Amazing improvement in graduation rate

Baptist Hill High School is a local public school in one of the more economically depressed areas in our county. The area is predominantly black, entirely rural and very closely related (everyone is someone’s cousin or aunt/uncle - fairly typical in the southern rural communities). Without any change in population, demographic or local economy, they went from a 30% graduation rate to over 70% in a few short years.

Given that every factor outside of the school remained unchanged, what accounts for this unusual turnaround? Some details are provided in the article, but if that’s all there is to it, why do we still have schools here and elsewhere maintaining graduation rates in the 30% range?

http://www.wcbd.com/midatlantic/cbd/news.apx.-content-articles-CBD-2008-04-01-0028.html

A new report shows some of the nation’s largest cites are getting a failing grade when it comes to graduation rates. News 2 checked rates here in the Lowcountry. According to the 2007 State Report Card: Berkeley county has a 68-percent graduation rate; 61-percent in Charleston county; 64-percent in Dorchester District 2; 59-percent in Dorchester District 4; and 78-percent in Georgetown county. Based on the 2006-2007 school year, in Charleston county, Academic Magnet had the highest graduation rate of 100%, while North Charleston High School had the lowest of 35.3%.

News 2 visited Baptist Hill High School in Hollywood, a school that was once in the same boat as North Charleston High School, but is now sailing to greater heights. Baptist Hill is breaking that declining cycle. Dr. James Winbush, a third year principal at Baptist Hill says thanks to hardworking staff and students, and prevention programs they have made significant progress. He says, “Because of hard work and diligence, we’ve come along way. A few years ago, we had a graduation rate of about 30-percent. Right now as of last year we had a graduation rate of 71 percent.” Dr. Winbush says because of programs, hardworking students and staff, this title one school with 429 students, has its eyes set on a number one goal. He says the focus is on accountability, tracking students, and keeping tabs on those who leave school. A typical graduation class has around 80 student, and making sure all students graduate is a top priority. Winbush says, “Putting in programs where students who have missed credits or failed credits being able to recover those credits in the summer or after school.”

Twelfth grader Michal Taylor says staying in school can be a struggle. He says, “Right now, I’m doing much better. I was struggling a little bit since the 9th grade, but my grades have improved since 9th grade.” Michal credits programs at Baptist Hill for helping him stay the course. He says, “We had a tutorial program that the students can stay and get extra tutoring from teachers that need help from teachers. To me it’s made a lot of difference and improved my grade and makes me want to stay.” Twelfth grader Edith Jenkins says it allows her to keep her eyes on a bigger prize. She says, “I thought about me being the first person in my family to go to college in my family.” While the graduation numbers are improving, for these students the journey to success continues well beyond walking across the high school graduation stage. Michael Taylor says, “I think that’s a great improvement. It shows if we try hard enough anybody achieve anything.”

School districts have started several programs to increase graduation rates. In Charleston county, M-GAP and E-GAP programs are used to bridge the gap between early, middle, and secondary education. There are also programs targeting at-risk students, and programs aimed at middle school reform. In Berkeley county, all 9th graders now have I-G-P-S, that’s Individual Graduation Plans, and next year the district will implement a Star Academy to reduce the number of over-age 8th grade students at risk of dropping out.

The State Department of Education says right now they have ten different formulas used to calculate graduation rates. Tuesday, the federal government announced a plan to adopt a uniformed formula for all states, which is something South Carolina has been pushing for.

Awesome. Thanks for posting.

North Charleston High School had the lowest of 35.3%.

This is the area where I typically work. I’m actually surprised it’s as high as it is, but really, if this dramatic improvement can happen out in the country with essentially the same factors at play (and with similar past rates), how do you account for such a drastic improvement? I realize the graduating classes are less than 100, and North Charleston is probably 4 times greater, maybe more, but what’s the magic ingredient here? What’s the common thread binding these success stories together?

graduation rate is just part of the story. What did they learn before graduation is another.

I’m not saying this for one specific school but the trend I’m seeing is that HS students have less math skills every year and as a direct result State Universities have to offer B.S. Introductory Math Classes. But that’s what you get when “everybody” is entitled to receiving higher education. Just like they are inflated the USD money supply they are also debasing the value of a college degree.

what accounts for this unusual turnaround?\

Possibly lower standards???

I don’t know if the school has the ability to lower standards independent of state requirements. They may, but I don’t think so.

And if that were the case, why are they the only one doing so? Or should we assume that North Charleston may have lowered standards as well, and still only squeezes out 35%?

what accounts for this unusual turnaround?\

Possibly lower standards???

Lets table low standards a minute (good issue, but suited for a different discussion). At least in the schools in which I worked, about the only factor that prevented one from graduating was attendance. Keeping a kid in school versus having him drop out is assuming that he is learning something. Without knowing the specifics, I’m assuming that their focus was probably driven toward just getting them to wak up in the morning, gettin gtheir asses out of bed, and showing up. Again, it may seem like its not that big of an accomplishment, but for some areas it is…especially when it takes little more than that for them to become productive members of society (you don’t need a high school education to do a no skill job…but you do need to show up every day).

My point being, it probably wasn’t the standards holding them back, but rather the not showing up.

I’m not saying this for one specific school but the trend I’m seeing is that HS students have less math skills every year and as a direct result State Universities have to offer B.S. Introductory Math Classes. But that’s what you get when “everybody” is entitled to receiving higher education. Just like they are inflated the USD money supply they are also debasing the value of a college degree.

Again, this is a different issue and one with which I agree with you on. However, graduation rates (showing up every day and passing some standard that a kid with an IQ of 60 can reasonably attain) and what they know going in to college are separate issues.

Off the top of my head, I’m assuming that a lot of colleges are offering remedial math classes because our college attendance rate is going up. In otherwords, that next tier of students is going to college now when they wouldn’t have in the past. This isn’t to say that the kids are learning enough (they aren’t as refelcted by our comparisons to Europe and Japan), only that the standards for getting into college have lowered.

There must be a lot of very smart kids around. I don’t think I’ve ever met a parent that didn’t have a straight A student.

Surprisingly I have to agree with BarryP. Simply graduating these days is more a function of showing up than actual academic performance.

However looking at the ACT scores from the Charleston district you also see a pretty impressive improvement.

2004 -18
2005 -19
2006 -20
2007 -20

NAtional average ACT is 21. This is also with a 25% participation rate which is actually higher than Detroit’s graduation rate.

All the more stunning is that they did this on a similar budget as the other districts in the top 50 urban areas at about 16% over state average. Some of the districts mentioned in the article actually had under the state average per pupil expenditures.

What ever they’re doing it’s working for them and warrants a strong look from some of the other districts not doing so well.

Another note and I realize this is not a fair comparison because ACT is Mandatory in Michigan thus there is 100% or close to 100% of juniors in the Detroit community. However since Detroit’s graduation rate is around 24.9% could make the “Leap” that the people left to take the test are the same people that voluntarily take the test in this district…but that’s a huge leap. Detroit’s ACT average is 16.

~Matt

Dr. James Winbush, a third year principal at Baptist Hill says thanks to hardworking staff and students, and prevention programs they have made significant progress. He says, “Because of hard work and diligence, we’ve come along way. . .”
*** Dr. Winbush says because of programs, hardworking students and staff, this title one school with 429 students, has its eyes set on a number one goal. He says the focus is on accountability, tracking students, and keeping tabs on those who leave school.***


Would probably have been nice to get a little more detail on that, eh?

And it isn’t clear to me whether or not all the E-Gap, M-Gap, I-G-P-S, and Star Academy programs are working or not.

Did anyone else catch that PBS show last night about public schools in DC?