Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Prev Next
Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains
Quote | Reply
well here is the next thing for those folks on the pointy end of races or looking for the extract marginal gain:
https://silca.cc/...;utm_source=hs_email

Diamond polished, WS2 impinged, then ultrasonic waxed...will such a chain not only reduce drive chain power loss, BUT will it last longer and protect your drive train? I am assuming lower friction might mean lower chain wear?
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [s5100e] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pretty soon wireless electronic groups will cost less than chains. $350 for the Ti YBN chain bundle. Ouch.

I'm sure the cost is justified based on the materials and work-hours, but this is one silca product that I will pass on. If i had the talent, desire, etc to go for an hour record then i'd probably have to think long and hard about this. It's cool they are doing it...it's just not a product for me.
Last edited by: rob_bell: Apr 20, 21 9:16
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [rob_bell] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I agree with you this will not work as a product for me but for some people it is a reasonable item to consider. When you look at basic numbers say that drive train losses are 1-2% of over all power, unless you are pushing 300 watts or more you are maybe saving less than (because the comparison is another prepared low friction chain not sure how that compares to the 1-2% drive train loss chain system).. does that mean you save say 1 or 2 watts by using this chain? over another prepared chain, or vs a normally lubed chain? I would love to know what it means for certain situations like plebeian 200 watts or pro 300+ watts of power input what does this chain save vs other chain prep options?
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [s5100e] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have played around doing something similar in the past (but not with diamond dust as I am not a baller) - sadly don't have a good setup to test efficiency gains/losses. I tell myself it's faster though and that + the effort put into it has to count for some placebo watts at least.

It's a niche product, but I would guess it has an audience. At a certain point of course, it's hard to get that last percent of a percent of efficiency, at any cost.

My Blog - http://leegoocrap.blogspot.com
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [s5100e] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The standard for testing comes from Ceramicspeed.. and it's watts of loss calculated on 250w input. 2.8-3.0w loss is really good.. a Molten speed waxed DuraAce chain might cost 4.5 watts. A SecretBlend waxed DA chain will cost 3w and a Ceramicspeed prepped/waxed/powdered chain might do 2.8w. With this process, we can get that same DA chain into the 2-2.1w range, and if you maintain it properly, you can keep it under 2.5 w for thousands of km.

I should also point out that if you take out the cost of the SuperSecret Drip and the Secret Blend, our chain really isn't all that much more expensive than some of the other offerings out there..but we feel you really need that other stuff to keep the investment running as long as possible.

http://www.SILCA.cc
Check out my podcast, inside stories from more than 20 years of product and tech innovation from inside the Pro Peloton and Pro Triathlon worlds!
http://www.marginalgainspodcast.cc
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [joshatsilca] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Will the chains be stocked by international distributors?

I'm already partway down this path - sonic stripping chains to sell paired with a bottle of SSL
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [s5100e] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I wonder how it compares to Dan’s Ultra Optimized Chain, which is a great chain and about half the cost:
https://www.premierbike.com/...ucts/optimized-chain
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [Northy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Northy wrote:
I wonder how it compares to Dan’s Ultra Optimized Chain, which is a great chain and about half the cost:
https://www.premierbike.com/...ucts/optimized-chain
It's not half the cost when you factor in that you're getting both the hot melt and drip lube as well.

Benjamin Deal - Professional - Instagram - TriRig - Lodi Cyclery
Deals on Wheels - Results, schedule, videos, sponsors
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [Northy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I’ll weigh in - I have been doing metal finish optimization for a long long time (almost 20 years). Many sports, industries and products.

SILCA has a nice bundle. Thier chains are very very good - as are our Connex chains.

We carry the Connex 11 speed chain.

SILCA is offering a wide range of chains - so good on them for that. Thier bundle includes their drip wax and hot melt which is really what you need to keep a chain like this efficient, smooth and long lasting.

As for watt savings and driveline efficiency - our testing shows that a physicaly polished chain (plates, pins and rollers) gives you around 2.3 watts additional savings over a chain that has only been cleaned, run-in and waxed.

Dan Kennison

facebook: @triPremierBike
http://www.PremierBike.com
http://www.PositionOneSports.com
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [realbdeal] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
realbdeal wrote:
Northy wrote:
I wonder how it compares to Dan’s Ultra Optimized Chain, which is a great chain and about half the cost:
https://www.premierbike.com/...ucts/optimized-chain

It's not half the cost when you factor in that you're getting both the hot melt and drip lube as well.

Very true. And I hope I wasn't coming across as critical, I love Silca's stuff. I'm just genuinely curious since I race with one of the Premier chains.
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [joshatsilca] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What about when I run the powder... how does it change the 4.5w loss?

And while I have you if you don’t mind ... any idea how much I’m giving up with my Sram 1130 chain vs a Dura Ace as you quoted?

Seems like your chain could be much more than 2w faster than what I do today
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [joshatsilca] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks for the info Josh, for crude comparison what is a "normal out of the box chain watts loss? The other data is really informative. I also saw your video, again 10,000 km of life vs what one would expect from say a non prepared chain? what I seem to see on Adam's site is the worst case is 1000 km life for a chain? so is it fair or accurate to say 5 or more (maybe 10x) the life of a normal untreated chain? So then the math starts to make sense for even punters like me?
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [joshatsilca] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I remember leaving a comment on one of the early ask Josh episodes about polishing a chain... never got mentioned... now I see why :D

My Blog - http://leegoocrap.blogspot.com
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [joshatsilca] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
maybe math is not my strong point but to me the cost is not that exorbitant if one assumes that the chain will last 3x longer than a typically prepared (home prepared) chain.. chains say YBN cost about $50 so the YBN chain option with Silca is $225... then back out the costs of the added items ca $80 so that leaves 145 for a highly and carefully prepared chain. Then the math works at 3 chains, so if it did last 3x as long you are break even at worse case but you also get the benefit of a chain prep you can not do at home.... the economics do not sound so bad and the upside is worth maybe a few watts saved or a few extra KPH each ride. God Josh please stop innovating! it is getting hard to explain to my spouse why I have so many Silca things!
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [dkennison] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
dkennison wrote:
As for watt savings and driveline efficiency - our testing shows that a physicaly polished chain (plates, pins and rollers) gives you around 2.3 watts additional savings over a chain that has only been cleaned, run-in and waxed.

