Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT
Quote | Reply
It’s GT time. Seems pretty wide open, what with Tom “Wait Up” Domoulin just rounding into form and Chris “Weezer” Froome looking less like a super freak. Expect the unexpected at the Giro. Snow, dysentery in the ranks, podium babes who don’t mind being called podium babes, it has it all. Abondanza.
Let’s chop it up.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Anyone know if DirecTv is airing ?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Interesting route with Israel, Sicily, the length of Italy, and the mountain stages. Froome's got the impending (any day now?) decision hanging over his head, and he won't have quite the same level of support he's had in the TdF (even though any Sky B-team is stronger than most any other team's A-team), but he'll be angry. Angry Froome for the win (although almost anyone else winning would be a nice surprise). I'm looking forward to the start!

"Human existence is based upon two pillars: Compassion and knowledge. Compassion without knowledge is ineffective; Knowledge without compassion is inhuman." Victor Weisskopf.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Alvin Tostig] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I am not ready to make a pick just yet, but I think I speak for many cycling fans when I say I am pretty excited to finally see Doumalin and Froome go head to head, my feeling is that if anyone current rider has the weapons to take down From it is Doumalin. as he can hang tough in the climbs and actually TAKE tome off asthma boy in the TT's, so Froome can't rely on the fact that he can always take time back in the TT, like he knows he can do when racing, Quninata, Nibali, Bardet etc...

----------------------------
http://www.instagram.com/cyclewise
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trener1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I am backing George Bennett to get on the podium...but I'm a biased NZer.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Man i love the Giro, i think it’s the best grand tour.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [TriguyBlue] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It would be cool to see Gorge Bennet on the podium, I think he has the talent but so far hasn't shown that he can ride a full grand tour without a bad day, where he loses 5 minutes.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Well Sky seem to have started trying to shine up froomes image:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DkKMH3DI3pw
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Fusion] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
When is Chris Froome's baby due? I have a feeling he is putting it ALL into the GIRO so he can spend time at home with baby number 2.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [TriguyBlue] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TriguyBlue wrote:
Man i love the Giro, i think it’s the best grand tour.

I do too. Unfortunately, this year will be less exciting with the Sky train which is a real drag.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [tlc13] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
tlc13 wrote:
TriguyBlue wrote:
Man i love the Giro, i think it’s the best grand tour.


I do too. Unfortunately, this year will be less exciting with the Sky train which is a real drag.

I don't know, that Sky start list doesn't exactly strike terror in me. And Sky hasn't looked good in the Classics, even by Sky standards for Classics.

(Froome aside)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
tlc13 wrote:
TriguyBlue wrote:
Man i love the Giro, i think it’s the best grand tour.


I do too. Unfortunately, this year will be less exciting with the Sky train which is a real drag.


I don't know, that Sky start list doesn't exactly strike terror in me. And Sky hasn't looked good in the Classics, even by Sky standards for Classics.

(Froome aside)

I'm not so worried about the Sky train as much as the lack of "animators" in this year's Giro. Without Nibali, Quintana, or Contador...who's going on the long range attacks? The Giro is generally set up with nastier climbs on the mountain stages that rewards early action and smaller GC groups. I don't really see the field comprising of those types of GC riders though. TD and Froome are much more steady state guys. Pinot I imagine is going to be stage hunting to prepare for the TdF. Not sure about how Aru is running this year.

Somehow the Giro tends to work itself out and be great racing though.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Looking forward to see Lopez go. He certainly is upbeat and confident
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
weezer. i like it. is that your own?

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Slowman wrote:
weezer. i like it. is that your own?

of course....all original material from McNutty on ST....
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jason N wrote:
trail wrote:
tlc13 wrote:
TriguyBlue wrote:
Man i love the Giro, i think it’s the best grand tour.


I do too. Unfortunately, this year will be less exciting with the Sky train which is a real drag.


I don't know, that Sky start list doesn't exactly strike terror in me. And Sky hasn't looked good in the Classics, even by Sky standards for Classics.

(Froome aside)


I'm not so worried about the Sky train as much as the lack of "animators" in this year's Giro. Without Nibali, Quintana, or Contador...who's going on the long range attacks? The Giro is generally set up with nastier climbs on the mountain stages that rewards early action and smaller GC groups. I don't really see the field comprising of those types of GC riders though. TD and Froome are much more steady state guys. Pinot I imagine is going to be stage hunting to prepare for the TdF. Not sure about how Aru is running this year.

Somehow the Giro tends to work itself out and be great racing though.

I think the absence of a dominant team will make for unpredictable racing and will open the door for some stage hunting from some talented dark horses who may fall out of the GC hunt........Woods, Dennis, Bennett, Formolo, maybe.
Aru, Pinot I can see on the podium if they stay up front and safe.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sorry for not chiming in...Jerusalem, Mt. Etna, Zocolan, Vatican City Finish...what's not to like of the best of the three grand tours!!! The 9K Jerusalem TT should be awesome and we'll see what form Froome and Dumoulin have. I still think that the Dutch Windmill should ditch the Giro and just do the TdF and make all the midget climbing robots hurt with all the cobbles in week on on that stage race!!! I think this Giro will be better than the TdF (again)!!! On the one hand I want Dumoulin to take it, on the other hand Froome could hold the Grand Slam of Grand Tours after this if he can take the win (before getting ejected for his doping violation from last year's Vuelta, but whatever)!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
as a kiwi i'm rooting for Bennett - exciting to have someone a genuine GC contender after most of our top riders coming out of the track program and being sprinter/rouleur types (especially in a country where the media are so uneducated about cycling they comment on how our sprinter is down in 150th overall). realistically, another top 10 would be great for George with a top 5 a dream result. a stage win along the way would be amazing.

i'd love to see Pinot win it - a new GT winner over the establishment (esp Froome) and he seems to race with some passion, especially in Italy. Hard to see past Froome and Dumoulin though really. i'd rate those 3 the likely podium. interesting that all 3 of them are probably doing le tour too

Will be interesting to see if Aru can pull himself back together after a shaky couple of years. although the GC field is pretty good, he seems the only real contender to shake up the above likely podium beyond a lower step for someone in the event of one of the top guys having issues. Dumoulin is a definite possibility to have issues - its only his 2nd time targeting GC and he's doing it under the pressure of defending champ with a shaky early season.

the giro is almost always a great race and unpredictable. hard to get a read on the form of the contenders compared to TdF deeper into the season where most guys are showing where they are at
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [pk1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
http://www.cyclingnews.com/features/giro-ditalia-10-non-gc-riders-to-watch/


Looking forward to fewer pure sprint stages and rollers like Wellens and Herman getting away for a stage win.
Last edited by: McNulty: May 2, 18 6:36
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
Slowman wrote:
weezer. i like it. is that your own?


of course....all original material from McNutty on ST....

I like Puff Daddy. (not mine).
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I just created my velogames.com team

Looks like the Slowtwitch league from last year is still there.

League Code: 521835710
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Good work, McNulty.

Got to throw out to Mike Woods too. Will be interesting to see if he can build on Vuelta and Liege successes.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ChrisC42780] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ChrisC42780 wrote:
I just created my velogames.com team

Looks like the Slowtwitch league from last year is still there.

League Code: 521835710


Entered! Perfect timing, I just made my team on there yesterday.

-Physiojoe
Instagram: @thephysiojoe
Cycling coach, Elite racer on Wooster Bikewerks p/b Wootown Bagels
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Good work, McNulty.

Got to throw out to Mike Woods too. Will be interesting to see if he can build on Vuelta and Liege successes.

yep, for sure............i'm pulling for him all the way.........i think he could hang in for a top ten, maybe a stage if GC things go south......i haven't looked closely at Ef but I think they're riding for him...
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
tlc13 wrote:
TriguyBlue wrote:
Man i love the Giro, i think it’s the best grand tour.


I do too. Unfortunately, this year will be less exciting with the Sky train which is a real drag.


I don't know, that Sky start list doesn't exactly strike terror in me. And Sky hasn't looked good in the Classics, even by Sky standards for Classics.

(Froome aside)

Also Froome tends to like the unexpected attack, he often animates rather dull stages. I agree that other than Tom nobody else will provide a real challenge to Froome. His form seems suspect after last week but he has always been the master at timing his taper to perfection.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
By the way are we going to do a single thread of the entire Giro, or a daily thread. I found the single thread (ex for the classics) creates limited interaction on this forum, whereas the daily thread (or at least 3-4 per week that are instigated by key stages) create a lot more dynamic discussion. With the single thread, you just get a few hard core fans participating.

I mean we have Mt. Etna, Zoncolan, Jerusalem TT, Stage 16 ITT, Sestrieres/Bardonechia, and Cervina/Zermatt...that's the last climb of the Giro, 19 km to the summit finish with a few 12 percents...Froome could easily have Dumoulin on the ropes and Nibali should be attacking like a madman on his final chance. Aru better go attack like batshit on Zoncolan...that mountain is calling his and his chance to make up time on Dumoulin. Meanwhile Froome is going to be spinning in his 34x32 like he's riding on the Kenyan mountain bike team and not getting dropped.

I think minimally we need threads for each one of these.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Also curious to see dynamic of Froome likely having to go on attack just to come even, considering how TD smoked him in worlds ITT last year.

Too bad Jungle Bob is lining up here, would be interesting with his form, even as a stage hunter.
Last edited by: Carl Spackler: May 2, 18 14:11
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Also curious to see dynamic of Froome likely having to go on attack just to come even, considering how TD smoked him in worlds ITT last year.

Too bad Jungle Bob is lining up here, would be interesting with his form, even as a stage hunter.

Yes, this should be really interesting. I assume the Jerusalem TT will tell us what to preview in stage 16 in terms of the delta between these two in the stage 16 TT later in the race and what they have to do in between and after to secure the win (assuming no mishaps). I would think Froome has the advantage on Zoncolan.

Dev
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
I mean we have Mt. Etna, Zoncolan, Jerusalem TT, Stage 16 ITT, Sestrieres/Bardonechia, and Cervina/Zermatt...that's the last climb of the Giro, 19 km to the summit finish with a few 12 percents...Froome could easily have Dumoulin on the ropes and Nibali should be attacking like a madman on his final chance.

I'd say if Nibali (Vincenzo) attacks Froome and Dumoulin at the Giro, he's definitely a madman. Given he's not racing. ;)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Lots of ways this Giro can go. The Froome vs Dumoulin thing is obvious, though I don't really know that either one has shown they're coming into this with great form. Lots of possibilities for who else could reveal themselves as contenders. Mitchelton-Scott have a few good cards to play, so does Astana. EF Education First - Drapac p/b Cannondale (had to write it all out) seem to be doing the opposite of what they did at the Vuelta (where they had Woods as a stage hunter, but switched into GC mode part way through), so he'll start with GC aspirations and switch to stage hunting if it's not looking good for him... the lack of TT mileage plays into his hands here (and against Froome and Dumoulin).

Lots of other exciting riders who can go for some stage wins, and of course, the Giro being the Giro, unexpected stuff will for sure happen. Should be great.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Who decides and how do they decide what the "Queen Stage" is....and can I put my two cents in for Stage 19 with the mtn top finish and the brutal, gravel climb mid way?

PS. I'm still on the fence about Hoogerland



Ian Murray
http://www.TriathlonTrainingSeries.com
I like the pursuit of mastery
Twitter - @TriCoachIan
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ianpeace] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ianpeace wrote:
Who decides and how do they decide what the "Queen Stage" is....and can I put my two cents in for Stage 19 with the mtn top finish and the brutal, gravel climb mid way?

PS. I'm still on the fence about Hoogerland


there's 3 of us decide that.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
how does Mitchelton-Scott go with Chaves and Yates and Astana has had a good start, can Lopez produce ?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Not sure what to think about this if true, would this be unprecedented?

http://www.velonews.com/2018/05/giro-ditalia/giro-director-uci-assured-us-froome-wouldnt-stripped-giro-win_464992


Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Runguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
“We’re confident that the winner in Rome will be the final result for the Giro d’Italia,” added Vegni


That's remarkable. Cheating in cycling has either been solved all of a sudden or they're prepared to commit to future sweep under of carpets.

How on earth can Vegni be confident that the winner in Rome will be the final result given the past history and current uncertainty around PED use in cycling. This statement doesn't make me feel better or more confident in the UCI/Giro's grasp of things. It makes me absolutely certain we'll get more of the same.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Slowman wrote:
ianpeace wrote:
Who decides and how do they decide what the "Queen Stage" is....and can I put my two cents in for Stage 19 with the mtn top finish and the brutal, gravel climb mid way?

PS. I'm still on the fence about Hoogerland



there's 3 of us decide that.

Col de Finestre on this stage has the Cima Coppi, plus the climb up to Sestriere....not sure if the descent is the one that Salvodelli won the 2005 Giro on before the final climb, but I'll put my vote in for this stage.

I was actually hoping to go on a family vacation to Rome to conveniently time it with the end of the Giro, but my plan got overruled by my family and we're sticking to local stuff ....so maybe next year when my startup has better cashflow/cash balance LOL!!!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ai_1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Looking forward to the GT and will participate in the threads as I had fun with the classics one.

But to be honest, I am tired about all the questions surrounding Froome. The focus on his outstanding case is taking away from the racing.

RE: Ai_1, I think Vegni is just so sure that Froome will win this one.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [noodle_soup] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
noodle_soup wrote:
....RE: Ai_1, I think Vegni is just so sure that Froome will win this one.
Do you mean this edition of the Giro or this drug case?

Either way, I don't think it makes his statement any less dubious.
Look what happened with Lance and his Tour "wins". Can any RD state that whoever wins their event, the result will stand the test of time? They can't say that unless he knows everyone who could win is clean or will never be found out if they're not.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Runguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Runguy wrote:
Not sure what to think about this if true, would this be unprecedented?

http://www.velonews.com/2018/05/giro-ditalia/giro-director-uci-assured-us-froome-wouldnt-stripped-giro-win_464992


As of now he is assumed to be innocent, he has the legal right to race. My understanding Is that even if he is given a ban this result would stand. I tried to look up the specific rules and could not find them. This whole doping case is stupid and killing the sport.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ClayDavis] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ClayDavis wrote:
Lots of ways this Giro can go. The Froome vs Dumoulin thing is obvious, though I don't really know that either one has shown they're coming into this with great form. Lots of possibilities for who else could reveal themselves as contenders. Mitchelton-Scott have a few good cards to play, so does Astana. EF Education First - Drapac p/b Cannondale (had to write it all out) seem to be doing the opposite of what they did at the Vuelta (where they had Woods as a stage hunter, but switched into GC mode part way through), so he'll start with GC aspirations and switch to stage hunting if it's not looking good for him... the lack of TT mileage plays into his hands here (and against Froome and Dumoulin).

Lots of other exciting riders who can go for some stage wins, and of course, the Giro being the Giro, unexpected stuff will for sure happen. Should be great.

feel the same way about the favorites.......Sky still is built for GC support and loaded but otherwise I'm not seeing any clear cut power team.......BMC looks good for Dennis who is reinventing himself as a GC guy but that's a big ask.........QS will ride for Viviani otherwise it's Grupetto time..i think after the first week it will be wide open and cray cray like a good Giro should be.....the favorite guy who stays upright and out of snow banks and who doesn't get busted for some wacky Italian racing behavior or have to take a dump at the wrong momento will have an opportunity to podium.....humbly submitted
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ron_Burgundy wrote:
Runguy wrote:
Not sure what to think about this if true, would this be unprecedented?

http://www.velonews.com/2018/05/giro-ditalia/giro-director-uci-assured-us-froome-wouldnt-stripped-giro-win_464992



As of now he is assumed to be innocent, he has the legal right to race. My understanding Is that even if he is given a ban this result would stand. I tried to look up the specific rules and could not find them. This whole doping case is stupid and killing the sport.

I'm not so bothered that he's allowed to race while his case is being worked out. I think it's pretty shady though that this case may not be resolved until the time that best fits the UCI's timeline...

“As for what could happen during the Giro, or the possibility that a decision is made on Froome’s case during the Giro, I also spoke with president Lappartient and he said it was not possible before the Giro and unlikely also before the Tour” de France."


Should Froome win both the Giro and TdF...and decide to go superhuman for the Vuelta as well...anyone want to bet that the decision gets pushed back to mid September? And if there is a suspension...it's 6 months where Froome can start racing again in mid March?

Not that I really care. I'm actually glad the UCI is being shady for my own entertainment purposes...but it's still shady.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The penultimate stage is going to be epic. The climb from aosta up to cervinia is amazing and the road is in just diabolical condition

It's still snowing there. Has been all week and the videography if it is clear could be spectacular as there will still be skiing and the view of the matterhorn on the climb is incredible

It will be a terrible night for the teams as they will need to clean, pack and then drive to time overnight...........
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ChrisC42780] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ChrisC42780 wrote:
I just created my velogames.com team

Looks like the Slowtwitch league from last year is still there.

League Code: 521835710

good on ya Chris, I'm gonna pick my team today

The Giro is usually the most entertaining of the GTs.

res, non verba
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
It’s GT time. Seems pretty wide open, what with Tom “Wait Up” Domoulin just rounding into form and Chris “Weezer” Froome looking less like a super freak. Expect the unexpected at the Giro. Snow, dysentery in the ranks, podium babes who don’t mind being called podium babes, it has it all. Abondanza.
Let’s chop it up.

Jimmaaayyyy, thanks for starting this. Surprised you can do something productive after those binge drinking sessions with Bunk :)

All jest aside (that was alluding to the Wire above), this should be a good one

Are we even certain that it would be Froome v Domoulin? There's also Nibali, and of course, Chavez. I really hope Chavez do well here
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ron_Burgundy wrote:
Runguy wrote:
Not sure what to think about this if true, would this be unprecedented?

http://www.velonews.com/2018/05/giro-ditalia/giro-director-uci-assured-us-froome-wouldnt-stripped-giro-win_464992



As of now he is assumed to be innocent, he has the legal right to race. My understanding Is that even if he is given a ban this result would stand. I tried to look up the specific rules and could not find them. This whole doping case is stupid and killing the sport.[/quote

The UCI tweeted later, that "they are not in a position make that call", it's complicated.
https://cyclingtips.com/...o-result-will-stand/

It comes down to the UCI anti-doping tribunal in concert with WADA rules.

I predict Froome will be stripped of his Vuelta result, and be given a 6 month back dated suspension

res, non verba
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
McNulty wrote:
It’s GT time. Seems pretty wide open, what with Tom “Wait Up” Domoulin just rounding into form and Chris “Weezer” Froome looking less like a super freak. Expect the unexpected at the Giro. Snow, dysentery in the ranks, podium babes who don’t mind being called podium babes, it has it all. Abondanza.
Let’s chop it up.

Jimmaaayyyy, thanks for starting this. Surprised you can do something productive after those binge drinking sessions with Bunk :)

All jest aside (that was alluding to the Wire above), this should be a good one

Are we even certain that it would be Froome v Domoulin? There's also Nibali, and of course, Chavez. I really hope Chavez do well here
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I’m in for Chavez.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tommy D!

impressive he went as fast as Dennis

also, made a mistake above. It's Nibali's brother, not il Squalo himself, who's at this race
Last edited by: echappist: May 4, 18 7:12
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
Tommy D!

impressive he went as fast as Dennis

also, made a mistake above. It's Nibali's brother, not il Squalo himself, who's at this race

dayum................i went with RO RO.......
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
echappist wrote:
Tommy D!

impressive he went as fast as Dennis

also, made a mistake above. It's Nibali's brother, not il Squalo himself, who's at this race


dayum................i went with RO RO.......

Little guys ballin' in the short TT! Pozzovivo, Yates!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
Little guys ballin' in the short TT! Pozzovivo, Yates!

Yeah, surprising to see both in the top 10, Yates actually faster than Tony Martin and Pozzovio tied with him. And with Froome losing lots of time things are shaping up for an interest race.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ClayDavis] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tommy D comes thru like the champion that he is; Ro Dog just not quite fast enough.
Froombutol still feeling the effects of the crash yesterday
Simon Yates also had a fast ride, which is good cause he's on my fantasy team.
Still not impressed with EF Education\Drapac kit colours, gonna be hard to pick out the leader this year

res, non verba
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ClayDavis] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Looks like Froome's front wheel washed out while cornering over a manhole cover during while test riding the course. The combination of his injuries and possibly being gun shy during the technical corners of the course could have been the major factors in him losing 37 seconds rather than pure fitness leading into today. Still...that's a TON of time to try and make up on TD...considering there's another 35km TT and he looks on form.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Winning a GT take a some luck and Frome didn't have it today. Looking at the video of the crash he wasn't doing anything aggressive. Looks like his back wheel just hit a manhole cover at just the wrong angle. Took the balls out of him on a course that needed them.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [torrey] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
torrey wrote:
Took the balls out of him on a course that needed them.

On the other hand, almost every GT victory involves being tested with serious adversity multiple times, and handling it gracefully. (e.g. Froome himself running a bike uphill). I was a little surprised that he'd get snakebit by something that didn't look, on the surface, all that big of a deal. Buy, of course, often reality is bigger than surface perception. Good chance Froome will show up in a big way for the rest of the race. (even though as a card-carrying Froome-hater I hope he undergoes a complete meltdown).
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Now that the Giro has officially started and see Tommy D win in fashion. I go back to last year and his fight to win, he was such a worthy winner last year. I can only hope we get a race like last year.

Enjoy the show everyone!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
torrey wrote:
Took the balls out of him on a course that needed them.


On the other hand, almost every GT victory involves being tested with serious adversity multiple times, and handling it gracefully. (e.g. Froome himself running a bike uphill). I was a little surprised that he'd get snakebit by something that didn't look, on the surface, all that big of a deal. Buy, of course, often reality is bigger than surface perception. Good chance Froome will show up in a big way for the rest of the race. (even though as a card-carrying Froome-hater I hope he undergoes a complete meltdown).

To be fair Froome has never really been great at short TT's, Martin also seems to struggle with short technical TT's......what is the deal with Martin he seems to have completely lost his ability to be a serious TT contender.

One potential issue is now Sunweb has a lot of responsibility early and i am sure Sky is perfectly happy to allow them to hold the pink jersey. If i was TD i would rather BMC have the jersey early and chill out for a week. Can sunweb protect TD for three weeks? TD cannot climb to the same level as an on form Froome, which begs the question is Froome on form or close to ideal form?

Who do you think is a serious contender outside of TD/Froome? Pinot, Yates, Woods, Bennett, Aru, do we know who Movistar is riding for?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Lopez?
Astana has the beef to protect him, maybe....he's a youngster, 24.
3rd GC in the Tour of Alps with a stage win.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yeah, I don't get Martin. He seems adrift.

Another GC contender would be Chaves, but his TT wasn't encouraging.

Don't know what Movistar is doing. Maybe try to encourage Betancur to keep his shit together for 3 weeks straight, but good luck. I think they're grooming Carapaz as a potential long-term GC project, but probably way too soon to expect anything in the Giro. I expect they'll be mostly stage hunting.
Last edited by: trail: May 4, 18 14:30
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It is a little funny that Movistar seems to effectively be sitting this one out... It's not like they don't have a few guys on their squad who could be legit contenders in this race. Will be interesting to how they ride as a team in the Tour... Valverde seems fine being a role player but I don't get the impression Quintana or Landa are willing to play second string.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ClayDavis] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ClayDavis wrote:
trail wrote:
Little guys ballin' in the short TT! Pozzovivo, Yates!


Yeah, surprising to see both in the top 10, Yates actually faster than Tony Martin and Pozzovio tied with him. And with Froome losing lots of time things are shaping up for an interest race.

early results were wind aided
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ron_Burgundy wrote:
trail wrote:
torrey wrote:
Took the balls out of him on a course that needed them.


One potential issue is now Sunweb has a lot of responsibility early and i am sure Sky is perfectly happy to allow them to hold the pink jersey. If i was TD i would rather BMC have the jersey early and chill out for a week. Can sunweb protect TD for three weeks? TD cannot climb to the same level as an on form Froome, which begs the question is Froome on form or close to ideal form?

Who do you think is a serious contender outside of TD/Froome? Pinot, Yates, Woods, Bennett, Aru, do we know who Movistar is riding for?

I'm pretty sure I read a quote somewhere that Sunweb has absolutely no intention of protecting the jersey now and riding at the front for 3 weeks.
They know as well as anyone that they will need to keep their troops fresh for the last week.
I bet they let a breakaway go up the road and dare the sprinters teams not to chase.

Outside of TD and Froome, my money is on Pinot to be on the podium, he finished 4th last year and has shown himself really strong this spring, Lopez could well upset the apple cart if he can climb like he did at the Vuelta last year.
Those other names you mentioned, while they are all good riders I just don't see them on the podium, top 5 yeah, Woods and or Yates top 5 if the chips fall right.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Runguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
He is not making the call. I'm predicting it here - win or lose, leading or trailing, Froome is disqualified during the Giro. Black eye for the UCI? Yes. BIGGER black eye for Team Sky? YES. I think that the UCI is pissed that they are stuck in the middle here - Froome can keep racing while waiting to clear his adverse finding. No one benefits if Froome does well/ wins the GdI and then gets sacked for last year's problems. This should have been resolved before the GTs and the fact that it is not - well, lots of folks are potentially swinging in the wind. UCI can't run the risk of a Froome victory in the GdI overturned. They will find a way to disqualify Froome if he survives he first 1/3-1/2 of the race.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [giorgitd] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
giorgitd wrote:
He is not making the call. I'm predicting it here - win or lose, leading or trailing, Froome is disqualified during the Giro. Black eye for the UCI? Yes. BIGGER black eye for Team Sky? YES. I think that the UCI is pissed that they are stuck in the middle here - Froome can keep racing while waiting to clear his adverse finding. No one benefits if Froome does well/ wins the GdI and then gets sacked for last year's problems. This should have been resolved before the GTs and the fact that it is not - well, lots of folks are potentially swinging in the wind. UCI can't run the risk of a Froome victory in the GdI overturned. They will find a way to disqualify Froome if he survives he first 1/3-1/2 of the race.

I think you're way premature. Assuming the initial finding against Froome, he's almost guaranteed to appeal to CAS, which takes weeks-to-months.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ron_Burgundy wrote:
trail wrote:
torrey wrote:
Took the balls out of him on a course that needed them.


On the other hand, almost every GT victory involves being tested with serious adversity multiple times, and handling it gracefully. (e.g. Froome himself running a bike uphill). I was a little surprised that he'd get snakebit by something that didn't look, on the surface, all that big of a deal. Buy, of course, often reality is bigger than surface perception. Good chance Froome will show up in a big way for the rest of the race. (even though as a card-carrying Froome-hater I hope he undergoes a complete meltdown).

To be fair Froome has never really been great at short TT's, Martin also seems to struggle with short technical TT's......what is the deal with Martin he seems to have completely lost his ability to be a serious TT contender.

One potential issue is now Sunweb has a lot of responsibility early and i am sure Sky is perfectly happy to allow them to hold the pink jersey. If i was TD i would rather BMC have the jersey early and chill out for a week. Can sunweb protect TD for three weeks? TD cannot climb to the same level as an on form Froome, which begs the question is Froome on form or close to ideal form?

Who do you think is a serious contender outside of TD/Froome? Pinot, Yates, Woods, Bennett, Aru, do we know who Movistar is riding for?

Well Woods isn't going to be a true podium contender until Vaughters glues his ass to a TT saddle for a couple months. He got caught for a minute by Campaerts (sp).

I am sometimes amazed that Slipstream went from a team that has won ITT and TTT events to what they are today. Except for Phinney, everyone n the team is a pretty weak TT rider. Maybe Uran can put in an OK ride from time to time, but most of his TTs are stinkers these days
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [grumpier.mike] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
http://www.cyclist.co.uk/in-depth/4701/going-for-20-adam-hansen-speaks-ahead-of-the-giro-ditalia


Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Froomes crash obviously cost him some time early but for us it makes for an interesting Giro. Froome needs to do something in the mountains and cannot just cover everyone else and rely on TTs. I see Dumoulin not yet in the Froome league in the mountains so the early gap is good for the race.

Doping case aside, if Froome is all in on the Giro-Tour Double then I asume he is not at his peak yet and will increase his fitness more and more the longer the Giro lasts. He did well on such an approach in last years Tour-Vuelta Episode. And I guess he values the Tour over the Giro so chances are even greater that he will be at his best in week 3.

10k - 30:48 / half - 1:06:40
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [grumpier.mike] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
grumpier.mike wrote:
Well Woods isn't going to be a true podium contender until Vaughters glues his ass to a TT saddle for a couple months. He got caught for a minute by Campaerts (sp).

I am sometimes amazed that Slipstream went from a team that has won ITT and TTT events to what they are today. Except for Phinney, everyone n the team is a pretty weak TT rider. Maybe Uran can put in an OK ride from time to time, but most of his TTs are stinkers these days

being on Cannondale bikes doesn't help :p. I think there was a former rider who trashed them for having unaero bikes (though this could just be publicity stunt for his new team)

Jest aside, wait and see. This Giro is quite hilly, who knows how it will shake out. That 2016 edition was quite something: Kruiswijk seemed to be in control, only to crash; then Chavez couldn't follow one Nibali acceleration (the only one he had trouble with), and his quest for the Maglia Rosa was over. Quite chaotic.

I used to never fully appreciate the chaos introduced by high mountains, but descending those things is no joke.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
grumpier.mike wrote:



being on Cannondale bikes doesn't help :p. I think there was a former rider who trashed them for having unaero bikes (though this could just be publicity stunt for his new team)

You are right, it was Ryan Mullen, he gave that interview earlier this year after he won a TT on his new (trek) bike/team.

----------------------------
http://www.instagram.com/cyclewise
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trener1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trener1 wrote:
echappist wrote:
grumpier.mike wrote:



being on Cannondale bikes doesn't help :p. I think there was a former rider who trashed them for having unaero bikes (though this could just be publicity stunt for his new team)


You are right, it was Ryan Mullen, he gave that interview earlier this year after he won a TT on his new (trek) bike/team.

Reading his interview he seemed to be trashing more of how old the bikes were (referencing them being 5 or 6 years old and super flexy due to their age/use) versus being a significant aero disadvantage. I also thought he made reference to the lack of adjustability and not being able to get in his ideal position. Definitely telling that he won a TT in one of his first races with Trek.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ttusomeone] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
breezy in the desert this morning....maybe some echelon shenanigans?......it's usually QS who does this but no incentive today
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
grumpier.mike wrote:

Well Woods isn't going to be a true podium contender until Vaughters glues his ass to a TT saddle for a couple months. He got caught for a minute by Campaerts (sp).

I am sometimes amazed that Slipstream went from a team that has won ITT and TTT events to what they are today. Except for Phinney, everyone n the team is a pretty weak TT rider. Maybe Uran can put in an OK ride from time to time, but most of his TTs are stinkers these days


being on Cannondale bikes doesn't help :p. I think there was a former rider who trashed them for having unaero bikes (though this could just be publicity stunt for his new team)

Jest aside, wait and see. This Giro is quite hilly, who knows how it will shake out. That 2016 edition was quite something: Kruiswijk seemed to be in control, only to crash; then Chavez couldn't follow one Nibali acceleration (the only one he had trouble with), and his quest for the Maglia Rosa was over. Quite chaotic.

I used to never fully appreciate the chaos introduced by high mountains, but descending those things is no joke.

Especially in the Giro....right now from what people are reporting those high mountains are covered with snow (ex Cervina)....2.5 weeks later allows for meltdown time, but the descents in the Giro high mountains can be the worst of all the Grand tours, because the riders can be going from bone dry to wet to dry to wet. That's different from a wet descent on the TdF or Vuelta on a rain day.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
breezy in the desert this morning....maybe some echelon shenanigans?......it's usually QS who does this but no incentive today

someone else on another board posted about something "interesting" extracurriculars. So interesting that the announcer lost his train of thought (his own words).

but man, those desserts...
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What other cycling boards do you follow? I occasionally stop by weight weenies then remember very quickly why i left there years ago.

I am somewhat surprised that Sam Bennett was not penalized for his sharp move into the barriers today, if it was Sagan or Cav the keyboard warriors would be in full mobilization. This stage was a good teaching stage to watch how splits form in crosswinds and how to move into position. The last 5k was interesting from a technical standpoint.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ron_Burgundy wrote:
What other cycling boards do you follow? I occasionally stop by weight weenies then remember very quickly why i left there years ago.

I am somewhat surprised that Sam Bennett was not penalized for his sharp move into the barriers today, if it was Sagan or Cav the keyboard warriors would be in full mobilization. This stage was a good teaching stage to watch how splits form in crosswinds and how to move into position. The last 5k was interesting from a technical standpoint.

paceline.net (formerly serotta forum). I used to hang out on the road racing subsection of bikeforums a lot, but the place got so snarky and inane over the years. I went from averaging a few posts/day to barely making a post every 6 months. Never spent much time on weight weenies. Particular reason you left?

As for Bennett, that was a bit ridiculous; more than 1 lane width of drifting. Perhaps him being non-Italian had something to do with actually being sanctioned, as usually such a move doesn't get penalized unless the person behind got impeded. In this case, Viviani still came around. Hopefully they'll be as strict on other stages.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
Ron_Burgundy wrote:
What other cycling boards do you follow? I occasionally stop by weight weenies then remember very quickly why i left there years ago.

I am somewhat surprised that Sam Bennett was not penalized for his sharp move into the barriers today, if it was Sagan or Cav the keyboard warriors would be in full mobilization. This stage was a good teaching stage to watch how splits form in crosswinds and how to move into position. The last 5k was interesting from a technical standpoint.


paceline.net (formerly serotta forum). I used to hang out on the road racing subsection of bikeforums a lot, but the place got so snarky and inane over the years. I went from averaging a few posts/day to barely making a post every 6 months. Never spent much time on weight weenies. Particular reason you left?

As for Bennett, that was a bit ridiculous; more than 1 lane width of drifting. Perhaps him being non-Italian had something to do with actually being sanctioned, as usually such a move doesn't get penalized unless the person behind got impeded. In this case, Viviani still came around. Hopefully they'll be as strict on other stages.

I do enjoy the technical information and bike builds posted on weight weenies, lots of interesting builds and hacks people detail. They also tend to have some "semi" objective reviews on equipment failures and items to avoid. Their wheel building thread is very helpful. But, their road racing discussions are not constructive. Just a lot of misinformed viewpoints arguing for no point. You also have a lot of the old school campy is king crowd and Etap is the devil which can muddy the discussions.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
another win for QS. I don't know how sponsors view ROI but all this winning is probably good.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ron_Burgundy wrote:
echappist wrote:
Ron_Burgundy wrote:
What other cycling boards do you follow? I occasionally stop by weight weenies then remember very quickly why i left there years ago.


I am somewhat surprised that Sam Bennett was not penalized for his sharp move into the barriers today, if it was Sagan or Cav the keyboard warriors would be in full mobilization. This stage was a good teaching stage to watch how splits form in crosswinds and how to move into position. The last 5k was interesting from a technical standpoint.


paceline.net (formerly serotta forum). I used to hang out on the road racing subsection of bikeforums a lot, but the place got so snarky and inane over the years. I went from averaging a few posts/day to barely making a post every 6 months. Never spent much time on weight weenies. Particular reason you left?

As for Bennett, that was a bit ridiculous; more than 1 lane width of drifting. Perhaps him being non-Italian had something to do with actually being sanctioned, as usually such a move doesn't get penalized unless the person behind got impeded. In this case, Viviani still came around. Hopefully they'll be as strict on other stages.


I do enjoy the technical information and bike builds posted on weight weenies, lots of interesting builds and hacks people detail. They also tend to have some "semi" objective reviews on equipment failures and items to avoid. Their wheel building thread is very helpful. But, their road racing discussions are not constructive. Just a lot of misinformed viewpoints arguing for no point. You also have a lot of the old school campy is king crowd and Etap is the devil which can muddy the discussions.


Why are we talking about going off to other cycling forums on ST....that's like being in a bar and talking beside the bartender about why the other bar across the street is so much better!!!

OK, back to the topic of the Giro. I actually found the logistics of doing a bunch of grand tour stages 4 hour flight away from most teams and Italy!


http://www.velonews.com/...t-israel-back_465344


I don't know if any of you have ever traveled into and out of Israel with a bike case filled with your personal gear, but this Giro operation takes it to a scale of a complex military forward deployment involving customs and shipping all in th ecohttp://www.velonews.com/2018/05/giro-ditalia/operation-jerusalem-giro-went-israel-back_465344
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [dsmallwood] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
dsmallwood wrote:
another win for QS. I don't know how sponsors view ROI but all this winning is probably good.

For a world tour team, yes. Unless you have a guy like Sagan on the team who can command media attention through personality, winning is just about the only ROI metric that you can take back to the sponsor.

For a proconti team, being a breakaway billboard at the Tour/Giro works too, though they have smaller budgets
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
Ron_Burgundy wrote:
What other cycling boards do you follow? I occasionally stop by weight weenies then remember very quickly why i left there years ago.

I am somewhat surprised that Sam Bennett was not penalized for his sharp move into the barriers today, if it was Sagan or Cav the keyboard warriors would be in full mobilization. This stage was a good teaching stage to watch how splits form in crosswinds and how to move into position. The last 5k was interesting from a technical standpoint.


paceline.net (formerly serotta forum). I used to hang out on the road racing subsection of bikeforums a lot, but the place got so snarky and inane over the years. I went from averaging a few posts/day to barely making a post every 6 months. Never spent much time on weight weenies. Particular reason you left?

As for Bennett, that was a bit ridiculous; more than 1 lane width of drifting. Perhaps him being non-Italian had something to do with actually being sanctioned, as usually such a move doesn't get penalized unless the person behind got impeded. In this case, Viviani still came around. Hopefully they'll be as strict on other stages.

After getting nipped at Gent, it's cool to see Viviani get some. Great ride today, shouldering then winning. The race isn't loaded with sprinters but getting wins back to back is tough anyway and he gets a big confidence boost. Max Schachmann did the monster mash lead out. Stybar looked like he was going to puke trying to keep the pace high for QS. Nice that there were no ugly crashes in these two days.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul[font Arial wrote:
][/font]

Why are we talking about going off to other cycling forums on ST....that's like being in a bar and talking beside the bartender about why the other bar across the street is so much better!!!

a). it's not verboten
b). we are actually saying this place is preferable to many others out there...
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
Yes, this should be really interesting. I assume the Jerusalem TT will tell us what to preview in stage 16 in terms of the delta between these two in the stage 16 TT later in the race and what they have to do in between and after to secure the win (assuming no mishaps). I would think Froome has the advantage on Zoncolan.


Dev


I don't think the Jerusalem ITT is a very good crystal ball / predictor for other ITTs. This course was mental, always up or down and full of sharp corners and tricky sections. I walked the whole thing during the stage, you could see former ITT WCs already cooked at the halfway mark (Kiryienka, Martin). It was more Classics Finale than traditional time-trialling.



ZONE3 - We Last Longer
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [tessar] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Back at it tomorrow. Lumpy fast stage. Who we like?

