Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots
Quote | Reply
Yuk! Seeing it on film made me wanna barf. Particular drills, mantras, thoughts that will help me break that nasty overgliding? I was part of that ugly generation of old fart tri geeks who were brought up on distance per stroke being the singular focus.

Obviously my goal is to keep that front hand moving all the time, but I have quite a bit of bad juju muscle memory and timing built in that we have to reprogram!
Last edited by: tigerpaws: May 19, 11 5:27
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [tigerpaws] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
wetronome
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [tigerpaws] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yeah, a water metronone (I use the Finis) and this:

http://www.swimsmooth.com/slowsr.html

Good luck...I'm having my own swimming issues right now :-(
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [tigerpaws] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sorry but a metronome sounds like a typical triathlete answer, i.e. a gadget is the answer.

Hard to say without a video but try this:
Out front, enter your hand/forearm earlier and steeper which will make it easier to grab an earlier catch.
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [schroeder] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
schroeder wrote:
Sorry but a metronome sounds like a typical triathlete answer, i.e. a gadget is the answer.

Hard to say without a video but try this:
Out front, enter your hand/forearm earlier and steeper which will make it easier to grab an earlier catch.

Thank you....that's why I said drills, thoughts or mantras. The metronome may very well work, but swim coaches were correcting overgliding long before the metronome and I'm not a gadget geek. Too bad I had one of the coaches who latched on to gliding!
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [tigerpaws] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm not a great swimmer but I definitely get lazy and glide sometimes. The mental key for me is "always be pulling" kindof a spin-off in my head of Glengarry Glen Ross.

Faster turnover, always be pulling and voila no more gliding.

Good luck.
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [masterslacker] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
masterslacker wrote:
I'm not a great swimmer but I definitely get lazy and glide sometimes. The mental key for me is "always be pulling" kindof a spin-off in my head of Glengarry Glen Ross.

Faster turnover, always be pulling and voila no more gliding.

Good luck.

Yea I have tried simply increasing my stroke rate, but I start slipping and my stroke falls apart with a lame catch. I need to slow this mo fo down and get myself to a point where I'm propelling myself 100% of the time and then crank up the volume. Or at least that's the way it makes sense to me....wish I had a real swim coach dangit!
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [tigerpaws] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Well then...Look up the Dave Scott videos, or Evanscoaching videos on youtube. They have some "quick catch" drills. I am still trying to correct that freakin glide crap from years ago while using total immersion techniques.
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [tigerpaws] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
As soon as you hand enter the water think finger tips down.

-Of course it's 'effing hard, it's IRONMAN!
Team ZOOT
ZOOT, QR, Garmin, HED Wheels, Zealios, FormSwim, Precision Hydration, Rudy Project
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [schroeder] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
schroeder wrote:
Sorry but a metronome sounds like a typical triathlete answer, i.e. a gadget is the answer.

And the wetronome is a device that a swim coach thought up becasue he/she was tired of standing on deck with a stroke rate watch only able to focus on one swimmer at a time.

schroeder wrote:
Hard to say without a video but try this:
Out front, enter your hand/forearm earlier and steeper which will make it easier to grab an earlier catch.

Not this.
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [tigerpaws] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Head-up freestyle. This pretty much forces you to pop the hand in the water and get grabbin. It also, in my opinion, helps to develop a high elbow, prevents over-rotation, and possibly cures acne and chronic halitosis.

If you are real bad-ass, you will do it with a dolphin kick. This will make you post up on the "cry like a little biatch" thread, but also does wonders for eliminating the dead spots, forcing proper timing, and preventing over-rotation.

regards,
r.b.

Bringing you Tweets @ http://twitter.com/findfreestyle and Not just a bunch of drills - A Process.
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [tigerpaws] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
tigerpaws wrote:
masterslacker wrote:
I'm not a great swimmer but I definitely get lazy and glide sometimes. The mental key for me is "always be pulling" kindof a spin-off in my head of Glengarry Glen Ross.

Faster turnover, always be pulling and voila no more gliding.

Good luck.


Yea I have tried simply increasing my stroke rate, but I start slipping and my stroke falls apart with a lame catch. I need to slow this mo fo down and get myself to a point where I'm propelling myself 100% of the time and then crank up the volume. Or at least that's the way it makes sense to me....wish I had a real swim coach dangit!

That is why a wetronome is the perfect tool for you. You have no coach on deck and we the internet don't really have all the facts about your stroke. Stoke rate is not just about "increase/decrease", it's about the rate that you and your personal stroke are best at. Using a wetronome to do a proper stroke rate test set will give you a guide to exactly what stoke rate is best. Once you have that, you can set up the workouts around being able to hold that stroke rate for longer sets or less rest or faster speed etc.

This is all assuming that "overgliging" is your one and only issue (most likely its not) but based on what we have from this thread, the wetronome used properly is going to be your best option IMO as a swim coach.
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [tigerpaws] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Boy, this sounds familiar. A bit of TI in your past? Catch-up drills? If you spent a lot of time building the "glide" (stall) into your stroke, it will take a long time undoing it. Somewhere I read about a "kayaking" drill where you think of your arms like a kayak paddle. I will be eagerly awaiting the swim coaches responses.

