What’s the biggest difference between the two? Anyone out there has tried both for racing?
As far as I know (I’ve run in several versions of both models) is that there are two series of Asics lines that these two shoes belong to. The DS racer belongs to the DS-racer, trainer, 2-00 series and I believe the Kayano. Simply a beefier shoe as you make your way up. The speedstar is in line with the Magic, speedstar and Nimbus. It’s two different lines of shoes for two different runners. My expierence has been that the DS series doesn’t work for me but the speedstar, nimbus and magic do.
For racing… real short stuff… Magic/DS Racer. Half’s… Speedstar/Trainer… Fulls… nimbus/2-00
Hope this helps.
I have wondered this as well. I’ve run in the DS racers as well, but not the speedstars. Curious as to why you would not run a marathon in them? If you that inefficient or have moderate to severe pronatory velocities, you probably shouldn’t be using the DS racer for a 1/2 either. Also, if you have not tried the new DS Trainers (XII), they are great and a LOT different then the last model. Might be perfect for you for a full mary.
I have used all of the last 3 itterations of the DS racer and been very happy with them. The oldest one about 3 goes ago was nice and yellow and had a sole of the shoe that was very grippy, very similar to the nerwer sole on the red shoes. The middle version that I used was white with a harder sole in sort of a sun pattern. The sole of the racer in its various types makes a reall difference as you can feel the different durometer ratings of the rubber and as the base of the shoes are pretty thin then a harder more solid rubber made my knees hurt a bit more. However, that latest red pair that I have has the grippy soles and I love them as they feel like I am runing on air! soo good I have bought a few pairs. As for the length of run I use them from anything from IM’s to sprints without any trouble.
The DS-Racer is a racing flat…very light, responsive, with some cushioning. Depending on your biomechanics, great for all distances up to a marathon. For the majority of folks, probably best for 5k-10k.
The Speedstar is a lightweight trainer…slightly heavier than the DS-R, wider base, more cushioning. A great shoe for the half and up and for those looking for ‘more’ shoe but who want something lighter than a normal training shoe.
However, with the introduction of the new DS-Trainer, I would skip the Speedstar and race in that.
If I’m not mistaken the DS-Racer has a medial post so it will help offset a little pronation whereas the Speedstar is a neutral shoe that lacks a medial post and has more cushion. I’ve run in asics racing flats since the early 90’s (Waikahuri racer, HyperPaw, Gel Magic, Gel Racer, Gel Tri-Paw, etc) and think the DS Racer V is one of the best although I haven’t tried the newest version yet.
I have wondered this as well. I’ve run in the DS racers as well, but not the speedstars. Curious as to why you would not run a marathon in them? If you that inefficient or have moderate to severe pronatory velocities, you probably shouldn’t be using the DS racer for a 1/2 either. Also, if you have not tried the new DS Trainers (XII), they are great and a LOT different then the last model. Might be perfect for you for a full mary.
I have been running in the DS-Trainer XII. Very good shoe. But I had seen it advertised that they were going to be MUCH lighter, like comprable to the DS-Racer. But that’s not the case, my XII’s were something like 8 grams lighter than the XI’s. Very odd. But they are lasting quite a bit longer than the XI’s, so that’s something. But I still love racing in the DS-Racers. I am by no means a “good” runner, but I’ve done a couple of IMs in the Racers with no ill effects.
-C
Yeah, I read that as wel - and I’m glad they are not that light. I actually weigh all my shoes (why not, I’m a closet, well not really closet, weight weenie and have a nice digital scale) and my size 9 DS Trainer XIIs were 9.6 oz each. GREAT for training shoe though, but original estimates were putting them under 9 oz. I don’t remember what the DS trainer was, but my current long distance race shoe, Saucony type-A, is 7.8 oz and feels about the same (but with a little more cusion) as the DS trainer.
Interestingly, it did take me a few runs to “break in” the new DS trainers that I don’t normally see with the shoes I use. I definitely notice the rearfoot medial posting on the DS trainer, despite it’s weight.
Thanks for all the responses!