Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned
Quote | Reply
After 30+ triathlons I experienced my first major bike crash last week at the Boise 70.3. It was not a good outcome...seven broken ribs, broken scapula, broken collar bone, one cracked vertebrae. My only goal here is to hopefully keep somebody else from making the same mistakes as me. Sure, the additional days spent in the Boise hospital unexpectedly extended my vacation, but I'm quite sure there would have been better uses of that time off.

I essentially got thrown after hitting a storm water drainage channel that was built into the road. Picture an inverse speed bump...a short but somewhat severe dip designed to channel water all the way across the road in one place during a torrential downpour that desert areas often get. I really can't blame my crash on the race organizers. We were warned about the dip in the pre-race briefing. Maybe the hazard could have been better marked, but I'm not aware of any other racers crashing there, so I think that's a pretty clear indication of a mistake on my part rather than something they failed to do.

So here were my key mistakes:

1) It was around mile 52 and I was getting tired...I was riding too much in a "head down" versus head up position. I would consistently look up to check position, look for other riders, hazards, etc. but late in the bike ride I'm sure I was spending too much time looking down versus looking ahead. As a result, I was essentially looking down at my front tire on a flat, straight section of road when I got to the hazard.

2) I was trying to stay loose so I wasn't really gripping my aero bars. Combine that with the head down position and I didn't see the dip until I hit it. The impact wrenched my wheel out of my hands to the side and I was airborne.

3) I was thinking about the run. With four miles to go, that's where my mind was versus finishing the bike ride. So, my concentration on the task at hand was probably diminished. Never stop thinking about the bike until it's parked.

In retrospect, there were a few scary downhills on the Boise course thanks to a nasty cross wind. When I see what a crash at 23 did to me it's quite frightening to think what could have happened at 40+.

The key takeaway is any amount of time lost by putting safety first, riding the brakes a little more is ultimately irrelevant. Based on my swim time and bike computer up to the crash with a decent run I was well positioned for a top 5 AG finish and a decent shot at top 3. Big fucking deal. If placing is that important then I better suck it up on the swim and run because the payoff for taking any risks on the bike just aren't worth it.

I think the other key lesson for me is in the future I will be more selective in which triathlons I enter. This IS NOT a knock on Boise as my experience was the race was very well run, well controlled on the bike course and stocked with plenty of volunteers....including the off duty EMT's that were there for me immediately after my crash. I'm really speaking about many of the local and regional tri's I've done over the years. The risks are simply too high to enter any race which can't afford solid traffic control, broad lanes for cyclists with plenty of volunteers. And there are a lot of races out there that fail this test.

End of rant. Stay safe. The alternative sucks.
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm sorry to hear about your accident. I wish you a speedy recovery. Thanks for the great advice about keeping focus on what you are doing. It's easy to look ahead, but can be dangerous. The paved drainage swale across the road is a real mess. That just doesn't mix with triathlon. Hopefully, race organizers will give some thought to the hazard and perhaps make course adjustments in the future for other competitors. I can't even imagine barreling down the road with your head down and then the next thing you know you're airborne!
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sorry to hear it and hope you're well on your way to recovering.

I think the head down position is the major issue. One just doesn't have enough time to react. In a recent TT, one of the strongest riders in the field ran into the person in front of him. Yep, he was head down and burying it for the line with less than a mile to go.

At 30mph, we're covering 44ft/sec. If you need 1/2 second to react, you need to be able to see 22ft in front of you. Not only to drivers underestimate how fast we're moving, we do to.

Hope you heal fully and fast.
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [FatandSlow] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Agreed... Hopeful for a speedy recovery but I'm not sure how/why anyone spends a significant amount of time head down on any roads in the US. The quality of roads here are bad, especially in a place like Boise. Good lesson though to stay aware and focused on the moment for everyone though.

Again best wishes on a speedy recovery.
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Any tips on how to deal with a incoming dip if you can't dodge it (say it goes all the way across the road)? In my roadie I would bunny hop the front tire. Not sure what I would do in TT position.
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [FatandSlow] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
FatandSlow wrote:
Sorry to hear it and hope you're well on your way to recovering.

I think the head down position is the major issue. One just doesn't have enough time to react. In a recent TT, one of the strongest riders in the field ran into the person in front of him. Yep, he was head down and burying it for the line with less than a mile to go.

At 30mph, we're covering 44ft/sec. If you need 1/2 second to react, you need to be able to see 22ft in front of you. Not only to drivers underestimate how fast we're moving, we do to.

