Pun_Times wrote:
That said, only a minute faster than an optimized old Shiv isn’t much given that the old Shiv always seemed to be a ways back in all the other manufacturers drag charts.Triathlon Forum
Login required to started new threads
Login required to post replies
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pun_Times]
[ In reply to ]
This. And it's still fugly, expensive and still a hard NO.
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer]
[ In reply to ]
When you say the fuel cell can be cut to fit based on rider morphology, does this mean it could be custom fit to any height even if it’s not one of the 4 standard sizes. For example, if the rider wanted to cut it to be in line and level with the top tube then this is possible?
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer]
[ In reply to ]
GatorRacer wrote:
Hey All, I am here to answer some questions about the bike.
- The hydration system does come in multiple sizes - There are currently 4 sizes based on the change in top tube height that help put the Fuelcell within the expected saddle adjustment ranges. The system can also be cut-to-fit for a rider that has a unique morphology.
- The frame has a permanently installed conduit within the frame that makes bladder removal very easy. You can push or pull the bladder system out with 1-hand. The permanent conduit makes sure you arent battling debris, tools, cabling, etc...while performing this process.
- The photo of the clear frame is not the production system - It is a mockup - The way it was made does not allow for the internal conduit and production lid system, etc...
- The rear reservoir is removeable! It is only 2 bolts and it comes off. Of course this feature is a big aero benefit at yaw, so removing it is not recommended but its the riders choice.
- BTA, TT and ST mounting points are provided for flexibility in mounting additional storage/nutrition
- The front nosecone is removable to allow access to all of the cabling and hydration straw for further ease of use
Come by the SHIV Launch display next to Ceramic Speed by Huggos this week to check it out in person!
Thanks for all the info!
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pyrenean Wolf]
[ In reply to ]
Excellent analysis Wolf.
Also, It would be great to have a reference how much faster is this new Shiv compared to the new generation of Aero Road bike like the new Venge or S5 Disc. I know it's going to be compare apples to oranges as they have different geometry and applications however as a consumer and amateur cyclist and triathlete I'm not planning to get the new generation bikes with disc brakes that are rated USD+10k each and if we are talking about the same marginal gains between the new Shiv and Venge (2, 3watts) I would just get the new Aero road bike.
Also, It would be great to have a reference how much faster is this new Shiv compared to the new generation of Aero Road bike like the new Venge or S5 Disc. I know it's going to be compare apples to oranges as they have different geometry and applications however as a consumer and amateur cyclist and triathlete I'm not planning to get the new generation bikes with disc brakes that are rated USD+10k each and if we are talking about the same marginal gains between the new Shiv and Venge (2, 3watts) I would just get the new Aero road bike.
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint]
[ In reply to ]
On the shiv's unique aero features:
The splitter in the back will have some benefits at yaw as mentioned, but also at 0 yaw only from the fact it's cleanly splitting the vortices from the thighs as well as potentially providing some flow reattachment through certain areas of the pedalling cycle. Gains will be greater the narrower your net stance is. Any word on the q-factor?
The fork is a very interesting piece. At 0 yaw there is a benefit from distancing the blades and crown from the wheel due to flow velocity in that area. The blades and nose cone area is a strange looking spot from an interference drag perspective. When you have openings, flow going through them usually increases with speed, compressing until it chokes and a stagnation bubble forms. What happens then is the rest of the fluid goes around that virtual sheild. Not sure at which speed that might happen on the shiv, but it's been designed to acheive that, otherwise we wouldn't have that nose cone shaped this way.
Bikes do not ride themselves so the fact this fork arrangement creates a larger front end is inconsequential to frontal area when you put a rider on the bike, due to the legs. It changes the Cd and that is the interesting part. If you could break it down, you would see the legs are a really important source of drag as a percentage of CdA. And you can't really bend or incline them with the same flexibility as the torso, head and arms to tune for drag (except riding knees in). The wake generated by the fork has an impact on the legs inbound flow, which can have an impact on leg drag. Solving this as a fork-leg-rear wheel/splitter system can lead to lower drag overall. Basically, you use the fork to engineer the flow hitting the leg so you can more efficiently manage the flow that leaves it.
Can't wait to see WT reports on this. I bet drag for the bike alone will be higher than usual at low yaw angles, but that's pointless. Drag with a rider on will be competitive at 0 yaw with a P5(x) and will beat it at >15°.
