A local bike shop employee just told me that a Cervelo P2 is stiffer than a P1 in addition to being more aerodynamic. I have not really found any objective data on stiffness on the internet. Theoretically, if bike stiffness is resulting in more or less efficient transfer of power from the cranks to the rear hub, then a Powertap should show a lower power than an SRM when both are used simultaneously. If you compared this difference between bikes, you should be able to objectively quantify the difference in efficiency of power transfer between 2 bikes. A quick Google search reveals one guy’s blog in which he ran an SRM and powertap simultaneously and he consistently got lower power readings on the SRM than on the Powertap (a physical impossibility). He suggested that the different software packages for the SRM and Powertap were interpreting the data differently. He did calibrate both SRM and Powertap before starting but he didn’t state his calibration protocol. Can I conclude from this that the power loss from the cranks to the rear hub is so small that it is not measurable with the same instruments that are commonly used to measure aerodynamic differences ? Has anyone gotten this method or any other method to show a measurable difference in power transfer efficiency between 2 bikes ?
Thanks.
it has been demonstrated that bike stiffness does not affect the power transfer efficiency.
the power lost when you bend the frame is returned almost 100% when it bends backs.
the p2 IS stiffer than the P1, and you MIGHT notice if you are on a larger size frame and very strong or heavy.
if the feeling annoys you, a stiffer frame will be nice.
if it doesn’t, there is no benefit to the stiffer frame.
The PT should show a lower power than the SRM, but that is due to power losses in the drive train (chain, rear derailleur, etc.), not stiffness of the frame. Put out X watts at the crank, a couple of watts are lost in bending the chain and spinning the rd wheels, and less gets to the hub where the PT measures it.
check www.efbe.de
great independent frame testing site.
cervelo’s do not score very well in the stiffness category.
check www.efbe.de
great independent frame testing site.
cervelo’s do not score very well in the stiffness category.
The thing I hate about these testing sites is unless they publish results for all bikes or at least most bikes it amounts to little more than thinly veiled advertising.
“cervelo’s do not score very well in the stiffness category”
I might’ve missed it - I didn’t see any Cervelo (or any brand name I recognize besides Scott) on the very small database shown.
check it again sparky.
specialized, trek, kuota, wilier, storck, isaac, cannondale, scott, cervelo, santa cruz, giant…do you need anymore??
And by the way, this is an independent test.
Not the normal bs that has been thrown around as gospel from certain manufacturers on this site and others.
it has been demonstrated that bike stiffness does not affect the power transfer efficiency.
the power lost when you bend the frame is returned almost 100% when it bends backs.
I was thinking about this on my (bike) commute home today, and I’m not sure I believe it. My issue is that as I envision it much (most?) BB flex happens side-to-side, i.e. pushing one end then the other of the BB axle toward the ground. This kind of flex doesn’t actually “return” energy to the drivetrain when it bends back, since the flex is happening perpendicular to the chain.
Am I missing something?
Ask Sean Kelly and his Vitus…
That bike was a noodle - and he still won damn near every sprint. Too many folks focus far too much on that. I would take some BB flex long before I would take a battering ram up the keyster any day…those are your options. Stiff is great, but it will also punish you.
yes, you are missing something.
to illustrate this, where do you think the energy is going?
its either going to heat the frame up, or go back to wheels.
it has been demonstrated that bike stiffness does not affect the power transfer efficiency.
the power lost when you bend the frame is returned almost 100% when it bends backs.
I was thinking about this on my (bike) commute home today, and I’m not sure I believe it. My issue is that as I envision it much (most?) BB flex happens side-to-side, i.e. pushing one end then the other of the BB axle toward the ground. This kind of flex doesn’t actually “return” energy to the drivetrain when it bends back, since the flex is happening perpendicular to the chain.
Am I missing something?
that testing is cool
the cervelos listed are either the old R2.5, or aero frames, not intended to be the stiffest on earth.
I imagine the R3 would stack up well if that is what you were after.
but again, stiffness is a red herring for almost everybody.
=)
check it again sparky.
specialized, trek, kuota, wilier, storck, isaac, cannondale, scott, cervelo, santa cruz, giant…do you need anymore??
And by the way, this is an independent test.
Not the normal bs that has been thrown around as gospel from certain manufacturers on this site and others.
Sorry, missed this reply.
I think the energy is going to “heat up” the frame. Heating would be pretty limited, but I think it’s going to bend the frame and never making it back to the wheels.
When you pedal out of the saddle, cranks serve to transfer the power produced in the pedal’s downstoke (vertical plane) to pulling the chain forward (horizontal plane). If the BB is flexing side-to-side, in teh vertical plane, some of the vertical energy goes to flex the frame. Because the flex is perpendicular to the direction of the chain pull, it would never be returned to the drivetrain, so side-to-side flex of the bottom bracket would be energy lost.
Kind of similar to a FS MTB: if you stand up and stomp causing lots of bob in the rear sus., you lose a ton of power just compressing the rear shock. The body weight you’re putting down onto the pedals, rather than being efficiently transferred into pulling the chain forward, is being absorbed by movement perpendicular to the chain, and when that movement “relaxes” (shock re-extends) it doesn’t go back to pulling the chain forward. 'Cause the “flex” is perpendicular to the direction of chain movement. Right? (and sorry for the long, boring reply!)
think about it:
If pedalling hard can bend the frame
then bending the frame can “pedal”
Really, its been physically demonstrated by putting a bike in a rack, applying torque until the frame bent, releasing the wheel, it spins and the frame bends back.
there is some energy lost as heat from bending a frame. but its more than just limited. its super mega limited and not worth worrying about. really!
