Would someone be willing to give me an overview of the type (material) of brake pads that are best for different rim surfaces (carbon, aluminum)? Also, is there a brake pad that works well on all rim surfaces?
Thanks…
Would someone be willing to give me an overview of the type (material) of brake pads that are best for different rim surfaces (carbon, aluminum)? Also, is there a brake pad that works well on all rim surfaces?
Thanks…
Swisstop yellow
.
Would someone be willing to give me an overview of the type (material) of brake pads that are best for different rim surfaces (carbon, aluminum)? Also, is there a brake pad that works well on all rim surfaces?
Thanks…
My hands-down favorite brake pad for aluminum braking surfaces is the KoolStop Salmon. Although they market them as being ideal for wet conditions, they also work much better than “stock” pads in dry conditions as well IME. They can literally transform the braking feel and performance.
For carbon braking surfaces, I’ve heard good things about the SwissStop yellow pads. KoolStop also make a carbon pad model that also apparently works pretty well.
http://www.koolstop.com/brakes/Compound.html
http://www.swissstop.ch/Road.aspx
http://www.koolstop.com/brakes/index.php#Anchor-The-36279
I don’t have any direct experience with either of those pads intended for carbon rims…all my wheels have aluminum brake tracks! ![]()
+2 for swissstop yellow.
best brake pads I’ve ever used on carbon rims, way better than zips own pads.
I haven’t tried the koolstop salmon, but their other pads are excellent.
I think it only makes sense that if you are spending good money on wheels and tires you should spend a little on good brake pads.
See slowman’s article on how better braking makes for faster riding.
is it accurate to say, then, that i need different brake pads for my ‘standard’ wheels vs. race wheels, if the rims are different materials (i.e. carbon and aluminum, respectively)?
You COULD use swissstop yellow for both.
BUT you then run the risk of having debris left in the pads from the aluminum rims damaging the surface of the carbon rims.
If you are running shimano/sram brakes then the pad swap takes only half again as long as the wheel change.
My recommendation would be to swap pads when you swap wheels.
What tri-tele said: swapping pads is best.
I’ve found it’s easier to get a separate pair of shoes to house the carbon pads. I’ve gotten reasonably proficient at pulling brake pads out of a shoe, but sometimes they’ve gotten jammed and I’ve had to sweat and grunt to get them out.
I’m another fan of Swisstop yellow pads for carbon braking surfaces: far better than the KoolStop-made, Zipp-branded pads I tried before.
You COULD use swissstop yellow for both.
BUT you then run the risk of having debris left in the pads from the aluminum rims damaging the surface of the carbon rims.
If you are running shimano/sram brakes then the pad swap takes only half again as long as the wheel change.
My recommendation would be to swap pads when you swap wheels.
Besides the embedded debris risk, I’ve heard that the Swiss Stop yellow pads don’t exactly give the best braking for aluminum tracks. Not only that, but they are a bit pricey…which might not be to appealing for everyday use.
edit: That said, I have a teammate who uses the yellow pads on both aluminum and carbon rims. He claims he just wipes down the braking surface when he swaps wheels and makes sure there’s no embedded aluminum bits. I’m not sure how the brake performance is for him on the aluminum…then again, he’s not exactly known as a steller descender in the first place, if you know what I mean ![]()
thanks, All!
Virtually every brake pad will work for every rim. However, there are definitely some that work better than others.
Stock pads from Shimano and Sram will work for both carbon and Al rims. They are definitely oriented toward aluminum, and work the best with those rims. There performance on carbon is acceptable, especially for a typical triathlon bike course, where there is little braking involved. In road race conditions, with carbon wheels, I would personally find something else, as there are much better options out there. Durability of these pads for each rim type is good. These stock pads are honestly my preference for Al rims.
Campy stock pads have great performance on Aluminum rims, but shouldn’t be used on carbon. They are extremely hard, and generate a ton of heat. Great pads for Aluminum rims, good feel in wet and dry conditions, and last a long time.
Swiss Stop Yellow pads can be used on both types of rims, however I personally wouldn’t use them on Aluminum and then carbon. The pads are pretty soft, and will have picked up some of the aluminum from your rim. There shouldn’t be much in there, but it will cause a small amount more wear on your carbon rims. I find the Swiss Stop yellows to be excellent on carbon, and acceptable on aluminum. When you use them with Al rims they wear incredibly fast.
Zipp Rubber Pads are great pads for carbon rims. You can use them on Al as well, but they wear much, much quicker. They are a fairly soft pad, so the lifespan is not as long as some others, but they do perform well.
Cork Pads are my preference for carbon rims. I have recently switched to the Zipp ones, which have only been out for a couple of weeks. Cork pads should really only be used with carbon rims. They will stop Aluminum rims, but you can easily find a better performing and cheaper alternative for Al rims. On carbon cork pads provide far better stopping power and modulation than any other material I have tried. They also generate far less brake heat, making them the only thing I would use on a carbon clincher.
Keeping your brake pads and the braking surface of your rims clean is one of the most overlooked parts of bicycle maintenance. This is especially important with carbon rims, where you want to periodically inspect the pads to make sure no large chunks of debris have become inbedded in the pad. Wipe down the rims with a clean dry cloth, and lightly sand down the surface of each brake pad. I check the pads everytime I change wheels, but if you often ride the same wheelset it probably isn’t a bad idea to check them out every 250 miles or so. Dropping the wheels out and cleaning and sanding probably wouldn’t even take a novice mechanic 10 minutes, and it is a great time to practice getting your wheel off and back on your bike quickly and correctly, like you would have to do for a flat change in a race.