this. The key to effortless, gliding " downhill" swimming is body positioning. The joyfull art of floating on water in a very aqua-dynamic position (parallel to surface) with almost no effort. That’s the 20% of swimming that gives you 80% of the speed!
My recommendations;
1.- Totally disregard any advice on propulsion (your stroke). It is irrelevant and ddistracting to try to work on stroke form when your body is not in the right position.
2.- Focus 100% on balance and drag reduction drills. You are getting very good tips on this (pressing the T, lowering your head, etc)
Just try to swim very easy, use fins if necessary and get that body/balance/position right. You goal is to be able to swim a 100mts in 1:45 just gliding with a very easy aerobic effort. Once you are there, then you can start working on propulsion
Have fun!
F’ing priceless…
sorry I misread…that’s enough yardage to improve, can’t believe there aren’t any good coaches near you.
would you consider traveling for a clinic? I can recommend someone that can probably really help, send me a PM.
Also, though it’s tough to tell from the video, it looks like your wrists are breaking on the pull. By that I mean, your wrists should never bend during the pull and yours appear that they are (but the video is bad so not sure).
help me understand about the wrists never bending, i thought that was how the hand became a “paddle” ???
F’ing priceless…
Now, Paulo, why can’t YOU have valuable input like that?! If only I’d known it could be so easly all along, and you’ve been holding out on me. ![]()
The hand+forearm should be your paddle. I’m not a big fan of seeing any wrist flexion either.
This site’s vid quality is a little clearer (though it appears it’s been clear enough to generate good comments). Thanks to all so far.
So much for coaches, eh? Even a 2-bit hack such as myself can see you don’t have any “catch” to speak of - you’re pulling with your elbow. Just fixing that will get you to 1:30.
You mention something about bad shoulders? Dropping your elbow like that is one way of protecting the shoulder, in my experience at least (bad tendinitis in my right shoulder). Might need some work there.
http://www.cruciblefitness.com/etips/Catch.htm
**Illustration of Proper Catch** Stick your left arm out directly in front of you, arm parallel to the table, palm down. Now bend your left elbow (without moving your upper arm), and touch your left finger tips to the desk in front of you. Your forearm is probably at a 45 degree angle from your upper arm. Notice three things: Your elbow is high and has not moved significantly. Your elbow is directly above or on top of your hand (sort of, you get the idea). Your "paddle" essentially includes your hand AND your forearm. This is very important. With your fingers still on the desk and elbow up high, now just let your elbow drop. This is referred to as a poor catch, dropping the elbow, slipping the front of your stroke, etc. Two things to notice here: Your elbow is leading your hand, as you pull. You have lost your forearm as a paddle.
I thought one his points was very good, body position is key… and i think you need to master that before you can think about propulsion… but also swimming hard/often is key to the whole process too!
(…) body position is key… and i think you need to master that before you can think about propulsion (…)
Why?
Of course you know why he said that but I’ll bite anyway. It comes from the TI school of thought - learn to balance in the water first, otherwise your propulsion is going to be used to correct your body position (like Aztec pushing down on the water instead of back) - and that ain’t economical (or efficient, I forget which). Then you combine that with the fact that us post-teens don’t pick up new movements very quickly/well (see any golf course driving range for examples) - so we need to take one thing at a time and work on it.
Not that I agree/disagree with any of it. Joey says “hey”.
I know all that about TI… but why should body position come before propulsion? Because Terry says so?
How’s Kim?
While my body position isn’t great, it’s also not terrible. I spent a lot of time on position awhile back, and mostly what happened (and happens) is that my upper half just goes lower. Note that although low in the water, I’m pretty close to level. Try that at 1:45 pace, brother! When I swim faster, say <:45 for 50y, I rise a bit in the water (of course).
What I’m really trying to say is that body position alone isn’t going to help, I need to swim faster to make use of it. But with all of the other flaws I have, I obviously can’t swim faster (well, not for long, that is!).
So body position is secondary (and will work itself out), fixing the propulsion stuff is primary.
i am by no means an expert but for 12 weeks last winter in put on zoomers and swam 10-12000 yards per week. as a result of swimming much faster because of the fins i could really feel that my arms were not participating very much. so when i took the fins off, my arms had sped up because they had to when using the fins. j kenny sells them with a 20 % discount and it did make a difference for me. good luck