Gruppo compacto? Or Stickabreakatto?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
Back at it tomorrow. Lumpy fast stage. Who we like?

Gruppo compacto? Or Stickabreakatto?

Woods; b/c i cant stand Ulissi (a cheating scum)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
McNulty wrote:
Back at it tomorrow. Lumpy fast stage. Who we like?

Gruppo compacto? Or Stickabreakatto?


Woods; b/c i cant stand Ulissi (a cheating scum)


OK, well feel free to speak your mind here....this thread is a safe place..:)
I like Wellens to go late after the break is controlled by BMC. Or maybe they let Wellens go? Or Woodsie, even better but they're not letting him go.
Last edited by: McNulty: May 7, 18 15:28
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Still in week 1, and coming off a rest day, I think breakaway. With the first 30 km net downhill, my guess is this is going to be one of those stages where the first 40-50 km might be full gas to establish the real breakaway. This isn't a sprinters stage, and I don't think the GC will be motivated to chase down the break as they want the time bonuses to be eaten up before they get there.

Without the help of a sprinter team or a GC team, BMC is going to have a tough time controlling the break on this course by themselves. They could, but Wednesday's stage is no slouch for BMC to control either and they need to manage their energy. So long as nobody within 90 seconds of Dennis gets away, I think you'll see BMC happy to just keep the margin to the break manageable rather than bring it all the way back and have to also worry about a more frantic finish in the last 5 km. We may may also see a few guys take flyers with 50 km to go to bridge up to the break if they sense BMC won't bring it back.

X factor in this whole "wild guess" of mine is that if a potential young rider threat gets away, you may see other teams with young rider aspirations help BMC and bring it all the way back.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
Or Woodsie, even better but they're not letting him go.

<fantasy>

C'dale might send Formolo up the road since he's an Ardennesy-type sprinter, and not a 2nd-tier GC threat like Woods. That way Woods can kick it back in the field and maybe clean up the mess if Formolo is caught.

</fantasy>
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
 
formolo is cannondale education first no more. alas.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [buzz] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
buzz wrote:

formolo is cannondale education first no more. alas.

GODDAMIT! I made this same mistake with ex-C'dale riders about 86 times in the Classics thread. I'm stuck in 2017.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I am finding all the logistics around running stages in Israel and moving the entire throng across the Med to Sicily fascinating. Maybe it's my old military deployment mindset getting more excited about that than the racing until they go up Etna on stage 6. I am particulary interested since there has been talk about kicking off the TdF in Quebec forever. The biggest obstacle seems to be the transfer back to France and all the riders potentially having to do a red eye flight in the middle of a Grand Tour. They really would have to run a direct day flight for the riders directly from Quebec to whatever airport in France is closest to the next stage on a rest day. If they leave at 8 am in Quebec, they get to France at 10 pm. That's still a killer transfer if you're going to do a stage the next day....if not, it is a 2 day gap. Same discussion about starting the Giro in Japan (which would be worse).

It was pretty cool having the Giro pop into Eilat....for those of you on this forum, that's the Red Sea resort that hosts the Israman Iron Distance event.











Looks like an awesome area to go riding!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
buzz wrote:

formolo is cannondale education first no more. alas.


GODDAMIT! I made this same mistake with ex-C'dale riders about 86 times in the Classics thread. I'm stuck in 2017.

JV raised Formolo from a pup and was not pleased when he went up the road.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
The biggest obstacle seems to be the transfer back to France and all the riders potentially having to do a red eye flight in the middle of a Grand Tour.

Certainly the team doctors have that covered!

Eliot
blog thing - strava thing
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Love this pictures, that place looks awesome.

As far as Formolo.. c'mon in the middle of the Vualta it looked like the team was going to fold, you can't exactly blame someone for trying to get a job.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
<fantasy>

C'dale might send Formolo up the road since he's an Ardennesy-type sprinter, and not a 2nd-tier GC threat like Woods. That way Woods can kick it back in the field and maybe clean up the mess if Formolo is caught.

</fantasy>
Keeping with the fantasy thought (and sorry that Formolo has left EF as already pointed out).

I sort of like the chances of Dombrowski getting into tomorrow's break. Definitely the win will come from the break.

"Human existence is based upon two pillars: Compassion and knowledge. Compassion without knowledge is ineffective; Knowledge without compassion is inhuman." Victor Weisskopf.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
A friend of mine works for Comcast, the local production company that basically organized the whole thing as contractors for RCS (and scored me VIP access to the start area, win). Months of work went into it, and to be honest we were quite skeptical at first: Anything from political pressure to our PM's tendencies to heat up Gaza when he's under pressure (and he has been, pretty severe corruption charges) to general police incompetence could've derailed it. Roads were resurfaced, months of public education about the race, a literal army of guards and policemen, an entire cargo 747 just for equipment and a fleet of rental cars painted to match team liveries. Even then, teams were hesitant to give bidons to fans out of fear of running out (and needing more water than expected in the heat of the desert). A truly incredible production, the biggest in the country's history - bigger than our recent anniversary Independence Day celebrations.

It was pretty terrific to watch the riders go on the very same roads I cycle and/or drive on a regular basis. Sadly, the organizers couldn't quite pull off the route they wanted - there was supposed to be a stage in the northern hills or proper mountains, which are very scenic, but RCS didn't want too hard a stage on the opening 3 days. I rode Be'er Sheva to Eilat - the 3rd stage - a bunch of times and that route is really fun. Too bad they opted for the "boring" finish via the main highway (the sketchy last 50km, always a backwind on that stretch) rather than descend via Route 12, which is the beautiful rolling hills of the Israman bike course. I guess that was just a bit too close to the border for comfort.

It's indeed a beautiful area for cycling, running and swimming - Dev, the Israman is quite your course, favouring the lighter rider and resilient, experienced runner. Post-race beers and reef snorkeling on me!

ZONE3 - We Last Longer
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trener1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trener1 wrote:
Love this pictures, that place looks awesome.

As far as Formolo.. c'mon in the middle of the Vualta it looked like the team was going to fold, you can't exactly blame someone for trying to get a job.

No, I don't blame him for moving on. But JV seemed to take it personally as he felt he really helped develop Formolo. But that's the business. If you want loyalty, get a dog.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Alvin Tostig] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
[/quote]
I sort of like the chances of Dombrowski getting into tomorrow's break. Definitely the win will come from the break.[/quote]
i'd like that but i think he's sitting on until the high mountains...............insane finish today, BMC is going to be trashed..........there will be blood
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
echappist wrote:
McNulty wrote:
Back at it tomorrow. Lumpy fast stage. Who we like?

Gruppo compacto? Or Stickabreakatto?


Woods; b/c i cant stand Ulissi (a cheating scum)


OK, well feel free to speak your mind here....this thread is a safe place..:)
I like Wellens to go late after the break is controlled by BMC. Or maybe they let Wellens go? Or Woodsie, even better but they're not letting him go.

Wellens perhaps to go early, with 3-4 km to go rather than on the final hill
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
good Lordy.................what racing..................WOODSIE.....thought he was going to come around.........Dennis has guts
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
good Lordy.................what racing..................WOODSIE.....thought he was going to come around.........Dennis has guts

had to burn a match to get up to speed to Wellens, who was just slightly ahead of the main group.

didn't think Wellens would have the kick, but he did. Bodes well for Woods
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
Wellens perhaps to go early, with 3-4 km to go rather than on the final hill

cycling news wrote:
17:48:13 CEST
Tim Wellens digs deep and takes the win

17:48:41 CEST
Michael Woods crosses the line in second place

good day for the ST crowd. the Giro is always entertaining.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I love that type of finish, I guess its the Classics fan in me!

My online feed sucks! Tiz Cycling does not work for me on my work computer and trying a different feed but it freezes all the time.

How how is everyone watching? Which Feed? Which Browser?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ChrisC42780] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
fubo when I can, cycling news when I can't

live.cyclingnews.com/
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ChrisC42780] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I bit the bullet and paid for flobikes.com. I'll try to cancel as soon as the race is over. So far, it has worked well, with excellent picture quality
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Woods continues to impress--he was in good position at key moments.

Froome is now almost a minute off TD. Considering worlds and stage 1, he could cough up nearly 90 seconds on stage 16. Certainly not over yet but bit of work for him to do.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ChrisC42780] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ChrisC42780 wrote:
I love that type of finish, I guess its the Classics fan in me!

My online feed sucks! Tiz Cycling does not work for me on my work computer and trying a different feed but it freezes all the time.

How how is everyone watching? Which Feed? Which Browser?

Eurosport feed; chrome browser with VPN
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
A couple of observations on/from todays stage.
With Froome losing another few seconds today and tomorrows stage finish being similes to todays, I wonder if we will see
some of the big GC teams (Sunweb, Mitchelton, FDJ) driving hard to the finish tomorrow t see if they can get another 20-30 seconds off Froome.

Also agree on Woods, he has got a win in him soon, but also the difference between a well run and organized team vs a ramshackle team couldn't have been more obvious today, I would say that Wellens and Woods were equally able to win today, on the one hand you saw the whole Lotto drilling it coming into the finish and giving him the perfect lead out, on the other hand you have the EF "team" just scattered through the peloton, with no obvious plan (and if they did have a plan it sure wasn't executed very well).

----------------------------
http://www.instagram.com/cyclewise
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trener1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trener1 wrote:
A couple of observations on/from todays stage.
With Froome losing another few seconds today and tomorrows stage finish being similes to todays, I wonder if we will see
some of the big GC teams (Sunweb, Mitchelton, FDJ) driving hard to the finish tomorrow t see if they can get another 20-30 seconds off Froome.

Also agree on Woods, he has got a win in him soon, but also the difference between a well run and organized team vs a ramshackle team couldn't have been more obvious today, I would say that Wellens and Woods were equally able to win today, on the one hand you saw the whole Lotto drilling it coming into the finish and giving him the perfect lead out, on the other hand you have the EF "team" just scattered through the peloton, with no obvious plan (and if they did have a plan it sure wasn't executed very well).

Woods had Hugh Carthy with him all day, even in the final k. He even sat up looking for Woods when the lead group split. Having 2 guys at the end after that run in isn’t ramshackle.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
trener1 wrote:
A couple of observations on/from todays stage.
With Froome losing another few seconds today and tomorrows stage finish being similes to todays, I wonder if we will see
some of the big GC teams (Sunweb, Mitchelton, FDJ) driving hard to the finish tomorrow t see if they can get another 20-30 seconds off Froome.

Also agree on Woods, he has got a win in him soon, but also the difference between a well run and organized team vs a ramshackle team couldn't have been more obvious today, I would say that Wellens and Woods were equally able to win today, on the one hand you saw the whole Lotto drilling it coming into the finish and giving him the perfect lead out, on the other hand you have the EF "team" just scattered through the peloton, with no obvious plan (and if they did have a plan it sure wasn't executed very well).


Woods had Hugh Carthy with him all day, even in the final k. He even sat up looking for Woods when the lead group split. Having 2 guys at the end after that run in isn’t ramshackle.

Agreed. Woods lost position on an acute downhill turn leading into the finish. That's what caused the split in the first place. This is perhaps where Wood's lack of experience is a hindrance, as those Belgians drilling it aren't too bothered by it whereas a relative newcomer to the sport might.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tomorrow things get down to business. Could be an interesting day--on paper it's a good one for TD and not as much one for pure climbers.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Tomorrow things get down to business. Could be an interesting day--on paper it's a good one for TD and not as much one for pure climbers.

indeed; though just a prelude, there should be some fireworks
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Tomorrow things get down to business. Could be an interesting day--on paper it's a good one for TD and not as much one for pure climbers.

indeed; though just a prelude, there should be some fireworks

We will see where Froome really is and TD has been invisible, like Sagan when he’s dialed in, so probably very dangerous. Etna may be the end of the beginning and be the selection stage. Agreed, it’s not for the pure climbers to win.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Simon Yates has looked *really* good too. He's had no problem being up near the front to avoid any risk of getting on the wrong side of a split in the finale. While Froome has struggled in doing that.
Last edited by: trail: May 9, 18 21:19
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Anyone know what time (New York time) race is starting?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [thatzone] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
follow http://www.inrng.com for the best blog analysis and everything you need to know about any stage. (timing, bits to watch etc.)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
Simon Yates has looked *really* good too. He's had no problem being up near the front to avoid any risk of getting on the wrong side of a split in the finale. While Froome has struggled in doing that.

i've been thinking Yates for this stage for some reason
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Joe D in the big break up front......I'm ok with this.....all due respect
Last edited by: McNulty: May 10, 18 6:54
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
quite a few climbers in the front group. Not a foregone conclusion that the winner would come from the peloton.

Joe D or Chaves taking this would be nice
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Froome is gonna go from the Maglia Rosa group.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TD punches Froome’s ticket in 3, 2, 1...
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
So much for that prediction, and climbers not winning today.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
So much for that prediction, and climbers not winning today.

Froome doesn't look very good. They need to attack and hold it; instead they are just soft pedaling after half a minute

-----

Really good to see Chaves up there. He's been through a lot...
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
So much for that prediction, and climbers not winning today.


Froome doesn't look very good. They need to attack and hold it; instead they are just soft pedaling after half a minute

-----

Really good to see Chaves up there. He's been through a lot...

Yates was ridiculously fresh. Good on Chavez. Ben Hermans, great ride, Pinot too. This is wide open though TD looks so confident.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Good interviews with Chavez and Yates. Both gave credit to their teammates, smiling Chavez says, "We now go to the mainland and keep it dreaming".
I'm rooting for them.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
on a wholly unrelated note, i've been looking to buy a new road bike to replace my 5-year old Scott Foil. My TT bike is a Scott Plasma (with the rare shark tooth stem). So naturally, I'd like to stick to another foil (despite it having a messier front end than a Trek Madone).

What turns me off at the moment is that the standard issue aero road bars on it are compact/anatomical/whatever inflexible people use, whereas I want a classic round. Seems like Yates has one of those (seems to be an one-off), and i'd really like to get my hands on a copy. That'd be very swell, and i could even tell Scott that their sponsorship sold a bike.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
on a wholly unrelated note, i've been looking to buy a new road bike to replace my 5-year old Scott Foil. My TT bike is a Scott Plasma (with the rare shark tooth stem). So naturally, I'd like to stick to another foil (despite it having a messier front end than a Trek Madone).

What turns me off at the moment is that the standard issue aero road bars on it are compact/anatomical/whatever inflexible people use, whereas I want a classic round. Seems like Yates has one of those (seems to be an one-off), and i'd really like to get my hands on a copy. That'd be very swell, and i could even tell Scott that their sponsorship sold a bike.

I am glad I'm not the only one that dislikes the ultra compact bars the manufacturers are infatuated with at the moment.

Today was an interesting stage, Froome looked like he was hurting but he always looks terrible. TD at one point looked to be hurting but made it back just fine. I think today confirmed what we already knew, Froome vs TD vs Pinot with yates as a long shot. I think Chaves will pay for the effort today. Sky did seem to be less cohesive today, potentially not 100% comitted to Froome? I think after today he proved that his form is good enough to be on the podium. Lets hope for a close race and everybody on form.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ron_Burgundy wrote:
Froome looked like he was hurting but he always looks terrible.

That's the funny thing with Froome, I've never seen him look like he was feeling good. His riding style never even makes him look fast, but somehow nobody can drop him.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Well Yates for one did drop him, but point taken overall.

What makes this race different for Froome from all of the past races, is that unlike every other race where all he had to do was hang in the Mountains and know that he can smash everyone in the TT, this won't win him the giro in this rodeo, he is already almost a minute behind TD, and even if was equal in time he more then likely won't be able to gain anything on TD in the TT, so his formula won't work if he wants to win (though it could still get him on the podium)


T3_Beer wrote:
Ron_Burgundy wrote:
Froome looked like he was hurting but he always looks terrible.


That's the funny thing with Froome, I've never seen him look like he was feeling good. His riding style never even makes him look fast, but somehow nobody can drop him.

----------------------------
http://www.instagram.com/cyclewise
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trener1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Give him until week 3.....then we will know what he's really doing. I'm not a Froome fan by any means, but he's not one to count out just yet.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
T3_Beer wrote:
Give him until week 3.....then we will know what he's really doing. I'm not a Froome fan by any means, but he's not one to count out just yet.

If he looked less ungainly, and didn't ride for Sky, I'd probably be a big fan, in spite of puffergate. I thought today would show a lot and it did. He's right there.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
If he looked less ungainly, and didn't ride for Sky, I'd probably be a big fan, in spite of puffergate. I thought today would show a lot and it did. He's right there.

It's funny, I used to despise Froome because of the way he treated Wiggins when he took over Sky and because he was a boring rider. His 2016 TDF performance made me like him a little bit, but I'm still not all the way there.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Fan of Chavez, happy for him today. But was wondering why the team didn't get Yates to cross the line first to get the bonus seconds. Having two leaders in the team always complicate things IMO. (But what do I know.)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trener1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
He lost nearly 1:30 to TD at Worlds last year and :27 or whatever in only 10k. It's not only unlikely he won't gain anything in 30k ITT, but likely he'll lose gobs of time.

Little surprised TD gave away that much time to Yates today. He looked in control the whole way, and is perhaps being patient for what's to come. That said, was probably worse outcome for Froome.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
trail wrote:
Simon Yates has looked *really* good too. He's had no problem being up near the front to avoid any risk of getting on the wrong side of a split in the finale. While Froome has struggled in doing that.


i've been thinking Yates for this stage for some reason

ST calls it again.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [noodle_soup] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
noodle_soup wrote:
Fan of Chavez, happy for him today. But was wondering why the team didn't get Yates to cross the line first to get the bonus seconds. Having two leaders in the team always complicate things IMO. (But what do I know.)

I think that the team was the antithesis of Sky today, actually taking into account human feeling and emotions, after all that Chavez has been through the last 12 months and how much work he put in the break today, they just figured that he deserved to have the stage, it seems that Yates was on board with that plan as well.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trener1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trener1 wrote:
noodle_soup wrote:
Fan of Chavez, happy for him today. But was wondering why the team didn't get Yates to cross the line first to get the bonus seconds. Having two leaders in the team always complicate things IMO. (But what do I know.)


I think that the team was the antithesis of Sky today, actually taking into account human feeling and emotions, after all that Chavez has been through the last 12 months and how much work he put in the break today, they just figured that he deserved to have the stage, it seems that Yates was on board with that plan as well.

classy ride by Yates.........Chavez won from the break, credited his teammate Haig for driving the break, which set up Yates for the GC.....cool team work, go figure........
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
Froome doesn't look very good. They need to attack and hold it; instead they are just soft pedaling after half a minute
Is Froome going to make it to Rome? Although I wouldn't bet on it, I won't be surprised if he pulls out of the race before the end. It doesn't seem like he (and Sky) really have their hearts into this Giro.

Lots of racing to go, though. Maybe they're saving themselves for the 3rd week.

"Human existence is based upon two pillars: Compassion and knowledge. Compassion without knowledge is ineffective; Knowledge without compassion is inhuman." Victor Weisskopf.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trener1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trener1 wrote:
noodle_soup wrote:
Fan of Chavez, happy for him today. But was wondering why the team didn't get Yates to cross the line first to get the bonus seconds. Having two leaders in the team always complicate things IMO. (But what do I know.)

I think that the team was the antithesis of Sky today, actually taking into account human feeling and emotions, after all that Chavez has been through the last 12 months and how much work he put in the break today, they just figured that he deserved to have the stage, it seems that Yates was on board with that plan as well.

Yes, and nice that still exists today.

Not like in 2012 when Froome won a stage and Wiggins said something along the lines of he now had his little glory and can now do his real job supportint me.

10k - 30:48 / half - 1:06:40
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ron_Burgundy wrote:
I am glad I'm not the only one that dislikes the ultra compact bars the manufacturers are infatuated with at the moment.

what's your current set up, btw?

I was also a bit disappointed when Sagan traded his classic rounds for compact bars. The aethestics of compact bars just look "off"


trener1 wrote:
noodle_soup wrote:
Fan of Chavez, happy for him today. But was wondering why the team didn't get Yates to cross the line first to get the bonus seconds. Having two leaders in the team always complicate things IMO. (But what do I know.)


I think that the team was the antithesis of Sky today, actually taking into account human feeling and emotions, after all that Chavez has been through the last 12 months and how much work he put in the break today, they just figured that he deserved to have the stage, it seems that Yates was on board with that plan as well.

indeed

Sean Kelly was saying how Yates should take the win to gain additional seconds, but even from a purely dollars and cents perspective, that wouldn't have been wise, as it'd have alienated someone who would help Yates, all for measly two seconds.

Also, Chavez being in the break meant that Yates could just sit tight and do diddly until he finally decided to kick it off. It was just reward for Chavez.

If there's any team that could leverage a dual-leader set-up, it would be this team. I think their all for one, one for all motto is more than just a marketing gimmick.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ToBeasy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ToBeasy wrote:
trener1 wrote:
noodle_soup wrote:
Fan of Chavez, happy for him today. But was wondering why the team didn't get Yates to cross the line first to get the bonus seconds. Having two leaders in the team always complicate things IMO. (But what do I know.)


I think that the team was the antithesis of Sky today, actually taking into account human feeling and emotions, after all that Chavez has been through the last 12 months and how much work he put in the break today, they just figured that he deserved to have the stage, it seems that Yates was on board with that plan as well.


Yes, and nice that still exists today.

Not like in 2012 when Froome won a stage and Wiggins said something along the lines of he now had his little glory and can now do his real job supportint me.

I'm all for feel good stories, but I don't really knock Sky for being what they are. When a domestique signs on with team Sky, presumably for more money than another team would offer...you know what you're getting into. And if you out grow that role, you're free to move on to another team like Porte and Landa.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
He lost nearly 1:30 to TD at Worlds last year and :27 or whatever in only 10k. It's not only unlikely he won't gain anything in 30k ITT, but likely he'll lose gobs of time.

Little surprised TD gave away that much time to Yates today. He looked in control the whole way, and is perhaps being patient for what's to come. That said, was probably worse outcome for Froome.

Perhaps it was "calculated?" His team really doesn't have the fire power to ride at the front for that long. Might as well "lend" the jersey to Yates, who'll cough up 1:30 on the time trial
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
On a different note, what's going on with Joe Dombrowski? He was in the break at the start of Etna climb, and then he was gone. Looks like he finished 5 minutes down.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [dalava] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey Thread,

How can you say no to loving these guys?



All that is right about the peloton in one squad,

Scott
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [GreatScott] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TD said his legs weren't great at the start of the climb, but after that they were OK but he was finished at the end. So it seems he's not at his top game yet, but manages to keep up going uphill.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [dalava] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
dalava wrote:
On a different note, what's going on with Joe Dombrowski? He was in the break at the start of Etna climb, and then he was gone. Looks like he finished 5 minutes down.

Good question. He may have been called off to come back to Woods, or he may have just been cooked and pulled the plug for the day. I admit being surprised he was off the climb. Hope he's healthy.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
How can I watch the Giro in the US?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [KingMidas] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
KingMidas wrote:
How can I watch the Giro in the US?



Eurosport + VPN

1st get a VPN service


next subscribe to Eurosport


which gives you access to both live streams and VOD (for at least one week)
For instance, all 260km of De Ronde was available for a whole month




Entire stages of the Giro are also available, commercial free. For example Stage 2





More from today's stage

Start


mid-stage


decisive move


finish, note the time on the slidebar and the time for the stage
Last edited by: echappist: May 10, 18 18:55
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [KingMidas] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
KingMidas wrote:
How can I watch the Giro in the US?

Check out Flo Tv
https://www.flobikes.com/...in-the-us-and-canada

----------------------------
http://www.instagram.com/cyclewise
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trener1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The peloton did not want Tony Martin in the break today.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
Good interviews with Chavez and Yates. Both gave credit to their teammates, smiling Chavez says, "We now go to the mainland and keep it dreaming".
I'm rooting for them.
Yes, that interview with Flecha was refreshing. None of the common meaningless coached interview drivel. They were obviously, and understandably, delighted with their performances and couldn't stop grinning but it also came across as very sincere when they were talking about their team mates etc. It put me in a good mood.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ai_1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Happy to see Sam Bennett finally win in a GT!

The QS train delivered Viviani a perfect lead out, Bennett stayed patient and rode around him in the final 10 metres - Outstanding

res, non verba
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [RoYe] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
RoYe wrote:
Happy to see Sam Bennett finally win in a GT!

The QS train delivered Viviani a perfect lead out, Bennett stayed patient and rode around him in the final 10 metres - Outstanding

that did look like a bit of line deviation from Bennett though; not sure what to think of it (I liked the win, but also those types of moves are dangerous, and he did actually body check a rider)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [RoYe] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
RoYe wrote:
Happy to see Sam Bennett finally win in a GT!

The QS train delivered Viviani a perfect lead out, Bennett stayed patient and rode around him in the final 10 metres - Outstanding

Yeah...Viviani was able to launch with about 125 to go with a clear shot to the line. That's textbook for a flat finish. For Bennett to be able to come around is pretty amazing.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Propers to our man Trail who currently leads (and may well stay there) in the Velogames thing. His team is 631 out of 21000+.

Coodoz.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
Propers to our man Trail who currently leads (and may well stay there) in the Velogames thing. His team is 631 out of 21000+.

Wasn't going to say anything because I've *always* come in near dead-last in velogames, and usually less than half my team makes it to the last day.

I thought it was a bit of a risk taking two GC-types from the same team. But these two seem to be genuinely happy for each other. Chaves handing out thank-you drawings to every member of his team after his win nearly brings tears to my eyes. It's funny to think of Wiggins-Froome/Landa-Quintana/Armstrong-Contador handing each other thank-you drawings.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
RoYe wrote:
Happy to see Sam Bennett finally win in a GT!

The QS train delivered Viviani a perfect lead out, Bennett stayed patient and rode around him in the final 10 metres - Outstanding


that did look like a bit of line deviation from Bennett though; not sure what to think of it (I liked the win, but also those types of moves are dangerous, and he did actually body check a rider)

Bennett's line was questionable the other day when he drove Viviani to the barriers on the right and then swung across to the left again but today looked okay to me. The rider he contacted was a Quickstep rider looking to obstruct him from chasing Viviani. I think it was legit.
A good win. First GT win in a while for an Irish rider.
Last edited by: Ai_1: May 11, 18 14:56
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
McNulty wrote:
Propers to our man Trail who currently leads (and may well stay there) in the Velogames thing. His team is 631 out of 21000+.


Wasn't going to say anything because I've *always* come in near dead-last in velogames, and usually less than half my team makes it to the last day.

I thought it was a bit of a risk taking two GC-types from the same team. But these two seem to be genuinely happy for each other. Chaves handing out thank-you drawings to every member of his team after his win nearly brings tears to my eyes. It's funny to think of Wiggins-Froome/Landa-Quintana/Armstrong-Contador handing each other thank-you drawings.

Having Pinot, Yates and TD going forward into the mountains is big, and it doesn't look like Chavez is at all done. Mich Scott seems to be riding with a lot of joy and camaraderie. I'll bet the vibe on the Sky bus is different. And Sven Tufts is a class guy.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ai_1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ai_1 wrote:
Bennett's line was questionable the other day when he drove Viviani to the barriers on the right and then swung across to the left again but today looked okay to me. The rider he contacted was a Quickstep rider looking to obstruct him from chasing Viviani. I think it was legit.
A good win. First GT win in a while for an Irish rider.

Yep, the minimal bumping today was completely legit. Nice to see Bennett win, he was obviously very pleased to get his 1st GT stage win. He's usually impetuous but took his time to launch, even freewheeling briefly not that far from the line. Nice job!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [eb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
eb wrote:
Ai_1 wrote:

Bennett's line was questionable the other day when he drove Viviani to the barriers on the right and then swung across to the left again but today looked okay to me. The rider he contacted was a Quickstep rider looking to obstruct him from chasing Viviani. I think it was legit.
A good win. First GT win in a while for an Irish rider.


Yep, the minimal bumping today was completely legit. Nice to see Bennett win, he was obviously very pleased to get his 1st GT stage win. He's usually impetuous but took his time to launch, even freewheeling briefly not that far from the line. Nice job!

I think since Nick Roche? Dan Martin hasn't won one, which is interesting. A little, anyway.
It's refreshing to see a wide open race and no dominant team for the GC.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I finally signed up for the flobikes coverage. Things were busy at work this week (and will be for the rest of the summer), but being able to watch all the replays and features is awesome! Thanks guys for the link. it works well.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
eb wrote:
Ai_1 wrote:

Bennett's line was questionable the other day when he drove Viviani to the barriers on the right and then swung across to the left again but today looked okay to me. The rider he contacted was a Quickstep rider looking to obstruct him from chasing Viviani. I think it was legit.
A good win. First GT win in a while for an Irish rider.


Yep, the minimal bumping today was completely legit. Nice to see Bennett win, he was obviously very pleased to get his 1st GT stage win. He's usually impetuous but took his time to launch, even freewheeling briefly not that far from the line. Nice job!


I think since Nick Roche? Dan Martin hasn't won one, which is interesting. A little, anyway.
It's refreshing to see a wide open race and no dominant team for the GC.

Pretty sure Martin won a stage at the Vuelta (back in 2011 or 2012); also a stage at the 2013 Tour. A good while back, sure, but he's had success.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Will be interesting to see if Froome is banged up after today's fall to the poinit that it affects tomorrow's summit finish or if he bounced back OK. He did ride back up to the group and went to the front and he rode back down the mountain, so I suspect it's just a little spill on wet stuff and the fall was "well lubricated"
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
in unrelated news, Andrei Griepel just won solo after attacking his break mates on a climb. Always liked the Gorilla, and his solo/small group raids in the classics in service of his teammates were always commendable, but this is a bit different. Perhaps he could seriously challenge for a spring classic if the stars align
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
McNulty wrote:
eb wrote:
Ai_1 wrote:

Bennett's line was questionable the other day when he drove Viviani to the barriers on the right and then swung across to the left again but today looked okay to me. The rider he contacted was a Quickstep rider looking to obstruct him from chasing Viviani. I think it was legit.
A good win. First GT win in a while for an Irish rider.


Yep, the minimal bumping today was completely legit. Nice to see Bennett win, he was obviously very pleased to get his 1st GT stage win. He's usually impetuous but took his time to launch, even freewheeling briefly not that far from the line. Nice job!


I think since Nick Roche? Dan Martin hasn't won one, which is interesting. A little, anyway.
It's refreshing to see a wide open race and no dominant team for the GC.


Pretty sure Martin won a stage at the Vuelta (back in 2011 or 2012); also a stage at the 2013 Tour. A good while back, sure, but he's had success.

right you are......11 for Vuelta, 13 for TdF..guess Roche won after that...in the discussion of Irish wins, Martin never came up....i guess 5 years is ancient history
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
in unrelated news, Andrei Griepel just won solo after attacking his break mates on a climb. Always liked the Gorilla, and his solo/small group raids in the classics in service of his teammates were always commendable, but this is a bit different. Perhaps he could seriously challenge for a spring classic if the stars align

Love him too, but winning a stage against the guys who didn't get picked for the Giro or ToC is a far stretch from challenging for a classic.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
echappist wrote:
in unrelated news, Andrei Griepel just won solo after attacking his break mates on a climb. Always liked the Gorilla, and his solo/small group raids in the classics in service of his teammates were always commendable, but this is a bit different. Perhaps he could seriously challenge for a spring classic if the stars align


Love him too, but winning a stage against the guys who didn't get picked for the Giro or ToC is a far stretch from challenging for a classic.

OK, back to the Giro....tomorrow 26K of climbing to a summit finish ending about 2000m:

Final kilometres: the ramps are steep over the last 7 km. The route reaches over 2,000 m in altitude on a relatively wide road, with gradients of around 9% and topping out at 13%. The finish line (6 m in width) sits on a 120-m long tarmacked home straight.


Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
first real major climbing stage, and only in the Giro is it rated a 3/5 in terms of difficulty.

Would be interesting to see how Dumoulin copes with the altitude (iirc, that was partially what contributed to the nature stop last year)

Think Orica and Pinot could do well
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
first real major climbing stage, and only in the Giro is it rated a 3/5 in terms of difficulty.

Would be interesting to see how Dumoulin copes with the altitude (iirc, that was partially what contributed to the nature stop last year)

Think Orica and Pinot could do well

I think most of this stage is at 1000m or under. The dual Stelvio climb stage spent a decent chunk of the day between 1500m and 2700m....just all the time spent at that altittude (they would have spent around ~120 min above 1500m at full throttle vs at 1000m makes the dual Stelvio climb stage more prone to mild altitude sickness type side effects. I think on this stage it should be negligible in terms of time at altitude, it's just a power to weight game tomorrow.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
yo, 40k of climbing to finish the day....this is Alpine grinder, rhythm guy territory, will be interesting to see who's in the break and how long a leash they get...i think it could be a stickabreaka day if a climber who is about 27 mins down gets away on that bump in the middle of the course but it's still a long way to go and big mountains beckon and team GC hopes are not dashed yet...... Gesink, Plaza, Roche, Hermans?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Break has 8 minutes and 1.5 minute virtual pink jersey on the flats before the climbing starts soon! Looks like pretty good weather so far, but they are saying 50% chance of rain further up the road on the mountain. Just saw a really borderline sticky bottle hand off. They just need to add that to Ironman Texas to complete the draft-dope-drive trifecta towards super fast bike splits!!!

I love my virtual trip to Italy every spring. I will go back to ride and watch one of these years (well, I guess I have to get back to riding first). The only time I actually saw the Giro in person was bike touring in 1985. I was riding with my buddy from Cortina d'Ampezzo to Innsbruck and the Giro was riding towards Val Gardena (if you are a downhill skier, you know all these towns). That was an awesome Giro because it was the first time there was an American team in a Grand Tour. Lemond and Hinault were on the same LaVie Claire team and competing with the Italian heros Moser and Saronni. I got pretty hooked following the Giro during that bike tour on nightly TV in the local bars. After a while I realized that riding into a bar with a Canadian bike jersey and a loaded touring bike around 5 pm daily was a good chance of the local bar owner giving myself and my buddy dinner on the house after 6-10 hours in the saddle!!!

In any case, 1985 got me hooked on the Giro. Since then, that's the part of year that I really get into my cycling overdose....this year the final week of Giro coincides with the Champion's league finals. I will be completely useless on the weekend of May 26/27!!!!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
one of my rules (more of a guideline) is not to use the term "epic" unless there is a decent chance of death.....this finish with the weather may not be epic, but fookin' crazy hard at the very least ...in honor of Mother's Day, it's gonna be a mother...........Ef has Carthy up the road, Woods is still in after Astana smashes it, Joe D riding clean up with Woods still.......
Last edited by: McNulty: May 13, 18 6:52
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The cool thing about the Giro (and also the Vuelta) is that there are pretty well high mountains available anywhere in the country within 200km of where you are, so the organizers can throw in mountain stages whenever they want. For the TdF they are locked into covering a a good spread of France which means mainly rollers or flats if you're not in the Alps, Massif Central, Pyranees. The Jura and Vosges are not really "high enough" to create those separations at the pro level
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carthy has a shot at a yuuuge win for EF.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
look for Chaves again; has good kick
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Good bye asthma boy
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TD is a big winner here. Yates is spooky fresh.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
TD is a big winner here. Yates is spooky fresh.

My fantasy team is big winner again! 1-2-3 on finish and GC.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
And Pinot too. Loosing :12 on Yates but getting almost another minute on Froome is a win for TD.

Starting to look like TD, Yates, Chavez and Pinot battling for podium. Not sure I believe Pozzovivo can be there all the way until end.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
TD is a big winner here. Yates is spooky fresh.

indeed

Pinot kept burning matches in the last km. I bet he'd have given Yates a run for the latter's money had he taken a few more chill pills.

I think Yates will ship ~2:00-2:30 to Dumoulin in the time trial. What would hamper Dumoulin is the cumulative fatigue from the few days before, so if they really put him under pressure, he may not recover in time to really put the hurt on the willowy climbers. Were the TT scheduled for this week or early next week, he'd have extracted more.

This is shaping up to be an intriguing battle. Orica's team advantage may very well give them the title when Dumoulin burns one too many matches following attacks.


devashish_paul wrote:

In any case, 1985 got me hooked on the Giro. Since then, that's the part of year that I really get into my cycling overdose....this year the final week of Giro coincides with the Champion's league finals. I will be completely useless on the weekend of May 26/27!!!!


Champion's League? what sort of effete European BS is that? ;)

Jest aside, I hope the Scousers sock one on Madrid; and if Ramos gets a literal socking, that wouldn't be half bad either. I do wonder for whom Xabi Alonso will be cheering? He's seems to be a bigger Scousers at heart, and admittedly, that final in Istanbul was nothing short of magical. Rafa most certainly would cheer for Liverpool.
Last edited by: echappist: May 13, 18 8:34
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
McNulty wrote:
TD is a big winner here. Yates is spooky fresh.


My fantasy team is big winner again! 1-2-3 on finish and GC.

great...wonder what your world ranking is now..i got 2-3...........really messed up not taking Yates, I'd be giving you a run for it
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TD didn’t necessarily follow every attack last year and conceded little bits of time here and there. When he stays steady—which he does as well or better than any GC guys there— it could almost be in energy conservation mode.

Sort of looks like he’s holding back a bit or might not be on same form at Yates, Pinot and Chavez yet, saving for 3rd week.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trener1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trener1 wrote:
Good bye asthma boy
He's saving himself for the fourth week.

"Human existence is based upon two pillars: Compassion and knowledge. Compassion without knowledge is ineffective; Knowledge without compassion is inhuman." Victor Weisskopf.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
McNulty wrote:
TD is a big winner here. Yates is spooky fresh.

indeed

Pinot kept burning matches in the last km. I bet he'd have given Yates a run for the latter's money had he taken a few more chill pills.

I think Yates will ship ~2:00-2:30 to Dumoulin in the time trial. What would hamper Dumoulin is the cumulative fatigue from the few days before, so if they really put him under pressure, he may not recover in time to really put the hurt on the willowy climbers. Were the TT scheduled for this week or early next week, he'd have extracted more.

This is shaping up to be an intriguing battle. Orica's team advantage may very well give them the title when Dumoulin burns one too many matches following attacks.


devashish_paul wrote:

In any case, 1985 got me hooked on the Giro. Since then, that's the part of year that I really get into my cycling overdose....this year the final week of Giro coincides with the Champion's league finals. I will be completely useless on the weekend of May 26/27!!!!


Champion's League? what sort of effete European BS is that? ;)

Jest aside, I hope the Scousers sock one on Madrid; and if Ramos gets a literal socking, that wouldn't be half bad either. I do wonder for whom Xabi Alonso will be cheering? He's seems to be a bigger Scousers at heart, and admittedly, that final in Istanbul was nothing short of magical. Rafa most certainly would cheer for Liverpool.

Keep in mind tha TD lost time on the double Stelvio stage last year, but otherwise survived the week three mountains OK and then buried Quintana on the TT. Yates should be a bit stronger than Quintana on the TT, but not by a ton, so week three is the battle for sure.

