Fishbum wrote:
Lol. PR stunt. Not saying she's not doing a good thing I just possibly question her motives. I think you need to separate her fundraising from the 50/50 claim.
NO NO....they are tightly coupled. Let's say I raise money for orphans in Nepal or in India. I could just say, "hey, I know these orphans, give me your money and I will collect money from you and give it to their local school, get the school internet access, get them tablets and bring them into the internet age".
I can assure you if I went out to my network, almost no one would give me money. There are plenty of orphans who need better education.
But let's say I want to raise money for those orphans and climb Everest. Suddenly my fundraising ability will go up 10-20x even though I fund my entire Everest expedition with my OWN money and give the exact same donor money to the orphans. But my donors would expect me to climb Everest legit. No cheating, no helicopter rides, no going to camp 4 and saying I did the summit.
I personally have a beef with people tying fundraising to personal selfish achievement. I'm all for self personal athletic pursuits, but I always question when the selfish athletic pursuits happen on the backs of a "good cause". Personally I am happy if someone wants to do any insanely personal athletic pursuit and I am happy when they also donate to a cause with "nothing in it for them".
It's when people use a cause to do a selfish personal pursuit, that I actually have cognitive dissonace about the entire pursuit.....I'm basically thinking, "you're full of shit, you would never care about said orphans or whoever, you just want to do the fun athletic thing".
So when someone markets that they are going to do something superlatively athletic to raise money for XYZ, I'm scrutinizing the claim, because they are claiming to do something to fund a personal pursuit of selfishness.
If she just claimed she was going to do 50/50/50 "just because it sounds hard", then I'm not paying any attention. If she's claiming to do 50/50/50 and raising money for something while covering the expedition, then the scrutiny is higher.....and it becomes tightly coupled.
Having said all that, I really want her to hit the athletic achievement legitimately. That would be ultra cool. And I want her to do it legit for both athletic purposes and for the authenticity of the entire enterprise that she's launched.