Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista
Quote | Reply
 
I’m in the need of a new bike helmet.

I currently have 2 helmets
-Road: Specialized Echelon
-Aero/Tri: Louis Garneau Superleggera(classic, long boat tail style)

Both are WAY past the 5 year recommendation, have had their fair share of drops and have spent quite a bit a time stored in my garage.

My main race distance is Olympic and 70.3; training and racing is hot(Houston,TX area), humid, and quite often windy.



I’ve narrowed my search down to the following 3 “aero-road” helmets

Specialized Evade

Giro Vanquish

Bontragger ballista mips


Any thoughts would be much appreciated!


M.S. x 2; CSCS; ATC/LAT, Functional Movement Specialist, USA Track and Field Level 1
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
In my experience Specialized helmets fit people with oval shaped heads and Giro's tend toward round heads.I have an Evade and really like it because it fits my head like a glove, now I am picturing myself with a glove on my head:-)

All 3 helmets you have your eyes on are really nice. Get the one that fits and comes in the color you like!

rich
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have an Evade. Really well made.

Never seems hot
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I had an evade and it was fine but then dawned on me, why not have the right tool for the job and bought an aerohead for racing and found a deal on a kask road helmet for training, been very happy with that decision.
I realize that wasn't your question but figured I would share.
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have a round head. The evade didn’t fit me well. It pressed on my temples.

The ballista fit me a lot better. I haven’t tried on the mips version to comment on that fit specifically.

Giros usually fit me well too.
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Of the three I think that the trek lid has scored the highest in the Virginia Tech testing (5 stars vs 4 for the Specialized). Only the Giro has a visor and it is a nice implementation. Drag savings are all pretty close but I would guess the Specialized and Trek are maybe a smidge faster on most people.
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What size was your specialized helmet? How did it fit and what size is your head?
I’m thinking about getting the Specialized 2020 Echelon II MIPS for my daughter who just had a pretty bad bike crash (all is ok but it FREAKED me out and she cracked her helmet). She has a size 22 inch head (right in between the small & large helmet).
Thanks!!!!
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Y-Tri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The Specialized helmet that's on its way out is a large, which at the time was 57-63 cm.

My head measurement in 58 cm, and using the adjustments the helmet fit perfectly. Based on their current sizing for the Evade, I would be a medium

Based on what people have said in regards to Giro and Specialized fitted different head shapes(I also read the same thing elsewhere), I'll most likely go with the Evade

Since her head measures 22 inches and is in between sizes, I would recommend measuring in cm and see if it gives a better number. If she's still in between, get the larger size. When I got my first helmet the gap was 57-63, now the gaps are much smaller and the helmets are very adjustable


M.S. x 2; CSCS; ATC/LAT, Functional Movement Specialist, USA Track and Field Level 1
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Cool.
Thanks and best of luck.
Stay safe!
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I know you already bought the Evade, but why did you chose that over the Prevail? Just curious.

I have an Evade II (that replaced an Evade I that saved my live a month ago) and it is light and cool and supposedly nearly as aero as the Evade. From what I read the Evade is out on the pointy end of aero at the cost of weight and ventilation (to a degree).

"...the street finds its own uses for things"
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [AutomaticJack] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I didn't actually but the Evade yet, just leaning that way.

As for why I'm looking at the Evade over the Prevail, it seems to has a good aero edge and costs almost the same($250 for the Prevail and $275 for the Evade)


M.S. x 2; CSCS; ATC/LAT, Functional Movement Specialist, USA Track and Field Level 1
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [grumpier.mike] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
grumpier.mike wrote:
Of the three I think that the trek lid has scored the highest in the Virginia Tech testing (5 stars vs 4 for the Specialized). Only the Giro has a visor and it is a nice implementation. Drag savings are all pretty close but I would guess the Specialized and Trek are maybe a smidge faster on most people.


There is another recent post on aero helmets and referenced the VT Testing.....so I took a look. Looks like almost all of the Lazer helmets rank high on the VT testing so....not on your list, but I bought the Lazer Bullet 2.0 - may want to consider.(actually found a new one for $125). Didn't need an aero helmet, just felt like getting one....although I thought I would not like the built in lens. For a person that sweats as much as I do.....the built in lens is beautiful!.....I can now finish a ride with an almost clean lens when my sunglasses are nothing but a sweat magnet. The vent system also works well.
Last edited by: MKirk: Jun 2, 20 17:45
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have a Ballista MIPS. I like it a lot. It's comfortable and not too warm.
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [biglazybum] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
biglazybum wrote:
I had an evade and it was fine but then dawned on me, why not have the right tool for the job and bought an aerohead for racing and found a deal on a kask road helmet for training, been very happy with that decision.
I realize that wasn't your question but figured I would share.