So what's the odds of Froome packing in his Giro training camp middle of next week, and getting back on the regular plan, showing up at the Dauphine and then the TdF in A form?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Greater than 50:50. Sky pulled the same thing with Wiggo in 2013
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Most of this week is flat to rolling. On Wed there is a short 16% grade before the finish. Then on Saturday is Zoncolan. I think Froome sticks around till Zoncolan and tests things out. There is no reason to gain or lose any time between today and Zoncolan unless he is really badly banged up.



If he gains back time on Zoncolan, I think he hangs out for week three. If he blows apart on Zoncolan, I don't think he hangs out for the next day's stage which is also pretty sawtooth-ish:


Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
So what's the odds of Froome packing in his Giro training camp middle of next week, and getting back on the regular plan, showing up at the Dauphine and then the TdF in A form?
I'd be a little surprised if he starts Tuesday's stage. Not much in it over the next few stages for a rider like him. And if he's going to lose even more time when they get to the mountains next week...........

Maybe the pre-race crash before the prologue affected him, but he hasn't seemed to be very fired up about the Giro.

Is it too late to get rid of the white jerseys and go back to the black (evil empire) jerseys?

"Human existence is based upon two pillars: Compassion and knowledge. Compassion without knowledge is ineffective; Knowledge without compassion is inhuman." Victor Weisskopf.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
great...wonder what your world ranking is now..i got 2-3...........really messed up not taking Yates, I'd be giving you a run for it

195th! So inside the top 1%.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
TD didn’t necessarily follow every attack last year and conceded little bits of time here and there. When he stays steady—which he does as well or better than any GC guys there— it could almost be in energy conservation mode.

Sort of looks like he’s holding back a bit or might not be on same form at Yates, Pinot and Chavez yet, saving for 3rd week.

TD is sitting pretty, the ITT is 34.2 long, which means Yates will lose about 2 to 2.5 minutes.
There are only 4 montain stages left after today.
Froomebutol is looking uncharacteristically out of form.
This is turning out to be a dream sceanario for Michelton-Scott, Yates & Chaves lead the GC and M-S leads the team Category

res, non verba
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [RoYe] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
RoYe wrote:


TD is sitting pretty, the ITT is 34.2 long, which means Yates will lose about 2 to 2.5 minutes.
There are only 4 montain stages left after today.
F



I don't know. I wouldn't feel like I was sitting pretty if I were TD. TD only put 20 seconds into Yates in the opening ~10km TT. Yates beat Tony Martin, and was only 4 seconds down on Dowsett. That's serious TT street cred. He looks like he's upped his game, and has zero intention of being the next Andy Schleck

20 seconds extrapolates out to a little over 1 minute for ~34K. Plus factor in the conventional wisdom that little guys accumulate less wear-and-tear.

TD is not in the danger zone yet, but those times bonuses, at some point, start to add up to real time.

Plus, as noted, Yates and Chaves look scary. You get the feeling they haven't thrown their haymaker yet. At some point you have to think they're going to go all-in to isolate TD with Yates and Chaves and just start tag-teaming him. And I have to think there'll be no agenda between those two. If Chaves gets up the road, Yates will absolutely sit on TD and let Chaves win GC if that's what it takes.
Last edited by: trail: May 13, 18 12:10
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:

TD is not in the danger zone yet, but those times bonuses, at some point, start to add up to real time.

Plus, as noted, Yates and Chaves look scary. You get the feeling they haven't thrown their haymaker yet. At some point you have to think they're going to go all-in to isolate TD with Yates and Chaves and just start tag-teaming him. And I have to think there'll be no agenda between those two. If Chaves gets up the road, Yates will absolutely sit on TD and let Chaves win GC if that's what it takes.

+1 on both points. Those pesky time bonuses might end up what does Dumoulin in. Time bonuses really don't favor the diesel types.

And I would love to see Chaves and Yates work over TD
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
trail wrote:


And I would love to see Chaves and Yates work over TD

I was actually a bit surprised that they didn't really try anything today (other then the last 500 meters).
Was todays climb to easy to really try a serious attack?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
trail wrote:


TD is not in the danger zone yet, but those times bonuses, at some point, start to add up to real time.

Plus, as noted, Yates and Chaves look scary. You get the feeling they haven't thrown their haymaker yet. At some point you have to think they're going to go all-in to isolate TD with Yates and Chaves and just start tag-teaming him. And I have to think there'll be no agenda between those two. If Chaves gets up the road, Yates will absolutely sit on TD and let Chaves win GC if that's what it takes.


+1 on both points. Those pesky time bonuses might end up what does Dumoulin in. Time bonuses really don't favor the diesel types.

And I would love to see Chaves and Yates work over TD

Just watched the last 4km replay again. Do you think that Pinot was actually the strongest in the lead group and just kept burning all kinds of energy for no good reason. Meanwhile Yates just sat and marked patiently and saved his one real attack for when it counted?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
trail wrote:


TD is not in the danger zone yet, but those times bonuses, at some point, start to add up to real time.

Plus, as noted, Yates and Chaves look scary. You get the feeling they haven't thrown their haymaker yet. At some point you have to think they're going to go all-in to isolate TD with Yates and Chaves and just start tag-teaming him. And I have to think there'll be no agenda between those two. If Chaves gets up the road, Yates will absolutely sit on TD and let Chaves win GC if that's what it takes.


+1 on both points. Those pesky time bonuses might end up what does Dumoulin in. Time bonuses really don't favor the diesel types.

And I would love to see Chaves and Yates work over TD

agreed, however TD is not so vulnerable to attacks on finishing climbs even 2-pronged ones. because he typically takes the steady pace approach rather than chasing after moves all the MS guys get is one of them sitting on which doesn't make much difference on a climb steep enough to favour them in the first place. in order to gain big time (ie the 2 minutes+ they need to account for the TT) they need to attack and isolate TD on a prior climb, force him to lead a chase group to the bottom of the finishing climb. that may be easier said than done. st14 only has cat 2&3 climbs leading to the zoncolan; st18 is just a finishing climb; st19 with the finestre mid-stage is a prime opportunity; maybe st20 with 3 cat 1s in a row and most domestiques fried by that point of the race.

i'm not counting froome out yet either - he hasn't looked good but if he's peaking in the 3rd week then the TT and mountains could see him right back in it - i hope so anyway, not that i want him to win but i want him in the battle
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trener1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trener1 wrote:
echappist wrote:
trail wrote:


And I would love to see Chaves and Yates work over TD


I was actually a bit surprised that they didn't really try anything today (other then the last 500 meters).
Was todays climb to easy to really try a serious attack?

In and of itself, the climb wasn't killer but it's length after a 200k day and a long week of work and then the final pitch up made for a very tough finish. I think that since it's only a third of the way through and the GC still tight, no one was going to go for a kill shot. I think Yates and Chavez were pleasantly surprised to be able to go 1-3. I think TD has to be quite pleased. I too am looking for him to battle those two. And as much as I like the M Scott guys, I'd like to see TD hang steady and tough and maybe even swat them back a bit.

I think Kreuziger moving to the front after Astana shot their wad was big. That's a hell of a teammate to have in that situation.

EF got great rides from Carthy, Woods, and Joe D. Bodes well if the keep recovering.

It's still very early and the mountains get bigger and the weather gets crazier. The Giro is the best.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [pk1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pk1 wrote:
echappist wrote:
trail wrote:


TD is not in the danger zone yet, but those times bonuses, at some point, start to add up to real time.

Plus, as noted, Yates and Chaves look scary. You get the feeling they haven't thrown their haymaker yet. At some point you have to think they're going to go all-in to isolate TD with Yates and Chaves and just start tag-teaming him. And I have to think there'll be no agenda between those two. If Chaves gets up the road, Yates will absolutely sit on TD and let Chaves win GC if that's what it takes.


+1 on both points. Those pesky time bonuses might end up what does Dumoulin in. Time bonuses really don't favor the diesel types.

And I would love to see Chaves and Yates work over TD


agreed, however TD is not so vulnerable to attacks on finishing climbs even 2-pronged ones. because he typically takes the steady pace approach rather than chasing after moves all the MS guys get is one of them sitting on which doesn't make much difference on a climb steep enough to favour them in the first place. in order to gain big time (ie the 2 minutes+ they need to account for the TT) they need to attack and isolate TD on a prior climb, force him to lead a chase group to the bottom of the finishing climb. that may be easier said than done. st14 only has cat 2&3 climbs leading to the zoncolan; st18 is just a finishing climb; st19 with the finestre mid-stage is a prime opportunity; maybe st20 with 3 cat 1s in a row and most domestiques fried by that point of the race.

i'm not counting froome out yet either - he hasn't looked good but if he's peaking in the 3rd week then the TT and mountains could see him right back in it - i hope so anyway, not that i want him to win but i want him in the battle

Watch Froome on the replay it almost looks like he was bonking or his form has a way to go. He did not look like he was phyically favoring anything from the crashes, but he looks so ungainly on the bike anyway that perhaps it is hard to say.

I think the only way these guys really beat TD is if he has an off day and Yates has a perfect TT. Froome has bled away enough time, that I can't see how he can close on TD, but who knows? If Froome is truly riding his way into fitness and giving away some time now, he may be fresher in week three when others who were peaking earlier are on fumes.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
echappist wrote:
trail wrote:


TD is not in the danger zone yet, but those times bonuses, at some point, start to add up to real time.

Plus, as noted, Yates and Chaves look scary. You get the feeling they haven't thrown their haymaker yet. At some point you have to think they're going to go all-in to isolate TD with Yates and Chaves and just start tag-teaming him. And I have to think there'll be no agenda between those two. If Chaves gets up the road, Yates will absolutely sit on TD and let Chaves win GC if that's what it takes.


+1 on both points. Those pesky time bonuses might end up what does Dumoulin in. Time bonuses really don't favor the diesel types.

And I would love to see Chaves and Yates work over TD


Just watched the last 4km replay again. Do you think that Pinot was actually the strongest in the lead group and just kept burning all kinds of energy for no good reason. Meanwhile Yates just sat and marked patiently and saved his one real attack for when it counted?

might not be the strongest, but certainly 2nd or 3rd strongest.

It was a headwind in the final, so takes a lot of energy to get free, but not as much to follow. After he tired himself from all those accelerations, Yates put in a decisive one to go over the top, and Pinot still had enough to follow for the most part.

-----------------------------------------

As for how one works over Dumoulin, I'm thinking of the way Nibali worked over Chaves in 2016. Or alternatively, send a teammate up the road (Kreuziger or Nieve), attack the penultimate climb (or even earlier), link up with a teammate in the valley, make Dumoulin work. He got worked over in the last stage of the 2015 Vuelta
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
devashish_paul wrote:
echappist wrote:
trail wrote:


TD is not in the danger zone yet, but those times bonuses, at some point, start to add up to real time.

Plus, as noted, Yates and Chaves look scary. You get the feeling they haven't thrown their haymaker yet. At some point you have to think they're going to go all-in to isolate TD with Yates and Chaves and just start tag-teaming him. And I have to think there'll be no agenda between those two. If Chaves gets up the road, Yates will absolutely sit on TD and let Chaves win GC if that's what it takes.


+1 on both points. Those pesky time bonuses might end up what does Dumoulin in. Time bonuses really don't favor the diesel types.

And I would love to see Chaves and Yates work over TD


Just watched the last 4km replay again. Do you think that Pinot was actually the strongest in the lead group and just kept burning all kinds of energy for no good reason. Meanwhile Yates just sat and marked patiently and saved his one real attack for when it counted?


might not be the strongest, but certainly 2nd or 3rd strongest.

It was a headwind in the final, so takes a lot of energy to get free, but not as much to follow. After he tired himself from all those accelerations, Yates put in a decisive one to go over the top, and Pinot still had enough to follow for the most part.

-----------------------------------------

As for how one works over Dumoulin, I'm thinking of the way Nibali worked over Chaves in 2016. Or alternatively, send a teammate up the road (Kreuziger or Nieve), attack the penultimate climb (or even earlier), link up with a teammate in the valley, make Dumoulin work. He got worked over in the last stage of the 2015 Vuelta

There is an additional scenario that starts playing out with Froome 2 min down. Suddenly Froome can become an ally of Yates because Yates MAY have enough time to hold off Froome in the ITT, but not enough to hold of TD. This could be kind of interesting on Zoncolan if Froome starts bouncing back from his crashes by then.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Lot of racing left in this one, way too soon to crown a victor. It’s gonna come down to third week and who is hitting form versus gassing. That’s the big question in my mind for TD or Yates.

In other news, much to ST’s dismay, Gaviria somehow managed a W on disc bike. Lucky for him Sagan was uncharacteristicly too far back when it went down.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I see TD as a very similar rider to Froomebuterol and JiffyBrad who had a very specific team tactic working for them.. turning the last x km of each stage into a threshold ride and basically forcing all of their GC competitors to ride the approaches in the red. Which works in your favour if you have a TTer with a very high threshold, who can also climb pretty well. Used to see quite a few attempted late breaks failing under seemingly tired legs, which bored everybody to death but was an effective strategy for this type of rider.

I don't see Sunweb doing this for TD in the same way that the Sky train has for their leaders in the last few TDFs?
Last edited by: knighty76: May 14, 18 2:38
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Lot of racing left in this one, way too soon to crown a victor. It’s gonna come down to third week and who is hitting form versus gassing. That’s the big question in my mind for TD or Yates.

In other news, much to ST’s dismay, Gaviria somehow managed a W on disc bike. Lucky for him Sagan was uncharacteristicly too far back when it went down.

I watch these guys and I think, he who recovers best, wins. Pinot is great but looks like a Euro mess at the end; unshaven, bent over the bars. Yates looks like he just finished a high school soccer match. That was a 200k day of racing with mountain winds.

TD, we will see. He doesn't have a train on the inclines, he's Saganing it and just has to follow the right wheel, or group of wheels. I saw him sit right on Froome yesterday and he may do this again. Not a bad way to go, given the Sky team strength. He seems super steady and that is going to count for a lot on the long climbs coming up and if Weezy is out of it, they may ride some for TD just because. Or for Yates as he's a Brit. Or maybe it's time to set up their other climbers.

Discs- I'd rather ride a crit with a lot of disc brakes than not. The braking is so much cleaner and smoother, which in tight spots is so much safer. In a crash the last thing I care about is a disc hitting me. The ground hits much harder. I don't get the concerns.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
echappist wrote:
McNulty wrote:
eb wrote:
Ai_1 wrote:

Bennett's line was questionable the other day when he drove Viviani to the barriers on the right and then swung across to the left again but today looked okay to me. The rider he contacted was a Quickstep rider looking to obstruct him from chasing Viviani. I think it was legit.
A good win. First GT win in a while for an Irish rider.


Yep, the minimal bumping today was completely legit. Nice to see Bennett win, he was obviously very pleased to get his 1st GT stage win. He's usually impetuous but took his time to launch, even freewheeling briefly not that far from the line. Nice job!


I think since Nick Roche? Dan Martin hasn't won one, which is interesting. A little, anyway.
It's refreshing to see a wide open race and no dominant team for the GC.


Pretty sure Martin won a stage at the Vuelta (back in 2011 or 2012); also a stage at the 2013 Tour. A good while back, sure, but he's had success.


right you are......11 for Vuelta, 13 for TdF..guess Roche won after that...in the discussion of Irish wins, Martin never came up....i guess 5 years is ancient history
Hopefully we'll have a few more in the next few years. Dan Martin is still a potential stage winner, Nicholas Roche isn't typically in the mix but you never know. No need for comment regarding Bennett, and Eddie Dunbar is on the way up.

Anyway, back tot he topic at hand......
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
My current theory is that Froome went into the Giro on a wing and a prayer that he could hold the three grand tour titles, but wasn't willing to sacrifice the 2018 TdF. The big pile of cash the Giro gave him just for showing up at the starting line could mean that he also just saw it as a three week training camp.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
McNulty wrote:

great...wonder what your world ranking is now..i got 2-3...........really messed up not taking Yates, I'd be giving you a run for it


195th! So inside the top 1%.

Your definitely running away with it. My only gamble is picking up Bennett. I wish I used my extra 2 credits not used and did not pick up Pantano and picked up Formolo instead.

The scenery on yesterday stage was stunning!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ChrisC42780] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ChrisC42780 wrote:
Your definitely running away with it. My only gamble is picking up Bennett. I wish I used my extra 2 credits not used and did not pick up Pantano and picked up Formolo instead.

I always thought they give you way too many points. You get to pick like 2/3 of the viable GC candidates, so having a good team is more about predicting who will bomb than who will do well. I wish the points only let you pick one super-high-quality GC guy (Froome or Dumoulin) or 2 of the second tier if you skip the top guys.

Quote:
The scenery on yesterday stage was stunning!

Unreal. Too bad the racers don't get to enjoy it. :)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What will be interesting is if Mitchelton sends Chavez up the road on penultimate climb on stage 14, putting TD to the sword early. The finale is so brutal that it's more or less everyman for themselves regardless. Stage 15 is no picnic either.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Lot of racing left in this one, way too soon to crown a victor. It’s gonna come down to third week and who is hitting form versus gassing. That’s the big question in my mind for TD or Yates.

Yeah, there is plenty of opportunity to gain or lose boatloads of time the between stages 14 and 20. And the way stages 19 and 20 are set up, it gives opportunity for guys to send teammates in the break and swing for the fences early if they are down on time. I also wouldn't count Froome out just yet. I think his chances of winning the Giro are extremely small...but I think he might stick it out to go out on the attack for training purposes and may shake things up.

If I am TD, I'm not feeling very comfortable right now. At this point, even if he puts 3 minutes on Yates and Chavez in the TT, he's got to hope that they fade and he gets stronger in the mountains as the tour goes on. At his rate, I think he bleeds more than 5 minutes to both of them in the remaining mountain stages.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
What will be interesting is if Mitchelton sends Chavez up the road on penultimate climb on stage 14, putting TD to the sword early. The finale is so brutal that it's more or less everyman for themselves regardless. Stage 15 is no picnic either.

I'd save him for stage 15; as you said, everyone man for himself on Zoncolan, so Chavez has to be on a really good day or he might crack on the final ascent. Stage 15 is much more open to chaos. Teammates up the road and perhaps even a countryman up the road may let him save energy in the break and put time into TD
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jason N wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Lot of racing left in this one, way too soon to crown a victor. It’s gonna come down to third week and who is hitting form versus gassing. That’s the big question in my mind for TD or Yates.


Yeah, there is plenty of opportunity to gain or lose boatloads of time the between stages 14 and 20. And the way stages 19 and 20 are set up, it gives opportunity for guys to send teammates in the break and swing for the fences early if they are down on time. I also wouldn't count Froome out just yet. I think his chances of winning the Giro are extremely small...but I think he might stick it out to go out on the attack for training purposes and may shake things up.

If I am TD, I'm not feeling very comfortable right now. At this point, even if he puts 3 minutes on Yates and Chavez in the TT, he's got to hope that they fade and he gets stronger in the mountains as the tour goes on. At his rate, I think he bleeds more than 5 minutes to both of them in the remaining mountain stages.

A lot of people thought TD would lose many minutes to Quintana in last years Giro during week 3 in the mountains, but it didn't happen like they envisaged [nobody anticipated his nature stop tho]
He was able to hang with the climbers through most of the very difficult stages and lost a handful of seconds; I'm anticipating the same this time around, especially since Sunweb brought more climbers in the roster for week 3.

res, non verba
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [RoYe] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yeah, agree. TD has shown that while he can't necessary punch like the climbers he can go into TT mode and not give up a lot.

Egan Bernal... that kid is good.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Agreed on both counts. TD isn't going to give up multiple minutes in my opinion. He will pace himself up those climbs and though he will lose time, he will gain time in the TT and that should be enough. I will say, Simon looks killer right now and it wouldn't surprise me if he might be able to hang on. I still tip my cap to TD though.

Bernal is looking amazing, I took holiday to the United States for the past few weeks and I am here in California catching a few stages. Everything I've seen from Bernal the past few years as well as what he did today makes me think I'm seeing the classiest climber I've ever witnessed with my own eyes. This chap will take GC wins; if not this year than he will in the future.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [RoYe] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
RoYe wrote:
Jason N wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Lot of racing left in this one, way too soon to crown a victor. It’s gonna come down to third week and who is hitting form versus gassing. That’s the big question in my mind for TD or Yates.


Yeah, there is plenty of opportunity to gain or lose boatloads of time the between stages 14 and 20. And the way stages 19 and 20 are set up, it gives opportunity for guys to send teammates in the break and swing for the fences early if they are down on time. I also wouldn't count Froome out just yet. I think his chances of winning the Giro are extremely small...but I think he might stick it out to go out on the attack for training purposes and may shake things up.

If I am TD, I'm not feeling very comfortable right now. At this point, even if he puts 3 minutes on Yates and Chavez in the TT, he's got to hope that they fade and he gets stronger in the mountains as the tour goes on. At his rate, I think he bleeds more than 5 minutes to both of them in the remaining mountain stages.


A lot of people thought TD would lose many minutes to Quintana in last years Giro during week 3 in the mountains, but it didn't happen like they envisaged [nobody anticipated his nature stop tho]
He was able to hang with the climbers through most of the very difficult stages and lost a handful of seconds; I'm anticipating the same this time around, especially since Sunweb brought more climbers in the roster for week 3.

I thought the same last year. What is working against TD this year though is that the TT is before the last 2 mountain stages. So assuming TD has pink after stage 16, his competitors will know the exact time they have to gain on him to peel the jersey off his back and can plan appropriately.

Also, I look at last mountain stages of last year (18-20), compared to this year (19-20) and see big differences that does not favor TD. I ask myself, could TD make it to the base of the final climb with the GC group and manage his losses from there in each stage. Or would there be long range attacks from the GC group and it would be a free for all well before the final climb of the stage.

When I look at last year's 18-20 (hindsight is 20/20 of course), I see crazy amounts of climbing and nastiness, but a profile where the lead group is likely to still be together at the base of the last climb. There was just too much descending and flats/rolling into the final climb for a GC guy to take the risk.

This year on the other hand, I look at the Finestre, and I ask my self if TD can hang with the GC group who will want to attack from 85-95 km out knowing the rest of the stage is all uphill or downhill. Sunweb will likely keep their entire team with TD in the peloton, but all the other GC teams will send guys in the break. If even just 2 GC contenders crest the Finestre with a 20 second gap on TD (I expect it will be more), look out. Their teams will pull guys from the break back and suddenly you'll see 4-6 guys working together to distance TD who may not have any teammates left with him. Same goes for stage 20 with about 40 km to go...there is a legit launch pad prior to the final climb that is relatively low risk high reward for the GC guys to make their move early.

If TD wins this year's Giro...he will have proven he can climb with the best of them.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jason N wrote:
RoYe wrote:
Jason N wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Lot of racing left in this one, way too soon to crown a victor. It’s gonna come down to third week and who is hitting form versus gassing. That’s the big question in my mind for TD or Yates.


Yeah, there is plenty of opportunity to gain or lose boatloads of time the between stages 14 and 20. And the way stages 19 and 20 are set up, it gives opportunity for guys to send teammates in the break and swing for the fences early if they are down on time. I also wouldn't count Froome out just yet. I think his chances of winning the Giro are extremely small...but I think he might stick it out to go out on the attack for training purposes and may shake things up.

If I am TD, I'm not feeling very comfortable right now. At this point, even if he puts 3 minutes on Yates and Chavez in the TT, he's got to hope that they fade and he gets stronger in the mountains as the tour goes on. At his rate, I think he bleeds more than 5 minutes to both of them in the remaining mountain stages.


A lot of people thought TD would lose many minutes to Quintana in last years Giro during week 3 in the mountains, but it didn't happen like they envisaged [nobody anticipated his nature stop tho]
He was able to hang with the climbers through most of the very difficult stages and lost a handful of seconds; I'm anticipating the same this time around, especially since Sunweb brought more climbers in the roster for week 3.


I thought the same last year. What is working against TD this year though is that the TT is before the last 2 mountain stages. So assuming TD has pink after stage 16, his competitors will know the exact time they have to gain on him to peel the jersey off his back and can plan appropriately.

Also, I look at last mountain stages of last year (18-20), compared to this year (19-20) and see big differences that does not favor TD. I ask myself, could TD make it to the base of the final climb with the GC group and manage his losses from there in each stage. Or would there be long range attacks from the GC group and it would be a free for all well before the final climb of the stage.

When I look at last year's 18-20 (hindsight is 20/20 of course), I see crazy amounts of climbing and nastiness, but a profile where the lead group is likely to still be together at the base of the last climb. There was just too much descending and flats/rolling into the final climb for a GC guy to take the risk.

This year on the other hand, I look at the Finestre, and I ask my self if TD can hang with the GC group who will want to attack from 85-95 km out knowing the rest of the stage is all uphill or downhill. Sunweb will likely keep their entire team with TD in the peloton, but all the other GC teams will send guys in the break. If even just 2 GC contenders crest the Finestre with a 20 second gap on TD (I expect it will be more), look out. Their teams will pull guys from the break back and suddenly you'll see 4-6 guys working together to distance TD who may not have any teammates left with him. Same goes for stage 20 with about 40 km to go...there is a legit launch pad prior to the final climb that is relatively low risk high reward for the GC guys to make their move early.

If TD wins this year's Giro...he will have proven he can climb with the best of them.

Great analysis...agreed about there being launch pad opportunities for other teams to gap TD before some of the final climbs using riders from the break dropping back. You would think that Bahrain Merida, Emirates and Scott can all afford to do that?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jason N wrote:
So assuming TD has pink after stage 16, his competitors will know the exact time they have to gain on him to peel the jersey off his back and can plan appropriately.


I call it a tactical wash. TD will then know exactly how much leash he can give surging attacks on climbs - similarly to how Froome let Quintana get a minute or so up the road a few times while he continued to diesel up the climb.

I like M-S much better than Sunweb as teams go, though. I'd love to have Tuft, Keuziger, Bewley et al, as my posse of thugs.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thinking the same, TD could be in a defensive position. All things considered, didn't give up that much riding the Stelvio solo last year, and when Wiggo won ToC, he basically rode all of Mt. Diablo at a tempo that barely anyone could attack from far out. If TD did that it'd force the climbers to burn matches trying to get up the road.

M-S has looked solid but it'll be week 3 when it really counts, and the Sunweb supporting cast is on cruise control right now.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Thinking the same, TD could be in a defensive position. All things considered, didn't give up that much riding the Stelvio solo last year, and when Wiggo won ToC, he basically rode all of Mt. Diablo at a tempo that barely anyone could attack from far out. If TD did that it'd force the climbers to burn matches trying to get up the road.

M-S has looked solid but it'll be week 3 when it really counts, and the Sunweb supporting cast is on cruise control right now.

Once it gets steep enough and group drafting has minimal impact, Tom Doumoulin's team can simply do the math and calculate the fastest the lightweights can make it to the top which is pretty well a deterministic number based on their power to weight, and they can calculate his time up the climb for a given power within seconds and sit on that number and limit losses. This would be the best tactic than worrying about yoyo lightweight climber surges during which those guys just ensure that their cumulative time to the top is slower than if they also just sat on their number given drafting will have less impact. Giant should basically be able to calculate exactly the worst case time loss if they just have TD sit on his power number on the steepest grade. Then it's down to the TT
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
...deterministic number blah blah blah




Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carapaz. Equadoran for “ rides away from”. I’d keep a close eye on this kid. Wins a stage and comes right back for 8th and picks up 2 spots in the process. I don’t see why he can’t move up more.

I think with the crazy climbing to come it’s about who can ride away from whom. The big team train dominance thing that destroys the front group is not really happening.

Chavez Yates look too good. TD is remarkable but he’s not dropping these guys. They’re going to wait until the gradient gets nasty and TD can only grind it out. He’ll limit losses but not enough, I think. Pinot could spoil the M Scott party too.

And then there is the “jour sans”. The day without. They all will have one now that the peloton is, um, cleanish. When does it occur and how does the GC guy limit his losses?
Last edited by: McNulty: May 15, 18 4:46
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Yeah, agree. TD has shown that while he can't necessary punch like the climbers he can go into TT mode and not give up a lot.

Egan Bernal... that kid is good.

They’ve got to throw him in the Vuelta.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Bernard looks awesome atm. Chaves is having his jour sans today. That was a surprise
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sky pisses me off again.

Chavez and a few others fell off the back of the peloton and Sky drilled it to keep them off and in the process reeled in a nice break group. Tony Martin was in the break then dropped the break and went with one guy from Israeli cycling. How would you like to be the only guy trying to ride away with Martin? He didn't last long.

On a cool note, the local kid on Bardiani, Ciccone, on his rest day went to a memorial for victims of an avalanche that destroyed a hotel last year. And then he got in the break today.
Last edited by: McNulty: May 15, 18 4:35
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
No fan of Sky but that’s the smart play. Bit of a turn of affairs today.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
No fan of Sky but that’s the smart play. Bit of a turn of affairs today.

true, though someone should still stick a copy of How to Win Friends and Influence People in Sir Dave's X-mas stocking
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Mohoric is such an insane descender. The weight of his massive balls must help him downhill.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
turdburgler wrote:
Mohoric is such an insane descender. The weight of his massive balls must help him downhill.


i think i was one of the first to take note of his pedaling while tucked style. dude sure is aero AF. I hope he wins with all the energy saved

Just found a good clip of that U23 race. and then for good measure after the descent, solo'ed it home while doing the IAB. Like a boss. Second place on that day was no slouch either: a certain Louis Mientjes.

The first four to go over the final passage of Via Salviatti were: Mohoric, Meintjes, Ewan, and Yates. What a group. Took a while for Mohoric to flourish.

The announcer was more than bemused, skip to 8 min 15 sec

Last edited by: echappist: May 15, 18 8:31
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I remember that race. Froome popularized it, but I don't recall ever seeing it before Matej. I hope he wins today. I'm certainly a fan.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Killer finish all around. Denz had the preferable position, but I was very happy to see Matej hold on!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
No fan of Sky but that’s the smart play. Bit of a turn of affairs today.

Doesn't really help Sky's GC chances, though. Yates picked up 3 seconds because the break was caught. And now that Chaves is 15 minutes down, he'll get some leash to get in breaks. (assuming Chaves can recover from the effects of his TvG-style rest day). Very weird to struggle so early in the day.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It certainly helps a bit. Not that I really think Froome has much of a chance left, but they have at least eliminated another GC contender. Chaves struggles were interesting. I don't recall him having issues like this after a rest day. I'll be interested to find out the back story on this.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pollen/asthma is what's being blamed
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Interesting. I saw Chaves interviewed at the end of the stage and he mentioned not having the strength to follow the others on the opening climb. No mention from him about pollen issues, though his director sportif did mention the high pollen count.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
No fan of Sky but that’s the smart play. Bit of a turn of affairs today.


Doesn't really help Sky's GC chances, though. Yates picked up 3 seconds because the break was caught. And now that Chaves is 15 minutes down, he'll get some leash to get in breaks. (assuming Chaves can recover from the effects of his TvG-style rest day). Very weird to struggle so early in the day.

In fairness to Sky, and I don't really want to be, other teams helped. I was really looking to see that break group interact.

Chaves is free now to start shit and this changes how he rides with Yates. No questioning roles. Chaves can cut loose and/or shepherd Yates when Kreuziger drops off. I don't see how this is bad for M Scott. Hope he bounces back.

Meanwhile other guys move up. How about Maxie Schachmann only 3:40 down? Joe D. 30 mins down, 47th with the bigger climbs to come. Movin' on up.......
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
trail wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
No fan of Sky but that’s the smart play. Bit of a turn of affairs today.


Doesn't really help Sky's GC chances, though. Yates picked up 3 seconds because the break was caught. And now that Chaves is 15 minutes down, he'll get some leash to get in breaks. (assuming Chaves can recover from the effects of his TvG-style rest day). Very weird to struggle so early in the day.


In fairness to Sky, and I don't really want to be, other teams helped. I was really looking to see that break group interact.

Chaves is free now to start shit and this changes how he rides with Yates. No questioning roles. Chaves can cut loose and/or shepherd Yates when Kreuziger drops off. I don't see how this is bad for M Scott. Hope he bounces back.

Meanwhile other guys move up. How about Maxie Schachmann only 3:40 down? Joe D. 30 mins down, 47th with the bigger climbs to come. Movin' on up.......

WTF....I go off the internet for 4 hrs (well the sport channel on the internet, I guess i was on work channels) and Chavez plummets to the floor. I guess this gives Scott a hand to play now sending Chavez up the road stage hunting with an option to drop back and pick up Yates if need be.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Mohoric, Meintjes, Ewan, and Yates.

Thanks for the trip down Memory Lane! I remembered Mohoric winning, but sure as hell didn't remember 2, 3, and 4. All very different riders, and all very talented.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
McNulty wrote:
trail wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
No fan of Sky but that’s the smart play. Bit of a turn of affairs today.


Doesn't really help Sky's GC chances, though. Yates picked up 3 seconds because the break was caught. And now that Chaves is 15 minutes down, he'll get some leash to get in breaks. (assuming Chaves can recover from the effects of his TvG-style rest day). Very weird to struggle so early in the day.


In fairness to Sky, and I don't really want to be, other teams helped. I was really looking to see that break group interact.

Chaves is free now to start shit and this changes how he rides with Yates. No questioning roles. Chaves can cut loose and/or shepherd Yates when Kreuziger drops off. I don't see how this is bad for M Scott. Hope he bounces back.

Meanwhile other guys move up. How about Maxie Schachmann only 3:40 down? Joe D. 30 mins down, 47th with the bigger climbs to come. Movin' on up.......


WTF....I go off the internet for 4 hrs (well the sport channel on the internet, I guess i was on work channels) and Chavez plummets to the floor. I guess this gives Scott a hand to play now sending Chavez up the road stage hunting with an option to drop back and pick up Yates if need be.
I reckon MS would have preferred to have Yates and Chaves at #1 and #2 as it would have let them push more work to the other GC teams. With Yates in Pink and Chaves within a minute, any Chaves attack would have to be chased by the other GC contenders and Yates could sit in for an easier ride.
With Chaves way back now, it gives him freedom to get away for stage wins or to assist Yates later in a stage but doesn't allow the same 2 way division of labour option.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ai_1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Today's stage is one for a strong break maybe. It's not an easy stage. You definitely can't be Assisi........
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ai_1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Maybe ir was all planned by the Yates/Chaves team.

Look where Yates is now. Fresh because he did not have something to do yesterday. The same for his teammates. The others (sky etc.) had to work hard for 244 km to gain time on Chaves, but maybe Chaves laughed secretly, bacause it was all an evil plan. Chaves had an easy day and can become a first quality helper for Yates. There is only one pink jersey isn't there?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [longtrousers] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
longtrousers wrote:
Maybe ir was all planned by the Yates/Chaves team.

Look where Yates is now. Fresh because he did not have something to do yesterday. The same for his teammates. The others (sky etc.) had to work hard for 244 km to gain time on Chaves, but maybe Chaves laughed secretly, bacause it was all an evil plan. Chaves had an easy day and can become a first quality helper for Yates. There is only one pink jersey isn't there?

Nice theory, but you just don't give up 2nd GC when Yates could go down at any moment due to 100 different reasons...crash, mechanical, flu, etc.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
In an unrelated note and @ Carl Spackler, did Tom Skujins hint at his plans when you interviewed him? What a helluva ride, and takes cojones to do an aero tuck down the Laguna Seca corkscrew
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
And his celebration across the line was spectacular as well. Toms seems like a great guy and kudos to him on the win after last years unfortunate exit from the TOC.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Insane finish today. What an incredible finish from Yates once again. I am starting to think that he is going to have enough time to hold of Tom D even with the expected losses in the stage 16 TT. Can't wait to see stage 14 & 15 in the mountains. I think Yates gets 1-2 minutes there. What I'm very curious about is how everyone responds after those mountain stages and the rest day before the TT. Should be fun!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
He did, called this stage out and described how to win out of a break. Exchanged some messages with him last night, such a good dude and awesome day for him.

Love the Giro for stages like today. Everyone’s thinking about Saturday when these intermediate stages are so unpredictable. Yates is starting to look dominant, though good to see TD seemingly on way up too. He just can’t afford t9 give up any more time.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
turdburgler wrote:
And his celebration across the line was spectacular as well. Toms seems like a great guy and kudos to him on the win after last years unfortunate exit from the TOC.

I don't know if I was clenching my cheeks more when he was doing the tuck down the Corkscrew or if he started celebrating with 150m to go, the latter b/c he looked a bit wobbly posting up due to the wind, and anything untoward would have been cruel after all that effort
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
When Sagan rolled to front at top of Corkscrew I knew he had it, with the group not wanting to take him to line.

Tell you want: it’s easy to hit 50mph in the drops going down it. Doing so in a Superman takes stones.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
turdburgler wrote:
And his celebration across the line was spectacular as well. Toms seems like a great guy and kudos to him on the win after last years unfortunate exit from the TOC.


I don't know if I was clenching my cheeks more when he was doing the tuck down the Corkscrew or if he started celebrating with 150m to go, the latter b/c he looked a bit wobbly posting up due to the wind, and anything untoward would have been cruel after all that effort

Agreed on all counts!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
turdburgler wrote:
And his celebration across the line was spectacular as well. Toms seems like a great guy and kudos to him on the win after last years unfortunate exit from the TOC.

I don't know if I was clenching my cheeks more when he was doing the tuck down the Corkscrew or if he started celebrating with 150m to go, the latter b/c he looked a bit wobbly posting up due to the wind, and anything untoward would have been cruel after all that effort

To be fair he was handed that stage in a gift basket, zero effort in the chase. Sky was uninterested, EQS disappeared, and MS did not want to pull Sagan.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yeah, it was obvious by how hard they went, and reduced peloton, that this was a gift <roll eyes>
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
turdburgler wrote:
Insane finish today. What an incredible finish from Yates once again. I am starting to think that he is going to have enough time to hold of Tom D even with the expected losses in the stage 16 TT. Can't wait to see stage 14 & 15 in the mountains. I think Yates gets 1-2 minutes there. What I'm very curious about is how everyone responds after those mountain stages and the rest day before the TT. Should be fun!

I sure hope Yates can hold it together. Relatively speaking, we're only about 10-15% done with the tour in terms of getting through the stages that you expect to see the biggest GC blows being thrown. He's burned a lot of matches so far, but at least his moves have been efficient in gaining time gaps and time bonuses...so as long as he doesn't crumble later...he's used those matches wisely thus far.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
We will see about Yates. I just saw he averaged 560W over the span of that last attack. Pretty decent for a man his size ;)

Now time to quit posting. Time to spectate a TT.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i am hugely impressed with Domoulin........he's the man on all but the steepest grades.....in a weird way, this can get in Yates' head later on
Last edited by: McNulty: May 16, 18 11:01
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I disagree with most of this. It looked to me like Sagan didn't want to pull everyone, only to end up not catching them anyway. The peloton was already reduced as well.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
those guys were shattered and if Sagan doesn't sit up and drags them Toms gets caught...........but that's why you attack......great ride, loved seeing it stick for a guy who deserves it
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Back to the Giro, TD wasn't far off Yates on that nasty kicker today. If his form is on the way up it'll be a really interesting third week, and on more moderate climbs.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
turdburgler wrote:
We will see about Yates. I just saw he averaged 560W over the span of that last attack. Pretty decent for a man his size ;)

Now time to quit posting. Time to spectate a TT.

barring illness, mechanicals, crashes, and such, how many minutes would Yates ship? Let's say, 2 bonus points (in next year's Spring Classic tally) for anyone being within 15 seconds of the right gap, 1 point for anyone within half a minute.

