(Forewarning: This goes far afield from the original post regarding good running dogs, and doves into a discussion about Dobermans misconceptions as well as proper training of dogs. Oh yeah, and its long. Stop here if this what you are looking for.)
Cerveloguy, I have to disagree with your post about Dobes. Although your post is based on commonly held beliefs, I believe it is a misconception.
Dobes aren’t “hit of miss”, it’s the owners that are “hit or miss.” Dobes are a function of their owners. If the owner is mealy, the Dobe WILL take over the role of leader of the pack and present a hand full of issues. On the other hand, if the owner is abusive, the Dobe will became fearful (which leads to fear biting) and/or aggressive.
For an owner that understands the dynamics of the breed and how to raise a good, social dog, there isn’t a finer breed. Trying at times, but not a better dog.
Tom’s post is accurate. Dobes require a lot of attention, and a strong willed owner. For potential owners that don’t meet these requirements, the breed is NOT for them and they should NOT purchase this dog. Dobe rescue organizations don’t need any additional help keeping themselves busy.
And to clarify a couple other points, Dobes, as a general rule, are not by nature aggressive. Protective, yes, but aggressive, no. (Yes, there are breeders that select aggression as a trait, but these breeders are easily identifiable and likely will advise you - - if not brag - - of the dogs tempermant. The same is true of many breeds; This is not Dobe specific).
With improper training and/or mistreatment, Dobes can become aggressive, but the same is true of all breeds. If you tie a Lhasa Apso up to a stake in your back yard and do not give it attention, guess what, it’s not going to be socialized and likely will exhibit aggressive tendencies. Again, it isn’t the breed, it’s the owner.
As for the “training” requirement that has been mentioned multiple times in this posting, this shouldn’t be confused with anything more than the training any responsible owner should undertake, i.e., Schutzhund or other advanced training isn’t necessary. However the training need to be continually enforced because the breed needs mental stimulation and constant reminders of who is the Alpha Male. Training and continued enforcement of what has been learned provides Dobes the direction. Without this direction, the Dobes’ extremely mischievous mind is left to wander. A very intelligent dog without direction can result in holes in your walls, a dog’s greeting card for “I need more attention.”
If you are thinking of buying a Dobe, think of raising a permanent three year old, temperamental child that weighs 85 lbs and you’ll have a good idea. The breed has drive, will power and determination that is unmatched. If my Dobe truly wants something, there is no amount of pain that can be inflicted that will break their this drive. This is the breed; You must be able to focus the drive and determination, or suffer the consequences. (Bear in mind here that my experiences are tempered by the fact that I have the Alpha Male of all Alpha Males; my dog is a worst case scenario for dominance issues. Note: the problems with the breed are primarily dominance issues, not aggression. Although the two are closely related, they are not the same thing - - not dog trainer here, but a very well read owner.)
And, if you are afraid to put a pinch collar/choke chain on your dog and snap the leash with substantial force, Dobermans are not the breed for you (nor are many of the medium/large size breeds). And if the dog responds by growling/showing his teeth and you don’t yank the leash twice as hard, Dobes are not the breed for you. (Yes. I can hear the gasps now from non-dog owner and owners of passive breeds. And if you did gasp, this should be your clue that you should never purchase a dog with any hint of dominance issues. No amount of love or praise is going to stop a dog that wants to chew on your shoe from doing so; it requires stern discipline.)
The key here is the difference between being a stern owner and a sadistic owner. When your dog respects you (this comes from learning to trust you) and learns that you expect his obedience, you will receive it. Until then, especially with a Dobe, your dog will continually test its boundaries to see what it can get away with.
Frankly, I’m happy keeping Dobes in a very small population of owners. I prefer having a dog that is uncommon. And for the sake of the breed, keeping them in the hands of the right owners is very important to me. I don’t ever want to see this dog becoming a popular/common breed. That is why I have no problems pointing out that this isn’t the breed for everyone. I just prefer that the misconception about their alleged aggressive tendencies be fully understood as being the fault of a bad owner and not the breed.