OK, so, I'm having a dispute with a buddy about bike gearing and its effects.
Let's say there are two bikes: mtn bike with big gears (Big Gear Bike) and a fast bike with low gears (Low Gear Bike). They are going up a hill (so, no wind, just power and cadence and gears).
He contends that the Big Gear Bike will take less power (and, at a higher cadence) and will go faster than the Low Gear Bike, which will be slower even at higher power and lower cadence. IOW, that the Big Gear Bike will take less power to move forward up the hill faster than the Low Gear Bike ... that this is the benefit of the Big Gear Bike.
I contend that power is power, and that the only benefit of the Big Gear Bike is that it enables you to spin at a higher cadence, which is better for humans to spin at 90 than 40; whereas, at 40 cadence in the Low Gear Bike it's hard to stay upright on a steep hill. But, that at the same power the bikes will move forward at the same rate, albeit at a different cadence (Big Gear Bike will spin faster using bigger gears; Low Gear Bike will spin slower using its lower gearing (i.e., its biggest gears are just too small going up a steep hill).
Let's say there are two bikes: mtn bike with big gears (Big Gear Bike) and a fast bike with low gears (Low Gear Bike). They are going up a hill (so, no wind, just power and cadence and gears).
He contends that the Big Gear Bike will take less power (and, at a higher cadence) and will go faster than the Low Gear Bike, which will be slower even at higher power and lower cadence. IOW, that the Big Gear Bike will take less power to move forward up the hill faster than the Low Gear Bike ... that this is the benefit of the Big Gear Bike.
I contend that power is power, and that the only benefit of the Big Gear Bike is that it enables you to spin at a higher cadence, which is better for humans to spin at 90 than 40; whereas, at 40 cadence in the Low Gear Bike it's hard to stay upright on a steep hill. But, that at the same power the bikes will move forward at the same rate, albeit at a different cadence (Big Gear Bike will spin faster using bigger gears; Low Gear Bike will spin slower using its lower gearing (i.e., its biggest gears are just too small going up a steep hill).