In Reply To:
Is it just me though or as soon as the cop yelled at me the first time, I would have pulled over. Whether asked to or not.
Seems to me there was lack of judgement on both parties. Mostly with the officer but if there is one thing I have learned, if you treat the police with respect and don't give them any lip, chances are they will let you go on your way.
I agree. Even though the officer was wrong, the cyclists exacerbated the situation. Did they really think that the guy was just going to let it drop and allow them to ride away? There doesn't seem to be a dispute that the officer was using his lights and siren so it's pretty obvious that he was telling them to pull over.
I'm not taking the officer's side in this. The story definitely suggests that he was out of line but after reading the first page, it was very easy to predict the outcome...which could have been avoided if the cyclists stopped and respectfully requested to speak with the officer's supervisor.
I can tell you for certain that this approach can work. I was riding in bumper-to-bumper traffic through Laguna Beach one weekend and decided it was safer to split the two northbound lanes of traffic than try to navigate the narrow space between the right lane and the parked cars. A police officer on foot yelled at me to stop doing what I was doing and I told her that what I was doing was legal. Her response was that if I didn't stop doing it, she would give me a ticket. So...I pulled over, walked up to her and asked her to show me what vehicle code I was violating. She started to get pissy with me so I asked her, "Will you please call your Watch Commander and have him or her meet us here to discuss it." For one reason or another, she decided she didn't want to do that, so I asked her if I could go. She told me I could and I went back to splitting the traffic. The whole thing probably cost me 3 or 4 minutes...much better than what these guys went through.