carlosflanders wrote:
I'm an anti-torque wrencher. 20 years in measurement science. Precisely for the reasons mentioned concerning calibration and thread condition I consider torque wrenches useless. If you're working on your own bike choose well-designed robust components that aren't sensitive to reasonable torque variations.
I guarantee that if you take 20 bike noobs, and give them no detailed instructions, and have them install a carbon stem + faceplate, their faceplate bolts will be all over the place in terms of tightness, from dangerously loose, to part-damaging tight. Not all carbon parts require such care, but it's really easy to get it wrong (permanently) in this area without a torque wrench.
If you have folks coming from experience with alloy faceplate and stem installation, they'll almost invariably torque it wayyy too high (yep did that) based on their experience with the alloy.
I was horrified at how off I was with my installations once I got a torque wrench - luckily, I had purchased the wrench right before doing the carbon install - my alloy faceplate bolts were over 2x the recommended tightness, which almost certainly would have broken the carbon pieces.