Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Crack where seatstay meets chainstay, is it fixable?
Quote | Reply
I have 2012 Quintana Roo Lucero that is cracked where the seatstay meets the chainstay. From what I can find online, QR made the dropouts replaceable...but this isn't the dropout (I think). It looks like it is a separate part that is bonded to the frame. I took it to a local bike shop where the mechanic said it is not replaceable. He did suggest that if the part is aluminum I might be able to weld it in order to save the frame. Anyone have any luck fixing an issue like this? The crack doesn't change if I apply pressure with the skewer locked down. moves a bit if I remove the skewer and press though.

https://imgur.com/a/SSTzbeU

Maybe a convenient excuse to buy a new bike?...
Last edited by: LuceroNoOh: Jun 26, 18 19:20
Quote Reply
Re: Crack where seatstay meets chainstay, is it fixable? [LuceroNoOh] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Welding aluminum... Yes, it can be done, but usually requires a post-weld heat treatment (depending on particular alloy). Basically, though, you're just kicking the can down the road a bit, and it's going to fail again soon.

---------------------------------------------------------------------
Some are born to move the world to live their fantasies...

https://triomultisport.com/
http://www.mjolnircycles.com/
Quote Reply
Re: Crack where seatstay meets chainstay, is it fixable? [brider] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
welding aluminium is often a PITA, first off, if you dont know what grade, then could have a hard time matching the filler material (and some grades cant be welded at least not reliably). also cast parts often have impurities in the metal that make them dificult to weld.

apart from all that, as soon as you weld that the heat will travel up to the carbon joint, so you'd need to remove it from the carbon frame to weld, in which case it would be best just to replace the part if available from QR, or get one from a scrap frame.
Quote Reply
Re: Crack where seatstay meets chainstay, is it fixable? [LuceroNoOh] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Agreed, new bike time.

I had my Crack and Fail do what it says on the tin, and not replaced under warranty - news to me and the bike shop that the minimum extension line had to be not in line with the top of the seat tube, but visible through the slot in the seat tube - long story short, horrible to deal with, only got a discount on a new bike that would fail anyway... had it rewelded by a guy who does rewelding for trials motorbikes and suchlike, still cracked again.

Perfect excuse for a new frame or new bike.
Quote Reply