=)
Sorry, missed this reply.
I think the energy is going to “heat up” the frame. Heating would be pretty limited, but I think it’s going to bend the frame and never making it back to the wheels.
When you pedal out of the saddle, cranks serve to transfer the power produced in the pedal’s downstoke (vertical plane) to pulling the chain forward (horizontal plane). If the BB is flexing side-to-side, in teh vertical plane, some of the vertical energy goes to flex the frame. Because the flex is perpendicular to the direction of the chain pull, it would never be returned to the drivetrain, so side-to-side flex of the bottom bracket would be energy lost.
Kind of similar to a FS MTB: if you stand up and stomp causing lots of bob in the rear sus., you lose a ton of power just compressing the rear shock. The body weight you’re putting down onto the pedals, rather than being efficiently transferred into pulling the chain forward, is being absorbed by movement perpendicular to the chain, and when that movement “relaxes” (shock re-extends) it doesn’t go back to pulling the chain forward. 'Cause the “flex” is perpendicular to the direction of chain movement. Right? (and sorry for the long, boring reply!)
Why do track riders need a really stiff frame?
This article is old but still interesting on flex http://www.tomsarazac.com/tom/opinions/stiffframe.html
.
Why do track riders need a really stiff frame?
They don’t, they just tend to like them.
Some of the fastest times have been set on bikes that were very much not stuff iirc that british superbike was near falling apart, riders didn’t like it, but they were fast.
If pedalling hard can bend the frame
then bending the frame can “pedal”
Not necessarily true. Imagine a frame with a really up-and-down flexy BB. Put it on a rack, flex the ends of the BB up and down in the vertical plane, i.e. perpendicular to the direction of the chain pull. With this kind of flex, the BB/chainrings stay equidistant from the rear cogs as they flex so the chain is not pulled and this kind of flex doesn’t “pedal”. Or, imagine you weld the chain to the rear cogs and the chainrings. You could still flex the BB up-down, and this kind of flex, with the chain so-welded, could by definition NOT return any energy to the rear wheel.
This is actually relevant, as most of the power is applied between 2 and 5 o’clock in the pedal stroke, producing just this kind of flex.
If you did the same experiment on a hypothetical bike with a VERTICAL chainline, i.e. rear wheel directly below the cranks, then I would say that the energy is returned. By the same token, if you flexed the BB fore-aft, rather than up-down on a normal bike (flex in the same direction as the chain line) I’d say that would also be returned. Right?
Now, with all that said, I have not idea how much difference any of this makes during normal use of a bike. Flex is presumably pretty small, and I doubt most of us are putting down enough torque to really make this an issue. I always think those reviews where someone raves about the “stiffness and efficiency” of the frame (“It rockets forward at the slightest touch to the pedals!”) are hokum.
This article is old but still interesting on flex http://www.tomsarazac.com/tom/opinions/stiffframe.html
That is pretty good, thanks!
couple of thoughts on this…
-
running a powertap and srm simultaneously can be very accurate, to the point that I have been able to measure the difference in drivetrain effecieny of different chainrings. If the powertap registers above the srm, that does not mean that they are not calibrated or inaccurate. I CAN mean that the powertap is reporting ~+2% and the SRM is reporting ~-2% which can add up enough to show the PT above the SRM.
-
lateral flex in a frame does not alter efficient transfer of power (unless it is SO flexable that the angle of the chain changes enough, but that is HUGH deflection and isn’t happening).
lateral forces are converted into one of two things:
- in a frame of infinite stiffness with no lateral displacement, the forces are converted into heat in the frame material as it resists flex.
or
- in a frame with not lateral stiffness, the lateral forces are converted into lateral deflection, which when unloaded returns the BB to it’s original location.
In either case, lateral forces are not and can no be “converted” into forward motion.
g
its terrible, he is just throwing out a claim that is merely an idea in his head.
yes the bike pushing back on your legs, which is how the energy gets back to the wheels.
his notion that your muscles get more fatigued by this is madness
This article is old but still interesting on flex http://www.tomsarazac.com/tom/opinions/stiffframe.html
That is pretty good, thanks!
the scenario you are describing is one where pedaling hard wouldn’t bend it that way
If pedalling hard can bend the frame
then bending the frame can “pedal”
Not necessarily true. Imagine a frame with a really up-and-down flexy BB. Put it on a rack, flex the ends of the BB up and down in the vertical plane, i.e. perpendicular to the direction of the chain pull. With this kind of flex, the BB/chainrings stay equidistant from the rear cogs as they flex so the chain is not pulled and this kind of flex doesn’t “pedal”. Or, imagine you weld the chain to the rear cogs and the chainrings. You could still flex the BB up-down, and this kind of flex, with the chain so-welded, could by definition NOT return any energy to the rear wheel.
This is actually relevant, as most of the power is applied between 2 and 5 o’clock in the pedal stroke, producing just this kind of flex.
If you did the same experiment on a hypothetical bike with a VERTICAL chainline, i.e. rear wheel directly below the cranks, then I would say that the energy is returned. By the same token, if you flexed the BB fore-aft, rather than up-down on a normal bike (flex in the same direction as the chain line) I’d say that would also be returned. Right?
Now, with all that said, I have not idea how much difference any of this makes during normal use of a bike. Flex is presumably pretty small, and I doubt most of us are putting down enough torque to really make this an issue. I always think those reviews where someone raves about the “stiffness and efficiency” of the frame (“It rockets forward at the slightest touch to the pedals!”) are hokum.