Today I rode first time my Karbona TT bike with carbon wheels 8 cm rim and Oval handlebar: very very beatiful bike BUT after riding every day my madone I felt wery hard to climg the 11 km with 690 meters ramp here in Chile. I mean, I use to use 39/19 for the hardest part with the madone. Today I had to use 39/23 with the TT bike for the same topography. Although the TT bike can have one and a half more pounds I really felt very difficult to push the pedals; Could have been for the geometry? it is normal? I mean, I know TT bikes are not made for climbing but is it so hard to climb on those bikes?
Thanks for your comments
Is your hip angle more closed on the TT bike than on the road bike?
Bikes don’t climb hills, people do.
A TT bike won’t climb as well as a road bike if your saddle is further forward. The muscle groups employed with seated climbing work better with a shallower seat
A TT won’t descend as well either, for much the same reason.
Although someone’s bound to contradict me, this is my experience.
Its not the weight - for me on a 5-10% grade I need to put out 1 watt for every extra pound (roughly). So 1 1/2 pounds = 1 1/2 watts so I would be the same gear and at a very similar bike with 1 1/2 extra pounds.
My guess is that it was either day to day variation - or it was in your head - or you weren’t used to climbing at a steeper seat angle on the TT bike. I mainly ride on my steep TT bike - I climb just as well on it as my slacker road bike.
Repeat multiple times and see if its consistent.
Dave
Just a couple of observations:
I was a course marshal at the US Junior National Championship time trial several years ago. The course was VERY hilly and I was stationed atop one of the larger climbs. The espoirs did three laps of this course and I began timing the climb each time up for the top riders. Those who stayed down on their aerobars and climbed in their aero tuck were consistently faster up the climbs than those who either sat up with their hands on the base bar or who got out of the saddle and tried to hammer the hill. Not real scientific, but I thought it was pretty interesting.
If I were you, I wouldn’t draw too many conclusions after only one ride. Even so, I don’t think you should be too surprised that your TT bike doesn’t climb like your road bike. The gap will likely close as you adapt to the new bike.
.
is your saddle-handlebar drop the same on both bikes? lower drop will recruit different muscles, and will take some time for you to adapt. also, like others have said, having the seat angle steep will make a difference too. Give it some time and practise more climbing in your TT bike. The power will come back.
Much of the climbing power comes from arse and hams, as you move back on a road bike saddle. Because of the closed hip position (seat angle) these powerful muscle groups are minimized. Case in point, any hilly short course tri will be faster on a road bike.
Give it time. Your expectations are too high. Don’t expect to jump on a new TT bike the first time and then climb like you are on a Trek Madone. The Madone is a climbing bike, the TT position takes getting used to, etc. Will the TT bike ever climb like the Madone, no. Neither will the Madone ever TT like the Karbona.
Ric
“The Madone is a climbing bike”
One of the only bikes I could find with a 140mm headtube, I use my SSL for crit racing and to stay low and aero.