I just purchased from bikeparts.com a pair of chainrings made by FSA 50 AND 38 teeth. This is ample for “ANY” hill that ive ever seen in 15 years of cycling. Also the 50 gives me less crossover when in just training. The only problem that I see is runnung out of gears on some decents.
Not everybody is as powerful and fit as you are. Cyclists come in all shapes and sizes and skill levels. If one person does a particular climb at 250 watts in a 39x21, why should the 175 watt cyclist climb in the same gearing? 30% less power requires 30% lower gearing to have the same cadence and RPE.
While I too can climb “ANY” hill in a 39x21, I choose to climb long hills in triathlons in lower gearing. I have a 34 small ring on my bikes (and I tend to ride in the top 12-15% of my AG).
Easy to say when you don’t say what cassette you use or what climbs you ride. 38x36: probably enough for any climb, but huge jumps between gears; 38x21: I don’t think so since there are climbs even pros need a 25 on.
The idea is to be able to spin up hills if you so desire. Sure you can get up the big hills in bigger gears, but you will use a low cadence and probably get up out of the saddle.
I want to get out of the saddle when I want to, not when I have to.
A 50/34 compact with 11/23 cassette also gives you a closer ratio range than does a standard size.
As for the hills the 34 allows you to spin better which is great for people like me who are natural spinners. It might be less of an issue for the mashers.
You’re not likely to spin out a 50 x 11 unless going down a pretty steep hill. And if you’re going that fast you’re better off to tuck aero and coast.
I switched to compacts last year and will never go back.
Easy to say when you don’t say what cassette you use or what climbs you ride. 38x36: probably enough for any climb, but huge jumps between gears; 38x21: I don’t think so since there are climbs even pros need a 25 on.
Im using a 12-23.
Easy to say when you don’t say what cassette you use or what climbs you ride. 38x36: probably enough for any climb, but huge jumps between gears; 38x21: I don’t think so since there are climbs even pros need a 25 on.
Im using a 12-23.
If that’s the case, you probably aren’t riding serious climbs. 50x12 isn’t desirable in the mountains. Where do you do put your base work in?
Easy to say when you don’t say what cassette you use or what climbs you ride. 38x36: probably enough for any climb, but huge jumps between gears; 38x21: I don’t think so since there are climbs even pros need a 25 on.
36?! I don’t think anyone makes a cassette larger than 34 tooth.
I started using compacts this past off season and continue to do so despite, if I dont say so myself, I am a strong climber.
My main reason is that it gives me options. For most of the time I run a 50/38 on the front with a 11-23 rear, that is good enough for most rides. If I ride Mt Humboldt locally (4 miles at an average of 12% grade) then I have the option of putting on the 34 and then I have a low enough gear without having to resort to a 12-27 on the back (which shifts terribly with a standard derailleur). With a compact you can run non compact gears such as a 52/38, but with a non compact you cant run anything smaller than a 38. Like I said, it is options.