Quantcast
    MAIN INDEX RULES & LEGEND LOG IN  

Slowtwitch Forums: Triathlon Forum:
Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!?

 

First page Previous page 1 2 3 Next page Last page  View All  


Ryon

Jun 9, 11 7:48

Post #1 of 75 (8833 views)
Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? Quote | Reply



I mean, he's always had an aggressive position, but it looks like he's moved back a bit and/ or more stretched out in the above photo from the Dauphine Libere this week (above) compared to the below photo from the 2009 TdF. Specifically, look at the distance from the knee to triceps.



How does he breathe like that? Is there some special technique to not crush your diaphragm?
-----------------------
My Science Blog
"The only fair race is the race against the clock" -Anquetil



draketriathlon

Jun 9, 11 7:50

Post #2 of 75 (8815 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Ryon] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

By opening his mouth causing a pressure difference in his lungs to the outside air ;) Really that's not a hard position to breath in.


Frenchman

Jun 9, 11 7:52

Post #3 of 75 (8792 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Ryon] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

Aero cannula.


justatest

Jun 9, 11 7:54

Post #4 of 75 (8770 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Ryon] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

This is not his normal TT position. In the other photos I saw from yesterday's TT, he was normally sitting in a much more forward position. In the first picture I suspect he's descending and trying to be as aero as possible, not necessarily powerful or comfortable.


Carl Spackler

Jun 9, 11 7:55

Post #5 of 75 (8763 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Ryon] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

I was watching the TT yesterday and with those socks hiked up high, all I could think is that he looks like a stork. "Lanky Scottsman" is an understatement, but damn, he tore up that TT. He also looks super lean and I'm really keen to see how he goes in the mountains this weekend.

__________________________________________________


VWN8

Jun 9, 11 7:55

Post #6 of 75 (8759 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Ryon] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

Likely he's expanding his lungs into his abdomen. Belly breathing! On another note, Is your downward sloping torso really faster than a flat/level back? Im sure Wiggins has spent some serious time in a wind tunnel, but his position is quite unique.


rrkid

Jun 9, 11 7:55

Post #7 of 75 (8759 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Ryon] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

Can't remember if it was Cobb or Hed, but somebody recently did a bunch of tunnel stuff w/ top TTers, and one of the most aero athletes they tested was Kristin Armstrong. The message, at least insofar as I got it right, was that her "superman" was more aero than most of the more contemporary 90-degree arm positions:


Your two pix of Wiggins makes me think he's moved in that direction.

Sidenote, I'm usually behind, but what is up w/ that helmet?


draketriathlon

Jun 9, 11 7:57

Post #8 of 75 (8738 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [rrkid] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

rrkid wrote:
Can't remember if it was Cobb or Hed, but somebody recently did a bunch of tunnel stuff w/ top TTers, and one of the most aero athletes they tested was Kristin Armstrong. The message, at least insofar as I got it right, was that her "superman" was more aero than most of the more contemporary 90-degree arm positions:


Your two pix of Wiggins makes me think he's moved in that direction.

Sidenote, I'm usually behind, but what is up w/ that helmet?

I would say more that that is shes female so probably has the smallest body of the group.


Slowman

Jun 9, 11 7:58

Post #9 of 75 (8733 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Ryon] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

i think the "breathing" issue is urban mythology. i think ventilation is rarely an issue in bike positioning. i think "opening up the lungs" is a proxy for other things, like, opening up the hip angle so that a mechanical advantage can be gained over the resistance that needs to be overcome.

elbows in tight, position too stretched out, armrest drop too low, are all problems, or can be problems. i just don't think they're usually problems of ventilation. of course, it's easily tested with a fit bike and a spirometer. still, even if a position caused a drop from, say, 4 liters of air per inhalation to 3.9 liters, you'd still have to demonstrate that uptake was compromised.

i'm not stating this as a fact, rather as an opinion. it's a guess, and my guess may be inaccurate. but i haven't seen anything yet that suggests that ventilation is the determiner of TT positions to the degree people seem to think they are.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman


jackmott

Jun 9, 11 8:00

Post #10 of 75 (8710 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [rrkid] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

yes it is pretty well understood that stretched out is fast.

the 90 degree rule of thumb is for comfort more than speed.


Local running hero Liz Shelton gets her first TT bike and reports on Jack's Generic Triathlon
Aeroweenie.com -Compendium of Aero Data and Knowledge
Freelance sports & outdoors writer Kathryn Hunter


rroof

Jun 9, 11 8:01

Post #11 of 75 (8697 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [draketriathlon] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

draketriathlon wrote:
rrkid wrote:
Can't remember if it was Cobb or Hed, but somebody recently did a bunch of tunnel stuff w/ top TTers, and one of the most aero athletes they tested was Kristin Armstrong. The message, at least insofar as I got it right, was that her "superman" was more aero than most of the more contemporary 90-degree arm positions:


Your two pix of Wiggins makes me think he's moved in that direction.

