windschatten wrote:
echappist wrote:
trail wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Maybe you missed where I first said â The only way to get good racing in a pack is to practice riding in a pack.â
That help? Separately, is it better to show up with no engine and get dropped?
I love it when someone in another thread tries to "roadie-splain" the significance of bike handling skills to a regular in our classics thread. :)
Said âsplainer probably has no idea just how accomplished Carl Spackler is as a road racer
He may be a f...goat on the crit circus, but telling a road racing Newby that Zwift racing is a great way to prepare for crit âphysiologyâ (whatever he thinks that entails), is poor advice.
Two things. First, your most recent argument (re: physiology) is completely irrelevant to the bike handling aspect quoted in your most recent post.
Next, of course Zwift racing doesn't duplicate the surge/coast dynamics as well as IRL technical crit does, but highly precise duplication of such dynamics isn't needed when the training stimulus is sufficiently close, and Zwift racing certainly does that. What is needed is the right type of stimuli to force the body to be able to adapt to the constant surges. For the most physiologically demanding crits (those with narrow roads and short straightaways), that's the ability to lay down short spurts of power for 10-20 seconds at 200% FTP or more, recover (combination of coasting and pedaling at up to 60% FTP), before laying down similar amount of power again. Rinse and repeat, until 40 minutes has been reached.
Tabatas could lead to the ability to do this, but I never did true Tabatas back when I raced, and I managed to cope just fine. What I did focus on was over-under intervals where I had to do over 130% for a minute, recover at 90%, and repeat. That, and other types of over-under intervals made sure that I could weather the type of surges that occur in some of the most physiologically demanding of crits (see below). For this particular race I did, there were some 50+ surges where I at least temporarily exceeded 200% FTP. In training, none of my rides came close to being as full of surges, yet the training applied the right stimuli, and those are substantially similar to the stimuli induced by a Zwift crit race. If nothing else, Zwift crit race is essentially a long over-under work out, with 30-60 second bursts that come pretty close to 130%, while recover at ~65-70%. Perhaps not as ideal as some of the more specialized training, but it certainly stresses the system that need to be stressed so that one could handle the surges.