Hope you heal fully and fast.

Whoa... that's pretty interesting... I too am guilty of relaxing my hands / looking a little too close to the front wheel. Gonna have to remember this story...

Get well soon man!

-Alex

Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm sorry to hear about your accident. Get well soon! Good to hear that the EMT's were on you quickly! Suspect that even if you saw that in advance it would have been hard to control. Hopefully next year they mark it somehow. I 2nd the statement that Boise is a well run race.

jsm

Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [PeteDin206] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
PeteDin206 wrote:
Agreed... Hopeful for a speedy recovery but I'm not sure how/why anyone spends a significant amount of time head down on any roads in the US. The quality of roads here are bad, especially in a place like Boise. Good lesson though to stay aware and focused on the moment for everyone though.

Again best wishes on a speedy recovery.

Pete-agreed. In my case I blame it on a bad neck and age. When I first got into triathlon my neck would absolutely ache after about an hour in aero. I went to see a neck specialist and after Xrays was surprised to learn I have two congenital fused neck vertebrae. They couldn't tell me if this was something I was born with or a result of some childhood accident, but it's there nonetheless and makes the upward tilted head in aero much more fatiguing to maining. With training time and flexibility work I'm better now at mostly riding head up. But us 50+ guys aren't that flexible anyway.

Those are just my excuses. I know from being in enough races I see lots and lots of people riding aero heads down just like me and it's an accident waiting to happen.

PS--I had no issues with the quality of the race course in Boise. It was mostly pavement really very little chip seal. Fortunately for me I crashed on very smooth asphalt so my road rash was minimal. But your point about road quality in general is spot on...especially when out riding alone on a long training ride.
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
lutzman wrote:
...seven broken ribs, broken scapula, broken collar bone, one cracked vertebrae.

Wow. Best of luck on a speedy and complete recovery.
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
lutzman wrote:
PeteDin206 wrote:
Agreed... Hopeful for a speedy recovery but I'm not sure how/why anyone spends a significant amount of time head down on any roads in the US. The quality of roads here are bad, especially in a place like Boise. Good lesson though to stay aware and focused on the moment for everyone though.

Again best wishes on a speedy recovery.


Pete-agreed. In my case I blame it on a bad neck and age. When I first got into triathlon my neck would absolutely ache after about an hour in aero. I went to see a neck specialist and after Xrays was surprised to learn I have two congenital fused neck vertebrae. They couldn't tell me if this was something I was born with or a result of some childhood accident, but it's there nonetheless and makes the upward tilted head in aero much more fatiguing to maining. With training time and flexibility work I'm better now at mostly riding head up. But us 50+ guys aren't that flexible anyway.

Those are just my excuses. I know from being in enough races I see lots and lots of people riding aero heads down just like me and it's an accident waiting to happen.

PS--I had no issues with the quality of the race course in Boise. It was mostly pavement really very little chip seal. Fortunately for me I crashed on very smooth asphalt so my road rash was minimal. But your point about road quality in general is spot on...especially when out riding alone on a long training ride.

Fully understand the neck issues. Definitely not a direct critique toward you. Just something that people should really focus on improving. I'm guilty of it as well and I'm only 35.
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Blah, blah, blah, blah...how is the bike? ;)


Hope you heal soon!!

--------------------------------------------------------
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [TunaBoo] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Not sure what I would do in TT position.

At the risk of stating the obvious . . . you would get out of the TT position sit up slightly and go through the dip, or any sort of rough section of road, riding on the bull-horn extensions, with access to the brakes in case you need to modulate speed and finer control of steering in case you need to change direction slightly. This would have also shifted the weight slightly to the rear of the bike, and stabilized your whole position. Had the OP done that, with all due respect, this thread would not exist!

To the OP - sorry to hear about your crash. Key thing you said was, the bike is not over until it's over. Up until that point you need to remain vigilant and aware of what's going on all around you. To be in the race, you need to get to the bike rack and then get out on that run. A triathlon bike leg is not an ITT - although it has the feel of that, and much of the same equipment is used. You are riding on open roads, with road hazards such as water channels like this, racing head-to-head with your fellow competitors out on the course. Ride heads up and aware at all times.


Steve Fleck @stevefleck | Blog
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Great thoughts, get well soon.

It is not about who have the fastest split, it is who gets to the finish line first, and can train the next day.

.