I'll go first (subject to changes), 2:45 lost by Yates
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
turdburgler wrote:
We will see about Yates. I just saw he averaged 560W over the span of that last attack. Pretty decent for a man his size ;)

Now time to quit posting. Time to spectate a TT.


barring illness, mechanicals, crashes, and such, how many minutes would Yates ship? Let's say, 2 bonus points (in next year's Spring Classic tally) for anyone being within 15 seconds of the right gap, 1 point for anyone within half a minute.

I'll go first (subject to changes), 2:45 lost by Yates

The TT looks like it has some lumps and technical corners in it similar to the opening TT. Dumoulin should still crush the rest of the GC guys, but I'm thinking the gap between TD and Yates is 2:25.

For my own entertainment purposes though, I hope TD minimizes losses this weekend and crushes the GC in the TT. Then try to defend a big lead in stages 18-20.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That is such a difficult question. The brutality of 14 & 15, the rest day before the TT...I'll take a shot in the dark though. Tom D will take 2:25 out of Simon, but that is a total crap shot. In a "fresh" TT I would give Tom a solid 3+ minutes. I just worry about the toll of Tom carrying his extra weight up the mountains on 14 & 15. Plus I don't think anyone knows what legs they will have riding a long TT after a rest day. If my 2:25 prediction swings +- 1:00 in either direction I wouldn't be surprised.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
turdburgler wrote:
That is such a difficult question. The brutality of 14 & 15, the rest day before the TT...I'll take a shot in the dark though. Tom D will take 2:25 out of Simon, but that is a total crap shot. In a "fresh" TT I would give Tom a solid 3+ minutes. I just worry about the toll of Tom carrying his extra weight up the mountains on 14 & 15. Plus I don't think anyone knows what legs they will have riding a long TT after a rest day. If my 2:25 prediction swings +- 1:00 in either direction I wouldn't be surprised.

you can revise until Tuesday morning :) But I fully agree, the toll in stages 14 and 15 are the most important, and that the TT is after a rest day always throws in a little bit more chaos. Reminds me of Evans at 2008 TdF: was expected to overhaul his rivals in the TT, but too tired to pull it off
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Yeah, it was obvious by how hard they went, and reduced peloton, that this was a gift <roll eyes>

Let me rephrase that without the hot take element. Sky could have shut it down but they did not care, most teams did not have their best domestiques with them and thus they were dropped by the end and everybody watched Sagan.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i've been reading predictions from this guy for quite a while;

his prediction for tomorrow seems off. The finale has a mile at 7-8% located 5 miles from the finish, and he's calling for a sprinter. Instead, I think the same actors who tried today could do well, including Wellens and Stybar. Perhaps Battaglin and Ulissi as well.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
turdburgler wrote:
We will see about Yates. I just saw he averaged 560W over the span of that last attack. Pretty decent for a man his size ;)

Now time to quit posting. Time to spectate a TT.


barring illness, mechanicals, crashes, and such, how many minutes would Yates ship? Let's say, 2 bonus points (in next year's Spring Classic tally) for anyone being within 15 seconds of the right gap, 1 point for anyone within half a minute.

I'll go first (subject to changes), 2:45 lost by Yates

I agree, between 2:30-3:00 unless Yates has an incredible day, which admittedely he seems almost too good at the moment so possibly only 2 minutes. I also wonder if he will pay for these "small" explosive efforts on week 3?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Week three, no problem....just get asthma LOL!!!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
i've been reading predictions from this guy for quite a while;

his prediction for tomorrow seems off. The finale has a mile at 7-8% located 5 miles from the finish, and he's calling for a sprinter. Instead, I think the same actors who tried today could do well, including Wellens and Stybar. Perhaps Battaglin and Ulissi as well.

d'oh, i really shouldnt quit my day job. Impressive ride from Bennett, took it up from a long way out (300 m?), and was also feisty on the climb. Didn't expect him to hang on the climb, but he did. Too bad Mohoric didn't make it. The Eurosport commentators were having a field day with Betancurt's weight though.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yes it was a very impressive ride for Bennett. He had one hell of a kick today.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This is the blog to follow for all the grand tours. Best analysis I have come across.

http://inrng.com/2018/05/giro-stage-12-preview-imola/#more-33504
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
echappist wrote:
i've been reading predictions from this guy for quite a while;

his prediction for tomorrow seems off. The finale has a mile at 7-8% located 5 miles from the finish, and he's calling for a sprinter. Instead, I think the same actors who tried today could do well, including Wellens and Stybar. Perhaps Battaglin and Ulissi as well.


d'oh, i really shouldnt quit my day job. Impressive ride from Bennett, took it up from a long way out (300 m?), and was also feisty on the climb. Didn't expect him to hang on the climb, but he did. Too bad Mohoric didn't make it. The Eurosport commentators were having a field day with Betancurt's weight though.

Bennett had to go early because Mohoric had a lead and the finish line was looming, how he managed to kick for that long is astounding- he's my new fave sprinter [plus he's on my fantasy team].
It is WAY COOL to see a stage of the Giro finish on the historic Imola track!

res, non verba
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I didn't follow today's stage, but looking at the results, Chaves was dead last, by himself, 15:24 down. Did something happen? Is he sick? Or is he simply saving himself for tomorrow?

"Human existence is based upon two pillars: Compassion and knowledge. Compassion without knowledge is ineffective; Knowledge without compassion is inhuman." Victor Weisskopf.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Alvin Tostig] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Good catch. He wouldn't ride in alone to save himself, wonder what happened.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Good catch. He wouldn't ride in alone to save himself, wonder what happened.

Yeah...there were options for him to ride with a group that was 3 minutes off the peloton, or even 8 minutes off the peloton if he really wanted to save himself. Finishing 5 minutes behind the last few riders means he was eating wind from a long way out. He must be struggling with something...this wasn't that long of a stage, but I didn't see the middle portions...maybe there was crosswinds and full gas sections in an attempt to split the peloton?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Alvin Tostig] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Alvin Tostig wrote:
I didn't follow today's stage, but looking at the results, Chaves was dead last, by himself, 15:24 down. Did something happen? Is he sick? Or is he simply saving himself for tomorrow?

I just saw that. By himself that far back doesn't look good, but could be anything. It's interesting and sometimes enlightening to see who pulls the plug for the day and when they grupetto it in and with whom. My boy Joe D has really conserved after riding on the front for the first part of yesterday. He was down 30 minutes in GC and has just added another 20 to that, I think, just by resting. A lot of climbing coming up so these past 2 days are "easy" and stay safe days. Chaves may be sandbagging but who knows.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
Alvin Tostig wrote:
I didn't follow today's stage, but looking at the results, Chaves was dead last, by himself, 15:24 down. Did something happen? Is he sick? Or is he simply saving himself for tomorrow?


I just saw that. By himself that far back doesn't look good, but could be anything. It's interesting and sometimes enlightening to see who pulls the plug for the day and when they grupetto it in and with whom. My boy Joe D has really conserved after riding on the front for the first part of yesterday. He was down 30 minutes in GC and has just added another 20 to that, I think, just by resting. A lot of climbing coming up so these past 2 days are "easy" and stay safe days. Chaves may be sandbagging but who knows.

Yeah...could be that he was riding the the last pack that finished 8 minutes down and had to take a Dumoulin?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Good catch. He wouldn't ride in alone to save himself, wonder what happened.

something seems seriously wrong. He was with the main group with still 15 km to go, and that one little measly hill saw him dropped. Real bummer. Hopefully not something more serious (I'm thinking along the lines of accidental brush with a tick or something).
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Good catch. He wouldn't ride in alone to save himself, wonder what happened.


something seems seriously wrong. He was with the main group with still 15 km to go, and that one little measly hill saw him dropped. Real bummer. Hopefully not something more serious (I'm thinking along the lines of accidental brush with a tick or something).

yeah, he seems sick.......Sky meanwhile is mauling Tejay but I believe he's going to get back close to Bernal and hang on....Bernal looks like Contador,.......
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Aaaaaaaand, I was wrong.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
Aaaaaaaand, I was wrong.

Bummer. But really impressive ride by McNulty.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Holy hell, Bernal.

Had McNulty not flatted yesterday he’d be sniffing GC podium. Nice guy, massive, massive potential.

Toms with KOM!
Last edited by: Carl Spackler: May 18, 18 17:38
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Holy hell, Bernal.

Had McNulty not flatted yesterday he’d be sniffing GC podium. Nice guy, massive, massive potential.

Toms with KOM!


Tejay did what he could do and then McNulty and others all descended with him. What was impressive is that the heavy chase group didn't put a dent into Bernal on the descent. Bernal killed it all the way down, maybe even added to his minute plus. Sky has a full stable.

On the Zonc today! The question is, Who will bonk on the Zonc?

I'm getting the impression that Froome is not going to fade. I think he makes at least a charge at a spot. TD hangs close, per usual. I think Formolo goes well again and Carapaz and Lopez too.

Pulling for Chaves to bounce back. He's up front with the team now but 120k to go.
Last edited by: McNulty: May 19, 18 4:33
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Should be epic with storms at the finish and slick descents. Might break up well before they even hit the base of the Zonc.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Holy hell, Bernal.

Had McNulty not flatted yesterday he’d be sniffing GC podium. Nice guy, massive, massive potential.

Toms with KOM!


Tejay did what he could do and then McNulty and others all descended with him. What was impressive is that the heavy chase group didn't put a dent into Bernal on the descent. Bernal killed it all the way down, maybe even added to his minute plus. Sky has a full stable.

On the Zonc today! The question is, Who will bonk on the Zonc?

I'm getting the impression that Froome is not going to fade. I think he makes at least a charge at a spot. TD hangs close, per usual. I think Formolo goes well again and Carapaz and Lopez too.

Pulling for Chaves to bounce back. He's up front with the team now but 120k to go.

which means he at least got over the first climb, which is quite nasty. where do they find all these climbs that average over 10%?

i think the Zoncolan might actually suit Dumoulin, assuming he has the right cassette. constant, non-relenting climbing at high gradient means people can't just ping off the front, as there's no respite. ergo, "slow" and steady win the day
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
McNulty wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Holy hell, Bernal.

Had McNulty not flatted yesterday he’d be sniffing GC podium. Nice guy, massive, massive potential.

Toms with KOM!


Tejay did what he could do and then McNulty and others all descended with him. What was impressive is that the heavy chase group didn't put a dent into Bernal on the descent. Bernal killed it all the way down, maybe even added to his minute plus. Sky has a full stable.

On the Zonc today! The question is, Who will bonk on the Zonc?

I'm getting the impression that Froome is not going to fade. I think he makes at least a charge at a spot. TD hangs close, per usual. I think Formolo goes well again and Carapaz and Lopez too.

Pulling for Chaves to bounce back. He's up front with the team now but 120k to go.


which means he at least got over the first climb, which is quite nasty. where do they find all these climbs that average over 10%?

i think the Zoncolan might actually suit Dumoulin, assuming he has the right cassette. constant, non-relenting climbing at high gradient means people can't just ping off the front, as there's no respite. ergo, "slow" and steady win the day


I agree with that if it's wet. He'll stay in the saddle and pound away, as will Froome. The lighter punchy Purito types won't be able to pop out of the saddle and bolt without risking spinning out. Pinot, even though he's on McNulty's team, Good Police, I see as being the desgnated bonk today. Something about that boy ain't quite right.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
I agree with that if it's wet. He'll stay in the saddle and pound away, as will Froome. The lighter punchy Purito types won't be able to pop out of the saddle and bolt without risking spinning out. Pinot, even though he's on McNulty's team, Good Police, I see as being the desgnated bonk today. Something about that boy ain't quite right.


I'll go with the opposite. I'll predict somewhat status quo and we'll see Yates and Pozzovivo punch free over the last few km. But they won't get too far from TD. There is no magic: Froome will fade again.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Viviani looks like Big Head on Silicon Valley.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
echappist wrote:
McNulty wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Holy hell, Bernal.

Had McNulty not flatted yesterday he’d be sniffing GC podium. Nice guy, massive, massive potential.

Toms with KOM!


Tejay did what he could do and then McNulty and others all descended with him. What was impressive is that the heavy chase group didn't put a dent into Bernal on the descent. Bernal killed it all the way down, maybe even added to his minute plus. Sky has a full stable.

On the Zonc today! The question is, Who will bonk on the Zonc?

I'm getting the impression that Froome is not going to fade. I think he makes at least a charge at a spot. TD hangs close, per usual. I think Formolo goes well again and Carapaz and Lopez too.

Pulling for Chaves to bounce back. He's up front with the team now but 120k to go.


which means he at least got over the first climb, which is quite nasty. where do they find all these climbs that average over 10%?

i think the Zoncolan might actually suit Dumoulin, assuming he has the right cassette. constant, non-relenting climbing at high gradient means people can't just ping off the front, as there's no respite. ergo, "slow" and steady win the day


I agree with that if it's wet. He'll stay in the saddle and pound away, as will Froome. The lighter punchy Purito types won't be able to pop out of the saddle and bolt without risking spinning out. Pinot, even though he's on McNulty's team, Good Police, I see as being the desgnated bonk today. Something about that boy ain't quite right.

Change the thread title for today to: "Europe's toughest climb....Zoncolan Blowups at Giro TODAY"!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Certainly no place for Froome or anyone else having a bad day to hide. I’m more in the camp that a few are together behind a non-GC guy who throws a Hail Mary and clips off the front.

Have to leave for a Grasshopper in 45 min right when it will start going down. Arrg.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
[/quote] There is no magic: Froome will fade again.[/quote]




Sky has a TUE for magic.
Last edited by: McNulty: May 19, 18 7:15
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote:
Sky has a TUE for magic.


Sigh. At least he didn't exactly blow up GC.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
Quote:
Sky has a TUE for magic.


Sigh. At least he didn't exactly blow up GC.

It ain't over till it is over.

The magic continues!!!! Go Froome :-)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I first thought Froome rides himself fit for week three and the Giro-Tour double. But after five stages it was clear to me that he will just call it a giro and head out the back door. Now I am again in theorie 1, but I guess Yates is in too much of a monster shape and Dumoulin doing too good in the mountains that he won't compete for the win. But the podium is now a real option.

Man, can keep Yates his level that high for another week? I guess he doesn't even need to keep it that sharp but rather avoid blowing up. Dumouli is lurking but at the moment Yates looks so fricking strong.

(And what was that from Poels in the first half of the mountain? He looked as if he could ramp it up at least two gears any moment. And then he was suddendly gone.

10k - 30:48 / half - 1:06:40
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yates still looks strong. He's now got 32 seconds worth of time bonuses accumulated. He's also got a 4th and 5th place finish in stages. Froome looking strong now makes the GC race a lot more interesting. Not that I think he can still win, but if he sends the Sky train to the front tomorrow, it could make tomorrow's stage a lot harder than it was already going to be. Could also increase the chances that the break is brought back and time bonuses are in play for the GC.

Dumoulin did well all things considered. But at this point I believe he has to hope Yates fades in week 3. I don't see how he can gain back enough time in the TT while surviving stages 18-20 the way Yates is riding now. There is also a pretty good battle for the remaining spot on the podium brewing. Froome's going to gain some time on Pozzovivo and Pinot in the TT...so they're sitting about even right now.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ToBeasy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ToBeasy wrote:
I first thought Froome rides himself fit for week three and the Giro-Tour double. But after five stages it was clear to me that he will just call it a giro and head out the back door. Now I am again in theorie 1, but I guess Yates is in too much of a monster shape and Dumoulin doing too good in the mountains that he won't compete for the win. But the podium is now a real option.

Man, can keep Yates his level that high for another week? I guess he doesn't even need to keep it that sharp but rather avoid blowing up. Dumouli is lurking but at the moment Yates looks so fricking strong.

(And what was that from Poels in the first half of the mountain? He looked as if he could ramp it up at least two gears any moment. And then he was suddendly gone.

Froome is till in striking distance for the win. A Yates and Dumoulin bonk or crash and he's there. It ain't over.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
Froome is till in striking distance for the win. A Yates and Dumoulin bonk or crash and he's there. It ain't over.

Indeed, this could be an absolute classic after that showing from Froome.

Yates still needs to attack in the mountains, but now Sky well may go all out for Froome.

That stage today though... the cameras on TV don't do it justice, but the profile is eye-watering, and the speed they go up it is bonkers. They're not spending 2mins at 15%, they're spending 30min. It's amazing.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
Quote:
There is no magic: Froome will fade again.





Sky has a TUE for magic.


He went up the Z faster than Basso.

Those pillows in Ferrara must be something else.
Last edited by: jdw: May 19, 18 12:05
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [jdw] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jdw wrote:
McNulty wrote:
Quote:
There is no magic: Froome will fade again.





Sky has a TUE for magic.


He went up the Z faster than Basso.

Those pillows in Ferrara must be something else.

Hey hey, let's not let any logic get in the way of the show. If we used the same logic for NFL we would never watch the Pharma-circus
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [jdw] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jdw wrote:
McNulty wrote:
Quote:
There is no magic: Froome will fade again.





Sky has a TUE for magic.


He went up the Z faster than Basso.

Those pillows in Ferrara must be something else.

Where did you get the Zoncolan times (both for the guys yesterday and Basso). I'd be interested in seeing them all tabulated.

Today's stage is not a cakewalk. They are going through Cortina d'Ampezzo, so through the same roads that I saw the Giro on in 1985. if you are a downhill skier or a downhill ski fan, they are close to the world cup mountains in Val Gardena and Cortina.


Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [bluefever] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
bluefever wrote:
devashish_paul wrote:

Froome is till in striking distance for the win. A Yates and Dumoulin bonk or crash and he's there. It ain't over.


Indeed, this could be an absolute classic after that showing from Froome.

Yates still needs to attack in the mountains, but now Sky well may go all out for Froome.

That stage today though... the cameras on TV don't do it justice, but the profile is eye-watering, and the speed they go up it is bonkers. They're not spending 2mins at 15%, they're spending 30min. It's amazing.

I was at a swim meet during the day and watched it several times later. At this point below, after Michael Woods attacked and everyone was on the rivet following Pouls the funniest part is that the peloton could not even drop the guy in the dinosaur suit, so Froome had to punch him to finally drop him



Eddy Merckx and Bernard Hinault approve of this type of "boss" like gesture to protect the rest of his fellow riders LOL!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ToBeasy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It's pissing rain pulling out of Cortina on the way up to the first major cllimb. Typical miserable spring day in the Dolomites. Advantage in the colder temp goes to the bigger riders who will freeze less on the descent.


Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Woods decides to attack early again, trying to bridge up to the leaders. In the process he puts a bunch of the GC guys in a bit of distress
Last edited by: devashish_paul: May 20, 18 6:13
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Probably suits Dumoulin who is both bigger and grew up in northern Europe. Froome doesn't like the cold and wet, and given his crashes earlier in the race imagine he'll be a bit nervous on the wet tarmac. Yates should be OK, smaller guy but they get plenty of cold and rain in Manchester!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm a Woods fan. The only Canadian to ever run a sub 4 minute mile- in Canada. But his Prefontaine stuff yesterday was ill advised. and he admitted as much. Got too excited. He's learning. I wish he were 24.

Love this Ciccione kid. He'll be like the Jeffersons soon, movin' on up.

Seeing guys pop and really suffer to finish is a good sign. It's natural. Hate it for them, but ya know.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
Seeing guys pop and really suffer to finish is a good sign. It's natural. Hate it for them, but ya know.


Poor Aru, waving away the camera bikes to not record his misery.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
McNulty wrote:

Seeing guys pop and really suffer to finish is a good sign. It's natural. Hate it for them, but ya know.



Poor Aru, waving away the camera bikes to not record his misery.

yeah, sucks that they do that.....................TD is hurting.....i
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Froome hurting more, paying for yesterday's effort. Yates crushing it again!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:

yeah, sucks that they do that.....................TD is hurting.....i

And Froome dropped again.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
cartsman wrote:
Froome hurting more, paying for yesterday's effort. Yates crushing it again!

No one can say Yates isn't racing to win, pushing all the chips in against Dumoulin going solo from 15K out.

His performances are pretty....er, remarkable.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
cartsman wrote:
Froome hurting more, paying for yesterday's effort. Yates crushing it again!


No one can say Yates isn't racing to win, pushing all the chips in against Dumoulin going solo from 15K out.

His performances are pretty....er, remarkable.

aided by the putzing chasers. it aint just the classics specialists who can't organize a chase. that gap should have been pegged below 20 seconds, instead it's approaching a minute.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yates riding away from TD and Pinot on flats? Uhhm
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Yates riding away from TD and Pinot on flats? Uhhm

the chasers are pissing away the seconds though. they decide to chase, gap dipping toward 35; when no one else comes through, gap shoots back up to 45.

TD just chased back to Pinot et al, closing 17 second gap. what are they all thinking? seems like they are more interested in podium positions than actually overhauling Yates
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
McNulty wrote:

yeah, sucks that they do that.....................TD is hurting.....i

And Froome dropped again.
Looks like yesterday was a wedding gift to Harry. Like the British equivalent to Bastille Day
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Well, TD was gapped repeatedly so they weren’t putzing the whole time. TD doesn’t appear at his best, but still.

It’s Yates’ race to lose at this point. Wonder if Froome throws in the towel and turns final week into training.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:

It’s Yates’ race to lose at this point. Wonder if Froome throws in the towel and turns final week into training.

You'd think for the $1.4M or whatever it was he should try for a 2nd stage win...maybe the TT.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Yates riding away from TD and Pinot on flats? Uhhm


the chasers are pissing away the seconds though. they decide to chase, gap dipping toward 35; when no one else comes through, gap shoots back up to 45.

TD just chased back to Pinot et al, closing 17 second gap. what are they all thinking? seems like they are more interested in podium positions than actually overhauling Yates

Carapaz rode like a twerp.

TD is money, just amazing. He saved his chances. Frickin' studly suffering. You look at the final sprint to the line and he looks like he's surrounded by munchkins.

Yates' attack was super ballsy and risky. If he didn't get enough of an initial gap before the descent and had been caught by the chasers, he could have blown it big time.

Earlier, when it was all blowing up, it was fascinating to see TD and Yates both looking around to see where Froome was. Respect.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [torrey] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Think he simply burnt all his matches yesterday, and then often has a bad day when it's cold and wet anyway. Plus Yates really is on superlative form, he seems to be able to have the acceleration to get that break on the hills whenever he wants. Reminds me a bit of Contador in his early days when he just had that explosive acceleration on the hills.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I really hope Yates is clean. I love how he rides, but I am concerned that he was putting time in to the others on the flats as well. The power feed from Yates is eye raising.

He looked like Pantani today and attacking out of the saddle, in the drops and big ring, spinning 75 rpm.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
just rewatched Yate's attack. Not saying that it isn't a bit "remarkable" how strong it looked, as he was caught and attacked immediately to gain 10 seconds, but the chasers certainly helped in letting him sail away. From his second attack to top of the hill, the gradient is ~5%. These guys should be going at a good 16-17 mph here, and drafting certainly helps.

At 16.5, Pozzovivo is driving on the front, gap down to 13 seconds (from 18); Pinot second in line, followed by Carapaz. This means that TD is 4th or 5th wheel



At 16.1, Pozzovivo presumably had peeled off from his turn. Pinot now on the front, with a gap to the second rider, Carapaz. Conclusion, Carapaz rode like a twerp and didn't pull through, Pinot got fed up and attacked.


At 16.0, again a paceline, with Pinot leading, followed by Pozzovivo. Everyone presumably has just went over threshold (Pinot to initiate attack, everyone else trying to follow). Gap at 14 seconds, which is insignificant from 13, but soon after, it went up to 18 seconds when Yates crested the hill



All the while, TD was nowhere near the front! From game theory perspective, it's awfully bad faith to be the strongest of the group and not contribute to the chase, especially as the gradient was low here. Gap continued to grow as they dropped into the valley, and finally we see TD working. Yet after one turn, TD has the temerity to tell others to pull through, when he went shirking on the climb...



My take from all this: Carapaz rode like a twerp, but TD was a bit too cynical and was solely concerned about additional energy he needed to burn. He had willing riders who cooperated, but refused to put his nose into the wind until the gap ballooned to over 30 second (12 of which from the descent). The other riders (Pinot and Pozzovivo) were right to shed him and make him work.

Also, at one point they had a graphic showing Yates averaging 420 W on the final incline (~1.5 km from ~3.5 to ~2km). That's 7 w/kg, after 14 days of racing, at the end of a stage, and an altitude of 4000 ft. A lot of power, indeed, but doesn't appear to have anything that jumps out. His ability to put in two attacks though, that was remarkable as noted above.
Last edited by: echappist: May 20, 18 8:47
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What was his power on the first attack? Maybe he was sandbagging it a bit the first time, softening them up and letting them think they'd pulled him back before going harder the second time?

I've given up second guessing who's doping, it's pretty much impossible to tell whether we're watching a cleanish rider dominate a cleanish peloton or a doped rider dominate a doped peloton. I'm certainly of the view that if there is cheating going on then there's enough movement between teams that the trade secrets will be fairly well spread around. E.g. if Sky's marginal gains have crossed the line into cheating, then key riders like Landa and Porte who have led the team in Grand Tours would certainly have been on the programme and will have taken that knowledge with them. So have to assume the top teams are all on similar programmes, whether they're legal or in grey areas.

My guess is that Yates is as clean as any of them, he's certainly been a top talent from an early age. I guess we'll find out at some point how clean the peloton currently is, through autobiographies if nothing else.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Is Tramadol still not banned?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yeah, he made a good move and stayed on the gas while the chase group squabbled. But he did that from 17k out, grew gap across flats, and a day after smashing the toughest climb in cycling. Three stage wins and missed 4th by a hair yesterday, while the rest of the contenders look fairly close in the fight for scraps. Nibali and Quintana never really put TD to the sword like that, so it Yates that good?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Yates that good?

If he beats Tony Martin in the TT like Contador was beating Cancellara for a while, I'll stop giving him the benefit of doubt.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
its sure been a race of unexpected performances. first chavez, now aru cracking completely. froome well below his normal level and yates well above the level he's previously shown. i'm taking the attitude that this is great as it gives us unexpected results. one can draw all kinds of conclusions based on this but its all speculation so best to just accept it is what it is and be happy with the excitement it provides.

dumoulin is keeping steady but i think if yates can keep climbing like he is he'll take it comfortably. still, the last week could well have even more twists than the first 2
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
I'm a Woods fan. The only Canadian to ever run a sub 4 minute mile- in Canada. But his Prefontaine stuff yesterday was ill advised. and he admitted as much. Got too excited. He's learning. I wish he were 24.

Love this Ciccione kid. He'll be like the Jeffersons soon, movin' on up.

Seeing guys pop and really suffer to finish is a good sign. It's natural. Hate it for them, but ya know.

Woods has said that he likes the tough steep climbs because at some point it gets down to the same times per km as his running paces, but if you're in a 10K track race, you don't attack at 6K out, which is what he did. He just built up too much lactate yesterday to deal with it. Also keep in mind that when the altitude gets above 1400m or so, there is some thinning of the air and then you have the final 400m of vertical to go
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Yates that good?


If he beats Tony Martin in the TT like Contador was beating Cancellara for a while, I'll stop giving him the benefit of doubt.

There may be a few restaurants in Spain that Yates has been getting his beef from :-). Actually, rolling back to last year's Vuelta, Contrador appeared (in my mind) to have have just too awesome form. It was an awesome gift to the Spanish fans with him taking Angliru and all, but it almost felt like he got a free pass...in any case, hopefully Yates is clean. Let's wait for Tuesday to gauge his Contador like awesomeness in TT's!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I hope we see some more power files released. I saw some power files that from some affiliates and university maths nerds that I trust and the NP or some guys is already crazy. Froome's Zoncolan ascent VAM estimates and what Yates has been doing on not just stage wins, but on finishes where he is powering on the flats are a bit unnerving.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
turdburgler wrote:
I hope we see some more power files released. I saw some power files that from some affiliates and university maths nerds that I trust and the NP or some guys is already crazy. Froome's Zoncolan ascent VAM estimates and what Yates has been doing on not just stage wins, but on finishes where he is powering on the flats are a bit unnerving.

Does anyone have the Froome time up Zoncolan vs Basso? Someone said Froome's was faster. I suppose we could just go to the video and time Froome and work the VAM data from there.

Dev
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
If I were a betting man I would say we will see some well written and researched articles in this area very soon as there are parties who have already seen interesting historical trends this year. I hope we see this same level of interest in triathlon because I am tired of the blind eye our sport turns as well.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Yeah, he made a good move and stayed on the gas while the chase group squabbled. But he did that from 17k out, grew gap across flats, and a day after smashing the toughest climb in cycling. Three stage wins and missed 4th by a hair yesterday, while the rest of the contenders look fairly close in the fight for scraps. Nibali and Quintana never really put TD to the sword like that, so it Yates that good?

we shall see. TD still looks good though, despite his struggles today. I'd say he takes back 2:30 on Yate, which would make it a really tight race.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
Is Tramadol still not banned?

No, Jimmy, it's not.

I don't get why. I rode on it once just to see what the hubbub was all about. I had heard about its use from a former high level Amateur Cali racer.

It wasn't a real race, it was the Wednesday Night Worlds, group race/ride of mostly team guys. Oftentimes it was harder than the races on Saturday.

I split a pill in half because I'm a weenie. I don't know the mg. There is one short steep hill that selects guys like me out. I always raced at 205 to 215 lbs.

This night I stuck in the front group of lighter 1's and former pros that attacked on the climb. It was remarkable to look down and see my numbers through the roof and go, huh, isn't that crazy. The pain that usually kicked in on the climb was not there and there was a certain detachment to the ride that was disconcerting. I can see why they say it causes crashes. You're less aware, you have this kind of, oh well, whatever feeling. It's an opiate.

I know it has been rampant in the amateur ranks. One friend with addiction issues in Cali, a former high level guy gave me a primer on it. Not pretty.

So when I see a guy seemingly not suffering like the other humans I wonder why. And do they simply pick their days to use it and go with no masking on other days? If it is not banned and you're looking up at Zoncolan, it would really be tempting.

I give the benefit of the doubt mostly but when something looks too good to be true, there ya go. But we'll see going forward. Yates is going to have to have his day without. He was completely shattered at the finish today. no faking it. Maybe he is that good.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
OK, looking at the time differences, if Dumoulin pulls back all of Yate's lead on the Tuesday TT, I don't see anything in between now and the Sestriere stage where Yates can gain back time and the Colle delle Finsestre may be too early in the stage, but who knows with the gravel.

Here is the description of this year's Cima Coppi....gravel on the second half:

The Colle delle Finestre (Cima Coppi) has a steady 9.2% gradient throughout (with just a short punchy bit in Meana di Susa topping out at 14%). The first 9 km are on tarmac, while the last 9 km is a gravel road, all the way to the summit. Twenty-nine hairpins are tucked in less than 4 km over the first part of the climb (45 hairpins overall until the summit). The descent is very technical as the roadway is narrow and initially unprotected, up to Pian dell’Alpe. As the route goes back onto the ss. 23, the climb is resumed with doable gradients all the way to the finish. A long uncomplicated climb follows, leading to the Sestriere categorised summit. Following a fast drop into Oulx and a false flat section leading to Bardonecchia (intermediate sprint), the route takes in the closing climb to the top of Jafferau. Final kilometres: the final 7 km run entirely uphill, with sharp 9-10% gradients, topping out at 14% in the first part. The road narrows in Maillaures, approx. 6 km before the finish, in the steepest section. The finish line lies on a 50-m long, 6-m wide home stretch.



And then Saturday's stage to Cervina/Zermatt



This queen stage across the Alps features a remarkable 4,000 m rise and drop, tucked away in the last 90 km, where the riders will tackle 3 climbs amounting to nearly 20 km each. The route climbs steadily all the way from Susa towards Turin, and then follows the gentle undulations of the Canavese to reach the Dora Riparia valley. The route then heads from the outskirts of Ivrea to the Aosta Valley to tackle the last 90 km. The stage takes in climbs up the Col Tsecore (16 km with long stretches exceeding 12% over the last 4 km), Col de St.Pantaléon (16.5 km at 7.2%) and Cervinia (19 km at 5%). The roads are always quite wide and well surfaced. Final kilometres: the route rises all the way to the finish. The steepest stretch is encountered just before Valtournenche, and throughout the town centre. The gradient starts to weaken at the 3 km mark, with slopes averaging 1.4% over the final 2 km. The home straight (450 m long, on 7-m wide asphalt road) has a 4% gradient. Note that the route passes through two well-lit tunnels over the final 6 km.

I am not seeing anything on the final hill stage to drop Dumoulin. The Sestriere/Finestre stage, I can see lots of things turning upside down through, with the gravel and technical descent too.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:

So when I see a guy seemingly not suffering like the other humans I wonder why.

Yeah, not going to attach a name (but not Yates), but a buddy of mine remarked on the behavior of the winner of a recent brutally hard WorldTour race. Usually when guys cross the line after having spent 5-6 hours at near-full gas, and the last 30 minutes at full-full gas, they appear to be exhausted. They go sit down for a while, or gingerly cool down. This guy was just utterly non-chalant after having shelled some huge names, like he'd ridden to pick up a six pack. Chatty, bouncy, etc. My buddy wasn't commenting out of suspicion, just admiration, but your words make me think about it.

My only similar experience was just with plain old ibuprofen in a running ultra. It was like 20 hours in, and I was in the depths of the abyss, angry, sullen, wanting to quit, and would have if there'd been a way out (I was in the boonies). I found 4 Advil in the bottom of my salt pill container, and downed them. My world completely changed. I became cheerful and giddy, and started flying.

Drugs - legal or otherwise - can really help.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
it looks like being an interesting last week :)
i see dumoulin more or less even with yates after the TT. if yates can keep climbing like he has been then i see him gaining back any minor time he may fall behind - he seems to be able to gain time at will in the mountains!
pinot will probably skip ahead of pozzivivo into 2nd but not by too much so that will be a good ongoing battle
if the froome we've seen in previous seasons shows up he should get close to that battle for the podium too.
lopez and carapaz sit 5th and 6th but seem more intent on battling for the young riders jersey which may or may not align with overall gc position
bennett in 8th still seems to be to enthusiastic and attacking early, he'll likely see dennis skip up into 8th in the TT anyway

Question: assuming everyone is equally fatigued, who loses more from their fresh TT performance - the usually strong TTer or the climber? i'm inclined to think the TTer can do a good TT regardless of their legs whereas a climber is inclined to fall apart when tired. but then being in the pink jersey will give yates all the motivation you could want
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [pk1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pk1 wrote:
it looks like being an interesting last week :)
i see dumoulin more or less even with yates after the TT. if yates can keep climbing like he has been then i see him gaining back any minor time he may fall behind - he seems to be able to gain time at will in the mountains!
pinot will probably skip ahead of pozzivivo into 2nd but not by too much so that will be a good ongoing battle
if the froome we've seen in previous seasons shows up he should get close to that battle for the podium too.
lopez and carapaz sit 5th and 6th but seem more intent on battling for the young riders jersey which may or may not align with overall gc position
bennett in 8th still seems to be to enthusiastic and attacking early, he'll likely see dennis skip up into 8th in the TT anyway

Question: assuming everyone is equally fatigued, who loses more from their fresh TT performance - the usually strong TTer or the climber? i'm inclined to think the TTer can do a good TT regardless of their legs whereas a climber is inclined to fall apart when tired. but then being in the pink jersey will give yates all the motivation you could want

Also let's not forget that TT day is the day after the rest day. Anything can happen. Pretty sure Froome and Dumoulin will be on though. I can't remember the last TT when Froome sucked other than Jerusalem after a crash. Same deal with Dumoulin. He is always on for a TT.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I don't understand why tramadol hasn't been banned or at least regulated under a TUE (where at least it's abuse would be documented...), given that everybody has been talking about it for a couple of years, and also that there would seem to be a clear health risk - over-riding the body's sense of pain to allow riders to dig deeper surely risks them damaging themselves, as will the increased likelihood of crashes due to the detachment and confusion that tramadol apparently brings.

Yates still gets benefit of the doubt for me. He's certainly riding at a higher level than previous years, but he's young enough (25) to make big natural gains from one year to the next, and has a solid pedigree and progression including junior and senior world track titles, multiple top 10 finishes in big stage races over the last 3 years, and a couple of top 10 GT finishes including TdF white jersey. Not like he's come from nowhere, he's the sort of rider you'd expect to have a breakthrough at some point as age, tactical awareness and team support all come together. Also worth noting that despite being a small guy he was a decent pursuit rider as a junior so should be capable of turning in a better TT than you might expect from a specialist climber.

I also think he's been somewhat flattered by the competition this year. Dumoulin hasn't had a great season to date and I think was always going to be slightly vulnerable to aggressive attacks on the steeper stuff - he surprised us with his tenacity last year but he's not quite in the same form and I also don't think either Nibali or Quintana were at their best last year either. Froome has clearly either been more affected by the doping case than he's letting on (would be surprising if he hadn't been to be honest), is really focusing on the TdF and/or just timed his peak wrong. No Nibali or Quintana, Pozzovivo would be delighted just to round off his career with a GT podium finish, Aru and Pinot have been disappointing.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
cartsman wrote:
Aru and Pinot have been disappointing.

I wouldn't lump Pinot with Aru. I think Pinot's doing well so far. In the past he's always had a really bad day that just destroyed his GC chances. So far in the Giro he hasn't had that really bad day.

He's raced aggressively when he can, maybe a little too aggressively at times. He's just not nearly as good as Yates or TD. But I wouldn't call that disappointing. Sometimes in bike racing you're not the best guy, and he's doing really well just to stay in the game. When you're in the game sometimes good things happen.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I will give you all the points on Yate's progression and him having a solid past track record of success in previous grand tours (but that past record includes a suspension too) and the competition perhaps not being as strong as past years. I think the Zoncolan VAM data will be a great way to know how legit or shady these performances are. It is good to see Froome vulnerable after emptying the tank. This is what we used to always count on in the pre epo era where all the favourites would have off days. I will concede that all the non pharma sports physiology knowledge about how to recover quickly for the next day helps us more today than in 1985, and perhaps it is possible for a clean rider to have no off days, and I kind of buy when they don't have off days if they are constantly holding back, but when they are attacking every day, all the time and not blowing up (like Landa in the TdF or Yates now) then you wonder. Even Contador at last year's Vuelta attacking like a madman, also had bad days (early in the race, so maybe he was rejuiced to the gills in in swansong grand tour). Froome in his last bunch of Grand Tours has raced just hard enough to stay in contention daily, but not so hard that he self buries for the next day. Yesterday is the first time in the long time that we saw him launch a long range attack and pay. Yates pretty well matched Froome and did not pay, but as a few have said, the cumulative load on a lighter rider is less and they may recover faster (maybe the organs of a small rider relative to body size are larger resulting in faster recovery....don't know, but I would be curious as to why smaller athletes tend to recover faster....I can see impact sports like running why they do, but cycling is a head sratcher unless if has to do with organ size/efficiency....maybe why we see some small people living long lives too).
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
cartsman wrote:
Aru and Pinot have been disappointing.


