You can't compare the two but if you try the Vaporfly win hands down.

Two things about reviews in a mag: Who is advertising/sponsoring the mag and reviews are opinions not fact. There is so much "drama" over the Nike now there is real research on them and its clear that....currently.....the Nike is the best.

However if your foot doesn't fit in them this entire thing is moot and Nike and Hoka fit completely different. My experience/opinion with the Nike is that my legs and feet were markedly less beat up at the end of the race than with any other shoe. I have a narrow foot so the Nike worked fit wise. The toe box on the Hoka is large and my feet raddled around in them.