Dave Campbell | Facebook | @DaveECampbell | h2ofun@h2ofun.net

Boom Nutrition code 19F4Y3 $5 off 24 pack box | Bionic Runner | PowerCranks | Velotron | Spruzzamist

Lions don't lose sleep worrying about the sheep
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [bhc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
bhc wrote:
Blah, blah, blah, blah...how is the bike? ;)


Hope you heal soon!!

This!
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Man, I really am sorry to hear about your crash! I must have come in a few minutes behind you, as I saw all the commotion and it looked pretty bad. I could relate to how you were feeling at that point, because we were only a few miles from the end, it was flat, and seemed like a good opportunity to pick up some time, but I was still tired. Your crash made me think twice about making a pass on a couple of racers ahead of me. I think that neighborhood section of the course was one of the sketchiest parts, not only with the frequent dips and manholes, but also with the endless cul de sacs and traffic control situations (my one accident in a race came as a result of a driver who misread a traffic instruction, which spooked me, and I faceplanted). Best wishes on a speedy recovery, and thanks for posting your thoughts. It's very helpful to keep in mind.
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The head down thing got me two years ago on a training ride. Thought I had the mental picture of the road ahead on my last glance but apparently not. On the ground before I know it. Broken collar bone. Could have been much worse as I ended up on the wrong side of the white line. I don't think I'm the only one who is guilt of trying to save seconds in risky situations. Unfortunately the bike is my strongest discipline so making it up elsewhere is tough.
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Good for you to take responsibility for your actions and warn others.

Heal quickly.

I'm just this guy ya know?
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [Fleck] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hope you get better fast, Wow, I saw you lying there and was wondering how you crashed there. The cross winds were quite a bit worse than the dips. I must admit the dip not seem that bad, but seeing an ambulance and athlete on the ground I get out of the aero bars.
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sorry to hear about that crash and your injuries that sucks!! Hope you heal quickly and get back out there

I was in a very similar accident recently athlough it was a training ride, not a race.

I was riding my tt in a bike lane (and not paying attention) hit a giant manhole that was 2-3 inch below grade. Didn't even realize I was in it until I was on the ground.

To make the story even more bizarre, my front wheel made it through no problem. Rear wheel hit, then totally collapsed, lodging in the rear stays and just obliterating that rear end of the bike. One of the stays looks like a chainsaw went through it! I have found a total of 6 cracks on the rear of the frame.

I got jacked up pretty bad too although I didn't go the hospital but probably should have.



"Keep those feet moving!" Me
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [mwanner1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It's scary!! Same thing happened to me about 3 weeks ago but mine was a manhole in a bike lane!



"Keep those feet moving!" Me
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Have to say my stomach turns over when anyone says "road rash", when it should do the same for broken bones. Best of luck in the mending.

My "aha" moment about not riding with my head down came at the age of about 10. When I was practicing being a racer on an old fashioned bike with "sit up and beg" handlebars. This bike also had metal brake levers and mechanics (it was older than me then). To get into the racing position I used the brake levers as drops and lowered my head to only see the front wheel. This, in the days before bicycle helmets. I realised my mistake the moment the rear bumper (of a parked car) came in contact with the front wheel at the same time it came into view. A ten year old doesn't go that fast and the car in question was shaped like a Beetle (relatively soft landing). But that was the last time I ever rode with my head down. Broke the bike, fortunately only hurt my pride.

Get well soon.
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [lutzman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Wishing you a speedy recovery. I broke my collar bone a couple months ago and it sucked! I cannot imagine having to deal with everything else you have going on. A big rock from a rock slide got me while descending. I have not gotten back on the bike outside since even though the doctor cleared me too. I want to make sure that thing is well heal so a minor mishap doesn't turn into a relapse. It think it will change my ability to descend with the same confidence especially on the road races.

Stay positive and do the physical therapy.
Quote Reply
Re: Crash at Boise 70.3--My rant/lessons learned [Raindown] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Lutzman,
Wishing you a speedy recovery and great advice about staying in the moment. I crashed a little over a week ago on a descent down a windy mountain road into a drainage ditch going around 40 mph (Garmin said 38.7). I broke 2 vertebrae in my back and one in my neck. I too hit a patch of rough pavement (loose from paving over a pothole section), hand slipped off the brake while braking heavily because it was on the lead up to a 90 degree left turn switchback at about a 20% grade. I was in the moment as not concentrating on a descent like that will make you pay. But from here on out I'll make sure my hands are dry after doing a big climb and heading directly into a a big descent and or wear cycling gloves. I'm also questioning whether I'll ride all carbon rims again...the stopping power in emergency situations leaves a lot to be desired. Good luck and get well soon.

Nick
Quote Reply