So would one be able to extrapolate that taking a chain that has been ridden for some time, then degreased, cleaned, and lubed with this super special wax will save watts as well over a fresh chain?

Stephen J

I believe my local reality has been violated.
____________________________________________
Happiness = Results / (Expectations)^2
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [stephenj] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
To a point. As a chain is worn it - it streaches. When it streatches the high points of the metal surfaces move.

If a new chain is treated properly all the high points are eliminated creating a honed platue surface. If kept lubrucated the fast chain lasts longer as it streaches.

Dan Kennison

facebook: @triPremierBike
http://www.PremierBike.com
http://www.PositionOneSports.com
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [dkennison] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
dkennison wrote:
To a point. As a chain is worn it - it streaches. When it streatches the high points of the metal surfaces move.

If a new chain is treated properly all the high points are eliminated creating a honed platue surface. If kept lubrucated the fast chain lasts longer as it streaches.

I may be wrong here, but my understanding is the source of the elongation of a chain is not that the metal actually stretched but that as the rollers wear they cause the chain to elongate. Now saying that the places where the outer plates touch each other does move in this case. I believe one of the fast chain companies does a run in before preparing with the super lubricants to glaze the surface but that is not the same as diamond polishing which physically removes the imperfections from the surfaces. I actually wonder if a run in would actually cause more problems than solutions because the imperfections may cause grooves in the opposite plate?

What I understand is the reason a well lubricated chain lasts longer is not due to stretch but rather the reduction in the wear of the roller and pin interfaces, so in fact it does not "stretch" since the elongation is the basis of chain replacement and therefore the longer it takes to reach the elongation point is a tribute to the quality of the lubrication to protect the pins and rollers from wear.

In the end this whole idea of polishing then impinging with WS2 is not really new it is just new in this application.
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [joshatsilca] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
 
thanks for this info. to clarify, over just a normal off the shelf chain and a normal non-wax lube, this prepared chain would save 3-4 watts at 250?
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [buzz] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
OK, so here is a rough breakdown of the scale of things.
Ceramicspeed 250w input testing

11speed chain with WhiteLightning: 9.1w
11speed chain with Tri-Flow: 7.2 w

11 speed chain with factory grease: 5.5-7.5 watts loss
11 speed chain with straight paraffin: 4.8-5.0 watts
11 speed chain with Synergetic: 4.7-4.9w
11 speed chain with MSW: 4.4-4.6 watts
11 speed chain with SuperSecret: 3.8-4.0w
11 speed chain with SILCA hot wax: 2.8-3.0
11 speed chain Ceramicspeed race prepared/powdered: 2.6-2.8w
11 speed chain SILCA Diamond polish/wax prepared: 2.0-2.2w

http://www.SILCA.cc
Check out my podcast, inside stories from more than 20 years of product and tech innovation from inside the Pro Peloton and Pro Triathlon worlds!
http://www.marginalgainspodcast.cc
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [joshatsilca] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Wow that is very interesting data. So the old belief that chain loss in the whole picture of where your power goes of say 1-2% if off by a bit, for the worst case it is 3.6% and the best case it is 0.8% power loss due to the chain friction. That is eye opening. If I understand correctly then at the pedal you are inputting 150 watts and when the rubber hits the road so to speak there is worst case 241 watts and best case 248 watts actually moving the bike forward. Is that correct?
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [joshatsilca] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
No test for rock n roll gold? A lot of us use that.

Anyway, manufacturers need to stop greasing their high end chains. Civilians aren't buying dura-ace chains. Those that do buy them know how to take care of them. It is sad that 1st step after obtaining a new chain is an ultrasonic bath....
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [joshatsilca] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey Josh- I heard a rumor that 12sp xtr chains have better shifting performance than 11sp dura ace on an 11sp system. Any idea/opinion if true?

Dimond Bikes Superfan
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [Dilbert] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Rock n Roll Gold 11sp chain ~5.1-5.3w

If you're a wet lube person look at Synergetic.. faster and significantly reduced wear according to data that isn't mine.. AND no PFAS we are working hard to bend the industry away from PFAS

http://www.SILCA.cc
Check out my podcast, inside stories from more than 20 years of product and tech innovation from inside the Pro Peloton and Pro Triathlon worlds!
http://www.marginalgainspodcast.cc
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [Dilbert] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I DO want manufacturers to keep greasing their chains.

As otherwise by the time it get to me, it's been in a warehouse in Japan for fortnight, in steel box on a Quay for week. On a ship stuck in the Suez for 6 weeks, on another Quay for 2 weeks, in another warehouse for a week or 3, in post office van, and then left dumped on my doorstep in a thin cardboard packet whilst it pisses down for several hours until I get home. It'll be a rusty POS.


And secondly, the grease will slow down those who don't know anything about friction and have left the grease on along with a top up of nice thick mineral oil.
Quote Reply
Re: Silca prepared chains... 30% less friction that other prepared chains [joshatsilca] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks for sharing the data. I’ve been waiting to try out one of your chains since you mentioned in the podcast that pre-waxed chains were on the horizon

Matt
Quote Reply

Prev Next