triguy86 wrote:
I don’t understand balance bikes at all. We bought our daughter a small bike from Guardian bikes and followed their instructions with excellent results. Remove the pedals and use the bike as a “balance bike”. When they’re ready put the pedals on. No balance bike needed. No training wheels either. She was able to ride it starting at age 3.
The average person probably doesn't have whatever combination of skillset and desire is required to do what you described. I sure don't. (the desire part). Much easier to buy a balance bike (~$100 one, not the $999 racing machine...) and then a pedal bike when they're ready.
Plus, not all kids learn to ride a real bike in a linear progression. My youngest spent a long time in the gray area where he could do the pedals, but still wasn't totally confident. There were days when he was up for the struggle of pedaling, and others when he wanted to go back to the balance bike so he could go fast and keep up with his older brothers and sisters. No way I would have wanted to remove/replace his pedals based on his whims of the day.