Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Prev Next
Gravel Bike. Who has what?
Quote | Reply
Looking at getting a Gravel Bike for a bit of off-road fun.
Not a lot of choices in my local area and was just wondering if anyone can recommend some brands I can research. Want a 1x
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
If you care about brand pedigree and bragging rights skip this post. I went to a local LBS and they showed me a Fuji Jari ... its features and capabilities were quite impressive. Tire clearance, mounting options and versatility. Not to mention always on sale somewhere.
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Iā€™m super happy with my Santa Cruz Stigmana; not the most obvious choice but hit the right notes for me.
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I had a 2011 Trek X01 CX bike that is converted to gravel over the year and it worked fine for 98% of the rides I go on. As I started entering longer and more adventurous tires I realized I was going to need wider tires (the Trek could run 38 rear, 40 up front). I have some epic rides planned for next year and just picked up a new 2019 Salsa Warbird and am in love. The big thing for me was the ability to run either 700c or 650b wheels, which allows me to go up to a 2.1ā€ mountain bike tire. If youā€™re just getting started keep an eye out on something used until you learn what type of terrain you enjoy... gravel is an all encompassing word.
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jonboy wrote:
Looking at getting a Gravel Bike for a bit of off-road fun.
Not a lot of choices in my local area and was just wondering if anyone can recommend some brands I can research. Want a 1x

I have a Raleigh Clubman. I built some 650b wheels for it and run Clement 42mm tires (same outer diameter as 700c x 28, so I can still run the fenders it came with) and it's awesome. It's not 1x but nothing really stopping me from putting a 1x crank on it if I wanted to do that.

There are a LOT of choices out there these days, from using a CX frame to a rigid MTB frame with drop bars.

Less is more.
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jonboy wrote:
Looking at getting a Gravel Bike for a bit of off-road fun.
Not a lot of choices in my local area and was just wondering if anyone can recommend some brands I can research. Want a 1x

You might check this thread.... 9 pages of gravel bike porn and discussion
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Big brand- Trek Checkpoint
Other popular bikes- Santa Cruz Stigmata, Ibis Hakka MX, Niner.
Scott makes a nice gravel bike too-

Obscure but nice- Norco.
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
 
You could do a lot worse than a Felt Breed: https://feltbicycles.com/...-30-gravel-road-bike
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Salsa Warbird, carbon frame with Force drive train. Great bike!
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Chan] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I also picked up a Fuji Jari. I was looking at the Ibis and the Norco but decided that I wanted something a little bit more beater so as to ride around the city and commute without worrying and wanted to save some money so as to get my next mountain bike sooner and radder.

Itā€™s got good spec, great versatility, very good tire clearance and options for adding 650B and all sorts of panniers and fenders. And, the price is right. Iā€™m not gonna be getting any elite cyclocross podiums but itā€™s perfectly capable. W a small portion of the money I saved I added a stages left-only power meter and now this is my main non-mtb bike
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [devolikewhoa83] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Raleigh Stuntman. I love it. No longer available, sadly.
Last edited by: hiro11: Nov 3, 18 14:30
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jonboy wrote:
Looking at getting a Gravel Bike ...Want a 1x

While a lot of people do 1X, it probably isn't the best for gravel if there is any sustained climbing. 1X is nice for CX where weight and simplicity matter a lot more.
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have a Cannondale CAADX that I'm about to put an adventure crank on (most likely 48/32) to replace the 46/36 it came with, but I ardently did not want a 1X because I like closer gear ratios. I looked really hard at upgrading and at the Specialized Diverge, but at the end of the day there's nothing right now spec'd such that I am willing to shell out for it. If I'm going to have to tinker, I may as well upgrade the perfectly good bike I already have - as much as not doing n+1 pains me.

My husband has a Trek Checkpoint that he absolutely adores. It was a replacement for a Ridley X-Trail that he really, really wanted but just never fit him quite right. Those are both are great bikes.
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I just got a Niner from Competitive Cyclist. It was $2200 with Ultegra components, Zipp service course fixed parts, and some nice Easton hoops. Iā€™ve only ridden it to the track so far for run intervals since Iā€™m tapering for Ironman Arizona and not ready to focus on cross/gravel, but itā€™s fun riding thru ditches and stuff taking shortcuts I couldnā€™t take with my tri bike! šŸ˜„

Oh, I went 2x but theyā€™re really good to work with if you want to switch components out.



Cheers,

thechromedome
http://www.favoritefinishlines.blogspot.com
http://www.cupcakecartel.org
My 20% off code for 2018 FS Series races: tricred18
"there are no drafters in heaven" - C Bonner
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm in the process of converting to disc... so my Gravel bike is my main road bike right now.

Parlee Z-Zero XD.. 8070/9170 Integra/DA mix, Enve 4.5ARs
Last edited by: spntrxi: Nov 3, 18 15:10
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
S-works crux. I think it was a Dirty Kanza edition or something like that. No complaints. I wouldn't want to switch it to 1x.