I wouldn't lump Pinot with Aru. I think Pinot's doing well so far. In the past he's always had a really bad day that just destroyed his GC chances. So far in the Giro he hasn't had that really bad day.

He's raced aggressively when he can, maybe a little too aggressively at times. He's just not nearly as good as Yates or TD. But I wouldn't call that disappointing. Sometimes in bike racing you're not the best guy, and he's doing really well just to stay in the game. When you're in the game sometimes good things happen.

Fair point. I guess with those 2 I partly meant their whole progression over the last few years has been a bit disappointing, they've not really fulfilled the early GT promise they showed. Pinot's best GT result came 4 years when he was 24. I guess at this point in his career I'd expected more from him than staying in the game and hoping for a podium which is where he seems to be. Aru obviously has a GT win under his belt, but after a couple of years of focusing on the TdF I'd hoped to see him really challenge here on home turf and steeper hills which should suit him.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Agreed re the Zoncolan data, though I do think sometimes people analysing VAM data don't take the full context into account. E.g. temperature and wind can still play a role even on the steep stuff, and race context even more so - how far into the race it was, how early the attacks started, whether the riders went up at a steady TT-type effort or were constantly surging and recovering, etc. Can't remember exactly which mountain it was in the Tour, but a couple of years ago people were getting over-excited about Froome going up it quicker than Lance did, while not really taking into account that Froome's time was set as the finale to a stage while Lance's time was set in the middle of a stage with another couple of climbs still to come.

Has Yates really been attacking every day, all the time? Agree he went early yesterday and looked to be all out by the end. But on other days it's seemed more to me like he's hung with the group and then just put in 1 or 2 decisive attacks to get away and make time in the last few km. I haven't had the benefit of watching all the racing live, I've just been catching text updates, stage finishes and highlights when I can, so could be I've missed some attacks. But what's seemed most remarkable to me isn't that he's burying himself every day and recovering but instead is the decisiveness and efficiency of his attacks. Seems to combine the tactical acumen to know exactly when to go, with the acceleration required to break away at will and make it stick. If he was repeatedly attacking from a long way out, being reeled back in, and then going again, then I'd agree it would be more suspicious.

Do also think the psychological benefit of the pink jersey on a 25 year old leading his first Grand Tour shouldn't be underestimated - given we've just been talking about Tramadol which doesn't provide any physiological benefit (like burning fat, increasing oxygen carrying capacity, etc) but simply allows you to ignore pain and dig deeper. Yates seems like he's absolutely loving every minute of this experience, he's got that confidence/cockiness of a young gun having his breakthrough race, and that's got to help him eke out an extra percent or 2 when others are suffering.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
cartsman wrote:
Agreed re the Zoncolan data, though I do think sometimes people analysing VAM data don't take the full context into account. E.g. temperature and wind can still play a role even on the steep stuff, and race context even more so - how far into the race it was, how early the attacks started, whether the riders went up at a steady TT-type effort or were constantly surging and recovering, etc. Can't remember exactly which mountain it was in the Tour, but a couple of years ago people were getting over-excited about Froome going up it quicker than Lance did, while not really taking into account that Froome's time was set as the finale to a stage while Lance's time was set in the middle of a stage with another couple of climbs still to come.

Has Yates really been attacking every day, all the time? Agree he went early yesterday and looked to be all out by the end. But on other days it's seemed more to me like he's hung with the group and then just put in 1 or 2 decisive attacks to get away and make time in the last few km. I haven't had the benefit of watching all the racing live, I've just been catching text updates, stage finishes and highlights when I can, so could be I've missed some attacks. But what's seemed most remarkable to me isn't that he's burying himself every day and recovering but instead is the decisiveness and efficiency of his attacks. Seems to combine the tactical acumen to know exactly when to go, with the acceleration required to break away at will and make it stick. If he was repeatedly attacking from a long way out, being reeled back in, and then going again, then I'd agree it would be more suspicious.

Do also think the psychological benefit of the pink jersey on a 25 year old leading his first Grand Tour shouldn't be underestimated - given we've just been talking about Tramadol which doesn't provide any physiological benefit (like burning fat, increasing oxygen carrying capacity, etc) but simply allows you to ignore pain and dig deeper. Yates seems like he's absolutely loving every minute of this experience, he's got that confidence/cockiness of a young gun having his breakthrough race, and that's got to help him eke out an extra percent or 2 when others are suffering.

I would say most of your counterpoints are accurate. It is true that he saves his attacks for the right time and does not do like others (ex: Pinot or Woods attacking too early). I do hope that after the ITT it all evens out mainly because I want to see the GC guys fight for the summit finishes on Fri and Sat and thus the time bonuses and not allow any breakaways to get too far up the road. If Dumoulin is too far behind after the TT, then the game will kind of be over unless Froome can pull off a miracle for the last few mountain stages after a solid TT.

Regardless of VAM data and what may appear like extra ordinary riding, the Giro to date has been really interesting. If Dumoulin can take the lead back on Tuesday, its going to be really explosive in the final days. I like it when the ITT is done earlier and you have a few mountain stages to go
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
cartsman wrote:
Aru and Pinot have been disappointing.


I wouldn't lump Pinot with Aru. I think Pinot's doing well so far. In the past he's always had a really bad day that just destroyed his GC chances. So far in the Giro he hasn't had that really bad day.

He's raced aggressively when he can, maybe a little too aggressively at times. He's just not nearly as good as Yates or TD. But I wouldn't call that disappointing. Sometimes in bike racing you're not the best guy, and he's doing really well just to stay in the game. When you're in the game sometimes good things happen.

I agree with everything you are saying here. Pinot has ridden a terrific race. H
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
but as a few have said, the cumulative load on a lighter rider is less and they may recover faster (maybe the organs of a small rider relative to body size are larger resulting in faster recovery....don't know, but I would be curious as to why smaller athletes tend to recover faster....I can see impact sports like running why they do, but cycling is a head sratcher unless if has to do with organ size/efficiency....maybe why we see some small people living long lives too).

Those are some interesting musings.

Isn't the size/lifespan issue connected to calories - the more calories processed the greater the toll on the body. (n.b I'm using processed on purpose, rather than consumed i.e. this isn't about being gluttonous or a fatty)

In which case, in a time microcosm, then the smaller rider consuming fewer calories over the race day may well lead to less damage (I don't know the process) and therefore faster recovery.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [tuckandgo] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Lurking more than posting on the GT threads....so let's hear it guys.

Will it be virtual tie on GC tomorrow? Or will Yates hold on for ~30ish seconds still?

Brooks Doughtie, M.S.
Exercise Physiology
-USAT Level II
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [B_Doughtie] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
B_Doughtie wrote:
Lurking more than posting on the GT threads....so let's hear it guys.

Will it be virtual tie on GC tomorrow? Or will Yates hold on for ~30ish seconds still?

I think Dumoulin pulls back enough time to take Pink. Maybe by 10-20 seconds. But it's not going to be enough unless Yates comes back to earth...or TD somehow joins him in the realm of the unbelievable. Yates is not just putting time on Dumoulin when the road goes up...he's putting time on EVERYBODY. Nobody can ride with him when he hits the gas. Well...maybe Froome for one stage...but we saw what happened to him the next day...while Yates was still fresh enough to attack solo from 16 km out.

I'm not sure if I want Yates to come back to Earth so the last few stages have drama...or for him to continue to dust everyone. I suppose for entertainment purposes, I can't go wrong either way. Worst case is Yates hangs onto pink after the TT, then rides conservatively the rest of the week only focusing on not losing time to TD rather than going on the offensive.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
turdburgler wrote:
We will see about Yates. I just saw he averaged 560W over the span of that last attack. Pretty decent for a man his size ;)

Now time to quit posting. Time to spectate a TT.


barring illness, mechanicals, crashes, and such, how many minutes would Yates ship? Let's say, 2 bonus points (in next year's Spring Classic tally) for anyone being within 15 seconds of the right gap, 1 point for anyone within half a minute.

I'll go first (subject to changes), 2:45 lost by Yates

submit your predictions. how much time would Yates lose? i originally called 2:45 and I think i'll go with 2:30

bonus points only in effect if 5 or more participate
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
2:45.............he could barely do the interview after Sunday and they're looking to get even
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
submit your predictions. how much time would Yates lose? i originally called 2:45 and I think i'll go with 2:30

bonus points only in effect if 5 or more participate


1:45. It doesn't make any sense. But it's what I'm seeing on the road.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm going with Yates up 0:23 after tomorrow's stage, so going with 1:48 advantage tomorrow (for TD).

Brooks Doughtie, M.S.
Exercise Physiology
-USAT Level II
Last edited by: B_Doughtie: May 21, 18 20:09
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yates coughs up :70.

I’m just glad the rest day is over.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
echappist wrote:

submit your predictions. how much time would Yates lose? i originally called 2:45 and I think i'll go with 2:30

bonus points only in effect if 5 or more participate



1:45. It doesn't make any sense. But it's what I'm seeing on the road.

OK, you picked my number so I will go with Yates losing only 1:50 and still being way up! I really want TD to draw even or a bit ahead so the last few stages are fireworks.

Dev
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
trail wrote:
echappist wrote:

submit your predictions. how much time would Yates lose? i originally called 2:45 and I think i'll go with 2:30

bonus points only in effect if 5 or more participate



1:45. It doesn't make any sense. But it's what I'm seeing on the road.


OK, you picked my number so I will go with Yates losing only 1:50 and still being way up! I really want TD to draw even or a bit ahead so the last few stages are fireworks.

Dev

you can pick the same number :)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
echappist wrote:

submit your predictions. how much time would Yates lose? i originally called 2:45 and I think i'll go with 2:30

bonus points only in effect if 5 or more participate



1:45. It doesn't make any sense. But it's what I'm seeing on the road.

Makes a bit of sense - a TT in week 3 of a GC when you've got 2 and a bit weeks of hard mountain riding in your legs is a very different beast to a fresh TT. The gaps between the TT specialists and the climbers are always smaller than they would be in week 1 (unless the TT specialists aren't in GC contention and have a team that allows them to take it easy in the mountains). Plus Yates was a very good team pursuit rider in his junior days (World junior silver medallist and GB national champion) so should be able to TT better than many of the smaller guys
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yates will lose 90 seconds and remain in pink.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
echappist wrote:
submit your predictions. how much time would Yates lose? i originally called 2:45 and I think i'll go with 2:30

bonus points only in effect if 5 or more participate


1:45. It doesn't make any sense. But it's what I'm seeing on the road.

I think 1:45 is more than reasonable. I’m revising down again, to 2:05
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TD will respond and win by ...2:42 :-)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [heyMartin] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Watching the ITT stage live right now. Trying to figure out the arm pad positions on most of the riders. Overall the arm pads seem way higher than what I am seeing in competitive Ironman athletes. Despite this the backs of al the riders are flat. Someone enlighten me as to what is going on here. I am thinking it has something to do with the UCI frame compliance (of which I know nothing), but can't figure it out.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [heyMartin] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
have we all underestimated Yates? At what point is this too much of a fairy tale?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pozzovivo looks like Sanders from behind, both with the wide legs!

Terrible Tuesday’s Triathlon
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What would Aru have split if he wasnt sucking wheel the whole time? Not impressed.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ntc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
1 min 15 seconds of difference...

Carl Spackler wrote:
Yates coughs up :70.

I’m just glad the rest day is over.

winner winner

trail wrote:
echappist wrote:

submit your predictions. how much time would Yates lose? i originally called 2:45 and I think i'll go with 2:30

bonus points only in effect if 5 or more participate



1:45. It doesn't make any sense. But it's what I'm seeing on the road.
not a bad call

eb wrote:
Yates will lose 90 seconds and remain in pink.

also a good call
Last edited by: echappist: May 22, 18 8:17
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I was far off on prediction of :70; he gave up a whole 75 seconds. *Remarkable*
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [TravelingTri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TravelingTri wrote:
Watching the ITT stage live right now. Trying to figure out the arm pad positions on most of the riders. Overall the arm pads seem way higher than what I am seeing in competitive Ironman athletes. Despite this the backs of al the riders are flat. Someone enlighten me as to what is going on here. I am thinking it has something to do with the UCI frame compliance (of which I know nothing), but can't figure it out.
Not an expert and some here are, but I think they are on smaller frames than ideal due to the UCI regulations. They all want the saddle further forward than they are allowed, so they go with a small frame to reduce the reach. The pedestals on the bars increase the stack.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
I was far off on prediction of :70; he gave up a whole 75 seconds. *Remarkable*
I thought you were only 5 seconds off? Or did it read it wrong?


---------------------------

I hope TD still has something left in the tank, but this looks a bit much like a procession already.

That said, grand tours are never over until they are over. Anton and Quintana at the Vuelta, Kruiswijk at the Giro; all in the lead when something bad befell them.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [torrey] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks for that, makes enough sense for my simple mind!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This edition does bring into question the role of time bonuses. Love them or hate them, they really help the climbers. But, even if you remove yates bonuses he would still be in the lead.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
70 seconds was my guess, was off by 5.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This Tweet made me laugh

https://twitter.com/MRasmussen1974/status/998951653347876865


@MRasmussen1974
FollowFollow @MRasmussen1974
More
Unless it turns out that Aru was pacing behind a motorbike or was riding on one, he will be my pick for every mountain stage to come in this Giro.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
have we all underestimated Yates? At what point is this too much of a fairy tale?

If/when he starts riding away from everyone in stages 18-20. As you mentioned, it's not over yet, but they guy's form is remarkable. Either that or Dumoulin, Froome, Aru, Pinot, and Pozzovivo are complete duds right now. If he doesn't have any issues the rest of the week, does he go for the double?

Rohan Dennis is quietly having himself a pretty darn good tour. Up to 6th overall now in the GC.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ChrisC42780] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
If Max Schachmann had been Aru's 30 second guy, Aru would have caught and passed him.

One more time: Fabio Aru would have caught and passed Max Schachmann.

No, still doesn't sound right. I'll try again later.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Somebody needs to get ahold of him and tell him to tone it down a bit. /pink?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That was eye-opening too. Not as wide as his grill, but still...

At this point the most intriguing narrative is battle for 3rd podium spot, and how many more stages Yates wins.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Sean H] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sean H wrote:
Somebody needs to get ahold of him and tell him to tone it down a bit. /pink?

LOL...I know your comment is in sarcasm, but seriously...public speculation isn't necessarily a bad thing.

Probably a good thing for the sponsors actually as it brings more attention to the team. Yates is going to get tested no matter what. I don't think he'll get tested *more* just because he unleashes hell in week 3, or would get tested *less* if he tones it down. If you're clean and having the Grand Tour of your life...who cares what anyone thinks. And if you're doping...well...people aren't going to fell less sorry for you if you only won by a reasonable margin so you may as go for maximum glory and hope you don't ever get caught.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jason N wrote:
echappist wrote:
have we all underestimated Yates? At what point is this too much of a fairy tale?


If/when he starts riding away from everyone in stages 18-20. As you mentioned, it's not over yet, but they guy's form is remarkable. Either that or Dumoulin, Froome, Aru, Pinot, and Pozzovivo are complete duds right now. If he doesn't have any issues the rest of the week, does he go for the double?

Rohan Dennis is quietly having himself a pretty darn good tour. Up to 6th overall now in the GC.

I don't think that Yate's performance is out of line relative to Rohan Dennis. I believe Dumoulin and Froome are relatively duds in that they underperformed relative to Dennis. At the moment and Yates has peaked reasonably well. I would have expected Dumoulin to be 45 seconds faster today, but he may just be fried. Defending is a hard job, but it is possible that Quintana and Pinot last year were not at the form of Yates (plus Yates being heavier is a better TTer than Quintana). Froome is not at peak fitness. Aru had a good TT, but he's relatively been a dud since the TdF last year aside from one early stage where he exploded!!!

I think the VAM data on Zoncolan while not conclusive may be useful. Zoncolan unlike Alpe d'Huez, Ventoux or Galibier is treed the entire way making it less susceptible to late afternoon thermals (which are generally massive tailwinds....if you want a fast time on Alpe d'Huez you hit is late afternoon in July when all the hang glider dudes are out)....Zoncolan VAM should be useful....other than it being at the end of a stage it was a pretty steady drag race.

Dev
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
 
Carl Spackler wrote:
Yates coughs up :70.


eb wrote:
Yates will lose 90 seconds and remain in pink.


I'm just quoting this here so I can tell my friends I finished 20 seconds behind Spackler in a 32k TT.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Dumoulin underperformed compared to Dennis, who lost the opening TT by only 2 seconds? They're not even in same race; wouldn't have been surprising for he and Martin to have an even bigger gap.
Last edited by: Carl Spackler: May 22, 18 10:47
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:

I don't think that Yate's performance is out of line relative to Rohan Dennis.

That's a good point...that I suppose I should have pointed myself to. LOL.

Dumoulin and Froome are targeting the TdF. Pinot I assume is doing the same being French. Aru and Pozzovivo are hit and miss sometimes. Mitchelton Scott has said that Adam is going to be the team leader for the TdF, not Simon...which is why they sent him to the Giro. So maybe it's just the perfect storm for him. He dialed in his peak for the Giro, and all the other big dogs are trying to dial in their peak for July.

All in all though...I really don't care if his performances are viewed as suspicious or not. I watch pro cycling for entertainment purposes...so here's to hoping that Yates keeps going on the attack!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ChrisC42780] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ChrisC42780 wrote:
This Tweet made me laugh

https://twitter.com/MRasmussen1974/status/998951653347876865


@MRasmussen1974
FollowFollow @MRasmussen1974
More
Unless it turns out that Aru was pacing behind a motorbike or was riding on one, he will be my pick for every mountain stage to come in this Giro.

One of the most remarkable and questionable rides in any GT ever.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [moonmonkey02] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
moonmonkey02 wrote:
ChrisC42780 wrote:
This Tweet made me laugh


https://twitter.com/MRasmussen1974/status/998951653347876865


@MRasmussen1974
FollowFollow @MRasmussen1974
More
Unless it turns out that Aru was pacing behind a motorbike or was riding on one, he will be my pick for every mountain stage to come in this Giro.


One of the most remarkable and questionable rides in any GT ever.


http://www.cyclingnews.com/...econds-for-drafting/
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Dumoulin underperformed compared to Dennis, who lost the opening TT by only 2 seconds? They're not even in same race; wouldn't have been surprising for he and Martin to have an even bigger gap.

This. TD has been having to chase every single break.. it is impressive that he kept the gap down as low as he did.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Twotter] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Twotter wrote:
moonmonkey02 wrote:
ChrisC42780 wrote:
This Tweet made me laugh


https://twitter.com/MRasmussen1974/status/998951653347876865


@MRasmussen1974
FollowFollow @MRasmussen1974
More
Unless it turns out that Aru was pacing behind a motorbike or was riding on one, he will be my pick for every mountain stage to come in this Giro.


One of the most remarkable and questionable rides in any GT ever.


http://www.cyclingnews.com/...econds-for-drafting/

yeah, its interesting that recently there has been a lot of comment that the less consistent performances (froome pre-giro excepted) are an indication of greater "humanity" in the peloton rather than the juiced up super heroes of days gone. yates is being questioned because he is dominating day in, day out, though in his case its not unreasonable to ask the question since he's never shown this level before.
now we're also seeing the opposite - questions being asked as a result of erratic performances. again though quite reasonably - how does a climber crack badly on a climbing stage and then come out and do a great TT? he was only penalised 20 secs for drafting whereas others got 2 minutes so either he wasn't getting enough benefit to explain his fast time or more likely he got off lightly due to being an italian in italy - either way something is well off here.

disappointing that TD couldn't close it up to make the last week interesting, i guess its not so surprising though given the amount of work he's had to do combined with yates' spectacular form

also disappointed to see george bennett losing time due to more mechanical issues. it always amazes me how many mechanical issues world tour riders seem to get given the level of mechanical support they have - bikes checked by mechanics every day and TT bike prepared specifically for this 34Km ride. i know they push their equipment hard but really?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [pk1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pk1 wrote:
he was only penalised 20 secs for drafting whereas others got 2 minutes so either he wasn't getting enough benefit to explain his fast time or more likely he got off lightly due to being an italian in italy - either way something is well off here.

Could also have to do with perceived intent and circumstances. Aru was flagged for drafting a cop, who "should" know to keep their distance from a rider, as the rider has the right to pick whatever line they want. Ulissi and Conti seems like they were penalized for working together in some capacity after Ulissi bridged the 1 minute gap. That shows a different form of intent, and Ulissi can't claim he didn't have a choice but to draft, where to a certain extent, Aru could make that case.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
If Max Schachmann had been Aru's 30 second guy, Aru would have caught and passed him.

One more time: Fabio Aru would have caught and passed Max Schachmann.

No, still doesn't sound right. I'll try again later.

No....still not happening for me.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
McNulty wrote:
If Max Schachmann had been Aru's 30 second guy, Aru would have caught and passed him.

One more time: Fabio Aru would have caught and passed Max Schachmann.

No, still doesn't sound right. I'll try again later.


No....still not happening for me.

Go party with Luca Paolini for a while then try again.

On the brighter side at least Yates easily passed my "Panzerwagen test"
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
McNulty wrote:
If Max Schachmann had been Aru's 30 second guy, Aru would have caught and passed him.

One more time: Fabio Aru would have caught and passed Max Schachmann.

No, still doesn't sound right. I'll try again later.


No....still not happening for me.

if he were racing in Spain, he'd have gotten a 2-minute penalty (or possibly DQ'ed). But as he wears il tricolore on the road...
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jason N wrote:
pk1 wrote:
he was only penalised 20 secs for drafting whereas others got 2 minutes so either he wasn't getting enough benefit to explain his fast time or more likely he got off lightly due to being an italian in italy - either way something is well off here.


Could also have to do with perceived intent and circumstances. Aru was flagged for drafting a cop, who "should" know to keep their distance from a rider, as the rider has the right to pick whatever line they want. Ulissi and Conti seems like they were penalized for working together in some capacity after Ulissi bridged the 1 minute gap. That shows a different form of intent, and Ulissi can't claim he didn't have a choice but to draft, where to a certain extent, Aru could make that case.

Yes. I would definitely like to see the footage of Aru drafting, because that should really be on the race organisers for not having this happen. The racer can pick whatever line he wants on the road. It's on the person on the MC to get as far in front as to not cause drafting to occur, not on the racer to avoid the line of the MC. I could perhaps see the problem if the MC continues to change line to try and not have Aru get draft, but Aru keeps changing lines to get draft. I can then see it's bad faith on Aru, but I would still say it's ultimately the MC at fault because it should just get further out in front. And if for some reason the MC can't do that then something is wrong with the route, barriers, organisation, or the like.

When this happens it's really a lose/lose situation, because I think the organisers know that it's relly their fault, but the blowback from other riders and the media/fan probably requires them to give him some kind of penalty.

I have tried in TT's that you get to a faster section (e.g. tailwind or down a hill) and the MC is asleep at the wheel and I almost catch the MC around a faster bend. I sure as hell am not hitting my brakes to avoid either catching the MC or to ride a slower line to avoid getting up behind it. So you can either choose to get illegal draft or hit the brakes and stay legal, but lose time due to a fault on the MC/organiser. No good option and when I have been in those situations I get quite annoyed, especially becuase I then wonder how many times this happens for the other competitors and how this might skew the result.

Now for Ulissi and Conti, no excuse for that. That's just bad form and I wouldn't mind them getting thrown all the way to the back in the results for the TT.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
McNulty wrote:
McNulty wrote:
If Max Schachmann had been Aru's 30 second guy, Aru would have caught and passed him.

One more time: Fabio Aru would have caught and passed Max Schachmann.

No, still doesn't sound right. I'll try again later.


No....still not happening for me.


Go party with Luca Paolini for a while then try again.

On the brighter side at least Yates easily passed my "Panzerwagen test"

Loved Paolini. Not a good way to exit, though. I was very impressed that he could party like that in the middle of a tour. I was thinking he should have been given points or something. But then it turns out he brought the marching powder to the start line. At that point, not recreational.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
McNulty wrote:
McNulty wrote:
If Max Schachmann had been Aru's 30 second guy, Aru would have caught and passed him.

One more time: Fabio Aru would have caught and passed Max Schachmann.

No, still doesn't sound right. I'll try again later.


No....still not happening for me.


if he were racing in Spain, he'd have gotten a 2-minute penalty (or possibly DQ'ed). But as he wears il tricolore on the road...




I think you're right. The ethic seems to be, get away with what you can get away with. Carlton Kirby just said, "Aru is moving to the fore. There must be a motorbike up there or something. "
Last edited by: McNulty: May 23, 18 5:31
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [torrey] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
torrey wrote:
TravelingTri wrote:
Watching the ITT stage live right now. Trying to figure out the arm pad positions on most of the riders. Overall the arm pads seem way higher than what I am seeing in competitive Ironman athletes. Despite this the backs of al the riders are flat. Someone enlighten me as to what is going on here. I am thinking it has something to do with the UCI frame compliance (of which I know nothing), but can't figure it out.

Not an expert and some here are, but I think they are on smaller frames than ideal due to the UCI regulations. They all want the saddle further forward than they are allowed, so they go with a small frame to reduce the reach. The pedestals on the bars increase the stack.

Can anyone else weigh in on this? The TT pros all had their arm pads raised up substantially higher than I usually see, especially compared to a triathlete's.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [spencer99w] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sky is harshing my mellow again with Pouls in the break. I want Ben Hermans to get a stage win.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [MTM] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Interesting to get first-hand perspective, thanks for sharing.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Let the madness begin. Tomorrow's stage is pretty mellow for the first 175k or so, but ends with a 13 km climb averaging 7.2%. Coming off the rest day and the TT, which some guys may have sandbagged, there may be quite a few guys feeling fresh. It will be interesting to see who is allowed into the break and how big that group is.

My guess is that the break gets a long leash and stays away. Unless Froome is feeling good and sends Sky to the front early on the climb, I think all the GC guys will be too fresh to create any time gaps. They'll also be weary of burning matches unnecessarily leading into tomorrow's stage especially if all the time bonuses are taken up.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:


I think you're right. The ethic seems to be, get away with what you can get away with.


I loved the fake crash by the CCC rider at the Tour of Norway (inside the last 3K so he could get the same time as the field)

(He's the last guy to "lay down", right in the middle away from everyone else.)


Last edited by: trail: May 23, 18 16:30
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
LOL. Not only does he look like an idiot faking a crash. He also looks like an idiot for not understanding how the 3 km rule really works.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
McNulty wrote:


I think you're right. The ethic seems to be, get away with what you can get away with.


I loved the fake crash by the CCC rider at the Tour of Norway (inside the last 3K so he could get the same time as the field)

(He's the last guy to "lay down", right in the middle away from everyone else.)


Maybe he was watching replays of the UEFA Champion's league for FIFA World cup qualifying and took a page out of the soccer player book!!!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jason N wrote:
Let the madness begin. Tomorrow's stage is pretty mellow for the first 175k or so, but ends with a 13 km climb averaging 7.2%. Coming off the rest day and the TT, which some guys may have sandbagged, there may be quite a few guys feeling fresh. It will be interesting to see who is allowed into the break and how big that group is.

My guess is that the break gets a long leash and stays away. Unless Froome is feeling good and sends Sky to the front early on the climb, I think all the GC guys will be too fresh to create any time gaps. They'll also be weary of burning matches unnecessarily leading into tomorrow's stage especially if all the time bonuses are taken up.

I'm calling my shot now, Froome is about to blow this thing apart. Yates will crack in the next couple of days and the Sky train will be in position to pick up the pieces with Froome delivering the knockout attack and winning the Giro. I'm not a Froome fan by any means, but I think there's a reason he stuck this thing out to this point. Think Stage 10 in the 2015 TDF....something like that awaits.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jason N wrote:
LOL. Not only does he look like an idiot faking a crash. He also looks like an idiot for not understanding how the 3 km rule really works.

Can you enlighten me? I always thought if you were in the main pack inside the last 3km then everybody got given the same time even if you had a crash or the pack split.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
T3_Beer wrote:
Jason N wrote:
Let the madness begin. Tomorrow's stage is pretty mellow for the first 175k or so, but ends with a 13 km climb averaging 7.2%. Coming off the rest day and the TT, which some guys may have sandbagged, there may be quite a few guys feeling fresh. It will be interesting to see who is allowed into the break and how big that group is.

My guess is that the break gets a long leash and stays away. Unless Froome is feeling good and sends Sky to the front early on the climb, I think all the GC guys will be too fresh to create any time gaps. They'll also be weary of burning matches unnecessarily leading into tomorrow's stage especially if all the time bonuses are taken up.



I'm calling my shot now, Froome is about to blow this thing apart. Yates will crack in the next couple of days and the Sky train will be in position to pick up the pieces with Froome delivering the knockout attack and winning the Giro. I'm not a Froome fan by any means, but I think there's a reason he stuck this thing out to this point. Think Stage 10 in the 2015 TDF....something like that awaits.

Or rather, there’s a stipulation in his contract stating that he’d get nothing iF he abandones due to issues other than injury and illness
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
echappist wrote:
T3_Beer wrote:
Jason N wrote:
Let the madness begin. Tomorrow's stage is pretty mellow for the first 175k or so, but ends with a 13 km climb averaging 7.2%. Coming off the rest day and the TT, which some guys may have sandbagged, there may be quite a few guys feeling fresh. It will be interesting to see who is allowed into the break and how big that group is.

My guess is that the break gets a long leash and stays away. Unless Froome is feeling good and sends Sky to the front early on the climb, I think all the GC guys will be too fresh to create any time gaps. They'll also be weary of burning matches unnecessarily leading into tomorrow's stage especially if all the time bonuses are taken up.




I'm calling my shot now, Froome is about to blow this thing apart. Yates will crack in the next couple of days and the Sky train will be in position to pick up the pieces with Froome delivering the knockout attack and winning the Giro. I'm not a Froome fan by any means, but I think there's a reason he stuck this thing out to this point. Think Stage 10 in the 2015 TDF....something like that awaits.


Or rather, there’s a stipulation in his contract stating that he’d get nothing iF he abandones due to issues other than injury and illness

SO cynical. I like it.

My boy Maxie Schachmann is in the break and Aru is not. Emirates called for more moto traffic and didn't get it.
Break has 13 minutes. I think it sticks and there's a GC war behind on the climb.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
T3_Beer wrote:

I'm calling my shot now, Froome is about to blow this thing apart. Yates will crack in the next couple of days and the Sky train will be in position to pick up the pieces with Froome delivering the knockout attack and winning the Giro.


Where's that block button again?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Break has this one. Makes for better viewing, like watching two races
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Well that was interesting!

Edit: And, man, what a year Quick-Step is having. Win after win after win.
Last edited by: trail: May 24, 18 8:29
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Giro delivers again; as does QS
next two days will be fun
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
T3_Beer wrote:

I'm calling my shot now, Froome is about to blow this thing apart. Yates will crack in the next couple of days and the Sky train will be in position to pick up the pieces with Froome delivering the knockout attack and winning the Giro.


Where's that block button again?

Yates showed weakness today......what happens tomorrow??
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
T3_Beer wrote:
trail wrote:
T3_Beer wrote:


I'm calling my shot now, Froome is about to blow this thing apart. Yates will crack in the next couple of days and the Sky train will be in position to pick up the pieces with Froome delivering the knockout attack and winning the Giro.



Where's that block button again?


Yates showed weakness today......what happens tomorrow??

the other twin shows up
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [spntrxi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
spntrxi wrote:
T3_Beer wrote:
trail wrote:
T3_Beer wrote:


I'm calling my shot now, Froome is about to blow this thing apart. Yates will crack in the next couple of days and the Sky train will be in position to pick up the pieces with Froome delivering the knockout attack and winning the Giro.



Where's that block button again?


Yates showed weakness today......what happens tomorrow??


the other twin shows up
Shots of Jack Daniel's?

"Human existence is based upon two pillars: Compassion and knowledge. Compassion without knowledge is ineffective; Knowledge without compassion is inhuman." Victor Weisskopf.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
T3_Beer wrote:

Yates showed weakness today......what happens tomorrow??

I predict he'll hang on.

Gotta love Pozzovivo. Not the most exciting rider, but fun to pull for the little guy (both metaphorically and literally). I hope he holds off Froome.

Pinot is now officially "disappointing".
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You're probably right, I just wanted to keep it fun around here!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
cartsman wrote:
Jason N wrote:
LOL. Not only does he look like an idiot faking a crash. He also looks like an idiot for not understanding how the 3 km rule really works.


Can you enlighten me? I always thought if you were in the main pack inside the last 3km then everybody got given the same time even if you had a crash or the pack split.

Correct...when there is a crash inside of 3 km on a flat finish stage, everybody in the group, whether you crash or not, gets the same time as the fastest finisher in that group. Therefore, there is no reason to fake a crash other than to make yourself look like an idiot.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
T3_Beer wrote:


Yates showed weakness today......what happens tomorrow??


What I hope happens tomorrow? A big break forms that has a marginal lead over the Finestre. The Finestre is ridden by the GC group with a hard tempo that sheds most of the GC teammates and you're left with a group of 8 or so that summits together. Then Froome and/or Pozzovivo attacks on the Sestriere to bridge up to teammates from the break and isolates Yates or Dumoulin with 50 km to go. Big change in the GC for first or second.

What I think is going to happen tomorrow? The stage is so hard that they ride conservatively over the Finestre and Sestriere, then leave all the action to the final climb. Time gaps for sure, but the break stays away and no time bonuses. Froome and Pozzovivo will attack here while Dumoulin TTs the last 5 km minimizing his losses, if any to either of them. It's just a matter of whether Yates recovers from today, or has another iffy day...or worse.
Last edited by: Jason N: May 24, 18 11:25
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yep, it would not be fun to be Simon Yates for the next 24 hours....
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Aru kicked Schachmann's ass in the TT. :)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jason N wrote:

Correct...when there is a crash inside of 3 km on a flat finish stage, everybody in the group, whether you crash or not, gets the same time as the fastest finisher in that group. Therefore, there is no reason to fake a crash other than to make yourself look like an idiot.

Is that right? From my reading of the text, if he had stayed upright and given no appearance of having actually been involved, but then popped somewhere in the last 3K and became detached from the group he was with, he'd get assigned a worse time. I could be wrong, though...wording is a little ambiguous.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I assumed he was just knackered or sick and fancied stopping there and then rather than getting mixed up in the frenetic final kms. Maybe garner some sympathy and be first on the massage table. I was also assuming he was a domestique who wouldn't care about time anyway, can't imagine a GC contender taking a chance for a cheeky lie down during the race.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
cartsman wrote:
can't imagine a GC contender taking a chance for a cheeky lie down during the race.

*unless Italian. :)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
T3_Beer wrote:

Yates showed weakness today......what happens tomorrow??

I predict he'll hang on.

Gotta love Pozzovivo. Not the most exciting rider, but fun to pull for the little guy (both metaphorically and literally). I hope he holds off Froome.

Pinot is now officially "disappointing".

If there were no bonuses TD would be winning, they need a TT time bonus :). This makes for a fun last two days. Froome trying to move into 3rd and TD trying for the win. Froome and TD have the incentive to work together.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
Jason N wrote:


Correct...when there is a crash inside of 3 km on a flat finish stage, everybody in the group, whether you crash or not, gets the same time as the fastest finisher in that group. Therefore, there is no reason to fake a crash other than to make yourself look like an idiot.


Is that right? From my reading of the text, if he had stayed upright and given no appearance of having actually been involved, but then popped somewhere in the last 3K and became detached from the group he was with, he'd get assigned a worse time. I could be wrong, though...wording is a little ambiguous.


You don't have to go down, you just have to be "impacted." Or at least from this example of Bradley Wiggins, just put your foot down. But I don't even think putting your foot down is a requirement. It's not like the UCI is going to review the video tape and note down all 100 riders that got caught behind a crash to see if they actually went down or put a foot down, or scraped their elbow on a barrier or something.

http://www.cyclingweekly.com/...kilometre-rule-41520
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Schachmann is a savage.


Tomorrow is a perfect stage for ambush. If Sky rides flat out to make as hard as possible and Yates is isolated then it could be interesting. Seems likely Froome and Pozzovivo go on attack no matter what. Whether it plays to TD's hands by Yates having to make a choice should be key factor.
Last edited by: Carl Spackler: May 24, 18 14:30
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Schachmann is a savage.


Tomorrow is a perfect stage for ambush. If Sky rides flat out to make as hard as possible and Yates is isolated then it could be interesting. Seems likely Froome and Pozzovivo go on attack no matter what. Whether it plays to TD's hands by Yates having to make a choice should be key factor.

Let's say Yates gets dropped and it's Domulin vs Froome on the last climb in an every man for himself situation. Do you think Froome can put a few minutes on Domulin? I think he can if he's having a good day.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
T3_Beer wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Schachmann is a savage.


Tomorrow is a perfect stage for ambush. If Sky rides flat out to make as hard as possible and Yates is isolated then it could be interesting. Seems likely Froome and Pozzovivo go on attack no matter what. Whether it plays to TD's hands by Yates having to make a choice should be key factor.


Let's say Yates gets dropped and it's Domulin vs Froome on the last climb in an every man for himself situation. Do you think Froome can put a few minutes on Domulin? I think he can if he's having a good day.

The last climb is 7.2 km at 9.1%. A "few" minutes implying 3 minutes would be a tough ask unless Dumoulin completely implodes...which is possible if they put in a really hard effort to drop Yates early in the stage. It's also possible that Froome may have a strong teammate with him at the time...maybe Poels stays with him or Henao is in the break and drops back while Dumoulin doesn't have any teammates. That could provide a scenario where Dumoulin is inclined to work hard on the descent and slight uphill leading to the final climb while Froome is allowed to sit in while one of his teammates works with Dumoulin.

Kind of a perfect storm though...I don't think Dumoulin would bury himself that deep.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Dumoulin has the true pedigree of a TTer when climbing. He doesn't seem to change speeds like Froome or Yates but he can tap out a pretty crazy tempo that won't bleed much time.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
How much more does Domulin weigh than Froome? Dom looks like a beast, but he may be deceptively light.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Dumoulin has the true pedigree of a TTer when climbing. He doesn't seem to change speeds like Froome or Yates but he can tap out a pretty crazy tempo that won't bleed much time.