From what I've read I don't think the aerohead will fit my head shape. I'm also not trying to spend that much; I'm getting back into the sport after a few years off and in recent weeks I've added a new bike computer, power meter and aero wheels to my bike(as well as a new fit).

However, I do like your overall advice. I'm still considered the Evade, but also looking into a basic Kask road helmet(the Rapido) and SLS3 Triathlon Helmet(the cost of both combined would be $180)


M.S. x 2; CSCS; ATC/LAT, Functional Movement Specialist, USA Track and Field Level 1
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
By chance in a nearby shop I saw a Limar 007. I liked the shape but it didn't have a shield. Just now I checked Limar's website and saw 2 helmets that do have shields. Both the new 007 and the Speed King look pretty fast.

https://limar.com/...ory/road-en/?lang=en

The more people I encounter the more I love my cats.
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Slug] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i’ll take a look at those.

i wear glasses, so a helmet without a face shield isn’t a deal breaker(i’ve read that some face shields won’t fit over glasses


M.S. x 2; CSCS; ATC/LAT, Functional Movement Specialist, USA Track and Field Level 1
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
POC Octal aero. Most comfortable helmet I’ve ever worn and I’ve worn a few.
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Easy. Just take a look at the Virginia Tech helmet safety rankings and select the safest helmet that actually fits you and that you can afford. Job done. Helmets are there to keep you safer, so why buy based on any other criteria????
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You might wanna check about the strength of the magnets holding the lenses on if you go that route. I've read that some other helmets that had lenses which were held on by weak magnets and were flying off during the ride.

The more people I encounter the more I love my cats.
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I love the Giro Vanquish. I thought it may be hot but I used it for Ironman 70.3 Boulder last year, which was a scorcher, and it felt great. My favorite feature of the Vanquish is the visor. It attaches easily and stays put even in bumpy rides and it makes everything look so crisp. I also find the helmet to be very comfortable, but that's more of a personal thing.

------------------
http://dontletitdefeatyou.blogspot.com
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Lock_N_Load] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Lock_N_Load wrote:
I love the Giro Vanquish. I thought it may be hot but I used it for Ironman 70.3 Boulder last year, which was a scorcher, and it felt great. My favorite feature of the Vanquish is the visor. It attaches easily and stays put even in bumpy rides and it makes everything look so crisp. I also find the helmet to be very comfortable, but that's more of a personal thing.

The Vanquish sits off my head a little and I find it cooler than some open road helmets that sit very close.

I talk a lot - Give it a listen: http://www.fasttalklabs.com/category/fast-talk
I also give Training Advice via http://www.ForeverEndurance.com

The above poster has eschewed traditional employment and is currently undertaking the ill-conceived task of launching his own hardgoods company. Statements are not made on behalf of nor reflective of anything in any manner... unless they're good, then they count.
http://www.AGNCYINNOVATION.com
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [Clyde M.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The SLS3 is an incredible price for a tri helmet.

I found a Vanquish for a nice discount but its still $50 more than the sls3.

What did you decide?
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [chgrubb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
chgrubb wrote:
Easy. Just take a look at the Virginia Tech helmet safety rankings and select the safest helmet that actually fits you and that you can afford. Job done. Helmets are there to keep you safer, so why buy based on any other criteria????


I remember a time when people bought helmets because they were faster and/or better cooling. Man I miss those days.

By the way, get the Evade. It's the best fitting and fastest helmet I've ever had. Enjoy!
Last edited by: stonerider: Jun 4, 20 6:04
Quote Reply
Re: Helmet Help-Specialized Evade v Giro Vanquish v Bontragger Ballista [curdog16] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
curdog16 wrote:
The SLS3 is an incredible price for a tri helmet.

I found a Vanquish for a nice discount but its still $50 more than the sls3.

What did you decide?

I’ve ruled out the Vanquish; based on what I’ve read I don’t think that it will fit my head the best.

I still considering the Evade, the SLS3 TT helmet for racing and a basic Kask road helmet for training, and I’m also looking at the Lazer Bullet 2.0(it has 2 different front vents-1 for more cooling and 1 for aero)


M.S. x 2; CSCS; ATC/LAT, Functional Movement Specialist, USA Track and Field Level 1
Quote Reply