Tom A. wrote:
Also...I think you overestimate the ability for this particular industry to "collude". I try not to ascribe "evil intent" to actions that can easily be explained by mere incompetence ;-)
Yup. This is why I think that many (but likely not all) government conspiracy theories aren't real. In most cases, I think it's less likely that the conspiracy is true, and more likely that they're not actually organized enough to pull it off (and that everyone involved would keep their mouths shut).
The other thing about road tubeless that a lot of people forget is air travel. When I was traveling and racing all the time, I had to deflate my tires most or all of the way, depending on the bike box used. That's a recipe for a sealant mess, and it made much more sense to use inner tubes.
I'm in the camp of "tried tubeless for every application - tons of different tires, tons of different wheels... I'm mostly back on tubes". I do use it for MTB, because of the arguments laid out in this thread (i.e. the advantages are clear). I'm also very picky about what wheels and tires I use. I don't have an air compressor, and I don't want to cut tires off because they're too tight (been there). I've had great success with using Hed Ardennes/Belgium rims (yes, they're approved for XC mountain use... and the inner rim profile seems to be very well done), with Maxxis tubeless-ready tires. They inflate with a floor pump, and I don't need tire levers. I've also gravitated towards Caffelatex and Orange Seal. The Bontrager TLR stuff seems to seal very well, but I had trouble with it separating over time... the bottle looked like mostly water, with all of the chunks glued to the inside of the bottle (no amount of shaking did anything). Seemed to do the same thing inside my tires, and it leaked quite a bit. I had a sealed/unopened bottle that sat for about 2 years - completely unusable when I opened it.
If road tubeless can get to a consistent level that's easy to install, I'm open to trying again. I see a lot of bike industry people being in support of it, but most don't fly to race often or do a heavy triathlon training schedule, and they can mess with their bikes/wheels/tires at the office during their work day. And in many cases they're getting free wheels and/or tires. Nothing against them - it's just not your average triathlon/road consumer.