milkman1982 wrote:
Does anyone have experience with Swagman's bike racks? I am looking at a platform rack, specifically the Semi 2.0. I realize Thule and others are the standard in the industry, but I would be curious to know how this compares. On Amazon it looks to be about $75 cheaper than the Thule T2 Classic for example, which is a premium I am more than willing to pay if the Thule truly is a better product. To me quality = doesn't fall apart and doesn't damage bikes over a long trip.
I have had a Swagman XTC-4 for about 3 years. I picked it up a at great price on Amazon. It has served my needs perfectly. A few things: there are some minor "fit and finish" things that I think are sort of cheaply made. For instance, the cable that holds one of the pins quickly broke. I was able to tie it on with no further problems. A few of the edges quickly showed a bit of minor surface rust, although it's only noticeable if you examine closely and there is no durability concerns whatsoever. The push-button for adjusting the arms will sometimes stick. I try to keep it lubed and usually carry a wrench or small hammer with me anyway (with my bike tools) to knock it loose if it jams. This doesn't happen often but I can happen). I've used it primarily to haul two tri bikes, but I have loaded it with 4 mountain bikes and have transported them across the country several times. It holds the bikes very securely and I have no concerns about the bikes touching, wobbling, falling off, etc. When I travel with my nice bikes I'll use a rag or something to put under the arm (under the existing padding) just to add a little extra protection.
At no point have I ever wished I spent more money and bought a different bike rack.