ajthomas wrote:
There is a principle that deserves a name. The principle is this: You cannot judge the performance of the super elite based on their place. Torenzo "won" a 70.3 the week after an IM so he must be juicing...KL beat Simone in a 200 free after a 400 IM so she can swim her best with no rest. Wrong and Wrong. The super elite still win under less than ideal conditions because...they are better than everyone else. Not because they are unaffected or cheating.
In order for KL to have her VERY BEST 100 free she cannot go all out in a 1650 2 hours before. This is 100% a fact even if she goes a 46.9 on the relay after smashing the 1650 in 14:55.
To your point, and Monty’s, and others...I am not missing your point, I just don’t entirely agree with it. Here is my view, Ledecky is obviously an elite athlete, and as such has physiological characteristics different than 99.999% of the population. This applies not only to her “speed”, but also to her resistance to fatigue. There is a reason why nobody else in the world, now or in the past, has been able to hold such a consistent stroke count and cadence for the entire swim, no matter how long the event. The reality for Ladecky is that a 15 min full effort swim does not fatigue her to the same extent that it would you or I (or any other current elite swimmer). So in considering her, you cannot use the standard “template”, you have to judge by past performances. Could she have swam a faster 200 Free at conference finals if she had not done the 400 IM? Maybe, but also maybe not- she could have very well swam slower. It was, after all, her best 200 scy swim of the season, and by a very similar margin to her time improvements in her other events. In regard to Monty’s reference to a “bad” relay swim- yes she had a bad swim. It happens. Bad swims happen to all swimmers, even the best, even when rested. She could have been tired, or, perhaps she was right in her statement that she got too excited and over swam it?? Here is a fact- there are very few facts when it comes to human performance! Anyone who has competed for any length of time has experienced unexplained great days or performances, and unexplained bad days. That is what makes it fun!
We will all find out soon enough.