mlegrand wrote:
Ok, I've loved watching Kona each October and it's disappointing that we won't get to see it happen this year. But who do you think would have won it had they been able to race in 2020? Who do you think would have made the podium on the men's side and the women's?
Here are my picks:
Women's 1. Daniela Ryf
2. Lucy Charles
3. Heather Jackson
Men's 1. Alistair Brownlee
2. Lionel Sanders
3. Cody Beals
I could see Alistair taking it, he definitely has the talent (Still not sure of the ability to run in the heat for that duration). As for Lionel and Cody, those guys would have to leap frog some other folks to be in this conversation. Lionel still has the swimming Achille's heel, which would also be a problem for those who cited Sam Long. Also it should be noted that Sam survived the Cozumel run on with Butterfield closing. Cozumel is hot, but Kona is twice as long and just as hot. Back to Lionel, he would need a low 2:40's marathon to make the podium. There is a common misbelief that some bike train lead by Wurf is going to catch Ali, Jan, etc...we already saw that and they didn't catch them. Jan and Brownlee are legit cyclists and they also cleverly used Maurice Clavel to destroy himself while keeping the pace high. As for Cody Beals, he just hasn't shown himself at that level. Yes he has won some Ironman races and put down some record times, but Kona is different. If you were a betting man would you take a bet on Cody Beals beating Kienle, Hoffman, TO, Currie, Skipper, Sanders, Lange? I know my answer.
For the guy who mentioned Joe Skipper, he definitely is really honed in on his racing this past year. That being said, Joe is a bigger guy and I'm not sure he'll ever be able to fully thrive in the heat and humidity of Kona.
As for the women, one has to think it's still Ryf. Ryf's age, experience, and her skills make her a tough act to beat. Anne Haug is 37, so she is starting to get into the later stages of her career. I would assume Anne still has the devastating run speed and will challenge for the podium any race that she's in right now. As for Lucy, she's so young and still getting better and better that her presence on the podium should never be counted out (Although, I think she should look to a coach outside of her husband). Heather Jackson is more of the old school triathlete, where she kind of learned on the job. More likely than not, Heather's days on the podium are behind her. It's not to say Heather is not a great athlete, but the sport has elevated to a level where people are coming in with no weaknesses. When you look at somebody like Laura Phillip who came to Kona last year on practically no run training and still beat Jackson. Correct me if I'm wrong, but has Jackson ever run sub 3:00 in Kona? Plus we can't discount the beast that is Sarah Crowley and her ability to run sub 3. I'm just not sure Heather has the pedigree to become significantly better at this age and her swimming struggles make the improvement on the bike and run significantly harder.
Obviously this is all hypothetical, so Jan currently being injured doesn't really matter. As for 2021, there could be some ITU guys who come over and could continue to increase swim speed and make the race that much crazier. As others have pointed out, it's hard to say anything without seeing some racing playing out during the year.
So in this crazy hypothetical landscape (assuming Jan is not hurt):
1. Jan Frodeno
2. Sebastian Kienle
3. Patrick Lange (The dude just runs so consistently, if he makes it to the run)
1. Daniela Ryf
2. Lucy Charles
3. Anne Haug
Team Zoot 2023