Dimond Bikes Superfan
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I love my Salsa Warbird.

clm
Nashville, TN
https://twitter.com/ironclm | http://ironclm.typepad.com
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have a motobecane cross bike. I want a Otso Warkin. Maybe in a few years I'll upgrade.
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jonboy wrote:
Looking at getting a Gravel Bike for a bit of off-road fun.
Not a lot of choices in my local area and was just wondering if anyone can recommend some brands I can research. Want a 1x

what i've found is that the same ambivalence to geometric care that plagued tri bikes until, this decade now plagues gravel bikes. this is in 2 areas: bottom bracket drop; and more importantly fit. stack and reach type stuff. nobody really knows why they're making their bikes the way they're making them. or if they do they aren't expressing it.

the first thing you need to do, in my opinion, is decide what gravel means to you. as a bike style. a riding style. does it mean mostly road, in terms of position? it does for me. but it might not for you. once you decide that, then you should look carefully at the geometries of these bikes. i can point to bikes that i absolutely love in terms of value, spec, features, but i just could never ride them.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This is not the most popular brand out there but I absolutely LOVE my Foundry Overland. I've used it all over Bend, OR for everything from singletrack MTB trails to fire roads and even as a standby road machine. One of my favorite bikes I've owned!
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I agree with this-
Part of this is forks- Enve and Parlee only make 47mm rake forks in cross/gravel models with the most clearance.
For me, the 55mm rake Seven Matador fork was a game changer. Handles so nice with a 71 degree head angle- And I was able to design all of the toe clip overlap out of the bike-

Other two things that bug me are:
1.) Components/groups. SRAM is firmly in the 1x camp, Shimano 2x.
There are problems with both of these approaches-
SRAM doesn't make clutch derailleurs for their road type derailleurs- So no Red or ETAP for wide range cassettes.
SRAM ETAP front derailleur runs into large tires (in some cases).
Shimano doesn't make the cassette sizes that they need- They need an 11-36 for gravel.
Shimano RX derailleur can be challenged when it is run with a large cassette (like an 11-40)- This is stupid, you want to be able to use low gears!
Lastly, the fact that you can't mix DI2 road and mtb front and rear derailleurs for a 2x setup. If you could do this, you could just use an XT or XTR rear derailleur for z 2x gravel setup. This is only a software hack, doesn't even take new parts.
2.) Frame parts to allow for short chain stays, big tires and 2x all at the same time.
Framebuilders needs tubes and/or yokes to allow for this to happen. Already happening, but a lot of bikes have really long stays to accomplish both-
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [bootsie_cat] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
bootsie_cat wrote:
I agree with this-
Part of this is forks- Enve and Parlee only make 47mm rake forks in cross/gravel models with the most clearance.
For me, the 55mm rake Seven Matador fork was a game changer. Handles so nice with a 71 degree head angle- And I was able to design all of the toe clip overlap out of the bike-

Other two things that bug me are:
1.) Components/groups. SRAM is firmly in the 1x camp, Shimano 2x.
There are problems with both of these approaches-
SRAM doesn't make clutch derailleurs for their road type derailleurs- So no Red or ETAP for wide range cassettes.
SRAM ETAP front derailleur runs into large tires (in some cases).
Shimano doesn't make the cassette sizes that they need- They need an 11-36 for gravel.
Shimano RX derailleur can be challenged when it is run with a large cassette (like an 11-40)- This is stupid, you want to be able to use low gears!
Lastly, the fact that you can't mix DI2 road and mtb front and rear derailleurs for a 2x setup. If you could do this, you could just use an XT or XTR rear derailleur for z 2x gravel setup. This is only a software hack, doesn't even take new parts.
2.) Frame parts to allow for short chain stays, big tires and 2x all at the same time.
Framebuilders needs tubes and/or yokes to allow for this to happen. Already happening, but a lot of bikes have really long stays to accomplish both-

clearance is a big deal. i run eTap and my bike is built with a 425mm chainstay. luckily. or, fortuitiously - because i chose the geometry ;-)

you mentioned groupkits. i think the single biggest issue now is gearing. gravel bikes need to be geared low. but they are built with a road motif. if you want to stay with a road stance width, a road crank, 110bcd isnt small enough. 34t isn't small enough.

in january a bunch of stuff is launching, i think, that should speak to forks, steering geometry, shoe overlap, gearing, etc., for gravel.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply


There are some options for sub-compact currently, such as FSA Adventure 46/30 which I have above with Stages PM on my Kona. I made lots of use of the 30-32 gearing yesterday riding, rather than walking, really steep loose stuff.

Other options from IRD, Sugino, Easton, maybe Rotor too? I suspect Shimano and SRAM will eventually have to offer something...do you know anything else here?
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [brando] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Praxisworks has subcompact options, too.

Now, if anyone knows of anything that will work on my Cannondale BB30 natively, I'd be interested to hear about it.
Quote Reply
Re: Gravel Bike. Who has what? [Jonboy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This is your first gravel/cross bike?

Guessing yes- So get something used like an older Cannondale caad cx-9/super X if you must need disc and spend your money on a nice set of tubeless/wide wheels with nice tires so you can actually ride and don't have to worry about flats.
Quote Reply

Prev Next