Edited to add: You might also try the band around your ankles. If you don't keep pulling your legs tend to sink.
Last edited by: Rambler: May 19, 11 7:22
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [tigerpaws] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I think some of the comments are slightly off-base.

Stroke timing and stroke rate are different things that are tangentially related.

You mention "over"gliding. Gliding has almost nothing to do with when you make your catch, it has everything to do with your recovery.

When you say gliding I immediately think of a person who finishes a stroke and then glides with one arm in front and one arm behind, neither arm moving. So you have a hesitation, between the end of your stroke and the beginning of your recovery.

Or the beginning of your recovery is VERY slow.

THIS is what needs to be fixed if you are gliding. Your catch isn't the part that needs fixing. You can exhibit a glide no matter when you make your catch. You can swim catch up style with a glide, you can swim catch up without a glide, your hand comes out and immediately start s a brisk recovery - yet you can still swim catch up style.

You can swim windmill style with a glide as well. your arms can be in complete opposition and your hand pauses between the end of your pull and recovery. The stroke timing, or catch timing and gliding are not the same thing.

The fix, a beeper will help. The one from finis works fine and is available at just about every swim shop online.

But the main fix is with you, you need to swim and concentrate that after your finish your pull you immediately begin your recovery. No pause there at all.

For me, like every other small technique fix like this. I like to have people start with 25s, then once they can concentrate on one thing for 25, move to 50s, then 100s, 200s and 400s concentrating on that one thing.

But that is the thing, work on removing the delay between the end of your stroke and the beginning of your recovery.
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [tigerpaws] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
One of my drills is an exaggerated push as the hand passes the torso and the hip. This forces the hand to come out of the water faster so that my other arm will move a bit quicker to keep the stroke rhythm going.
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [Kevin in MD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Kevin in MD wrote:
But the main fix is with you, you need to swim and concentrate that after your finish your pull you immediately begin your recovery. No pause there at all.


But that is the thing, work on removing the delay between the end of your stroke and the beginning of your recovery.

That's it! The more I think about it this is my guilty area....lingering around the back end and not getting that are back up front and put to work! Thanks.
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [tigerpaws] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I've done quite a bit of reading on this as of late...Seems the consensus is that once the lead hand enters the water it should never stop moving...Point fingers toward bottom of pull, grab/catch water, pull, etc. So, you have to get the timing down so the recovering hand gets into proper position as all of this is going on.

Plus, seems the new consensus is that the pulling hand doesn't really need to pull much further back than the beltline as there is not much propulsion advantage past that. Making too long of a pull could be leaving your forwar hand hanging, waiting for the recovering hand to catch up.

I stand by my recommendation to view the Dave Scott and Evans Coaching videos on Youtube.

As a side not, after years and years of never getting past 1:35/100, I'm having a priviate session with a well known local coach this weekend. It's kinda like playing guitar...Practice doesn't make perfect, perfect practice makes perfect. I'm not upping any yardage till I get my errors on their way to be corrected. There's too low of a return on investment otherwise.
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [vibrolux] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
vibrolux wrote:
As a side not, after years and years of never getting past 1:35/100, I'm having a priviate session with a well known local coach this weekend. It's kinda like playing guitar...Practice doesn't make perfect, perfect practice makes perfect. I'm not upping any yardage till I get my errors on their way to be corrected. There's too low of a return on investment otherwise.

And, you will probably find that if you correct any flaws, you will go faster on the same yardage because you have increased the efficacy of the stroke. Someone mentioned the kayak, it would be as if you were going 1:35 only using 2/3 of the paddle blade. If you use all the blade, you'll go faster for the same effort.

John



Top notch coaching: Francois and Accelerate3 | Follow on Twitter: LifetimeAthlete |
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [Devlin] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That's what I'm hoping for anyway. Thanks.
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [vibrolux] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
vibrolux wrote:
I've done quite a bit of reading on this as of late...Seems the consensus is that once the lead hand enters the water it should never stop moving...

Assuming your hand enters the water far enough in front of you to be effective. Entering just in front of your shoulder and starting your pull immediately is not good.

Good luck with your private lesson.

----------------------------------
"Go yell at an M&M"
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [klehner] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
A good drill to "speed up" the arms is to put on your fins and do some 25yd sprints. The fins will really increase your speed and will force a self-correction of the dead spots in your stroke. Swim some normal 50's after a set of 10 25's with fins. You should notice a difference in your stroke. Repeat this process over a few weeks, and it should start to become more natural to you.
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [schroeder] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Amazing post!

But please, - don't bring reason into the tri-athlete's fetish to use technology to avoid actually doing hard work.

And please, don't ever mention spending time in the weight room. That will really rile things up.
Quote Reply
Re: Swim coaches: Breaking the timing of overgliding and dead spots [tigerpaws] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Best answers have probably already come, but one of the keys for improving my stroke rate was improving my kick. Not necessarily my kick rate, but my kick/stroke timing. Once I had that settled, I found it easier to increase my stroke rate as my kick sped up.
Quote Reply