Quote:
I'm looking at the Scicon hard case, but because I have an integrated stem/bar means that I will have to affix the bar to the frame using my own velcro strips. Not against that, but the Scicon road bike softshell bag doesn't require me to remove either the bar or seatpost. But then there's the issue of a softshell bag versus a hard case.
Every fellow mechanic I have talked to at the big races over the last several years has confirmed my own observation; there are an awful lot of bikes showing up at races with broken bars ever since the "bar on" soft and semi-soft cases started showing up. I wouldn't use one, and I try to talk athletes I work with out of using them. If you absolutely have to keep the bars on, something like the BBA is the way to go.
I'm definitely on team soft case; nearly 100% of the problems I have had with bike transit over the years have been clearly identifiable as TSA not being able to get everything back in the case correctly, and even TSA agents seem to be able to operate a zipper correctly most of the time.
Personally, I use a soft case from DaKine. After several years of traveling to races for work, and using a bunch of different cases/bags, this was the one that had the lowest failure rate, and It fits every bike I've had occasion to use it with (and I've had some oddball frames in it).
On my recent trip to Kona I was using this bag, and It came home carrying a road bike with an additional set of wheels, bike shoes and running shoes, helmet, my workstand, 4 spare tires, a tool roll, and two bottles of sealant. No problems at all, and it flew for free - thanks Alaska Air credit card :)
Just fwiw, on Alaska Air, once your bag is oversize, it's oversize, and the 50# weight limit doesn't matter anymore. Standard bike bags/boxes are automatically oversize, so when they weigh it they're just checking to see if it needs an overweight handling tag. IME, the bike actually seems to get better treatment with the overweight tag, so game on.
Tech writer/support on this here site. FIST school instructor and certified bike fitter. Formerly at Diamondback Bikes, LeMond Fitness, FSA, TiCycles, etc.
Coaching and bike fit -
http://source-e.net/ Cyclocross blog -
https://crosssports.net/ BJJ instruction -
https://ballardbjj.com/