I would agree that his style doesn't bleed as much time than if you were more of a punchy climber. We are talking in huge what ifs already, but assuming Froome has a chance to put "a few minutes" into Dumoulin, it isn't going to be Froome attacked and Dumoulin burned matches trying to stay on him. It's going to have to be that Froome TTs the last climb 3 minutes faster than Dumoulin because he's shattered at that point and Froome is relatively fresh. Certainly possible, but seems like a fairy tale. How hard the Finestre is ridden does leave some possibility though.

I think Dumoulin will do well this stage...it's really more about how Yates will respond.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jason N wrote:
T3_Beer wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Schachmann is a savage.


Tomorrow is a perfect stage for ambush. If Sky rides flat out to make as hard as possible and Yates is isolated then it could be interesting. Seems likely Froome and Pozzovivo go on attack no matter what. Whether it plays to TD's hands by Yates having to make a choice should be key factor.


Let's say Yates gets dropped and it's Domulin vs Froome on the last climb in an every man for himself situation. Do you think Froome can put a few minutes on Domulin? I think he can if he's having a good day.


The last climb is 7.2 km at 9.1%. A "few" minutes implying 3 minutes would be a tough ask unless Dumoulin completely implodes...which is possible if they put in a really hard effort to drop Yates early in the stage. It's also possible that Froome may have a strong teammate with him at the time...maybe Poels stays with him or Henao is in the break and drops back while Dumoulin doesn't have any teammates. That could provide a scenario where Dumoulin is inclined to work hard on the descent and slight uphill leading to the final climb while Froome is allowed to sit in while one of his teammates works with Dumoulin.

Kind of a perfect storm though...I don't think Dumoulin would bury himself that deep.

Whatever happens for the rest of this Giro (unless Froome takes back a massive amount of time on both Dumoulin and Yates), it seems that Dumoulin is the beneficiary of the Sky train for the most part.

I also think that the Colle della Finistre favours Froome's spinning in a low gear and his mountain biker pedigree on the gravel. This should be interesting. It will be interesting to see if the bigger guys have better traction on the gravel on their road wheels or if they sink more into it. Seems like Finistre would be a good reason to go at the low end of the psi range.

Dev
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Some pics to get warmed up for Finistre:

Contador 2015



Aru





Giro 2015 again










Giro 2011?




Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Max was 35th at LBL riding in support of everyone, pretty much. Just picks up a GT stage at 24. Will be interesting to see who he becomes as a rider, especially at QS.

Mighty spikey today.
Tired riders, lots of changes today.
Last edited by: McNulty: May 25, 18 3:19
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The official Giro app has Dumoulin at 1.85cm and 69kg, with Froome at 1.86cm and 67.5kg.

However, as with Hollywood celebrities' ages, I'd take those figures with a pinch of salt
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yates getting gapped early on Finistre...barely hanging onto teammate Nieve....or is he faking it like LA vs Ullrich?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This is not faking it....gap already at 30 seconds with 75% of the Finistre to go. He could lose 5 min at this rate.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
How the heck am I going to get any work done? Sky asthma train already puts >1min on Yates.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Wow...I need to pause work and watch this.


devashish_paul wrote:
How the heck am I going to get any work done? Sky asthma train already puts >1min on Yates.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
They have not reached the gravel and the asthma train has put 2 min on Yates with Dumoulin and Pozzovivo (sp?) in tow!!!!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [EnderWiggan] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
EnderWiggan wrote:
Wow...I need to pause work and watch this.


devashish_paul wrote:
How the heck am I going to get any work done? Sky asthma train already puts >1min on Yates.



LOL....there is a benefit to running my startup company and paying others and not myself....I guess I pay myself with the flex of watching the Giro when I want! If you want I can offer you a job for the next 3 hours and join the meeting I am in with flobikes.com....no pay and no options though!

Is Scott paying for attacking too often almost every day last week? They are aboutu to get on the gravel now! Sky asthma boys dropped their own man Pouls
Last edited by: devashish_paul: May 25, 18 5:38
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Team Kenya's South Africa trained mountain biker is chomping at the gravel....Pozzovivo dropped

Holy crap, 80K's to go and Froome is going on an ITT....this feels like Floyd in the TdF 2006 whiskey and testosterone stage.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Wow Froome all alone for 80km?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
How fat tires is Froome using? It is almost like he is on 26-28mm range on the back wheel. That tire looks huge!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
Team Kenya's South Africa trained mountain biker is chomping at the gravel....Pozzovivo dropped

Holy crap, 80K's to go and Froome is going on an ITT....this feels like Floyd in the TdF 2006 whiskey and testosterone stage.

If there was ever a stage for it this is it.

Both down and uphill negate (well, reduce) the advantage of riding in a group. And almost all the rest of it is down or uphill
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [EnderWiggan] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
EnderWiggan wrote:
Wow Froome all alone for 80km?


Floyd did it, so yeah. Why not?
Last edited by: McNulty: May 25, 18 5:44
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [tuckandgo] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tom looks good, Froome isn't taking 3 minutes from him. In fact I wouldn't be surprised if Tom beats him to the line.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
EnderWiggan wrote:
Wow Froome all alone for 80km?


Floyd did it, so yeah. Why not?

Ha, just a little implication there. Why don't you just say it.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [tuckandgo] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
tuckandgo wrote:
devashish_paul wrote:
Team Kenya's South Africa trained mountain biker is chomping at the gravel....Pozzovivo dropped

Holy crap, 80K's to go and Froome is going on an ITT....this feels like Floyd in the TdF 2006 whiskey and testosterone stage.


If there was ever a stage for it this is it.

Both down and uphill negate (well, reduce) the advantage of riding in a group. And almost all the rest of it is down or uphill

Well, I suppose if you have won enough mountain bike races, you've done a 2.5 hour solo ride off the front, so why not....go Floyd....ahem go Sky!

Serious question, do you guys think Yates took away his strength (climbs) by going too deep on his weakness (TT)? He's been flat since the TT
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [tuckandgo] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
tuckandgo wrote:
McNulty wrote:
EnderWiggan wrote:
Wow Froome all alone for 80km?


Floyd did it, so yeah. Why not?


Ha, just a little implication there. Why don't you just say it.

hey don't mess around with my NFL entertainment (oh, sorry, I meant UCI)....it's like watching a hollywood movie, in all three cases we suspend our belief of what is humanly possible and revel in the superhuman in exchange for a show. Seriously though, the UCI is much cleaner than the NFL and all riders have shown signs of being human, so I think we're watching relatively cleaner racing, whatever that means.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
tuckandgo wrote:
devashish_paul wrote:
Team Kenya's South Africa trained mountain biker is chomping at the gravel....Pozzovivo dropped

Holy crap, 80K's to go and Froome is going on an ITT....this feels like Floyd in the TdF 2006 whiskey and testosterone stage.


If there was ever a stage for it this is it.

Both down and uphill negate (well, reduce) the advantage of riding in a group. And almost all the rest of it is down or uphill


Well, I suppose if you have won enough mountain bike races, you've done a 2.5 hour solo ride off the front, so why not....go Floyd....ahem go Sky!

Serious question, do you guys think Yates took away his strength (climbs) by going too deep on his weakness (TT)? He's been flat since the TT

Serious answer.

I think he consistently burnt too many matches (to use a good tri analogy) trying to gain a time buffer, and then burnt the last one and set fire to the box on the TT. He probably thought he could smash it up to and through the TT and then would have enough left to tick over defending the lead. In reality he has burnt all his matches and bonked (in grand tour terms), rather than be able to press on at steady state. You can't attack again, and again, and again, successfully, against the best cyclists in the world, and not expect to force a sans jours
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply


I feel like I am watching a totally different Giro from the one I started following.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [noodle_soup] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That's the enjoyment of a 3 week tour (and especially the Giro). Love it!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Sean H] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sean H wrote:
Tom looks good, Froome isn't taking 3 minutes from him. In fact I wouldn't be surprised if Tom beats him to the line.

And now Poels attacks Pozzovivo to try to bridge up. Sky found some really good pillows last night.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
Serious question, do you guys think Yates took away his strength (climbs) by going too deep on his weakness (TT)? He's been flat since the TT

No. You can't pace the TT.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [tuckandgo] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
tuckandgo wrote:
devashish_paul wrote:
tuckandgo wrote:
devashish_paul wrote:
Team Kenya's South Africa trained mountain biker is chomping at the gravel....Pozzovivo dropped

Holy crap, 80K's to go and Froome is going on an ITT....this feels like Floyd in the TdF 2006 whiskey and testosterone stage.


If there was ever a stage for it this is it.

Both down and uphill negate (well, reduce) the advantage of riding in a group. And almost all the rest of it is down or uphill


Well, I suppose if you have won enough mountain bike races, you've done a 2.5 hour solo ride off the front, so why not....go Floyd....ahem go Sky!

Serious question, do you guys think Yates took away his strength (climbs) by going too deep on his weakness (TT)? He's been flat since the TT


Serious answer.

I think he consistently burnt too many matches (to use a good tri analogy) trying to gain a time buffer, and then burnt the last one and set fire to the box on the TT. He probably thought he could smash it up to and through the TT and then would have enough left to tick over defending the lead. In reality he has burnt all his matches and bonked (in grand tour terms), rather than be able to press on at steady state. You can't attack again, and again, and again, successfully, against the best cyclists in the world, and not expect to force a sans jours

Yeah, that was my feeling when he was attacking constantly and having no jours sans. Froome has been off and honestly Dumoulin has only done ONE attack so far which was yesterday. Other than that, he has marked the competition.

Having said that, either Froome has ridden his way to week 3 peak, or he's going to blow apart tomorrow after today's stage.

Froome 10 min up on Yates. 37 seconds on Dumoulin,

This descent should be epic too. Froome has built a buffer so he does not need to take risk.

Pinot riding well with Dumoulin and looks like he flats!!!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
Sean H wrote:
Tom looks good, Froome isn't taking 3 minutes from him. In fact I wouldn't be surprised if Tom beats him to the line.


And now Poels attacks Pozzovivo to try to bridge up. Sky found some really good pillows last night.

Floyd sent them shots of whiskey!!!

These cameramen on the descents are awesome!!!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
devashish_paul wrote:

Serious question, do you guys think Yates took away his strength (climbs) by going too deep on his weakness (TT)? He's been flat since the TT


No. You can't pace the TT.

But what if Yates went 20-30 seconds easier on the TT....maybe he saves some legs and does not get gapped yesterday and is with Froome today?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
Froome 10 min up on Yates. 37 seconds on Dumoulin,

This descent should be epic too. Froome has built a buffer so he does not need to take risk.

Froome may still need to take risks if he is trying to win it all with this suicide attack. He is a great descender and is putting time into TD on the descent as well. The real question is whether the Dumoulin group will work together to catch Froome on the flats or whether they just tell Dumoulin to do the work if he wants to win.

Yates must have had whatever breakfast today whatever Chaves had last week...boom goes the dynamite.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Twotter] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Twotter wrote:
devashish_paul wrote:

Froome 10 min up on Yates. 37 seconds on Dumoulin,

This descent should be epic too. Froome has built a buffer so he does not need to take risk.


Froome may still need to take risks if he is trying to win it all with this suicide attack. He is a great descender and is putting time into TD on the descent as well. The real question is whether the Dumoulin group will work together to catch Froome on the flats or whether they just tell Dumoulin to do the work if he wants to win.

Yates must have had whatever breakfast today whatever Chaves had last week...boom goes the dynamite.

I think Dumoulin "bought" a TT partner on the Finistre climb. When Pinot flatted, he took the gas of the pedals and sat up to wait for Pinot. Dumoulin does not need to catch Froome today, he just needs to limit any loss to Froome. Dumoulin is in pink now and I assume he has a magic number that he does not want to let Froome get any closer to and so he can just pace with his virtual Sunweb mates now.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Where is Lopez ?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Twotter] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Twotter wrote:
devashish_paul wrote:

Froome 10 min up on Yates. 37 seconds on Dumoulin,



Yates must have had whatever breakfast today whatever Chaves had last week...boom goes the dynamite.

Armstrong (of the good at cycling fame) flagged that stage on his podcast as one where someone would get screwed. Something to do with a hard start straight out of a rest day.

PD - yes, Dumoulin seems to have 'made some friends'
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
EnderWiggan wrote:
Wow Froome all alone for 80km?


Floyd did it, so yeah. Why not?

When Floyd did wasn't he off the front of a peloton most of the day? Froome is just being chased by a handful of guys that he's already shown he is stronger than. Looks like only 3 guys are contributing to the chase.

I don't want to see that gangly bastard win the Giro, but looking good unless he cracks.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ThisIsIt] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tom could be going harder than this right now but he wants to stay with the guys to get some breaks. Once they start up the final climb I imagine he'll go to the front and push his own pace all the way up.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Sean H] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sean H wrote:
Tom could be going harder than this right now but he wants to stay with the guys to get some breaks. Once they start up the final climb I imagine he'll go to the front and push his own pace all the way up.

If his lead keeps growing at this rate he's going to be a minute or more down on GC when they start it.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sitting up to wait that far out is called a smart tactical decision. TD and Pinot have the same objectives.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Sean H] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
woah, glad I checked this thread.

This is a once in a very long time kind of stage to watch.

My Blog - http://leegoocrap.blogspot.com
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ThisIsIt] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ThisIsIt wrote:
McNulty wrote:
EnderWiggan wrote:
Wow Froome all alone for 80km?


Floyd did it, so yeah. Why not?


When Floyd did wasn't he off the front of a peloton most of the day? Froome is just being chased by a handful of guys that he's already shown he is stronger than. Looks like only 3 guys are contributing to the chase.

I don't want to see that gangly bastard win the Giro, but looking good unless he cracks.

As we speak Froome is 34 seconds away from Virtual Pink...still 2 climbs to finish. This could make Saturday on Cervina/Zermatt really interesting. Don't forget that Froome can get 10 second bonus on the stage finish
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ThisIsIt] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ThisIsIt wrote:
Sean H wrote:
Tom could be going harder than this right now but he wants to stay with the guys to get some breaks. Once they start up the final climb I imagine he'll go to the front and push his own pace all the way up.


If his lead keeps growing at this rate he's going to be a minute or more down on GC when they start it.

True, and you might see Tom have to pick it up before then. But there's also another climbing stage tomorrow, right? If Froome kills himself today and Tom doesn't then he can take the jersey tomorrow. Lots to think about for Tom.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Sean H] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Anyone got a watchable link? I don’t care if it’s in Swahili
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ridenfish39] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
fubou in US, eurosportplayer in europe.

Don't know about fubo but ES is ÂŁ6.99 for one month and you can sign up in about 30 seconds
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Sean H] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Wow, looks like Froome is going to win this whole thing, and man I don't believe of a 1/2 second that is any cleaner then Floyd was.

----------------------------
http://www.instagram.com/cyclewise
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
ThisIsIt wrote:
McNulty wrote:
EnderWiggan wrote:
Wow Froome all alone for 80km?


Floyd did it, so yeah. Why not?


When Floyd did wasn't he off the front of a peloton most of the day? Froome is just being chased by a handful of guys that he's already shown he is stronger than. Looks like only 3 guys are contributing to the chase.

I don't want to see that gangly bastard win the Giro, but looking good unless he cracks.


As we speak Froome is 34 seconds away from Virtual Pink...still 2 climbs to finish. This could make Saturday on Cervina/Zermatt really interesting. Don't forget that Froome can get 10 second bonus on the stage finish

They all look on the limit in the chase, TD is sucking down gels like they are candy.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ridenfish39] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ridenfish39 wrote:
Anyone got a watchable link? I don’t care if it’s in Swahili

Go to cyclingfans, the Hebrew one is good.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ridenfish39] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
http://tiz-cycling.live/
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trener1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trener1 wrote:
Wow, looks like Froome is going to win this whole thing, and man I don't believe of a 1/2 second that is any cleaner then Floyd was.


TD only one chasing, and the lead is growing again as soon as they are off the descent.

Looks like they sat up to let Pinot's team mate back.
Last edited by: ThisIsIt: May 25, 18 7:03
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ThisIsIt] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ThisIsIt wrote:
ridenfish39 wrote:
Anyone got a watchable link? I don’t care if it’s in Swahili


Go to cyclingfans, the Hebrew one is good.

Thank you!!!



"Are you sure we're going fast enough?" - Emil Zatopek
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Bretom] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Bretom wrote:
ThisIsIt wrote:
ridenfish39 wrote:
Anyone got a watchable link? I don’t care if it’s in Swahili


Go to cyclingfans, the Hebrew one is good.


Thank you!!!

yeah. wow. you did us a solid.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Bretom] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
One crazy stage going on right now. Have to say watching this on OSN Sports with no commercial breaks is quite a departure from TDF on NBCSN with the incessant breakaways for ads. That much being said the overall broadcast content and quality when not in commercial break is much better on NBCSN. Back to the action now 26km to go. Finally another sport besides Aussie Tennis Open where living in Dubai makes the watching easier.
Last edited by: TravelingTri: May 25, 18 7:10
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Slowman wrote:
Bretom wrote:
ThisIsIt wrote:
ridenfish39 wrote:
Anyone got a watchable link? I don’t care if it’s in Swahili


Go to cyclingfans, the Hebrew one is good.


Thank you!!!


yeah. wow. you did us a solid.

For real! Thanks!!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What Froome is trying to do is not possible.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
froome in virtual yellow. is dumoulin saving bullets? best grand tour stage in many years.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trener1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trener1 wrote:
I don't believe of a 1/2 second that is any cleaner then Floyd was.

I'm with you on that. But it sure is a hell of a lot more interesting to watch than what we've seen recently.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Slowman wrote:
froome in virtual yellow. is dumoulin saving bullets? best grand tour stage in many years.

IMHO he (dumoulin) is going full gas. He really doesn't look comfortable.
The question is whether Froome blows
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [IvarAlmere] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have to say, I have never been much of a Froome fan, but my goodness, what a fighter! If he pulls this out you can't not respect him.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Slowman wrote:
froome in virtual yellow. is dumoulin saving bullets? best grand tour stage in many years.

Virtual pink**
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [formula bike] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
formula bike wrote:
I have to say, I have never been much of a Froome fan, but my goodness, what a fighter! If he pulls this out you can't not respect him.

yeah, i'm with you on that.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [formula bike] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm sorry, but i follow cycling long enough to know that if looks like it is not possible it most likely is not possible.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [IvarAlmere] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
IvarAlmere wrote:
I'm sorry, but i follow cycling long enough to know that if looks like it is not possible it most likely is not possible.

we take your point.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [kmill23] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
kmill23 wrote:
Slowman wrote:
froome in virtual yellow. is dumoulin saving bullets? best grand tour stage in many years.


Virtual pink**

yeah. well. ;-)

i'm still picking dumoulin for the actual PINK at the end of the day. but i don't know.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [IvarAlmere] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
IvarAlmere wrote:
I'm sorry, but i follow cycling long enough to know that if looks like it is not possible it most likely is not possible.

Perhaps true.
But Froome hasn't been consistently strong through the Giro, he's had a good days and bad days. This is a good day.
That is far more plausible than being consistently strong for 3 weeks racing.

And you have to admire his balls!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [IvarAlmere] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
while I agree for the most part... sometimes you just want to turn off the pessimism and watch a stage. If that's today... damn it's a fun watch.

My Blog - http://leegoocrap.blogspot.com
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Just got the stats for the last climb, this is gonna be good
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Morelock] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I agree. This is one of the best grand tours I've ever seen.
Last edited by: IvarAlmere: May 25, 18 7:30
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [tuckandgo] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
tuckandgo wrote:
Slowman wrote:
froome in virtual yellow. is dumoulin saving bullets? best grand tour stage in many years.


IMHO he (dumoulin) is going full gas. He really doesn't look comfortable.
The question is whether Froome blows

He's continued to pull out time when the chase should have had the advantage. TD only hope is Froome hitting the wall, doesn't seem like he has the power to pull it back on the last climb.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ThisIsIt] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
in my opinion: i think TD could shut down froome's virtual lead now. but the rest of his group is on the rivet. if he goes any harder he'll blow the group apart. so it's a calculated risk to lose a little time now and keep that group together until the road points up.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Morelock] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This is an amazing stage and GT. Lot of credit to Froome, he’s a gamer.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [tuckandgo] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
tuckandgo wrote:
IvarAlmere wrote:
I'm sorry, but i follow cycling long enough to know that if looks like it is not possible it most likely is not possible.


Perhaps true.
But Froome hasn't been consistently strong through the Giro, he's had a good days and bad days. This is a good day.
That is far more plausible than being consistently strong for 3 weeks racing.

And you have to admire his balls!

Impossible to say, there has certainly been plenty of indications over the years that riders can also be prepared for a single day performance (e.g. corticosteroids). Gaumont way back when talked about the Cofidis (IIRC) team bus looking like a medical clinic on a TT day.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Slowman wrote:
in my opinion: i think TD could shut down froome's virtual lead now. but the rest of his group is on the rivet. if he goes any harder he'll blow the group apart. so it's a calculated risk to lose a little time now and keep that group together until the road points up.

We'll find out momentarily, he's got about 30-45 seconds to pull back.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
This is an amazing stage and GT. Lot of credit to Froome, he’s a gamer.

now we're going to see. i think we'll know in 5 minutes how this is likely to go. but it's a nail biter!

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
This is an amazing stage and GT. Lot of credit to Froome, he’s a gamer.


No kidding...and it will still make tomorrow interesting...this day is going to leave marks so it sure isn't folded no matter what happens.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Francois] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This is an all time classic day. So much for boring Sky, they just blew everything open.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pretty sure yesterday made it clear that Yates was done and it just gave hope to everyone.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Francois] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Francois wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
This is an amazing stage and GT. Lot of credit to Froome, he’s a gamer.



No kidding...and it will still make tomorrow interesting...this day is going to leave marks so it sure isn't folded no matter what happens.

dumoulin is one cool customer. he immediately gets dropped as the road points up, but it's because the leaders (pinot) took it out too hard, trying to drop his GC rivals.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
"He's a jedi master of the controlled effort" ... LOL
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Francois] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Crazy how evenly matched Froome and TD are today, guess the big question is how much is left in tank tomorrow.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
T3_Beer wrote:

I'm calling my shot now, Froome is about to blow this thing apart. Yates will crack in the next couple of days and the Sky train will be in position to pick up the pieces with Froome delivering the knockout attack and winning the Giro.


Where's that block button again?

Just wanted to come back and tell all you bastards I told you so!!!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ThisIsIt] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Given what's going on with froome right now, you think he'd risk his career on something like that? A bad tour wouldn't end him, but a full on doping violation would, especially right now.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
So far it looks like reducing GC squad size has paid off for more exciting racing. This is an old school mano-y-mano battle. Tour might even be interesting this year
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [imswimmer328] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
imswimmer328 wrote:
Given what's going on with froome right now, you think he'd risk his career on something like that? A bad tour wouldn't end him, but a full on doping violation would, especially right now.

I have no idea, people do crazy shit all the time.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Gold
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Sean H] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sean H wrote:
Tom looks good, Froome isn't taking 3 minutes from him. In fact I wouldn't be surprised if Tom beats him to the line.

I just wanted to quote this, that is all.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [imswimmer328] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
imswimmer328 wrote:
Given what's going on with froome right now, you think he'd risk his career on something like that? A bad tour wouldn't end him, but a full on doping violation would, especially right now.


There have been GC stars in the past under the most intense scrutiny who kept right on the program. Lance had to get a back-dated TUE after accidentally messing up his corticosteroid program, and he didn't bat an eye.

Froome - clean or not - is ruthlessly competitive. Nevermind the gentlemanly act. That dude is intense on the bike, and has a barely-contained hatred for losing.
Last edited by: trail: May 25, 18 8:13
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
T3_Beer wrote:
trail wrote:
T3_Beer wrote:


I'm calling my shot now, Froome is about to blow this thing apart. Yates will crack in the next couple of days and the Sky train will be in position to pick up the pieces with Froome delivering the knockout attack and winning the Giro.



Where's that block button again?


Just wanted to come back and tell all you bastards I told you so!!!

Froome said it himself in week 1 that he was going to go on the attack during week 3...so duh!!! /pink

Fucking amazing stage. I was entertained.


Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
T3_Beer wrote:

Just wanted to come back and tell all you bastards I told you so!!!

Ug. I openly have Sky Derangement Syndrome, and I was genuinely angry for about 5 seconds before I slapped myself for letting entertainment affect me that way.

Still thinking of blocking your ass. :)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
T3_Beer wrote:


Just wanted to come back and tell all you bastards I told you so!!!


Ug. I openly have Sky Derangement Syndrome, and I was genuinely angry for about 5 seconds before I slapped myself for letting entertainment affect me that way.

Still thinking of blocking your ass. :)

I hate Sky and Froome too, I just didn't trust them to lose this race.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Well in my defense, Tom did look good the whole way imo. Froome just looked other worldly.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ThisIsIt] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ThisIsIt wrote:
imswimmer328 wrote:
Given what's going on with froome right now, you think he'd risk his career on something like that? A bad tour wouldn't end him, but a full on doping violation would, especially right now.


I have no idea, people do crazy shit all the time.


NMV...I misunderstood the context of the response
Last edited by: Jason N: May 25, 18 8:29
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Where's Yates? I'm following the Giro live tracker and he's still not in after 26 minutes. It's pretty crazy that only 30 guys have come in so far.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
He went home.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Francois] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Francois wrote:
He went home.

What a punk, he should have rode it out.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tomorrow isn't going to be easy for any of these guys. There are going to be opportunities galore now that everyone in the top 5 spent a ton of energy today. It would be a shame if we didn't see Pink, or at least virtual Pink change hands tomorrow after today's stage.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jason N wrote:
Tomorrow isn't going to be easy for any of these guys. There are going to be opportunities galore now that everyone in the top 5 spent a ton of energy today. It would be a shame if we didn't see Pink, or at least virtual Pink change hands tomorrow after today's stage.

Froome's going to have about a minute or so on Tommy D. He's so good at protecting a lead I don't see him losing the jersey. I guess with 4000m of climbing anything is possible though.....
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
80k solo TT to go in to Pink. Wow, what a stage!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
puff daddy is back! he did a landis today!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ianpeace] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ianpeace wrote:
80k solo TT to go in to Pink. Wow, what a stage!

OK, I'll say it...reminds me of Floyd ;-)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ianpeace] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It was the perfect stage for Froome to go out on the attack, his team really would have done nothing for him anyway. First you have all that severe climbing which he is great at, especially when he just gets to ride his tempo. And then you have severe decents where he is likely one of the best if not the best at descending. He would have dropped any small groups there too, so really having his nose in the wind anyway.

So a smart and probably calculated weeks or months ago that this would be his day to just take off. The course rode like a very long tt anyway, and who is going to tt on up and down mountains with Froome at any time??
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yates rolls across.....38min down.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Francois] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Incredible day, love him or hate him. It was as much a crazy effort as it was a crushing end for Yates. It happens, but I can't imagine. It would feel like Jean Van de Velde at the Open golf final day 20 years back. Watching that live was just horrible.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Francois] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Wonder if tomorrow Sunweb basically needs does same thing Sky did today, on first climb. Get Froome isolated, then let him and TD settle it on the road. Or instead play the waiting game to see if Froome cracks on last climb? Either way seems like they need to make it as hard as possible after Froome's effort today.
Last edited by: Carl Spackler: May 25, 18 8:48
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Wonder if tomorrow Sunweb basically needs does same thing Sky did today, on first climb. Get Froome isolated, then let him and TD settle it on the road. Or instead play the waiting game to see if Froome cracks on last climb? Either way seems like they need to make it as hard as possible after Froome's effort today.

But what does Dumoulin have left? While he wasn't solo for 80k, he didn't have a day in the park today either. I can't imagine how those guys are feeling with this much fatigue in their legs facing the stage tomorrow. Ouch.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ianpeace] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ianpeace wrote:
Yates rolls across.....38min down.

Glad to see he stuck it out.

As for Tommy D isolating or dropping Froome tomorrow.......aint gonna happen unless Froome is feeling bad. TD simply can't climb like a 4X tour winner.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Sean H] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sean H wrote:
Well in my defense, Tom did look good the whole way imo. Froome just looked other worldly.

Haha, I thought he would get caught as well.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [kmill23] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
kmill23 wrote:
Carl Spackler wrote:
Wonder if tomorrow Sunweb basically needs does same thing Sky did today, on first climb. Get Froome isolated, then let him and TD settle it on the road. Or instead play the waiting game to see if Froome cracks on last climb? Either way seems like they need to make it as hard as possible after Froome's effort today.


But what does Dumoulin have left? While he wasn't solo for 80k, he didn't have a day in the park today either. I can't imagine how those guys are feeling with this much fatigue in their legs facing the stage tomorrow. Ouch.

i don't think anybody has the formula for knowing how to feel good on a day after one like today. unless it's the actual *formula*. froome has had an up-and-down tour. or, he got to the tour not quite ready and raced himself into shape by week-3. dumoulin has ridden a great tour. if he has his average day and froome has one of his down days then dumoulin wins.

but tomorrow is different than today. no early climb to take off on. but, tomorrow is also a longer day than today.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [monty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Froome's descent off the Finestre was LEGIT!!! He added almost 1 minute more on his gap to Dumoulin et al, 12' 15" of downhill, wet corners, averaged 53.4 km/h with a top speed of 80k.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [hairypiernas] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
hairypiernas wrote:
puff daddy is back! he did a landis today!


Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Oh dear...with Froome back on form we've got another Sky dominated TDF to look forward to..ugh!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Remember Froome lost almost a minute to Tom on stage 15 after going deep to win on the Zonc. I think Froome has better form this week, but I would give a 50/50 he cracks tomorrow.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [torrey] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
torrey wrote:
Remember Froome lost almost a minute to Tom on stage 15 after going deep to win on the Zonc. I think Froome has better form this week, but I would give a 50/50 he cracks tomorrow.

I predict he'll put on a show of being vulnerable, but then somehow manage to not give up very much time.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ianpeace] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Froome doesn't get due credit for being a complete, all-around rider. He can climb, TT, positions well, descends and has tactical noir--anyone remember going off the front in crosswinds with Sagan, Bodnar and Thomas? Froome's other questionable stuff aside, Nibali is probably the only other GC guy with that game.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Froome's other questionable stuff aside

----------

Thanks for all the great comments on the stage today. I've really enjoyed watching Yates' team's youtube videos daily usually 8-10 min segments. Tonight's episode is going to be painful to watch I'm sure.




Now regards to Froome. What is the verdict on this result if his issue is upheld? Does he lose it, or does he only start the ban once decision is final (assuming he loses the Vuelta title)?

Brooks Doughtie, M.S.
Exercise Physiology
-USAT Level II
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [torrey] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
torrey wrote:
Remember Froome lost almost a minute to Tom on stage 15 after going deep to win on the Zonc. I think Froome has better form this week, but I would give a 50/50 he cracks tomorrow.

Froome is a 4X TDF winner, TD is a 1X Giro winner. He knows how to defend a lead, I don't see him giving up 40 sec to TD tomorrow. I put his chances at losing the jersey to TD at more like 5% or less. Like I said, I'm not a Froome fan at all, but we've all seen how this plays out many times over.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [B_Doughtie] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
B_Doughtie wrote:
Froome's other questionable stuff aside

----------

Thanks for all the great comments on the stage today. I've really enjoyed watching Yates' team's youtube videos daily usually 8-10 min segments. Tonight's episode is going to be painful to watch I'm sure.




Now regards to Froome. What is the verdict on this result if his issue is upheld? Does he lose it, or does he only start the ban once decision is final (assuming he loses the Vuelta title)?

It will be a painful watch. I felt really bad for Simon today.

That aside this whole stage was outrageous. One of the most entertaining I have ever witnessed.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The cynic / realist in me thinks this is a bit too Landis-esque.

Don't drown. Don't crash. Don't walk.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [rotosound] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I thought the same. Jaw dropping solo win. Can't wait to see some analysis of what the hell he was pushing. He better buy some pints for his boy's work today.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [B_Doughtie] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
B_Doughtie wrote:
Froome's other questionable stuff aside

----------

Thanks for all the great comments on the stage today. I've really enjoyed watching Yates' team's youtube videos daily usually 8-10 min segments. Tonight's episode is going to be painful to watch I'm sure.




Now regards to Froome. What is the verdict on this result if his issue is upheld? Does he lose it, or does he only start the ban once decision is final (assuming he loses the Vuelta title)?

He keeps the Giro but would loose the Vuelta, or so says the UCI. Interestingly, he could also win the TDF and keep that as well which will likely happen as a descision does not appear immenent.

On a side note this is a really interesting case from a biochemistry standpoint. I have a good friend who works for a pharm company as a biochemist and specializes in drug dosing. In particular how long does a drug last in ones system and how your body responds to said drug. Anyways, the primary takeaway i had from that conversation is that there is a high degree of variability in the rate of metabolism of different drugs. Add in potential variances with testing proceducres and then the unique stree of a race senario and you have a lawyers field day ahead of you in the court room.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
somewhat... my wife worked in drug transport.. yes differences can occur but Sky would have known .. besides 2x the amount is fishy as hell.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [spntrxi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
spntrxi wrote:
somewhat... my wife worked in drug transport.. yes differences can occur but Sky would have known .. besides 2x the amount is fishy as hell.

Not arguing any specific point, just suggesting that if i was a lawyer this would be rather fun. Yes 2x the limit either means a 1/1,000,000 biological abnormaility or he took a large dose to help get through his cold.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Ron_Burgundy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ron_Burgundy wrote:
Add in potential variances with testing proceducres and then the unique stree of a race senario and you have a lawyers field day ahead of you in the court room.

Yeah, I had similar conversations about it with a buddy of mine who's a post-doc in pharmacology.

Because the CAS leans athlete-friendly when presented with confounding scientific data, I'm predicting little-to-no sanction for Froome. Which, with my Froome Derangement Syndrome, will constitute statutory justice, but not poetic justice.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [monty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
monty wrote:
It was the perfect stage for Froome to go out on the attack, his team really would have done nothing for him anyway. First you have all that severe climbing which he is great at, especially when he just gets to ride his tempo. And then you have severe decents where he is likely one of the best if not the best at descending. He would have dropped any small groups there too, so really having his nose in the wind anyway.

So a smart and probably calculated weeks or months ago that this would be his day to just take off. The course rode like a very long tt anyway, and who is going to tt on up and down mountains with Froome at any time??

Froome seems to have had Zoncolan as day 1 of his virtual yearly Dauphine single week stage race, except he's doing that 1 week stage race in Italy this year. It's his proven formula to peak for the TdF by having a hard hit out several weeks before the TdF for a week. He paid the day after Zoncolan, and was steady on the TT and now seems to be peaking as he planned for this final weekend. I feel that with the gravel on Finistre and his mountain biking background, he had all this planned out long ago. What an awesome stage. Regardless of the Sky asthma train (or not), that was some seriously gutsy racing.

I think the calculation he made well was how well could he blow apart the entire peloton so that the entire race turned into an Eddy Merckx era line of single riders and more like a mountain bike race where everyone is in an ITT mode vs a road bike stage. Once everyone is in ITT mode then him being in ITT mode is no longer a disadvantage. The stage profile was conducive to effectively turn the race into more like an individual battle for all vs a few singles vs the peloton.

I can't wait to watch the rest of the stage tonite. I had to stop watching after the Finistre descent on account of work obligation !!!!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
turdburgler wrote:
I thought the same. Jaw dropping solo win. Can't wait to see some analysis of what the hell he was pushing. He better buy some pints for his boy's work today.

When I watched Froome make the intial gap on Yates (you can see my comments on this thread as it happened), I was joking that it was a Floyd like day. But realistically, he just blew the race apart and forced everyone into ITT mode for 80K. Seriously at the end of the day he beat Dumoulin by 3+ min over 2.5 hours on a mountain day that favours Froome with lots of gravel and technical descending. That does not seem like an outrageous margin for two riders who are similarly matched but with one being the stronger climber.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [B_Doughtie] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Brooks,

If I recall correctly... In 2011 Cantador had the pink jersey on the last day of the Giro and on that day anyone would have said that he "won the Giro". The problem was that he had a doping issue (clenbuterol positive test from 2010 TdF) that was roiling in the courts. Later the CAS stripped him of that Grio win.

I haven't been following Froome's inhaler drama that closely but it seems evident that he (they?) abused the TUE system. Froome's situation could be seen as very similar to Contador's at the start of the 2011 Giro. I haven't let it bother me at all because Froome was sitting 7th on GC and Yates was looking great, and the defending champ was 2nd, and Pozzovio (who just looks so wrong on a bike) was 3rd, and life was grand.

Now I'm super torn. What I saw today - a guy going solo for 80k to win the stage, take the leaders jersey (the climbers jersey too, 'cause why not) it was so magical. But now were in a place where the dark cloud will be discussed nearly as much as the amazing day. And then there's an even worse part: Froome will likely hold off Dumoulin and win. And now we'll all wait for the investigation to end - which might even be after the Tour - and Froome might get stripped of this Giro win and all the others will bump up a slot on paper but they will have missed the champagne, lipstick smudges, etc. etc.

Some would argue that Froome shouldn't have been allowed to start. But then what if he's cleared of this issue and now we've got a guy who's won the TdF 4x, won the Vuelta 1x and deserves his Giro win to move him up on the list of true greats.

It's not as clear as we'd all like

Ian

PS. I really think we've haven't seen anything like this since Floyd, Stage 17 TdF 2006. As a reminder: Stages 7,8,9 Floyd is 2nd on GC +1min. Stage 10 he slips to 4th +4:45. Stage 11 he takes the Yellow, keeps it for Stage 12, slips to 2nd on Stage 13, holds 2nd Stage 14. Back into Yellow on Stage 15. On Stage 16 he plummets to 11th on GC over 8 minutes down. The next day, Floyd goes 120k solo over 4 mountains include Colombiere and the Joux-Plane - wins, takes back Yellow. What a great day. As it would happen, Floyd pissed out a sample that was 3x the legal testosterone to epi ratio and all the greatness of that day is erased.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ianpeace] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pffft!

Pantani says both Froome and Landis are soft.

....wasn’t even raining!

Maurice
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ianpeace] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Really wished the Giro was carried on Directv! Ain't one for 'streaming' quit yet. Will be interesting to see how this plays out.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [ianpeace] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey, have a look at what I posted on a few posts on this thread. Given that Froome made up vs Dumoulin and moreso how much time on the descents on this stage (I think I added it up to 1:40 of the 3ish minutes he made on Dumoulin), I don't think that this performance was anymore "not normal" than the chasers. His attack on Finistre was just marginally faster than Dumoulin....so if you look at it from the doping angle, he does not appear to be any dirtier nor cleaner than Dumoulin and Pinot. Dumoulin and Pinot crested Finistre only 30+ seconds slower than Froome and that included Dumoulin waiting for Pinot's broken spoke induced wheel change. On the final climb of the day, Froome's lead was initially shrinking on the lower slopes and then he managed to get some of the shrink back. Dumoulin was gased at the end, but for this weight vs Froome's the performances of both men were largely in line given that Froome made a ton of the gap on the descents.

