I would
I spent the first 30 min of my ride tonight pissed as my 55mm lens cap
that is reported to be a solution just kept leaking h2o all over.
There is no way I’m putting anything but h2o in there because of the sticky problem.
I would
I spent the first 30 min of my ride tonight pissed as my 55mm lens cap
that is reported to be a solution just kept leaking h2o all over.
There is no way I’m putting anything but h2o in there because of the sticky problem.
I bought a styrofoam cone at an art supply store. Cut down the foam to the diameter that fit the hole and loop a couple of rubber bands over the top to keep it in place. Works great.
I’d buy one. Tried a 55mm lens cap and it popped right off at the first bump. A Jetstream bottle sponge works better but I still lose fluid if I fill the bottle up close to the top.
you’re exactly right; been using one last couple of years myself…
Steve B. suggested this a while back.
Here’s mine:

Notes:
You have to trim down the bottle 1/8" to make it large enough for the lid.
You can add a tether to the lid so it won’t get lost.
Silicone glue sucks for this – try two screws through the bottle near the opening.
A lid for these would be amazing for short races, but Im not goonna lie I loved the spnge in long course cause I just fill that baby up.
WOOOO
I use the same thing, after your design I believe. I tethered it with a needle and fishing line. No problems so far.
I stick the straw through part of the OEM sponge inside the bottle. Sponge stays put. I can pour through it, or yank it out and it stays tethered.
If you were going to make a cap, could you make it in a funnel shape? That way you could still just pour into it to refill but I don’t think it would splash much at all because the splashed fluid would be to the sides of the funnel and not in the middle where the hole is. Hope that made sense.
I’d just use the NXT Jetstream bottle instead. The Profile ones kept cracking on me, so I switched and have no problems with splashing from the Jetstream, even with the water right at the top of the sponge.
My bike shop refitted me (aero bar length shortened) and with my Profile knub and bike computer on my handlebars my profile bottle will not fit (even with a bracket) without hitting the computer.
The bike shop said to put the bottle between the bars and rest the “rear end” on the stem (maybe use 2-sided tape to hold it).
Anyone do this?
I use a largish spongey thingy that I got at a grocery store for $1.xx (after a suggestion here on ST). (Is is a pot scrubber? synthetic loofa?) Whatever it is, it works great in the Profile bottle! You really have to cram it into the bottle. Fits tightly, no splashing, easy to refill.
I did this a few years ago. I still use more or less the same system. It works well, but the rubber bands dry rot after a few months.
It doesn’t lend itself well to cleaning either.
Based on the various creative solutions to this problem, I think this thing would be worth developing. I’ll make a simple cap that snaps securely to the bottle and has a plastic retention strap that snaps in the extra straw hole. It should be fairly simple to open and refill on the go and would certainly solve the splash problem. I hope to have parts by Aug 26th for the Chicago tri. I’ll post again when it’s completed. I’ll probably ebay them for $5 plus USPS shipping since selling things on forums is a no no…
Don’t take this the wrong way and I hope you can make a little money with this, but if you make a commercially viable solution aren’t you just doing R&D for Profile. Unless they are totally asleep at the wheel, well maybe they are judging by the number of complaints without a resolution, Profile more than likely could manufacture a similar system and just include it with the bottle.
I don’t understand why any of them can’t use something like the flip top lids on cheap water bottles. It doesn’t have to be rocket surgery, just a plastic top with small thumb tab and a retention ring.
To answer your original question…
Sure, I’d buy one just because I’m always looking for a “better” solution for everything. ![]()
I’d be cautious about investing big bucks in tooling, though. You’re at the mercy of Profile. They might obsolete their bottle and come out with a new one with a different opening and/or better lid at any moment. (Their spys are probably watching this thread right now…)
I’ll make a simple cap that snaps securely to the bottle…
How will it snap on? There are no ridges to snap onto…the rim is smooth.
I’d buy one.
What I’d also like is an aero bottle made from the nalgene material; I hate the taste of plastic and I can’t help but think that it’s adding to the chemical load in our bodies.
And, …no logos, please.
MOP Mike showed a good example of the idea that I crafted for my two Profile bottles. I don’t know where he found that cool red lid; mine are beige. If your proposed product had been available I’d definitely have bought one or two. I only created mine because of a vacuum in the market. I’d still buy yours if you can improve on the Rubbermaid version. Here’s what I’d do if I were designing and manufacturing from scratch:
If you make a primitive, rubber-snugged product, $5 is probably about the right price. If you can design in some valuable features, you could probably charge up to $10. But Profile could orphan you tomorrow.
Good luck!
Sign me up for one.
Steve