We, as a society, have determined that some substances are so harmful/damaging/addictive/bad that they should be illegal. Their ill effects to the individual and to society as a whole far outweigh their benefits. We say that there is no way to use these substances responsibly, or at least that it is extraordinarily rare. There aren’t many social meth users, for example.
Other substances, in our judgement, can be and are used responsibly by millions of people, and they have significant benefits for those people. Additionally, the ill effects of these substances are often a result, not of their use, but of their abuse. So while there are a lot of alcoholics who have ruined their lives, they did so by abusing alcohol. And there are a lot more people who have used alcohol responsibly for their enjoyment.
There can be, I think, a legitimate argument about where the line between “licit” and “illicit” drugs should be. Maybe pot really is benign and should be legal. Maybe tobacco is the scourge of humanity and should be banned. That’s all debatable. But to argue that having any line at all is hypocritical is silly. Surely you’re not going to argue that, in the real world, it doesn’t make any difference if I go home and have a beer after work, or if I go home and take a hit off the crack pipe. Are you?
Maybe there should be a line drawn, but I think the line should be drawn somewhere other than where it is now. Living in Austin most of my years from 18 - 29, I know many, many intelligent people who have used marijuana, mushrooms, ecstasy, cocaine, and acid responsibly(if that is possible w/ an illegal substance) for their enjoyment. I happen to know two succesful attorneys and a couple of succesful business people who have smoked pot on a regular basis for years(all 4 are in their 40’s and 50’s). Just as in any situation(riding a bike, driving a car, hangliding, having unprotected sex, etc…) a certain amount of risk is assumed.
I’ve tried all of the above at some time in my life and never felt like I** absolutely ***had *to have more even though I had fun virtually every time. I do admit that I have never had an addictive personality, but off the top of my head I can think of about 8 or 9 college buddies who have tried some or all of the above and have never developed an addiction. Strangely enough, I’ve never smoked a cigarette or had a cup of coffee, though. Funny thing is, during the same period of experimentation I wouldn’t touch beef or pork
(still won’t).
I don’t know if things are different with drugs like heroin, crack, crystal meth, oxycontin, etc… I’ve never tried them - I hear they are super addictive like cigarettes. I just think adults should be able to make their own decisions when it comes to their bodies(sex, drugs, etc…)
An addition: I know ecstasy was used for years in psychotherapy before it was made illegal, and that the FDA approved a study fairly recently examining it’s uses in that area.