The Yaqui Carbo is a great riding bike, even over the rough stuff. I think it's due to the thin scandium tubing used. I always compare bike rides to my old standard, a steel SLX tubing frame, my old Razesa, because it was SO comfortable. (It was also fairly flexible!) The Yaqui surpasses the ride quality of the old steel SLX frame, but the Yaqui is MUCH more stiff in the rearend. It's also very light, I don't know the actual weight, but it is VERY light. As far as rear-end stiffness, at my weight and power output, that's important...this was reason enough for me to get the Carbo...a stiffer rear-end due to the carbon mono-seatstay. Although the carbon stiffens the rear end, the carbon probably absorbs some of the road vibrations. The Kestrel is stiffer overall, and it's noticeably more heavy than the Yaqui. I would think the newer Kestrel SL would address this weight issue somewhat, to the tune of about $800.00 more?
Compared to my Kestrel Talon, I'd say the Carbo seems to soak up the bigger stuff a little better, and the Talon seems to deaden out all the smaller bumps better. The Talon's ride seems to be "wooden" or almost dead...it's definitely different. On alligator pavement, the Kestrel feels like it's on almost smooth pavement, on quick turns or going downhill on rougher surfaces, the Yaqui tracks straighter...I'm assuming it is at least partly because the Yaqui soaks up some of the bigger stuff better with it's more flexible frame.
The shifting is the same on both bikes, nearly instant, except you hear it much louder on the aluminum framed bike, again, because the carbon soaks up those high-frequency sounds better, i.e., I really can tell if my front derailler is off just a little on the Yaqui, on the Talon, sometimes that little rub just isn't heard, especially at speed when the wind noise is in your ears.
I have Syntace C2s, Ouzo Pro Aero fork, Dura-Ace crank spinning on Ultegra bb, Dura-Ace shifters, externally-routed cables.
I don't know how to describe it, but my Yaqui seems to be alive and surges ahead easier when my adrenaline is up, although the Kestrel should be just as efficient, if not moreso due to the stiffness of the carbon, something about the way my body interacts with the two bikes makes the Yaqui seem livelier, faster.
So, I set my Kestrel up as a daily workhorse to be flogged and slogged through the rain and dirt, and my Yaqui as a TT/race-day racing thoroughbred.
If you fit on the Kestrel, it will impassively and obligingly deliver you over whatever distance you want to ride it, and do so for a LONG time, it has a lifetime warranty I believe. The Yaqui WILL fit you, if Ves gets your correct measurements, and it will deliver you over the same distances, dancing and singing to you as it does so. Will it last as long as the Kestrel? I don't know. It just depends upon what appeals to you most.
Quid quid latine dictum sit altum videtur
(That which is said in Latin sounds profound)