What's not normal is Froome rolling the dice and trying to blow things apart 80K out, but yesterday I said that he would use the gravel and technical descent to his advantage. I really think that Froome thought the tactics through well in advance and then optimized the execution on the tricky terrain.

I don't think this one is anywhere in the Floyd 2006 category, simply because Froome was not much better than the chasers on the climbs....just a touch better, but come on, he's always been a better climber than Dumoulin and Pinot. It's not like he was dropping a fully peaked Nario Quintana or full juiced Marco Pantani.

Yates should have been the escapee with Froome today, but he burnt out his legs earlier with too much too often.

Everyone looking at how "not normal" today was needs to look at how "not normal" Froome's descents and technical skills were. Almost (or maybe beyond) the category of "Il Falco" Paolo Salvodelli. In 2005 it was on the same Finistre decent to Sestriere that Salvodelli closed the gap to Simoni for the Giro win. Everyone is forgetting about how much time a good descender going solo without other riders in the way can make up on this descent. I've been waiting for this stage to see what impact this climb and descent would have and was not dissappointed.

Now having said, that, Sky could be doped to the same level or slightly more than Scott, Sunweb, Bahrain, Emirates etc. I just don't think that Froome's performance is eyebrow raising from a relative watts per kilo vs his chasers. It was barely marginally better based on rates of climb that were not that different.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ppl keep bringing up the descents like it's battle of just coasting down them..if you take the doping angle as you say...well the dope is going to help you downhill too.. aint it. Yeah there is bike handling and what not, but Froome was clearly shown peddling on the downhill.. and hitting the pedals sitting on the downtube and all.

Besides I doubt he's doped right now.. I just dont think he should even be racing.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
Hey, have a look at what I posted on a few posts on this thread. Given that Froome made up vs Dumoulin and moreso how much time on the descents on this stage (I think I added it up to 1:40 of the 3ish minutes he made on Dumoulin), I don't think that this performance was anymore "not normal" than the chasers. His attack on Finistre was just marginally faster than Dumoulin....so if you look at it from the doping angle, he does not appear to be any dirtier nor cleaner than Dumoulin and Pinot. Dumoulin and Pinot crested Finistre only 30+ seconds slower than Froome and that included Dumoulin waiting for Pinot's broken spoke induced wheel change. On the final climb of the day, Froome's lead was initially shrinking on the lower slopes and then he managed to get some of the shrink back. Dumoulin was gased at the end, but for this weight vs Froome's the performances of both men were largely in line given that Froome made a ton of the gap on the descents.

What's not normal is Froome rolling the dice and trying to blow things apart 80K out, but yesterday I said that he would use the gravel and technical descent to his advantage. I really think that Froome thought the tactics through well in advance and then optimized the execution on the tricky terrain.

I don't think this one is anywhere in the Floyd 2006 category, simply because Froome was not much better than the chasers on the climbs....just a touch better, but come on, he's always been a better climber than Dumoulin and Pinot. It's not like he was dropping a fully peaked Nario Quintana or full juiced Marco Pantani.

Yates should have been the escapee with Froome today, but he burnt out his legs earlier with too much too often.

Everyone looking at how "not normal" today was needs to look at how "not normal" Froome's descents and technical skills were. Almost (or maybe beyond) the category of "Il Falco" Paolo Salvodelli. In 2005 it was on the same Finistre decent to Sestriere that Salvodelli closed the gap to Simoni for the Giro win. Everyone is forgetting about how much time a good descender going solo without other riders in the way can make up on this descent. I've been waiting for this stage to see what impact this climb and descent would have and was not dissappointed.

Now having said, that, Sky could be doped to the same level or slightly more than Scott, Sunweb, Bahrain, Emirates etc. I just don't think that Froome's performance is eyebrow raising from a relative watts per kilo vs his chasers. It was barely marginally better based on rates of climb that were not that different.

I think a lot of his strategy was to get out in front by himself on the descents and make up the time there. It's so much easier to haul ass down a mountain when there aren't 3-4 other guys you have to avoid.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [T3_Beer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
T3_Beer wrote:
devashish_paul wrote:
Hey, have a look at what I posted on a few posts on this thread. Given that Froome made up vs Dumoulin and moreso how much time on the descents on this stage (I think I added it up to 1:40 of the 3ish minutes he made on Dumoulin), I don't think that this performance was anymore "not normal" than the chasers. His attack on Finistre was just marginally faster than Dumoulin....so if you look at it from the doping angle, he does not appear to be any dirtier nor cleaner than Dumoulin and Pinot. Dumoulin and Pinot crested Finistre only 30+ seconds slower than Froome and that included Dumoulin waiting for Pinot's broken spoke induced wheel change. On the final climb of the day, Froome's lead was initially shrinking on the lower slopes and then he managed to get some of the shrink back. Dumoulin was gased at the end, but for this weight vs Froome's the performances of both men were largely in line given that Froome made a ton of the gap on the descents.

What's not normal is Froome rolling the dice and trying to blow things apart 80K out, but yesterday I said that he would use the gravel and technical descent to his advantage. I really think that Froome thought the tactics through well in advance and then optimized the execution on the tricky terrain.

I don't think this one is anywhere in the Floyd 2006 category, simply because Froome was not much better than the chasers on the climbs....just a touch better, but come on, he's always been a better climber than Dumoulin and Pinot. It's not like he was dropping a fully peaked Nario Quintana or full juiced Marco Pantani.

Yates should have been the escapee with Froome today, but he burnt out his legs earlier with too much too often.

Everyone looking at how "not normal" today was needs to look at how "not normal" Froome's descents and technical skills were. Almost (or maybe beyond) the category of "Il Falco" Paolo Salvodelli. In 2005 it was on the same Finistre decent to Sestriere that Salvodelli closed the gap to Simoni for the Giro win. Everyone is forgetting about how much time a good descender going solo without other riders in the way can make up on this descent. I've been waiting for this stage to see what impact this climb and descent would have and was not dissappointed.

Now having said, that, Sky could be doped to the same level or slightly more than Scott, Sunweb, Bahrain, Emirates etc. I just don't think that Froome's performance is eyebrow raising from a relative watts per kilo vs his chasers. It was barely marginally better based on rates of climb that were not that different.


I think a lot of his strategy was to get out in front by himself on the descents and make up the time there. It's so much easier to haul ass down a mountain when there aren't 3-4 other guys you have to avoid.

I agree. His goal here was to thin it out in Finistre and safely take risks (if you can call it that) without having other riders cluttering the road. We seems to have made the most of that on each descent and rode the valleys and climbs fairly steady. He was not dramatically faster than Pinot+Dumoulin on the valleys and climbs today.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
agreed, it was a highly impressive ride, particularly for having the balls to try it at all. it was not incredible though given it was essentially man vs man.
thats one way this differs from landis who i believe basically rode away from the peloton. the other is that froome has shown over 6 years that he is pretty much the strongest gc type rider going so its no massive surprise to see him besting these guys. landis was a decent rider but not a standout champion except for that one day

i was hoping to see someone else win, as much for variety as anything against froome and his inhaler but really he has earned pink. he could yet pay for it tomorrow, though i doubt it with the team he has around him and everyone having suffered much the same today
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [pk1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pk1 wrote:
it was not incredible

George Bennett doesn't agree. :)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I saw that video and it cracked me up. Pure disbelief. I truly hope this shit is legit because I'm tired of being disappointed with the behavior in my sports. Time will tell.

There is also this:

"The adjective I'd use to describe Froome's performance is 'mostruoso' - monstrous. If I look at my watts and think I finished eight minutes down then he did a huge ride, something incredible," Pozzovivo said.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
turdburgler wrote:
I saw that video and it cracked me up. Pure disbelief. I truly hope this shit is legit because I'm tired of being disappointed with the behavior in my sports. Time will tell.

There is also this:

"The adjective I'd use to describe Froome's performance is 'mostruoso' - monstrous. If I look at my watts and think I finished eight minutes down then he did a huge ride, something incredible," Pozzovivo said.

I guess then the question is how did Carapez, Pinot, Lopez and Dumoulin finish ~3 min behind Froome of which only half was on the climbs and valleys...the rest of Froome's gap was on the descents. If Froome was superhuman, then minus Dumoulin who has proven he is on Froome's level, how did the rest of these guys pull off such miraculous rides? Froome's climbing gains over more climbing today, seems to be much less than what he did proportionally on Zoncolan. If Froome put say 90 seconds on these guy over the climbs and valleys on today's stage, that would be totally in line with what he can put on them during a TT of that length given that their cooperation was pretty piss poor.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote:
Ryan Mullen‏ @ryanmullen9 11h11 hours ago
More
Today I did 300 watts average for 6 hours to finish 45 minutes behind the winner. Hahahahaha.

Rhymenocerus wrote:
I think everyone should consult ST before they do anything.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
We get it. You think it's normal. You've made your case.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
We get it. You think it's normal. You've made your case.

I did not say it is normal relative to the rest of the population or the rest of the peloton, I am saying its just as normal as Dumoulin, Pinot, Carapez, Lopez. So if we're going to pick on Froome, we need to pick on those guys too for doing a performance more or less in line with Froome given their own power to weight ratios and the terrain at hand.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [B_Doughtie] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Do we think that the whole adverse analytical findings case with just evaporate into thin air. CF will win the Giro on Sunday. The UCI is so disorganised and full of contradicting statements. They are never going to ban CF. By the way I think he has not done anything wrong.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Anybody got any links were I can watch highlights of yesterday's stage?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [AlexS321] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Cracked me up.


Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [AlexS321] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
AlexS321 wrote:
Do we think that the whole adverse analytical findings case with just evaporate into thin air. CF will win the Giro on Sunday. The UCI is so disorganised and full of contradicting statements. They are never going to ban CF. By the way I think he has not done anything wrong.
Do you think that the test results were wrong, or that he took the legal amount but excreted double the legal amount? Or do you think he should be allowed to puff as much salbutamol as he wants?

Do you have any other examples of people testing way over the limit for salbutamol, who haven't been banned?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [NUFCrichard] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Seen this all before. I can’t suspend disbelief yet again. Guy drops the field at 80k out and sticks it. Then cycling fan physicists explain why, so we rationalize what we’ve witnessed and can breathe easy knowing our heroes are heroes.

If UCI had their shit together he wouldn’t be riding at all. Brailsford is a hypocrit.. Sky is dirty and they’re not alone.

Can’t wait to see another Hejedal spinning bike and have it explained away as perfectly normal. Another clean guy unfairly maligned.

Corticosteroids for weight loss and body comp changes are still there. Tramadol, micro dosing, it’s all still there. I applaud and respect the majority of the peloton trying to do this clean.

If you’re looking for clean, look down the mountain. If you’re not, happy viewing.

Jimmy out.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [NUFCrichard] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
this topic has probably been discussed to death anyway. There was a scientific paper published last month claiming that the current test to detect levels of salbutamol in urine is inadequate. Coincidence or not the Sky lawyers will use it in his defence.
Still though the stage yesterday was amazing to watch.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [AlexS321] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
How long have you been a professional road cycling fan?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
If UCI had their shit together he wouldn’t be riding at all. Brailsford is a hypocrit.. Sky is dirty and they’re not alone
I still feel like when Sky started up they had genuine intentions of riding clean, maybe I'm naive on that. But I think the pursuit of marginal gains gradually led them down the road of exploiting every possible opportunity to "legally" dope, and then to bending the rules and finding loopholes to squeeze out even more gains, incrementally becoming dirtier and dirtier. I wonder what Brailsford circa 2010 would think of Brailsford now.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
If you think Sky is dirty then what makes you think that the majority of the peloton is trying to do it clean? Plenty of riders have left Sky and gone to other teams - Landa, Porte, Cavendish, Kennaugh, Boassen Hagen, Nieve, Viviani for example. You think they were dirty for Sky and then suddenly cleaned up their act when they moved teams? If they are advocates for clean riding and knew that Sky were dirty why not say something?

Based on past history it seems highly likely that if there's doping going on amongst the top teams then most of the riders will be doing it to a greater or lesser degree.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [PJC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
PJC wrote:
Quote:

Ryan Mullen‏ @ryanmullen9 11h11 hours ago
More
Today I did 300 watts average for 6 hours to finish 45 minutes behind the winner. Hahahahaha.

I saw that but everytime they showed Dumoulin's power on the climbs it was 350W!!!! So that would be "only" 5W per kilo. I did not see any 420W (6W per kilo) readings on the flobikes feed, but I may have missed them. Don't know how accurate those numbers are.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pinot has blown and is way off the back today. Can barely turn the pedals and has teammates trying to nurse him through to the finish line. Still a lot of climbing to go with 35k or so left.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Jackets] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jackets wrote:
Anybody got any links were I can watch highlights of yesterday's stage?

I am using flobikes.com in Canada. It is available in the US. Cost was $30 for one month.

Dev
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Just to pull today's profile up again. One last chance for Tom D on Cervinia


Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
 Am I the only one rooting for Lopez ?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [marcag] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
marcag wrote:
Am I the only one rooting for Lopez ?

There is one more person in Ottawa in your camp! When am I going to see you next time at the pool before you head to the TdF with team Astana?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
marcag wrote:
Am I the only one rooting for Lopez ?


There is one more person in Ottawa in your camp! When am I going to see you next time at the pool before you head to the TdF with team Astana?

I have made myself obsolete by training the coaches on how to use the device. They don't need me anymore.

As a matter of fact they tested Lopez a few weeks ago. Last weekend they were testing Valgren and Cataldo on various positions for break aways and descents. This weekend they are testing Fuglsang on the TT bike.

All I get are test results and pictures :-( The riders love this shit.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Froome maintained his lead across all the flat valley kilometers over three guys trading pulls, then went up last climb faster than any of them. As I said before, Froome is a complete GC guy but that really shows the extent of his effort.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:
Seen this all before. I can’t suspend disbelief yet again. Guy drops the field at 80k out and sticks it. Then cycling fan physicists explain why, so we rationalize what we’ve witnessed and can breathe easy knowing our heroes are heroes.

If UCI had their shit together he wouldn’t be riding at all. Brailsford is a hypocrit.. Sky is dirty and they’re not alone.

Can’t wait to see another Hejedal spinning bike and have it explained away as perfectly normal. Another clean guy unfairly maligned.

Corticosteroids for weight loss and body comp changes are still there. Tramadol, micro dosing, it’s all still there. I applaud and respect the majority of the peloton trying to do this clean.

If you’re looking for clean, look down the mountain. If you’re not, happy viewing.

Jimmy out.

maybe you guys can help me with this, because i haven't really followed it. i think there's every possibility froome did a landis yesterday. but not with salbutamol. there is no way you can puff your way to victory. oral salbutamol? yeah. that's a performance enhancer. but that would show up in a blood test and probably a urine test and maybe that's the hubbub, that his levels were too high for it to be inhaled? it's not a strong enough beta-2-agonist to provide an androgenic effect.

i don't see froome's giving a pink jersey to glaxo for his ride yesterday. are we basically saying the peloton is on a relative level clean, even the top guys, except that they're abusing the TUE system with the need for corticosteroids and beta-2-agonists? because, if so, flay me if you want, but if that's where we are then that would be a huge anti-doping victory.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I don't believe that any of your post was a contention.

Nonetheless I do agree with your conclusion: I do not believe there is any eveidence to suggest that anything has changed since the Festina affair, except the methods.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Good point Carl, but I watched a lot of it and it looked like TD doing the majority of the pulling. They attacked TD on occasion, and TD also had to shepherd them down the hills as they can’t descend like Froome and TD.



Carl Spackler wrote:
Froome maintained his lead across all the flat valley kilometers over three guys trading pulls, then went up last climb faster than any of them. As I said before, Froome is a complete GC guy but that really shows the extent of his effort.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [EnderWiggan] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TD admitted it might have been a mistake to wait for Reichenbach because he “descends like an old lady,” but even if TD was doing 70% of work on flats it would be more likely to see Froome slow from the additional effort.

But whatever, is what it was, which was certainly entertaining. The Giro is a no-win deal for Froome wrt to public opinion. If vindicated of adverse finding he’ll still be scrutinized for stage 18 effort. If not he’ll be hammered much worse, and rightfully so. At end of the day the sport can’t seem to move beyond past mistakes.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I’ve never been a big fan of Froome, but he’s impressive. Three GT wins in succession and looking good for a Giro/Tour double. Not to mention that would make it a Tour/Vuelta/Giro/Tour quad. Throw in the back from the dead aspect of the Giro win and you have to give him some props.

"Human existence is based upon two pillars: Compassion and knowledge. Compassion without knowledge is ineffective; Knowledge without compassion is inhuman." Victor Weisskopf.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [Alvin Tostig] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Alvin Tostig wrote:
I’ve never been a big fan of Froome, but he’s impressive. Three GT wins in succession and looking good for a Giro/Tour double. Not to mention that would make it a Tour/Vuelta/Giro/Tour quad. Throw in the back from the dead aspect of the Giro win and you have to give him some props.

I think he is the favourite for the Quad. His Giro was more like a 2 week loss limting training camp followed by a one week serious stage race with 3 really hard stages with extended efforts (Zoncolan, ITT and Finistre) plus 2 stages with short surges (today and Prato Nevoso). With the extra time to the TdF, I would imagine he will be ready. Maybe he won't be on full form in the first 10 days if he takes a large chunk of easy days/time off immediately after the Giro, but I would imagine that Sky would have him ready for the back half of the race when everyone is tired and the top end of most of the peloton is diminished....then he can out diesel everyone. Froome just needs to sit on Richie Porte, Quintana, Simon Yates, Barguil, Bardet, Uran, Landa and limit losses the first 10 days while these guys overcook it....then a few hard stages and solid TT and these guys can't beat him. The thing about Froome is the guy really knows how to use his resources over 3 weeks and largely saves any crazy attacks. There were stages early in the Giro when Pinot was attacking all the time. That guy was the strongest on multiple stages. Same with Yates. Froome and Dumoulin, these guys save their matches. i'd love to see a rematch between the two guys at the TdF.

Last year Quintana over raced before the Giro and was done by the TdF. Froome seems to have followed a more sensible early season scheudule compatively.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I am new to watching cyling so perhaps this is a very dumb question. But why has Froome already won? Tommorow is the last stage right? It seems to be a formality for some, not for others. I'd really don't understand.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [ic3d] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ic3d wrote:
I am new to watching cyling so perhaps this is a very dumb question. But why has Froome already won? Tommorow is the last stage right? It seems to be a formality for some, not for others. I'd really don't understand.
The last stage of a Grand Tour is generally seen as a procession and one for the sprinters to contend. The stage into Rome will be no different.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia- SPOILER ALERT [AlexS321] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yes, I think that Salbutamol Dog's performance is like a teflon suit wrt the AAF. Can you imagine the problems that would occur if the AAF was upheld and SD's GdI results were voided? Terrible, terrible outcome. It now does not matter if SD can demonstrate the high levels in urine with a legal inhaled dose or not. He's gonna walk.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [BayDad] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
But, again I am new to this, why wouldn't Tom Dumoulin (yes I am Dutch), try and attack tommorow? His chances are slim, but probably better than attacking in the mountains today (as he tried several times at the end).
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [ic3d] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ic3d wrote:
But, again I am new to this, why wouldn't Tom Dumoulin (yes I am Dutch), try and attack tommorow? His chances are slim, but probably better than attacking in the mountains today (as he tried several times at the end).
He could. Wouldn't work though.

There’s no way he could put 48s into Froome on such a flat short stage.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [ic3d] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
So let's just play it out. Let's say TD WANTS to attack and tries to. Here's how you do it, you get in a break.

But the thing is, breaks only happen because the racers want them to happen. TD could try 10 times to get a gap, and every time Sky most certainly would shut it down. Ever wonder notice in every stage breakaway, the rider has zero GC threat. They are X athlete in 89th position 48 mins down. Joined by 10 others with the best placed guy in 38th, 22 mins down. There are likely attacks on just about every stage that get pulled back for various reasons until pretty much the one that has the least amount of issues gets the freedom to go.

It may have been in the Lance era but I remember there was like a top 10 GC guy trying to get in the break, and all his breakmates were yelling at him because they knew they were doomed and 10 mins later, it was caught. Of course this is often times not seen on tele because it's 28 mins into a 6 hour stage and no tv cameras are following it.

So it's not so much that it's ceremonial, it's ceremonial because the tactics of creating GC time gaps isn't there on flat stages. It's why it's almost unheard of when GC time changes on flat stages, it's either crash/flat and/or sketchy crosswind that causes time changes.

Essentially TD's team would have to go all Breaking Away to Chris Froome (I hope you get the reference).

Brooks Doughtie, M.S.
Exercise Physiology
-USAT Level II
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [B_Doughtie] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks I think I've got it now. I saw Froome escape yesterday and everyone told me "nah, he won't make it", yet he did. But I understand what you're saying. I'd still be rooting for Tom tommorow though. ;)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [B_Doughtie] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
B_Doughtie wrote:
So let's just play it out. Let's say TD WANTS to attack and tries to. Here's how you do it, you get in a break.

But the thing is, breaks only happen because the racers want them to happen. TD could try 10 times to get a gap, and every time Sky most certainly would shut it down. Ever wonder notice in every stage breakaway, the rider has zero GC threat. They are X athlete in 89th position 48 mins down. Joined by 10 others with the best placed guy in 38th, 22 mins down. There are likely attacks on just about every stage that get pulled back for various reasons until pretty much the one that has the least amount of issues gets the freedom to go.

It may have been in the Lance era but I remember there was like a top 10 GC guy trying to get in the break, and all his breakmates were yelling at him because they knew they were doomed and 10 mins later, it was caught. Of course this is often times not seen on tele because it's 28 mins into a 6 hour stage and no tv cameras are following it.

So it's not so much that it's ceremonial, it's ceremonial because the tactics of creating GC time gaps isn't there on flat stages. It's why it's almost unheard of when GC time changes on flat stages, it's either crash/flat and/or sketchy crosswind that causes time changes.

Essentially TD's team would have to go all Breaking Away to Chris Froome (I hope you get the reference).

The only time I remember was actually when Froome took advantage of crosswinds to bridge to Sagan at the tour to gap the GC contenders. Otherwise, I’ve never seen GC time changes on flats.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [KingMidas] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I thought one of the best flat stages I've ever seen was I believe in 2013 Tour when Contador took advantage of a crosswind and gained like a min with like 30k to go in a stage. It turned into almost an team time trial to the line, and it actually didn't turn out to matter much as he didn't ride well in the mountains, but it was one of the most brilliant bike tactic stages I had ever seen. It literally became 2 groups of roughly the same size riding against each other, just really brilliant racing.

Brooks Doughtie, M.S.
Exercise Physiology
-USAT Level II
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [ic3d] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ic3d wrote:
Thanks I think I've got it now. I saw Froome escape yesterday and everyone told me "nah, he won't make it", yet he did. But I understand what you're saying. I'd still be rooting for Tom tommorow though. ;)

There's nothing to root for. There is a gentleman's agreement that the last stage on a grand tour is a procession for the GC and to be contested by the sprinters.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [tuckandgo] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The only time I've seen the gc change on the last day was the '89 Tdf, which was a shortish TT. Now that was exciting to watch. No one gave Greg a chance. But with his Tri bars he overcame fignon who was wobbling all over the place with a disc front wheel.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [KingMidas] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
KingMidas wrote:
B_Doughtie wrote:
So let's just play it out. Let's say TD WANTS to attack and tries to. Here's how you do it, you get in a break.

But the thing is, breaks only happen because the racers want them to happen. TD could try 10 times to get a gap, and every time Sky most certainly would shut it down. Ever wonder notice in every stage breakaway, the rider has zero GC threat. They are X athlete in 89th position 48 mins down. Joined by 10 others with the best placed guy in 38th, 22 mins down. There are likely attacks on just about every stage that get pulled back for various reasons until pretty much the one that has the least amount of issues gets the freedom to go.

It may have been in the Lance era but I remember there was like a top 10 GC guy trying to get in the break, and all his breakmates were yelling at him because they knew they were doomed and 10 mins later, it was caught. Of course this is often times not seen on tele because it's 28 mins into a 6 hour stage and no tv cameras are following it.

So it's not so much that it's ceremonial, it's ceremonial because the tactics of creating GC time gaps isn't there on flat stages. It's why it's almost unheard of when GC time changes on flat stages, it's either crash/flat and/or sketchy crosswind that causes time changes.

Essentially TD's team would have to go all Breaking Away to Chris Froome (I hope you get the reference).

The only time I remember was actually when Froome took advantage of crosswinds to bridge to Sagan at the tour to gap the GC contenders. Otherwise, I’ve never seen GC time changes on flats.
Yeah that was a great move by Froome at the end of the race is the move which ultimately won him the Tour. But only happened because of the major cross winds.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [B_Doughtie] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
B_Doughtie wrote:
I thought one of the best flat stages I've ever seen was I believe in 2013 Tour when Contador took advantage of a crosswind and gained like a min with like 30k to go in a stage. It turned into almost an team time trial to the line, and it actually didn't turn out to matter much as he didn't ride well in the mountains, but it was one of the most brilliant bike tactic stages I had ever seen. It literally became 2 groups of roughly the same size riding against each other, just really brilliant racing.

Any replay of that anywhere? I’ve only been following cycling for the last 3-4 years
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [KingMidas] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
KingMidas wrote:

Any replay of that anywhere? I’ve only been following cycling for the last 3-4 years

It was Stage 13 of the 2013 Tour:

Part 1:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=utqI6KMsZnc
Part 2:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uPkO8SBMPbA
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [tuckandgo] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
tuckandgo wrote:
ic3d wrote:
Thanks I think I've got it now. I saw Froome escape yesterday and everyone told me "nah, he won't make it", yet he did. But I understand what you're saying. I'd still be rooting for Tom tommorow though. ;)

There's nothing to root for. There is a gentleman's agreement that the last stage on a grand tour is a procession for the GC and to be contested by the sprinters.

^^^^This.

In the TdF the rule is no attacks until the finishing laps in Paris (and then only by non-GC guys). The rest of the race is a slow roll with lots of photo ops. Giro is the same way. As mentioned, the exception is when the last stage is a TT.

ECMGN Therapy Silicon Valley:
Depression, Neurocognitive problems, Dementias (Testing and Evaluation), Trauma and PTSD, Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [Titanflexr] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Although 1 year, when there were still bonus seconds at the Tour, Vino grabbed one of the intermediate sprints to leapfrog Leipheimer from 6th to 5th, I believe. Of course, probably no one else would've done that, Vinokourov being the kind of person he is.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [Ken] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ken wrote:
KingMidas wrote:

Any replay of that anywhere? I’ve only been following cycling for the last 3-4 years

It was Stage 13 of the 2013 Tour:

Part 1:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=utqI6KMsZnc
Part 2:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uPkO8SBMPbA

Thx. 4 hr trainer ride tomorrow. Between champions league final and this, I have it covered.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [KingMidas] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Let me here temper my previous remarks re Froomie's Excellent Floyd Day Out. I took a couple of pulls on the puffer and went on a nice little morning ride. Might hit Bed Bath and Beyond later. I don't know if we'll have time......

After Zoncolan I had the thought, "Nobody can suffer like Froome". I think that's a bullshit thought, one of many I have. If you saw Yates in the post stage 18 interviews, he was beyond wasted. These guys at the World Tour level can all suffer. Or they're not there.

And the same guys that could hang with Froome up Sa Collabra in Mallorca in January are getting bottles and in the grupetto when Froome is up the road for 80k.

I think many in the pro peloton have used cortico roids to transform their body composition to be able to even complete a GT. There are guys with 420 ftp who weigh 150 pounds NATURALLY, and they have team guys following them around in the off season with body fat pincers telling them to ride for 5 hours with water and bananas to lose 1.5 kg. . It's completely insane.

I think so many over the years have sought an "unfair" advantage in many ways. And that's the rub. What is unfair? It's about the money. The rest is conversation.

I don't condemn them to burn in hell. The awful thing they did was be part of the problem and take spots from guys who said no. But back when it was an industry standard, well, why not? That said, I'm not buying their clothes or staying at their hotels or posing for pix with them. But I get why they did it. Amateur Masters cheats, of which there are many, I find far more heinous and pathetic and should be kicked in their synthetic testosterone filled nuts.

I don't think Sky has a program to cheat. I do think Brailsford is a massive tool and hypocrit and has huge pressure on him to win the GT's. And he will look the other way if he has to. They have a big budget, buy the best talent and hope. They are no more organized than any other WT team and have no superior approach.

What I believe is that many riders have their special bottle, their Billy Baroo putter for big moments. I think Tramadol may be rampant. It's the kind of drug that masks the pain that kills the superhuman effort. I do not buy the old "Wow, didn't Froome's form really kick in at just the right moment? Brilliant!"

Anyway, awesome to have kicked this Giro around with the group. Great, respectful and fun discussions, and great racing. Just a little blown away by Froomie Day.

To quote Tony Soprano, "All in all though, it was a pretty good visit."
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Every great athlete is on something. I don’t believe any of them are clean. Pretty much every major NFL NHL NBA MLB soccer players. Just look at them and look at the players from 80’s and 90’s. How does a sprinter and swimmer and 10k specialist dominate 3 Olympics? How is it that top 2 sprinters in men and women are all from a tiny island in carrebean? All great marathoners are from 3 countries in Africa? You have countries that push it on athletes, governing bodies that turn the other way and take the money, a sporting company that has hired special docs and has a history of supporting dirty athletes, not to mention commercial bullying tactics.
It’s a waste of time to care about records.
I just watch for entertainment purposes and do my best in my hobbies.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [KingMidas] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
For a sport that is dying for fans and viewers, neutralizing the GC on a day that would have been riveting is the dumbest thing I've ever seen.

*Yes I'm very aware of cycling tradition, but its 2018 and it might be time to make some decisions for the good of the sport.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [Hammer Down] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
All these "gentlemen agreements" always come on flat as pancake easy stages. If this was a mt stage as the final stage, they'd have no procession, they'd show up ready for a fight. It's a gentlemen's lap because it's an stage that cant/wont break up the GC. That's precisely why they have an gentlemen's agreement. ETA: The gentlemen's agreement is only there because it's a flat stage. This isn't your local cat 5 race where you can just breakaway off the front and TD "itt" his way to time gains. That move would be meet with such a shut down force that they'd boot his ass to the back of the peloton for stupidity. No one that wants to go in the break wants an GC guy in their break, because it means shut down before it starts. So it's not that they all are saying we give in. It's that the race profile won't allow any gaps to form for GC to matter. Like I said it's unheard of in cycling for a flat stage to result in GC time changes unless they get an unfortunate flat/crash and/or a crosswind (and people will know those locations likely weeks ahead of time based on predictable locations).


ETA: So no this was not going to be riveting. Nothing about a flat stage is riveting except the final 20km and when the break will get caught and which sprinter will win and which GC will *hopefully* not get crashed out. You can't attack flat stages for GC time, everyone knows that...that's precisely why they can all enjoy the process of finishing an GT.

Brooks Doughtie, M.S.
Exercise Physiology
-USAT Level II
Last edited by: B_Doughtie: May 27, 18 9:18
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [KingMidas] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
KingMidas wrote:
Every great athlete is on something. I don’t believe any of them are clean. Pretty much every major NFL NHL NBA MLB soccer players. Just look at them and look at the players from 80’s and 90’s. How does a sprinter and swimmer and 10k specialist dominate 3 Olympics? How is it that top 2 sprinters in men and women are all from a tiny island in carrebean? All great marathoners are from 3 countries in Africa? You have countries that push it on athletes, governing bodies that turn the other way and take the money, a sporting company that has hired special docs and has a history of supporting dirty athletes, not to mention commercial bullying tactics.
It’s a waste of time to care about records.
I just watch for entertainment purposes and do my best in my hobbies.

The way I look at this, pro athletes and teams will push the boundary of the box of rules you put them inside. They will maximize without getting caught (or they may). It's not a sham. This has been going on since the days of Jacques Anquetil and Vince Lombardy and Maurice Richard and Lasse Viren. Really it's pro sport, so its just easiest to assume that EVERY ATHLETE and EVERY TEAM is pushing the written rules and going into the grey zone. It's like speeding....drivers speed to the limit that the police enforcement and generally accepted driving behaviour will allow. When a driver ventures too far outside they get nailed. I don't buy the arguement that clean athletes get spots taken by cheaters. It's like any profession, at the ultimate level of performance, leaders and organizations maximize what they can do inside the rules and enforcement....every now and then you get a company on NASDAQ who plays the loopholes too far and go on the wrong side of what is legal thinking they found a loophole that gets shut on them hard. They may have nailed Jose Cruz for shooting up, but at the same time there were a ton of players in MLB shot up to the gills and we all enjoyed the homerun derby....until we were told the obvious that they were doped (doh....did you see rookie Barry Bonds vs Bonds before retirement???). In any case, as I said, if Froome was doped on Friday and he just may have been, I'm not sure that Thibault, Dumoulin, Carapez, Reichenbach, Lopez were squeeky clean either. The numbers for Froome were not that much better than those guys. Froome had the best body composition of all those guys and yes he may have gone over the legal limit to get there, but whatever. For example Reichenback looks like a doughboy compared to Froome.....not that he is, he's ultra lean compared to anyone on ST.

In any case, cycling gets a bad wrap because it actually does something to keep a lid on doping. Of all major sports it has the most active program and because of that, it gets slammed. It was pretty funny, I was talking to a close friend of mine, who is a former 2:23 marathoner, riders and former and now current hockey player.....his words, "No hockey does not have a doping culture, doping does not matter in hockey." I replied, "really, are you really that clueless that you think that in a power endurance sport with no testing with all that money on the line, that the Pittsburgh Penguins, or Boston Bruins would be on bread and water when they have access to all the best medical advice that the Pittsburgh Steelers and New England Patriots have?.....do you really believe that? If so, you have no clue about pro sport".
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
In any case, cycling gets a bad wrap because it actually does something to keep a lid on doping. Of all major sports it has the most active program and because of that, it gets slammed.

-------
I think what I find most frustrating is the unfairness the IOC dictates with it's doping programs for each olympic sport. The NBA dictated a few years ago that if the IOC wanted Kobe and Lebron in the Olympics the only way was drug testing only happened in the 6 months run in to the olympics. And the IOC wants the eye balls on Lebron so of course they let it happen. So cycling has and likely always will (along with T&F) take it on the chin in regards to doping.

Brooks Doughtie, M.S.
Exercise Physiology
-USAT Level II
Last edited by: B_Doughtie: May 27, 18 10:14
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [B_Doughtie] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
B_Doughtie wrote:
All these "gentlemen agreements" always come on flat as pancake easy stages. If this was a mt stage as the final stage, they'd have no procession, they'd show up ready for a fight. It's a gentlemen's lap because it's an stage that cant/wont break up the GC. That's precisely why they have an gentlemen's agreement. ETA: The gentlemen's agreement is only there because it's a flat stage. This isn't your local cat 5 race where you can just breakaway off the front and TD "itt" his way to time gains. That move would be meet with such a shut down force that they'd boot his ass to the back of the peloton for stupidity. No one that wants to go in the break wants an GC guy in their break, because it means shut down before it starts. So it's not that they all are saying we give in. It's that the race profile won't allow any gaps to form for GC to matter. Like I said it's unheard of in cycling for a flat stage to result in GC time changes unless they get an unfortunate flat/crash and/or a crosswind (and people will know those locations likely weeks ahead of time based on predictable locations).


ETA: So no this was not going to be riveting. Nothing about a flat stage is riveting except the final 20km and when the break will get caught and which sprinter will win and which GC will *hopefully* not get crashed out. You can't attack flat stages for GC time, everyone knows that...that's precisely why they can all enjoy the process of finishing an GT.

I'm assuming you didn't watch the stage? This was far from your run of the mill flat stage. It isn't the champs. The course was extremely technical and challenging. The group was blistered to bits the second they started racing, that is the entire reason they neutralized the GC halfway through the stage. There would have been splits and tons of opportunities.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [Hammer Down] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I didn't see it. I gave up hope after Froome didn't falter yesturday in the only hope to change the final GC at that point.

ETA: Your point stands, just re-read the cyclingnews live feed. Sounded like the stage could have led to atleast some good racing as many were not ready for the conditions of the road. I always hate the "neutralize or not" BS that riders discuss mid ride......makes me go back to Spartacus who would push the pace when the cobbbles took out the other team's leaders then cry foul when his own leader went down and he wanted it neutralized.


So to your point, if today's stage was ceremonial, put it on a ceremonial stretch so that they don't have that type of rider discussion mid stage.

Brooks Doughtie, M.S.
Exercise Physiology
-USAT Level II
Last edited by: B_Doughtie: May 27, 18 10:38
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [B_Doughtie] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
B_Doughtie wrote:
In any case, cycling gets a bad wrap because it actually does something to keep a lid on doping. Of all major sports it has the most active program and because of that, it gets slammed.

-------
I think what I find most frustrating is the unfairness the IOC dictates with it's doping programs for each olympic sport. The NBA dictated a few years ago that if the IOC wanted Kobe and Lebron in the Olympics the only way was drug testing only happened in the 6 months run in to the olympics. And the IOC wants the eye balls on Lebron so of course they let it happen. So cycling has and likely always will (along with T&F) take it on the chin in regards to doping.

NBA and NHL cannot afford to have IOC driven positive drug tests on their stars. They know from baseball that having your homerun king equivalents test positive is bad biz because moms and dads don't want to believe that the only way Johnny boy makes it to the pros is do what the pros are doing....IOC wants the stars for their TV rights so money talks. I would not be surprised if you dope test every MLB player today on this week's games using the WADA code the number of positives would be insanity relative to cycling. At least in cycling, whatever doping the guys are doing is under a threshold....big 4 sport is a free for all.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
McNulty wrote:

I don't think Sky has a program to cheat. I do think Brailsford is a massive tool and hypocrit and has huge pressure on him to win the GT's. And he will look the other way if he has to. They have a big budget, buy the best talent and hope. They are no more organized than any other WT team and have no superior approach.
Actually they do. Several World Tour teams are surprisingly unprofessional in so many ways - both as to relating to training and science, as well as organization.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
B_Doughtie wrote:
In any case, cycling gets a bad wrap because it actually does something to keep a lid on doping. Of all major sports it has the most active program and because of that, it gets slammed.

-------
I think what I find most frustrating is the unfairness the IOC dictates with it's doping programs for each olympic sport. The NBA dictated a few years ago that if the IOC wanted Kobe and Lebron in the Olympics the only way was drug testing only happened in the 6 months run in to the olympics. And the IOC wants the eye balls on Lebron so of course they let it happen. So cycling has and likely always will (along with T&F) take it on the chin in regards to doping.

