Buying a new car to trade back in

I have a '96 Nissan Pathfinder that I have thought about trading in under cash 4 clunkers. The Pathfiner needs new brakes, has a coolant leak, the AC no longer works, one of the doors won’t open anymore, the head gaskets need replaced, the cd player no longer plays cd’s, a couple of speakers are blown, the tires are going bald, there’s rust, and it has 147000 miles. Needless to say it is a beater that is ready to die and worth nothing, but it still runs for now. The issue is there really is not a new car that I want or would trade it in for under cash for clunkers (or maybe I want to get another used car). So my question is, could I trade it in on something like a Kia Spectra and turn around and trade that in for something else or resell it and buy what I want? The Spectra’s price (negotiated) is around 14000 and has a rebate of 3000 bringing it down to 11000. I would trade the truck in and get 4500 and pay cash for the rest.

What’s the minimum price point I would need to trade it in for or sell it for to make it worth my while?

…the head gaskets need replaced…

Are you near Pittsburgh, or do you live in central PA?

; ^ )

If it was that easy - everyone would do it. From what I understand from a few folks…most people wanting to trade in their clunker really just want a piece of Govt. cheese and dont want a new car…nor can they qualify for the credit needed to afford “the rest” of the car.

I think you would take a bath trading the brand new Kia in. I don’t think another dealer is going to get you your money back on trade in even if it is brand new. Good luck!

If I were considering resale or trade-in value - I wouldn’t touch a Kia. I’d look at other cars with rebates and then run the numbers to see if there is any gain that would make it worth the trouble. keep in mind, you’ll have to pay sales tax on two purchases - so you may not end up too well.

cheese and dont want a new car…nor can they qualify for the credit needed to afford “the rest” of the car.

The only people that can afford a new car right now will also qualify for the credit and the “Cash for clunkers”. One might say this is welfare for the rich :slight_smile: Of course “Rich” will be defined as anyone that happens to have the cash and credit to buy a new car.

~Matt

I was thinking the same thing.

So the Kia is 14K. You trade in the pathfinder for 4500 and drive off the lot with your new Kia for 9500$.

You then drive over to GM and tell them I want a new Silverado and want to trade this Kia in on it. You owe 9500$ on the Kia, more than likely the second you drove it off the lot it lost 20% or more of it’s value so if you sold it outright you MIGHT be able to get 11K for it which means you’ll likely get 20%-30% less than that as a trade in which puts you at ~8K.

In the end you’d end up paying more for the Silverado to pay off the Kia and you’d loose the rebate entirely.

You might be able to pull it off if YOU sold the car. So you owed 9500$ and sold it for 11-12K cash and walked away with 1500-2500$.

OTOH if there is a way to get this done I hope you do it. Makes me smile when the average person figures out a completely legal way to get around “Morality” legislation.

~Matt

i doubt many “rich” people have cars worth less than $4000.00. Lucky for me my wife’s brother-in-law owns a junkyard.

The Kia was just an example for a car that I could probably get in the 10-11 thousand region before applying the C4K rebate. In realize I would have to pay tax on 2 vehicles. However if I can trade Pathfinder in in out of state say in Illinois I would not have to pay taxes on it there. I would pay taxes on it in my home state when I registered it with the county Treasurer. Well what if I don’t register it and just turn around and resell it or trade it in. Theoretically I shoud be able to avoid paying taxes on it. However there may be some nuance of Iowa Law I have not looked up yet that would require me to remit taxes either way.

Well the KIA (does not have to be a KIA) would actually be around $6500 ($14000 minus $3000 rebate minus $4000 trade in = $6500 final cost.) if you take in the manufactures $3000 rebate and the C4K trade in value of $4500. Do I still come out behind? I can pay cash for the rest of that $6500. Does your 20-30% trade in value still work at the original $14000 price or does it also adjust with the manufactures rebated price of $11000?

OK. I played around at the Kelley Blue Book site (link here) and it looks like you might be able to make this work. You’d take your clunker and $6500 (plus taxes) and might be able to turn it into $9225 of trade in value. I don’t know the clunker rules, but you’d want to make sure that there wasn’t something that said you had to keep the new one for two years or something…

As I stated "Of course “Rich” will be defined as anyone that happens to have the cash and credit to buy a new car. "

What I’m saying is that people that are in a pinch right now aren’t looking to buy a new car. “Poor people” would never buy a new car.

The people taking part in this deal are the people that are doing better than “Poor” or “Middle class in danger of loosing their job or recently laid off” but not as well off as “I’m so rich that my car is worth more than 4500$”

Also apparently on top of the 4500$ you get a “Scrap Value” cost added in.

At that you may be looking at a trade in value of 5-6K or so which covers what you’d get for an aweful lot of cars.

~Matt

I would suggest it’s 20% off of whatever your “Drive off the lot” cost is sans government “Junker” cost is.

In short why would a person buy a car from you for 10K, or whatever the cost is, when they can buy the same car for the same cost from the dealer? You always take a hit simply driving it off the lot.

~Matt

You’d take your clunker and $6500 (plus taxes) and might be able to turn it into $9225 of trade in value.

That would be kelly blue book. I doubt many dealers are going to give a person that especially in today’s market. You might get that selling to another person. But then why would they buy a new car from a person for 9225$ when they could probably get it from a dealer for 11K?

Even using those numbers you’re looking at turning your 4500$ rebate into 2725$. That’s not bad but add in tax and and the likely hood that you’re not getting 9225$ for your trade in and you’re probably down to less than 2K, maybe less.

Another, better idea IMO, would be to simply find someone who is looking to buy a new car and already has a fuel efficient car. Say someone like me, if I were looking to buy a new car.

Sell them the car for 2-3K. That person gets an effective 1500-2500 rebate and you walk away with 2-3K everyone is happy with a bunch less screwing around.

~Matt

There are provisions in the bill that prevents turnaround like that. Not sure about how they will enforce but it is in there. Also, is your car on the list of approved cars? I was thinking about it too but my POS isn’t on there.

It’s on the list for an approved car, it’s a 96 pathfinder with a combined epa of 15mpg (much worse in current condition). The provisions could be an issue if I have to keep the car for any length of time. Truthfully the hassle in trying to do the turnaround might not be worth it to me anyways.