Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

erg trainer question
Quote | Reply
Say i am doing an interval of 1 minute at 400w. i am approaching spiral of death 90 rpm for 30 seconds, down to 10rpm at finish....so I am able to turn the pedals through out the minute . why does this not count as me doing 400w the whole time? says I did 350 or so.
Quote Reply
Re: erg trainer question [synthetic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Your trainer probably cannot create high enough resistance at low rpm to hit 400w. Only the most stout trainers are capable of the very high resistance you probably need.
Quote Reply
Re: erg trainer question [synthetic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It is because you are shooting for a number that is too high for you (at least right now).
You your power starts dropping, then the trainer tries to adjust to keep you at 400, so cadence gets harder to maintain, repeat, repeat, repeat down to 10 rpm.
Smart trainers go into the "cadence death spiral" when you are not holding the number that you set.

If you set 400- and kept holding 400 at 90 rpm or better there would not be an issue. In fact if you try to boost power by a measurable amount it will keep adjusting and cadence will increase.
Quote Reply
Re: erg trainer question [synthetic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The way trainer control works, your cadence drops, your power drops, your trainer increases resistance. You were working at an unsustainable power, so the actual power you output was dropping continuously for the last 30 seconds following that cycle. Plus if you're moving at 10 rpm at the end, I highly doubt you were actually putting out 400W at that point. Long story short, it doesn't count as 400 W because you werent putting out 400 W. As soon as the cadence starts dropping, your power will have as well.
Quote Reply
Re: erg trainer question [synthetic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'd question why you're trying to do intervals like that in erg mode.
Quote Reply
Re: erg trainer question [philg] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
philg wrote:
I'd question why you're trying to do intervals like that in erg mode.

Why? We do lots of trainerroad erg workouts that have us doing intervals like that. Though if it has us to the point of almost grinding to a halt, then could be a sign we have our ftp set too high.
Quote Reply
Re: erg trainer question [bootsie_cat] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
bootsie_cat wrote:
It is because you are shooting for a number that is too high for you (at least right now).
You your power starts dropping, then the trainer tries to adjust to keep you at 400, so cadence gets harder to maintain, repeat, repeat, repeat down to 10 rpm.
Smart trainers go into the "cadence death spiral" when you are not holding the number that you set.

If you set 400- and kept holding 400 at 90 rpm or better there would not be an issue. In fact if you try to boost power by a measurable amount it will keep adjusting and cadence will increase.

400w is 400w no matter the cadence no?

or at 10 rpm i am putting out more torque than watts?



philg wrote:
I'd question why you're trying to do intervals like that in erg mode.

ramp test
Quote Reply
Re: erg trainer question [exxxviii] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
exxviii said, at that low of a speed the trainer isn't capable of producing enough resistance to do 400W. DCR just mentioned something similar in his Tacx Flux 2 review.
Quote Reply
Re: erg trainer question [synthetic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
As other have hinted at. I would not try intervals below like 50 rpms at higher wattages. Trainers simply are not engineered for the torque created at a really low cadence. Also, I'm not sure what value doing such low cadence training will do for you. If you are trying for weight training, then just go to leg presses and squats. Trainers are better used for aerobic fitness.
Quote Reply
Re: erg trainer question [nightfend] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
nightfend wrote:
As other have hinted at. I would not try intervals below like 50 rpms at higher wattages. Trainers simply are not engineered for the torque created at a really low cadence. Also, I'm not sure what value doing such low cadence training will do for you. If you are trying for weight training, then just go to leg presses and squats. Trainers are better used for aerobic fitness.

i guess it applies more for hill climbing. i like to stand up and mash the big gears while others sit and spin granny gear. but i guess changing my style of training knowing this via the trainer can only make me better
Quote Reply
Re: erg trainer question [synthetic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Maybe back into it by forgetting the number and ask if you have a training goal related to riding 10 rpm, if not then adjust the duration or load to keep the revs up. Or just do the same workout in non erg and see what the number look like
Last edited by: jroden: Jul 16, 20 15:09
Quote Reply
Re: erg trainer question [jroden] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jroden wrote:
Maybe back into it by forgetting the number and ask if you have a training goal related to riding 10 rpm, if not then adjust the duration or load to keep the revs up. Or just do the same workout in non erg and see what the number look like

i am sure we all hit that one hill where we run out of gearing and have to do that... unless you live somewhere flat.
Quote Reply
Re: erg trainer question [synthetic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
 

philg wrote:
I'd question why you're trying to do intervals like that in erg mode.


ramp test[/quote]
In that case its not an interval per se.

This is one of the problems with ramp tests imo in trying to determine ftp, people aren't willing to take an ego hit, and the likes of TR and Zwift want people to see bigger numbers.

The idea of the test is to go until you can't hold it STEADILY. If your cadence has dropped by more than about 4 or 5 rpm over the last couple of steps, then you are done. That's why its saying you haven't averaged whatever power it was meant to be.
In your case, I'd say you are probably 2 steps lower than that as a finish point.

Now if you were doing it as a straight out minute interval, my initial post remains.
Do them out of erg mode; Its quite possible being able to change gear a little to keep on top of cadence and you might be able to complete the intervals rather than getting your leg humped to death by the trainer equivalent of a jack russell.
It also gives you the feel of what those intensities feel like, unless you always ride on whats essentially a 15% gradient in 54/12 to hit those numbers.
Quote Reply
Re: erg trainer question [philg] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
philg wrote:


philg wrote:
I'd question why you're trying to do intervals like that in erg mode.


ramp test


In that case its not an interval per se.

This is one of the problems with ramp tests imo in trying to determine ftp, people aren't willing to take an ego hit, and the likes of TR and Zwift want people to see bigger numbers.

The idea of the test is to go until you can't hold it STEADILY. If your cadence has dropped by more than about 4 or 5 rpm over the last couple of steps, then you are done. That's why its saying you haven't averaged whatever power it was meant to be.
In your case, I'd say you are probably 2 steps lower than that as a finish point.

Now if you were doing it as a straight out minute interval, my initial post remains.
Do them out of erg mode; Its quite possible being able to change gear a little to keep on top of cadence and you might be able to complete the intervals rather than getting your leg humped to death by the trainer equivalent of a jack russell.
It also gives you the feel of what those intensities feel like, unless you always ride on whats essentially a 15% gradient in 54/12 to hit those numbers.[/quote]
i have also done it in interval training. training programs like zwift not really based on your ftp, at least im glad you can hit page up/down to adjust the interval.
Quote Reply