NBA and NHL cannot afford to have IOC driven positive drug tests on their stars. They know from baseball that having your homerun king equivalents test positive is bad biz because moms and dads don't want to believe that the only way Johnny boy makes it to the pros is do what the pros are doing....IOC wants the stars for their TV rights so money talks. I would not be surprised if you dope test every MLB player today on this week's games using the WADA code the number of positives would be insanity relative to cycling. At least in cycling, whatever doping the guys are doing is under a threshold....big 4 sport is a free for all.

It’s blatant. How would you like a rejuvenation cocktail?


Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [KingMidas] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
KingMidas wrote:
Every great athlete is on something. I don’t believe any of them are clean. Pretty much every major NFL NHL NBA MLB soccer players. Just look at them and look at the players from 80’s and 90’s. How does a sprinter and swimmer and 10k specialist dominate 3 Olympics? How is it that top 2 sprinters in men and women are all from a tiny island in carrebean? All great marathoners are from 3 countries in Africa? You have countries that push it on athletes, governing bodies that turn the other way and take the money, a sporting company that has hired special docs and has a history of supporting dirty athletes, not to mention commercial bullying tactics.
It’s a waste of time to care about records.
I just watch for entertainment purposes and do my best in my hobbies.

Agreed, where there's money there's dope!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I think there is still a valid distinction to be drawn between pushing the envelope of what you can get away with within the letter of the laws versus completely ignoring the laws and getting away with whatever you can.

I think what we are seeing currently in the peloton is mostly the former, whereas what we were seeing in the 90s and early 00s was mostly the latter. It's still far from perfect but I think teams getting marginal gains from questionable TUEs (which the UCI have still signed off on), from legal but likely to be restricted soon drugs like Tramadol, or from taking right up to the legal limit of allowed substances like salbutamol, is a whole lot better than getting massive 20% gains from clearly banned doping like EPO, HGH, testosterone and blood transfusions.

I do also think that Froome and Sky get a lot of abuse because people just don't like them. Froome was having cups of piss thrown at him before any of this salbutamol stuff came out! People don't like him because Sky are dominant and dominant teams make for more boring racing. Some of the Europeans don't like him because he's British (in the same way there was always resentment of USPS for being so American), and some of the Americans don't like him because having seen so many of their own heroes torn down they assume everybody is doping. He's been accused of being a boring rider who can't handle a bike and looks ugly (I hope this week has finally laid to rest the first 2 of those points). And even the Brits haven't taken to him because he was born in Kenya and/or they hold the Wiggins thing against him. It is ironic that it's Froome who is being chased up the mountain by a guy dressed as an inhaler when Yates seems to be universally popular and has actually served a ban for asthma drug use without a TUE. Yes his team took responsibility but their explanation has been accepted without question - would Sky be afforded the same respect?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
https://www.theguardian.com/...itish-winner-cycling

Quote:
In claiming the maglia rosa, Froome also became the first cyclist in 35 years to hold all three grand tour titles – the Tour de France, Vuelta and Giro – at the same time, joining Bernard Hinault and Eddy Merckx, the Badger and the Cannibal, in a super-exclusive club.

Shame Froomie doesn't have a badass nickname

Weezer
The Inhalorator
Mr. Stem

Don't have the same panache

"What's your claim?" - Ben Gravy
"Your best work is the work you're excited about" - Rick Rubin
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [RandMart] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Mr. Stem is awesome haha.

Wasn’t rooting for Froome at the beginning l, but after that stage 19 I am happy to see him win.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [RandMart] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Before the Giro started, I decided that it wouldn't be a success unless we saw at least one drunk fan in a giant inhaler costume chasing Froome uphill.

Sure enough, there it was - right as he was making his attack on the Finestre.

Coincidence?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [McNulty] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
As Giro spectacle winds down the question on my mind is this: does ASO allow Froome to ride Le Tour or block him? RCS got the show they wanted (so far) but is ASO willing to take the Lance-era risk all over again?
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
cartsman wrote:
I think there is still a valid distinction to be drawn between pushing the envelope of what you can get away with within the letter of the laws versus completely ignoring the laws and getting away with whatever you can.

I think what we are seeing currently in the peloton is mostly the former,

That's the problem. When everybody was getting a 20% boost from EPO, the playing field was more or less level. If nobody doped, Pantani and Indurain would still win.

Now, it seems, we are back to "a peloton of two speeds" were most teams can only do low level doping, but one team still can do blood bags on the last rest day.

There lies my resentment for Froome. He is, in my opinion, not in the "would win even if they didn't dope"-category of Indurain, Ullrich and Wiggins. Rather he is in the "doped up donkey"-category of Riis, Ricco and Rumsas. Armstrong falls somewhere in between as I'm pretty sure he had at least one honest Tour win in him.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [fb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
fb wrote:
cartsman wrote:
I think there is still a valid distinction to be drawn between pushing the envelope of what you can get away with within the letter of the laws versus completely ignoring the laws and getting away with whatever you can.

I think what we are seeing currently in the peloton is mostly the former,


That's the problem. When everybody was getting a 20% boost from EPO, the playing field was more or less level. If nobody doped, Pantani and Indurain would still win.

Now, it seems, we are back to "a peloton of two speeds" were most teams can only do low level doping, but one team still can do blood bags on the last rest day.

There lies my resentment for Froome. He is, in my opinion, not in the "would win even if they didn't dope"-category of Indurain, Ullrich and Wiggins. Rather he is in the "doped up donkey"-category of Riis, Ricco and Rumsas. Armstrong falls somewhere in between as I'm pretty sure he had at least one honest Tour win in him.

I don't think Lance had a single undoped Tour win in him. If you read what his first wife said (in his first book) when he made his comeback, Lance was wishy washy about being "totally committed" which if you read between the lines also includes the full dope program and he was fully "committed" by the time he beat Zulle in the 1999 TdF. And he needed some luck on the Passage gu Gois which ended up being pretty well his margin of victory on a fully doped Zulle (we're talking about Zulle who in 1998 rode for Festina and moved to Banesto in 1999...Banesto, you know the choirboy team of Delgado-Indurain-Iles Balaeris-Movistar). But Lance was a 16 year old phenom beating Allen, Pigg and Tinley in triathlon so he had some pretty darn good sport genetics out of the gate.

In any case is the ASO has the chance to have Froome at the start line "clean and off the hook" damn right they will have it since he is the holder of all the grand tour titles and 4x winner of the TdF. He will sell hits and eyeballs (as he just did at the Giro).

I am not sure how you come up with the list of guys who would win if they did not dope. Every protour rider was winning at some leve at some point without doping as a kid, but we have no proof which riders' physiology responds better to doping. A kid with a natural hematocrit of 48 sshould respond less to doping that brings him to 50 than a kid who is naturally at 42. The thing is we don't know whose physiology started where in an unenhanced mode and how much is due to natural training and how much due to dope enhancement.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [fb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
How do you think Sky are getting away with a level of doping that nobody else is? Why do you think the likes of Porte, Nieve or Landa haven't taken Sky's doping secrets with them to their new teams? And if Froome is a "doped up donkey" then why did he spend 2 and a bit weeks of the Giro suffering and leaking time to the leaders? Surely it would have made more sense to dope a bit more in the first two weeks to stay in contention so that he wouldn't need a solo 80km attack to win the race?

Your analysis makes absolutely no sense. It also doesn't explain why nobody else on the Sky team appears to be a doped up donkey, since every time they try to win a GT without Froome they fail miserably.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
cartsman wrote:
How do you think Sky are getting away with a level of doping that nobody else is?
They, like USPS, have more economic resources than the rest. They can afford "motomen" and lawyers.

cartsman wrote:
Why do you think the likes of Porte, Nieve or Landa haven't taken Sky's doping secrets with them to their new teams?

Because those teams do not have the same resources and do not have a national federation that turns a blind eye. Or maybe the just didn't want to be a part of such an organisation, but can't speak out without incrimination themselves.

cartsman wrote:
And if Froome is a "doped up donkey" then why did he spend 2 and a bit weeks of the Giro suffering and leaking time to the leaders?
Because the way to gain an edge over your competition nowadays is to have the "motomen" and dirty doctors to make it possible to do blood bags *during* the race.

cartsman wrote:
Your analysis makes absolutely no sense. It also doesn't explain why nobody else on the Sky team appears to be a doped up donkey, since every time they try to win a GT without Froome they fail miserably.

They probably don't have either the mentality to go all out on doping or the mentality to be a team leader.

This is of course just speculation based on the many similarities with earlier cases of organised doping.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:


I don't think Lance had a single undoped Tour win in him.

I'm not saying he won any tours without doping but I think he could have won one with some luck, if everybody was clean.

devashish_paul wrote:
In any case is the ASO has the chance to have Froome at the start line "clean and off the hook" damn right they will have it since he is the holder of all the grand tour titles and 4x winner of the TdF. He will sell hits and eyeballs (as he just did at the Giro).

I agree

devashish_paul wrote:
I am not sure how you come up with the list of guys who would win without doping.
I have several friends who raced at that level and I have also watched even more TV coverage than you. The "donkeys" are spoken about as "freaks" and the real talents as "freaks of nature" (or similar wordings in different languages). The Danes speak differently about Riis and Rolf Sørensen for sure.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [fb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Another Great Giro! As for Froome I am pretty null on the subject, but I am impressed with the minute gained on the descent. Tommy D. is a classy rider and I am a fan. I hope he recovers for the TDF!

Big congrats to Ivar on the last day comeback to beat Trail in the Slowtwitch Velogames league.

Trail was in first place for almost the entire Giro and lost on the last day!

See everyone in the TDF league!
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [ChrisC42780] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
A random brain-dump.

Froome’s FTP is like 420ish isn’t it??
Every time the Velon power data flashed up as the Sky train (the Stem Cell perhaps we could call them!) set up his move he was doing 350. That’s not â€not-normal’ for a do or die mountain stage.

His attack up Finestre from there was 397w average... a Sweetspot interval!!

Then he had huge recovery on the descent- albeit a white knuckle one.

And then he would have had time gaps to the scruffy, disorganised chase group piped into his ear.

Combined with the attention to detail with the nutrition and the fact he was executing a preconceived plan whilst the others clutched at defensive straws means there really isn’t a fishy smell to any of this.

I do wonder how busy the myriad of Giro threads would have been without him there too...


On a slightly different topic (perhaps pertinent right now if your name is Coach Chad ;) ) but Froome runs double sided Stages no??
Do they account for his osymetric chainrings before they Ant+ to the Velon gadgetry?? Or is the data they (Velon or Froome!?!) use therefore flawed??

https://www.velon.cc/...-and-takes-race-lead
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [ChrisC42780] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ChrisC42780 wrote:
Big congrats to Ivar on the last day comeback to beat Trail in the Slowtwitch Velogames league.

Trail was in first place for almost the entire Giro and lost on the last day!

See everyone in the TDF league!
Dang, that was a tough league. Between Froome and Viviani, my team won six stages, the GC, and the points competition. Formolo squeaked in with a top 10 in the GC, and Woods and Gesink earned some useful points. But we finished at the bottom of the table. (Well, I did have Aru on the team.)

Thanks for keeping the ST league going. Here's hoping for a comeback at the Dauphine and TdSuisse before the TdF.

"Human existence is based upon two pillars: Compassion and knowledge. Compassion without knowledge is ineffective; Knowledge without compassion is inhuman." Victor Weisskopf.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [Crosshair] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Crosshair wrote:
A random brain-dump.

Froome’s FTP is like 420ish isn’t it??
Every time the Velon power data flashed up as the Sky train (the Stem Cell perhaps we could call them!) set up his move he was doing 350. That’s not â€not-normal’ for a do or die mountain stage.

His attack up Finestre from there was 397w average... a Sweetspot interval!!

Then he had huge recovery on the descent- albeit a white knuckle one.

And then he would have had time gaps to the scruffy, disorganised chase group piped into his ear.

Combined with the attention to detail with the nutrition and the fact he was executing a preconceived plan whilst the others clutched at defensive straws means there really isn’t a fishy smell to any of this.

I do wonder how busy the myriad of Giro threads would have been without him there too...

Well done for posting some sense. He made most of the time on the descents, and then had a more or less one to one TT battle with TD. The last climb they climbed more or less the same time. Sestriere Froome was a little quicker, but not a lot.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [bluefever] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
bluefever wrote:
Crosshair wrote:
A random brain-dump.

Froome’s FTP is like 420ish isn’t it??
Every time the Velon power data flashed up as the Sky train (the Stem Cell perhaps we could call them!) set up his move he was doing 350. That’s not â€not-normal’ for a do or die mountain stage.

His attack up Finestre from there was 397w average... a Sweetspot interval!!

Then he had huge recovery on the descent- albeit a white knuckle one.

And then he would have had time gaps to the scruffy, disorganised chase group piped into his ear.

Combined with the attention to detail with the nutrition and the fact he was executing a preconceived plan whilst the others clutched at defensive straws means there really isn’t a fishy smell to any of this.

I do wonder how busy the myriad of Giro threads would have been without him there too...


Well done for posting some sense. He made most of the time on the descents, and then had a more or less one to one TT battle with TD. The last climb they climbed more or less the same time. Sestriere Froome was a little quicker, but not a lot.

yes, if we trust that TD is clean (as seems to be the general feeling, as much as anyone trusts any pro athletes) then froome's performance was not vastly different.
the catch is that he had not previously been showing anything like the form to be able to do that. there was an article on cyclingnews the other day saying that you can't ride yourself into form during a grand tour, if the fitness isn't there you're not going to get it that way. i'm not sure that's quite the same thing - froome has the fitness base from 5 years of being the top GC man and a big pre-season. we know the principle form = fitness - fatigue. but we also know that performance can be poor if you taper too much, despite in principle having high fitness and low fatigue - you get rusty. that is where froome was at to start (deliberate strategy) so for 2 weeks he gained fitness (to some extent, though no rest means limited benefit despite the efforts) and fatigue, much like everyone else. the difference is that he started with lower fatigue than everyone else so by week 3 he'd shaken off the rust and his form = fitness - fatigue was in a better place than everyone else's. especially compared to yates who had great form in the first 2 weeks but then fatigue overcame him in week 3.

to be clear, i'm not saying froome is clean - i find his medical history concerning - just that i don't see his giro turnaround as being especially unbelievable in context and comparison to TD. incredible in the loose meaning, not the specific not credible.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [fb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
fb wrote:
That's the problem. When everybody was getting a 20% boost from EPO, the playing field was more or less level. If nobody doped, Pantani and Indurain would still win.

More or less, but not completely. There were almost certainly some guys who either would have been stars or at least "really good" who instead struggled to just keep a job. Or guys who chose not to become pros in the first place because they didn't want either to dope, or to be chumps trying to compete against dopers while clean.

Those are tragic figures. I could name some guys, but of course few would know their names.

The other tragic figures are the guys who are just amazing athletes, but get accused of doping because their performances are so extraordinarily that they have the characteristics of doped performance. It's very difficult to tell who these people are. Particularly if they're already sanctioned dopers.

Both types of people are victims of dopers.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [pk1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pk1 wrote:
bluefever wrote:
Crosshair wrote:
A random brain-dump.

Froome’s FTP is like 420ish isn’t it??
Every time the Velon power data flashed up as the Sky train (the Stem Cell perhaps we could call them!) set up his move he was doing 350. That’s not â€not-normal’ for a do or die mountain stage.

His attack up Finestre from there was 397w average... a Sweetspot interval!!

Then he had huge recovery on the descent- albeit a white knuckle one.

And then he would have had time gaps to the scruffy, disorganised chase group piped into his ear.

Combined with the attention to detail with the nutrition and the fact he was executing a preconceived plan whilst the others clutched at defensive straws means there really isn’t a fishy smell to any of this.

I do wonder how busy the myriad of Giro threads would have been without him there too...


Well done for posting some sense. He made most of the time on the descents, and then had a more or less one to one TT battle with TD. The last climb they climbed more or less the same time. Sestriere Froome was a little quicker, but not a lot.


yes, if we trust that TD is clean (as seems to be the general feeling, as much as anyone trusts any pro athletes) then froome's performance was not vastly different.
the catch is that he had not previously been showing anything like the form to be able to do that. there was an article on cyclingnews the other day saying that you can't ride yourself into form during a grand tour, if the fitness isn't there you're not going to get it that way. i'm not sure that's quite the same thing - froome has the fitness base from 5 years of being the top GC man and a big pre-season. we know the principle form = fitness - fatigue. but we also know that performance can be poor if you taper too much, despite in principle having high fitness and low fatigue - you get rusty. that is where froome was at to start (deliberate strategy) so for 2 weeks he gained fitness (to some extent, though no rest means limited benefit despite the efforts) and fatigue, much like everyone else. the difference is that he started with lower fatigue than everyone else so by week 3 he'd shaken off the rust and his form = fitness - fatigue was in a better place than everyone else's. especially compared to yates who had great form in the first 2 weeks but then fatigue overcame him in week 3.

to be clear, i'm not saying froome is clean - i find his medical history concerning - just that i don't see his giro turnaround as being especially unbelievable in context and comparison to TD. incredible in the loose meaning, not the specific not credible.

Cyclingnews is full of shit claiming that you cannot gain fitness during a grand tour. The more accurate statement is that you gain fatigue through a grand tour, but one can absolutely gain fitness off 4-7 hours of training per day. The problem is the fitness does not show because of the fatigue accumulation especially if the athlete poorly manages recovery. Sure, SKY may monkey around on the grey zone maximizing recovery approaches, but so do all the other teams (it's like not Sky grads like Landa, Nieve, Porte and others can't take the SKY recovery monkey business to other teams).

Once Froome (or anyone starts gaining fitness after starting in a lower state of fatigue due to being a bit undertrained, then his relative performance vs the field may appear to be better, while others gain fatigue and have already maximized fitness gains (you can't be at max fitness forever). So in addition to pacing out a grand tour so you can minimize fatigue there is gaining fitness.

One more thing....gaining fitness while losing weight simultaneously is a disaster in terms of feeling sharp in that when you are eating into body reserves daily, you just gain fatigue. If you already come in with body composition optimized, then on a daily basis after training you gain less fatigue because you're topping up to where you were, not topping up only to a smaller body that is shrinking over the race. I don't have a Froome weigh in before an after (does anyone) , but his body composition looked excellent before the Giro. Did Froome employ monkey business grey zone tactics to get to superior body composition before the Giro, while being on light training load? Well, that's another topic. But he showed up ripped and by all accounts under trained so that he can peak in late July with a small mini peak last week. It's not like he has been hiding what he was planning to do, it was known to everyone from day 1, except we were all counting him out after the 2x unplanned deck hitting stress loads. While is he was squirming around in pain, (and having to devote body resources to rebuild his body from those), we all figured that he had no chance until he threw the hail Mary on Finistre.

Having said all that, Sky planned his week three surge along with his teammates' form really well, or they are able to get week three blood bags when no one else can. It's all the realm of posibility, but I don't think the delta in his performances (and his teams') are glaringly blood bag worthy. My feeling is if he did, so did Dumoulin, and the rest of the chasers down Finistre.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [bluefever] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
bluefever wrote:
Crosshair wrote:
A random brain-dump.

Froome’s FTP is like 420ish isn’t it??
Every time the Velon power data flashed up as the Sky train (the Stem Cell perhaps we could call them!) set up his move he was doing 350. That’s not â€not-normal’ for a do or die mountain stage.

His attack up Finestre from there was 397w average... a Sweetspot interval!!

Then he had huge recovery on the descent- albeit a white knuckle one.

And then he would have had time gaps to the scruffy, disorganised chase group piped into his ear.

Combined with the attention to detail with the nutrition and the fact he was executing a preconceived plan whilst the others clutched at defensive straws means there really isn’t a fishy smell to any of this.

I do wonder how busy the myriad of Giro threads would have been without him there too...


Well done for posting some sense. He made most of the time on the descents, and then had a more or less one to one TT battle with TD. The last climb they climbed more or less the same time. Sestriere Froome was a little quicker, but not a lot.

Right...because bombing down a technical descent just takes some handling skills and balls. It doesn't require any additional effort, exertion, or fitness than someone riding with more caution and will be just as fresh at the bottom of the hill as the guy who descended 1 minute slower.

It's no wonder that all the top downhill mountain bikers, skiers, and snowboarders are 350 pound out of shape fat asses who simply use gravity to go faster while taking some risks. Makes sense...
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Making time uphill or downhill - no one would really care if Salbutamol Dog was simply Froome Dog (no pending AAF). The FACT that the AAF is swinging in the wind while SD performs some pretty unbelievable feats of strength at a grand tour that many thought he should skip (although it was totally legal for him to participate) while riding for a team with some ... ahem ... questionable ethics... Is it really so hard to connect the dots here? I'm not proposing anything one way or the other, just saying - without any ambiguity - that the circumstances bring the performance into question.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Really, since you have so much more experience riding GTs than Philippa York? Please, impart your wisdom here.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Really, since you have so much more experience riding GTs than Philippa York? Please, impart your wisdom here.

If you have nothing useful to add other than a shot about not riding Grand tours, at least amplify with what you want in term of wisdom...or just dont bother posting.. Its a stupid endurance sports forum that we are on. If the only people who can comment on here did grand tours, then we have no forum.

Neithere Philippa York does nor you have a monopoly on informed or uninformed opinion. It's a forum for cripes sake (and yes, its OK to simply take the diametrically opposite angle on anything I post just because its me who posted...its totally cool).

But, fans are supposed to be able to discussion without actually having ridden Grand Tours. Or go to another forum with your former grand tour riding poster friends and have a great discussion there.

You know no more or less about Grand tours than any other uninformed poster on this thread...even guys riding them don't even know the optimum approach (just ask some of the guys who have won them and what they know about their rivals who did not win). Pro athletes are not always the smartest guys and girls....they often have better genetics, but simply riding a grand tour, racing a diamond league 10,000, doing an ATP tennis grand slam, although on the surface making someone expert at them, does not mean they know everything all the time.

In any case, fans are entitled to opinions...that's why we have pro sports and sports fans. Fans are allowed any opinion they want on what the pros did. That's really what makes a sport a pro sport. If it is limited to only people who raced/competed, then the sport is no longer pro (ex Western States 100 or Ultraman Hawaii...largely no one cares).

Dev
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Actually I don’t talk to hear the sound, or contradict one comment in next sentence. Or proclaim that someone who rode a dozen? GTs is “full of shit.” Your commentary on the post about how triathlon is like a GT is fascinating and all, so true, I don’t really know anything about that.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Carl Spackler wrote:
Actually I don’t talk to hear the sound, or contradict one comment in next sentence. Or proclaim that someone who rode a dozen? GTs is “full of shit.” Your commentary on the post about how triathlon is like a GT is fascinating and all, so true, I don’t really know anything about that.


Hey, just cause Millar/York rode 18 Grand Tours does not mean that she can't be wrong about any given point especially racing today vs the 80's...that's like Terry Bradshaw mouthing off about Tom Brady (and he may or may not be right...the sports have changed a bit).

She wrote this:



Now, despite what anyone says, you don't ride yourself into form in a brutal three-week race. If you aren't in good shape at the start, the kicking you get each day adds up and you only become more and more tired. Add a fall – or in Froome’s case two falls – or injury of any kind and your recovery is highly compromised. Hence the comment from Contador that it was over for Sky's hopes. He saw the signs and understood the situation.


and she wrote this in cyclingnews:



''To bring in some context, we need to take a look at the race as a whole. Froome's Giro began with a fall in Jerusalem and was followed by iffy form and calls from ex-riders like Alberto Contador for the Team Sky leader to abandon ship and concentrate on the Tour de France. As a rider, when you hear such talk you know that things are dire. That’s because Contador raced with Froome, and he knows the signs, sees the grimaces, recognises the tormented hollow face we all saw after a few of the mountain finishes, and his conclusion was that the Giro was over for his former rival. We all thought Froome would take note. "


WTF? Now, York is an expert on physiology and the resident expert on whether someone can or cannot gain form over a 3 week period of racing and she's quoting Mr. Beef guy Contador as the expert (the same Contador that was done in the first few days of last year's Vuelta and rode himself back up to the win on Angliru and if Froome get's DQ'd a podium place on the Vuelta? Contador knows as much about Froome as Froome knows about Contador...whatever that is worth. Contador is probably bent out of joint that Froome emerged right after his beef suspension and he was unable to win after all that. So neither Contador, Millar (nor the badger for that matter) are that objective.

Sorry, but not accepting York's opinion (and that's all it is, she rode several grand tours and got some Giro podiums)....maybe sour grapes that she no longer has the highest Giro finishing position by a Brit (that would be second for her as Robert Millar). She may or may not have a clue on what form a rider may or may not gain, but her wide sweeping statement in bold and underline "now despite what anyone says". She is pulling out an opinion out of thin air with no scientific backing. Sure she rode Grand Tours in the 80's and its not like athletes were idiots then but that does not mean some approaches to training and recovery have not changed. Back then everyone rode every race

PS. that other thread discussion about an Ironman and a Grand tour most of you missed the logical connection in terms of analologies that the OP there made vs the physical comparison...obviously on the latter, they are entirely different and there is no physical comparison between the events.
Last edited by: devashish_paul: May 29, 18 22:11
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Did you see the post from The Secret Pro?

https://cyclingtips.com/...s-crazy-giro-attack/

Very good analysis.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I wasn't buying Philippa Yorke's post at all.

And I have just found it that it is really Robert Miller. (As in I didn't know who she was so had to google).

I used to like his blogs about racing but some of his recent stuff (mainly posted under 'Philippa York') seems very uninformed as to the nuances of modern day sports science and how to approach big races, particularly long multi day races. Which isn't unexpected given how long ago he was properly active in the sport.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [tuckandgo] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Guess you missed the bit where he transitioned from Mr Robert Millar to Ms Philippa York - https://www.bbc.com/sport/cycling/40529614

Trust me I’m a doctor!
Well, I have a PhD :-)
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [RandMart] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
RandMart wrote:
Shame Froomie doesn't have a badass nickname

Weezer
The Inhalorator
Mr. Stem

Don't have the same panache

Can I propose for consideration the nickname Stembuterol ?

Rich.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [PhilipShambrook] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
PhilipShambrook wrote:
Guess you missed the bit where he transitioned from Mr Robert Millar to Ms Philippa York - https://www.bbc.com/sport/cycling/40529614

No, I didn't miss that.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
fb wrote:

That's the problem. When everybody was getting a 20% boost from EPO, the playing field was more or less level. If nobody doped, Pantani and Indurain would still win.


More or less, but not completely. There were almost certainly some guys who either would have been stars or at least "really good" who instead struggled to just keep a job. Or guys who chose not to become pros in the first place because they didn't want either to dope, or to be chumps trying to compete against dopers while clean.

Those are tragic figures. I could name some guys, but of course few would know their names.

The other tragic figures are the guys who are just amazing athletes, but get accused of doping because their performances are so extraordinarily that they have the characteristics of doped performance. It's very difficult to tell who these people are. Particularly if they're already sanctioned dopers.

Both types of people are victims of dopers.

This is definitely true. David Moncutie comes to mind.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [tuckandgo] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
tuckandgo wrote:
I wasn't buying Philippa Yorke's post at all.

And I have just found it that it is really Robert Miller. (As in I didn't know who she was so had to google).

I used to like his blogs about racing but some of his recent stuff (mainly posted under 'Philippa York') seems very uninformed as to the nuances of modern day sports science and how to approach big races, particularly long multi day races. Which isn't unexpected given how long ago he was properly active in the sport.

Yeah, its like Bjorn Borg providing expert commentary on Roger Federer....the game has changed since wooden tennis rackets too. The old guys/women could temper what they say on what is possible or not in today's pro sport when they just pull their own experienced based opinion out of the air and apply it like it is universal truth. Robert Millar in his day had several near wins at the Vuelta and one near win at the Giro. Sure, he/she has credibiliity from that angle, but also the same writer can be viewed as havinig a non winner's bias ("if I could not win this way, no one can" etc). When there is a critical analysis (or a flat out throwing of anyone under the bus, I am going to look at the writer's personal biases on the story aside from what they objectively say or not.

Froome may just be on the same crap that Dumoulin, Pinot, Carapez and Lopez are/were on that day. Doping aside his execution on the last 80K was superior. All the tactics in terms of gear selection, style of riding, risk taking, pacing and fueling he did better than the other guys. It was completely well organized. He was on the offensive everyone was reacting, but they were not just reacting to one small attack....they were reacting to this long drawn out campaign that Sky had planned out. If there were blood bags involved, then the other chasers were on blood bags too, or they would have been off the back like Yates, Woods and many other strongmen.

The mistake that the other team may have made was never nailing the Sky coffin shut in the first half of the Giro when he was banged up. They left Froome dangling close enough to have hope starting weeks 3 on Zoncolan.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
tuckandgo wrote:
I wasn't buying Philippa Yorke's post at all.

And I have just found it that it is really Robert Miller. (As in I didn't know who she was so had to google).

I used to like his blogs about racing but some of his recent stuff (mainly posted under 'Philippa York') seems very uninformed as to the nuances of modern day sports science and how to approach big races, particularly long multi day races. Which isn't unexpected given how long ago he was properly active in the sport.


Yeah, its like Bjorn Borg providing expert commentary on Roger Federer....the game has changed since wooden tennis rackets too. The old guys/women could temper what they say on what is possible or not in today's pro sport when they just pull their own experienced based opinion out of the air and apply it like it is universal truth. Robert Millar in his day had several near wins at the Vuelta and one near win at the Giro. Sure, he/she has credibiliity from that angle, but also the same writer can be viewed as havinig a non winner's bias ("if I could not win this way, no one can" etc). When there is a critical analysis (or a flat out throwing of anyone under the bus, I am going to look at the writer's personal biases on the story aside from what they objectively say or not.

Froome may just be on the same crap that Dumoulin, Pinot, Carapez and Lopez are/were on that day. Doping aside his execution on the last 80K was superior. All the tactics in terms of gear selection, style of riding, risk taking, pacing and fueling he did better than the other guys. It was completely well organized. He was on the offensive everyone was reacting, but they were not just reacting to one small attack....they were reacting to this long drawn out campaign that Sky had planned out. If there were blood bags involved, then the other chasers were on blood bags too, or they would have been off the back like Yates, Woods and many other strongmen.

The mistake that the other team may have made was never nailing the Sky coffin shut in the first half of the Giro when he was banged up. They left Froome dangling close enough to have hope starting weeks 3 on Zoncolan.

So then you would agree that Yates did all the right things in the mountains the first 2 weeks by attacking often to gain time, and your suggestion of him possibly pacing the final TT 20-30 seconds slower to save his legs for the final climbs was total garbage? Because he basically tried to do exactly what you suggested in bold and unfortunately he came up short. In terms of Dumoulin, are you implying he should have taken the opportunity to go with Yates on some of those attacks (or Froome on the Zoncolon), but chose not to because he wasn't worried about Froome's position behind him, or Yate's position ahead of him?

All in all, the racing at this Giro has been fantastic. Guys put it on the line early and often and rarely did we see the top 5 GC guys ride to the line together on a stage that had the possibility of time gaps. Sometimes it's fun to play monday morning quarterback...but you're kind of all over the place.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
velon have belatedly released some power data from froome on stage 19. i haven't seen detail and there don't seem to be any direct comparisons let alone a full picture but general summary is that his power was similar to dumoulon's through the critical sections so the difference was benefit of being a bit lighter on the uphills and not waiting for slow FdJ riders on the downhill. both proven strong TT riders did about the same effort on the day. as cyclingnews commented, froome was planning on an 80Km TT so would have been fully prepped in terms of equipment, nutrition and mental composure for that whereas dumoulin may have lacked a few details.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I still think if Yates took the TT easier he would have been safer on week 3. His attacks early were only from shorter range at what appeared to be super high output...could he have dropped Froome earlier in climbs and built a bigger buffer at lower effort from further out vs just doing short range ballistic attacks for stage win bonus segments. Not sure, but when a rider is hurting it might be better to try early and see if he loses big time vs let him dangle around till later attacks. But maybe they could not do anything useful revving it up early because even a wounded Froome is hard to drop. That's the fun of following an event. It think if we were in a pub interactively discussing vs in text you would get the nuances of where I am coming from.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
I still think if Yates took the TT easier he would have been safer on week 3. His attacks early were only from shorter range at what appeared to be super high output...could he have dropped Froome earlier in climbs and built a bigger buffer at lower effort from further out vs just doing short range ballistic attacks for stage win bonus segments. Not sure, but when a rider is hurting it might be better to try early and see if he loses big time vs let him dangle around till later attacks. But maybe they could not do anything useful revving it up early because even a wounded Froome is hard to drop. That's the fun of following an event. It think if we were in a pub interactively discussing vs in text you would get the nuances of where I am coming from.

So you're suggesting Yates should have gone to the front early in climbs and just hammer out a hard tempo to drop the likes of Froome and Dumoulin...just ride them off his wheel to build up a bigger gap? Even if Yates could get a gap early with minimal effort, he'd be playing right into their hands by basically turning the mountains into a ITT...or worse an ITT for Yates and a TTT for the chasers behind him. And if he were able to build up a bigger gap that way, it's not like it comes at no cost.

Whatever the underlying circumstances, Froome killed it. He came in with a plan and it worked great despite the crash in the TT warmup and getting gapped on a couple of the uphill sprint finishes. Dumoulin I think stuck to his plan, and came up short. Yates came in with a plan, it worked extremely well for a while, then he crumbled. It is what it is. Your hindsight is 20/20 suggestions of how things could have been different are certainly creative...but are you even reading what you're writing?

And nobody in contention for the GC paces a TT thinking 2 days ahead. Nobody.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jason N wrote:
And nobody in contention for the GC paces a TT thinking 2 days ahead. Nobody.

Come on, dude's on a roll. Pass him another doobie....don't spoil the party.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This thread is solid gold! haha
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [Jason N] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jason N wrote:
devashish_paul wrote:
I still think if Yates took the TT easier he would have been safer on week 3. His attacks early were only from shorter range at what appeared to be super high output...could he have dropped Froome earlier in climbs and built a bigger buffer at lower effort from further out vs just doing short range ballistic attacks for stage win bonus segments. Not sure, but when a rider is hurting it might be better to try early and see if he loses big time vs let him dangle around till later attacks. But maybe they could not do anything useful revving it up early because even a wounded Froome is hard to drop. That's the fun of following an event. It think if we were in a pub interactively discussing vs in text you would get the nuances of where I am coming from.


So you're suggesting Yates should have gone to the front early in climbs and just hammer out a hard tempo to drop the likes of Froome and Dumoulin...just ride them off his wheel to build up a bigger gap? Even if Yates could get a gap early with minimal effort, he'd be playing right into their hands by basically turning the mountains into a ITT...or worse an ITT for Yates and a TTT for the chasers behind him. And if he were able to build up a bigger gap that way, it's not like it comes at no cost.

Whatever the underlying circumstances, Froome killed it. He came in with a plan and it worked great despite the crash in the TT warmup and getting gapped on a couple of the uphill sprint finishes. Dumoulin I think stuck to his plan, and came up short. Yates came in with a plan, it worked extremely well for a while, then he crumbled. It is what it is. Your hindsight is 20/20 suggestions of how things could have been different are certainly creative...but are you even reading what you're writing?

And nobody in contention for the GC paces a TT thinking 2 days ahead. Nobody.

i've read a quote from i think one of the MS DSs (Matt White?) basically saying that Yates destroyed himself in the TT and never recovered from that. the following stage was expected to be easy but turned into yet another giro smashfest so you could say that "sprinters stage" was where yates lost the giro. he took a calculated risk that he could push hard in the earlier mountains and TT and just didn't get the recovery he had banked on.

really, everyone did their race with their tactics and froome came out on top. dumoulin is on record saying he's happy with 2nd on a route that didn't play to his strengths (TT). froome and sky have proven they are masters of working out the right tactical approach to each goal they set. they've played it differently each time but always with the same result except for TdF 2014 when froome crashed which really is just bad luck. i wouldn't be surprised if froome wins the TdF this year, assuming he is allowed to race.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
At least we have something to keep entertained with until the Dauphiné gets going.

And I’ll say it again like I did before Giro: one of you bike guys needs to start the Offical TdF thread and not leave it to fate.
Last edited by: Carl Spackler: May 30, 18 21:49
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [Carl Spackler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
PSA the Velogames Dauphine fantasy game is open.

https://www.velogames.com/criterium-du-dauphine/2018/entryform.php#

"Human existence is based upon two pillars: Compassion and knowledge. Compassion without knowledge is ineffective; Knowledge without compassion is inhuman." Victor Weisskopf.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [pk1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It sounds like Froome will be on the start line for the TdF and they won't get all the legal stuff cleaned up. Hinault will whine the entire time in the mean time about Froome not being among the greats. Not like the greats did not have their positive tests (although I don't recall Hinault having one, but Merckx did and Indurain, well, that's just all high octane dope). So with Hinault's double standard definition, anyone racing after 1995 can't be in the group of great racers. He could not handle Lemond on the same team so at least he is consistent.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [pk1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Unless the uci and aso have pockets deep enough to go toe to toe with sky he will start
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hinault is a hypocrite and an old curmudgeon. His doctor believed in restoring what was suppressed during training and racing and was receiving injections. Not that he was being boosted beyond natural levels, but the doctor even talked about using testosterone because the cyclists levels were so suppressed.

I don't begrudge any of these people for what happened during each era. I can't imagine the pressure of knowing you likely won't have a job if you aren't keeping a level playing field with others. It is what it is. I also certainly don't condone doping now or in the future. I wish we could get a level AND clean playing field. That is likely wishful thinking though.
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [turdburgler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
turdburgler wrote:
Hinault is a hypocrite and an old curmudgeon. His doctor believed in restoring what was suppressed during training and racing and was receiving injections. Not that he was being boosted beyond natural levels, but the doctor even talked about using testosterone because the cyclists levels were so suppressed.

I don't begrudge any of these people for what happened during each era. I can't imagine the pressure of knowing you likely won't have a job if you aren't keeping a level playing field with others. It is what it is. I also certainly don't condone doping now or in the future. I wish we could get a level AND clean playing field. That is likely wishful thinking though.

Agree 1000 percent. This is the same across all pro sport. Players are put inside a box and they try to maximize unless everything is tightly enforced. Minimally they all try to get level with the other guy. In the process they also try to out fox the other guys and the enforcers. Almost like drivers speeding. Even when there is no testing like on the autobahn, the athletes/drivers still tend to converge on some norms
Quote Reply
Re: 2018 Giro D’Italia [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
Agree 1000 percent. This is the same across all pro sport. Players are put inside a box and they try to maximize unless everything is tightly enforced. Minimally they all try to get level with the other guy. In the process they also try to out fox the other guys and the enforcers. Almost like drivers speeding. Even when there is no testing like on the autobahn, the athletes/drivers still tend to converge on some norms

To continue your analogies:

1. Sometimes you have teams or nations who manage to buy their own, bigger, box.

2. I don´t know if you have driven on Euro motorways but there are of course people who break the norm and do stuff like try to pass on the shoulder or cut people off. In Italy this is silently accepted whereas in Germany, other motorists make it clear that this behaviour is not accepted.
Quote Reply