The splitter in the back will have some benefits at yaw as mentioned, but also at 0 yaw only from the fact it's cleanly splitting the vortices from the thighs as well as potentially providing some flow reattachment through certain areas of the pedalling cycle. Gains will be greater the narrower your net stance is. Any word on the q-factor?
The fork is a very interesting piece. At 0 yaw there is a benefit from distancing the blades and crown from the wheel due to flow velocity in that area. The blades and nose cone area is a strange looking spot from an interference drag perspective. When you have openings, flow going through them usually increases with speed, compressing until it chokes and a stagnation bubble forms. What happens then is the rest of the fluid goes around that virtual sheild. Not sure at which speed that might happen on the shiv, but it's been designed to acheive that, otherwise we wouldn't have that nose cone shaped this way.
Bikes do not ride themselves so the fact this fork arrangement creates a larger front end is inconsequential to frontal area when you put a rider on the bike, due to the legs. It changes the Cd and that is the interesting part. If you could break it down, you would see the legs are a really important source of drag as a percentage of CdA. And you can't really bend or incline them with the same flexibility as the torso, head and arms to tune for drag (except riding knees in). The wake generated by the fork has an impact on the legs inbound flow, which can have an impact on leg drag. Solving this as a fork-leg-rear wheel/splitter system can lead to lower drag overall. Basically, you use the fork to engineer the flow hitting the leg so you can more efficiently manage the flow that leaves it.
Can't wait to see WT reports on this. I bet drag for the bike alone will be higher than usual at low yaw angles, but that's pointless. Drag with a rider on will be competitive at 0 yaw with a P5(x) and will beat it at >15°.
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD]
[ In reply to ]
BryanD wrote:
No. It's a bladder system with a straw. The bladder fits into the draft box. It's not an open tank.
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic]
[ In reply to ]
Oh how wrong you are. Let me upload a photo
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD]
[ In reply to ]
I'm just going on the Talbot video and Sarah said she can fill it on the fly. Explain that?
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic]
[ In reply to ]
Shambolic wrote:
I'm just going on the Talbot video and Sarah said she can fill it on the fly. Explain that?You can fill it THROUGH a fly. So, ya know, pee into it....
Alex Arman
Strava
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic]
[ In reply to ]
She pretty much described how to fill it on the fly and according to her, you just remove the top and squirt away. Plus, the opening seems awfully narrow to try to squeeze a filled bladder through.
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic]
[ In reply to ]
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD]
[ In reply to ]
Lol really? I suggest you read back through the thread about that picture...
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic]
[ In reply to ]
You can see the bladder in the video. You don't fill up the box.
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD]
[ In reply to ]
Explain the Sarah True video showing off her bike explaining she can flip the top off and fill it on the fly?
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic]
[ In reply to ]
Explain the plastic bladder you can so easily see in that box.
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic]
[ In reply to ]
At 1:53 in the video, you can clearly see a plastic bladder. You will not be refilling this on the fly. No one could do that while riding. It's a bladder that holds 2 bottles of fluid with a straw.
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Runorama]
[ In reply to ]
Runorama wrote:
Any word on the q-factor?I'd imagine it's the OSBB BB, unless they decide to break their recent trend with this bike.
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jamlo]
[ In reply to ]
If it has a bladder you couldn't fill on the fly. If it had an plastic removable lining with an open top you potentially could fill it. Certainly would be hard to fill on the fly regardless...
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic]
[ In reply to ]
What do you think this is? It's a plastic bladder
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD]
[ In reply to ]
Very conclusive picture...
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic]
[ In reply to ]
Seriously? The origins of the clear frame was well understood. Do you honestly think Specilaized wouldn’t show a bladder on their instagram if there wasn’t one? Keep in mind they have a patent on a bladder hydration system.
I don’t understand why this is so difficult....
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
I don’t understand why this is so difficult....
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD]
[ In reply to ]
Why would you put a bladder there if you already have a tank. You need a bladder in a frame. I'm sure Sarah would know how to fill her hydration?
I don't understand why this is so difficult...
I don't understand why this is so difficult...
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic]
[ In reply to ]
I’ll call Specialized on your behalf
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [gregtay]
[ In reply to ]
gregtay wrote:
I was curious to see what it looks like without the sail...no sponsors | no races | nothing to see here
Lol just do it on yours and then pass the info on to Sarah as it could hurt her on race day. Cheers