I have a 2011 Specialized Transition. Specs online say it has a threaded BB. Currently it has a SRAM GXP crankset on it. If I were to buy a crank based power meter, am I correct in saying I am limited to a GXP meter or is there compliance with BB30? Any benefits/drawbacks if I could use either? Thanks, not a bike pro but wanting a PM but would like to get one that works on the damn bike.
Triathlon Forum
Login required to started new threads
Login required to post replies
Re: GXP vs. BB30 - Power Meter Question [ilikepizza]
[ In reply to ]
GXP only on that one. If it were BB30, you could use either a BB30 or GXP crank based power meter.
Re: GXP vs. BB30 - Power Meter Question [ilikepizza]
[ In reply to ]
Re: GXP vs. BB30 - Power Meter Question [ilikepizza]
[ In reply to ]
Got it, I think. So since its a threaded BB I can use:
1. GXP
2. get an adapter like the BSA and then be able to use BB30
I assume from a future proofing standpoint this doesn't matter. If I bought a new bike with either standard I'd be able to use an adapter if necessary to keep using whatever meter I had, yeah? Thanks for the info, this is what I was looking for to prevent a costly mistake.
1. GXP
2. get an adapter like the BSA and then be able to use BB30
I assume from a future proofing standpoint this doesn't matter. If I bought a new bike with either standard I'd be able to use an adapter if necessary to keep using whatever meter I had, yeah? Thanks for the info, this is what I was looking for to prevent a costly mistake.
Re: GXP vs. BB30 - Power Meter Question [ilikepizza]
[ In reply to ]
You can put in a bottom bracket that will be compatible with a BB30 Rotor crank. I don't think any other BB30 crank would work. The Rotor cranks have a longer spindle which makes it possible.
This is the bottom bracket I used to try a BB30 (Rotor 3d+) on an old frame with a threaded BB. It allows me to 'borrow' the Power2Max from my tri bike occasionally.
The tool to put it in is different that nearly every other BB tool out there.
(edit: Looks like the same response came up above while digging for links)
This is the bottom bracket I used to try a BB30 (Rotor 3d+) on an old frame with a threaded BB. It allows me to 'borrow' the Power2Max from my tri bike occasionally.
The tool to put it in is different that nearly every other BB tool out there.
(edit: Looks like the same response came up above while digging for links)
Re: GXP vs. BB30 - Power Meter Question [dangle]
[ In reply to ]
thanks again all for the responses. I feel like black friday just got a lot more interesting.
Re: GXP vs. BB30 - Power Meter Question [ilikepizza]
[ In reply to ]
Call Amanda at Rotor USA
Re: GXP vs. BB30 - Power Meter Question [dangle]
[ In reply to ]
Do those adapters really work correctly? From what I have read while you can get the crank to fit, the ball bearing race won't align correctly in all situations (it might with a Rotor or BBright crank which are longer than a standard BB30 crank).
Re: GXP vs. BB30 - Power Meter Question [mcmetal]
[ In reply to ]
mcmetal wrote:
Do those adapters really work correctly? From what I have read while you can get the crank to fit, the ball bearing race won't align correctly in all situations (it might with a Rotor or BBright crank which are longer than a standard BB30 crank).I have no experience with this bottom bracket outside of 30mm Rotor cranks.
Any BB386EVO crank should fit. Any Rotor 3D+ or 3D30 should work as their spindles are long enough to fit. True BB30 is more narrow (at the bearings) than BSA/threaded, so a true BB30 crank would not fit into a BSA/threaded bottom bracket.
There are some BBRight specific Rotor cranks out there. Basically any recent 'takeoff' from a Cervelo is going to be a BBRight. Even though they say "the spider" is the difference, the only difference is that the lockring holding the spider on is 15-16mm instead of ~4-5mm. That can be replaced easily so it would fit into a BSA application.
BBRight spider lockring
Normal lockring.
The same tool removes them both.
Re: GXP vs. BB30 - Power Meter Question [ilikepizza]
[ In reply to ]
ilikepizza wrote:
thanks again all for the responses. I feel like black friday just got a lot more interesting.I have the same bike (2012 SRAM version) and just installed a Riken AL. The BB30 version is $30 more (at retail) then the GXP. No reason to convert.
"...the street finds its own uses for things"
Re: GXP vs. BB30 - Power Meter Question [dangle]
[ In reply to ]
dangle wrote:
I have no experience with this bottom bracket outside of 30mm Rotor cranks. Any BB386EVO crank should fit. Any Rotor 3D+ or 3D30 should work as their spindles are long enough to fit. True BB30 is more narrow (at the bearings) than BSA/threaded, so a true BB30 crank would not fit into a BSA/threaded bottom bracket.
There are some BBRight specific Rotor cranks out there. Basically any recent 'takeoff' from a Cervelo is going to be a BBRight. Even though they say "the spider" is the difference, the only difference is that the lockring holding the spider on is 15-16mm instead of ~4-5mm. That can be replaced easily so it would fit into a BSA application.
Thanks, appreciate the additional details.
Re: GXP vs. BB30 - Power Meter Question [ilikepizza]
[ In reply to ]
I haven't seen this mentioned yet but you can also put in a shimano bb and use shimano/fsa verisons of whatever powermeter you're looking at.
There will ALWAYS be an adapter to convert bb30/pf92... ...etc to a threaded bb. just something to keep in mind.
There will ALWAYS be an adapter to convert bb30/pf92... ...etc to a threaded bb. just something to keep in mind.
Re: GXP vs. BB30 - Power Meter Question [ilikepizza]
[ In reply to ]
Food for thought, the Powertap P1 pedals. I'm just finishing up a review article on them and they are quite impressive, especially in your case for install, and if you upgrade your bike.
Generally speaking, if it's BB30, you can only use it on BB30. GXP will work on both. You just need the Wheels MFG adaptor that retail for $30 to take up the space on a BB30 frame. I honestly think BB30 cranks really limit you. I would NEVER get a crank based power meter that was BB30. Really limits you to only those frames with BB30.