scorpio516 wrote:
slowguy wrote:
BLeP wrote:
JasoninHalifax wrote:
BLeP wrote:
JasoninHalifax wrote:
Isnât that how it is now though? If its a sport where thereâs no âmenâsâ and âwomenâsâ, then thereâs just âthe teamâ. Eg football, hockey in many areas, artistic swimming.Sure for those sports. How about basketball. Should there be a team for basketball? Tennis?
Thereâs menâs and womenâs basketball. Same in tennis, soccer, swimming, water polo etc etc.
Thereâs virtually no womenâs football. There is womenâs hockey, but in a lot of areas there isnât enough participation (either through interest or availability) to have a womenâs league. Thereâs no menâs artistic swimming. So if a man wants to do artistic swimming, heâs got to join âthe teamâ which will be all women.
Yes I understand all that. The poster I replied to suggested we do away with menâs and womenâs sports. Just have teams.
So should we do away with womenâs basketball? Let the womens try out for the basketball team?
Or let men try out for field hockey? How long before that sport was all men and virtually no women.
There's nothing wrong with acknowledging that men and women are not exactly the same.
Men are allowed. And some colleges have mens' field hockey. And big field hockey countries - i.e. Germany, Netherlands - have mens national hockey teams as well as club level teams. Canada competes in most mens Olympics. The US hasn't fielded a mens team since 96, we we had an automatic bid as host. We ended round robin 0-0-5, scoring 3 goals. Allowing 23... We were the worst of the 10 teams by a huge margin.
Menâs field hockey isnât an NCAA sport. I think a handful of schools may use men on their practice squads. Iâm sure there may be some schools that offer it as a club sport and Iâm aware that there is international menâs field hockey. How our men perform in that league is kind of immaterial. My point was that, if you stopped differentiating between menâs and womenâs teams or sports, and just recruited the best athletes for each sport, women would end up getting shut out a lot more than they currently are.
There are a lot of guys who canât get a scholarship for menâs football, baseball, basketball, soccer, etc, because theyâre not quite good enough. A lot of those guys would be pretty good if not top tier players if they were on the womenâs teams.
Slowguy
(insert pithy phrase here...)