Sidenote, I'm usually behind, but what is up w/ that helmet?


I would say more that that is shes female so probably has the smallest body of the group.

Not sure about that - can't get pipes any thinner than Wiggins! Plus, women generally have much wider hips, esp to very thin body types like Bradley's.
____________________________________
Fatigue is biochemical, not biomechanical.
- Andrew Coggan, PhD


Rappstar

Jun 9, 11 8:02

Post #12 of 75 (8691 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Ryon] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

Does anyone else find the "PROtotype" decals on what are so obviously HED3s to be incredibly funny? Of all the wheels to pretend are Shimano PRO prototypes, you'd think they'd pick a wheel that isn't universally recognizable...


"Non est ad astra mollis e terris via." - Seneca | rappstar.com | Facebook - Rappstar Racing | @rappstar | WTC Ironman Pro Ambassador

Ask me about: Specialized | Compex 20% OFF - RAPPSTAR20 | Zipp | 1st Endurance | Normatec 10% OFF - RAPP2013 | Quarq | SRAM | ZICO | Smith Optics


Tri or Die

Jun 9, 11 8:13

Post #13 of 75 (8620 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Ryon] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

his crank/big ring is funky as hell? whats with the 'extra' oval shape???


draketriathlon

Jun 9, 11 8:16

Post #14 of 75 (8604 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [rroof] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

rroof wrote:
draketriathlon wrote:
rrkid wrote:
Can't remember if it was Cobb or Hed, but somebody recently did a bunch of tunnel stuff w/ top TTers, and one of the most aero athletes they tested was Kristin Armstrong. The message, at least insofar as I got it right, was that her "superman" was more aero than most of the more contemporary 90-degree arm positions:


Your two pix of Wiggins makes me think he's moved in that direction.

Sidenote, I'm usually behind, but what is up w/ that helmet?


I would say more that that is shes female so probably has the smallest body of the group.


Not sure about that - can't get pipes any thinner than Wiggins! Plus, women generally have much wider hips, esp to very thin body types like Bradley's.

Not disagreeing you may very well be right. I just think there is more than one variable going into the equation then she is faster because her arms aren't at 90 degrees. If that makes sense.


Ryon

Jun 9, 11 9:28

Post #15 of 75 (8437 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Slowman] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

Slowman wrote:
i think the "breathing" issue is urban mythology. i think ventilation is rarely an issue in bike positioning. i think "opening up the lungs" is a proxy for other things, like, opening up the hip angle so that a mechanical advantage can be gained over the resistance that needs to be overcome.

elbows in tight, position too stretched out, armrest drop too low, are all problems, or can be problems. i just don't think they're usually problems of ventilation. of course, it's easily tested with a fit bike and a spirometer. still, even if a position caused a drop from, say, 4 liters of air per inhalation to 3.9 liters, you'd still have to demonstrate that uptake was compromised.

i'm not stating this as a fact, rather as an opinion. it's a guess, and my guess may be inaccurate. but i haven't seen anything yet that suggests that ventilation is the determiner of TT positions to the degree people seem to think they are.

That's a very good point. TT's are almost never at VO2max effort, so compromising more than a few % of maximum breathing might not be an issue.

Regarding the stretched position... I found this on the Team SKY website.

contrast to the 2009 TdF photo

He looks pretty far forward perched on both saddles. Perhaps more so for the TdF? It could also be a longer saddle. Though it does look like he is farther aft in his overall position and more "stretched out"... I wonder if this is an aerodynamic advantage?
-----------------------
My Science Blog
"The only fair race is the race against the clock" -Anquetil



Ryon

Jun 9, 11 9:43

Post #16 of 75 (8376 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Rappstar] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

Rappstar wrote:
Does anyone else find the "PROtotype" decals on what are so obviously HED3s to be incredibly funny? Of all the wheels to pretend are Shimano PRO prototypes, you'd think they'd pick a wheel that isn't universally recognizable...

Haha. Yeah, I was thinking the same thing...
-----------------------
My Science Blog
"The only fair race is the race against the clock" -Anquetil



Landyachtz

Jun 9, 11 9:47

Post #17 of 75 (8355 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Matafan] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

Matafan wrote:
This is not his normal TT position. In the other photos I saw from yesterday's TT, he was normally sitting in a much more forward position. In the first picture I suspect he's descending and trying to be as aero as possible, not necessarily powerful or comfortable.

This is correct. When I initially saw this photo yesterday I thought he had completely changed his position, but when watching the coverage on versus I'm not even sure it's different from what he's been riding all year. I think you're right that this was just during a decent and he's tucking to get more aero.

________________________________________________________________
When you try to be good at too many things at the same time, you usually end up average in all of them. Heck, a triathlete should be well aware of that ;-) -Tom A.


footwerx

Jun 9, 11 9:53

Post #18 of 75 (8317 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Rappstar] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

well at least they didn't bother to PROtotype the lightweight disc.


msuguy512

Jun 9, 11 10:05

Post #19 of 75 (8243 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Slowman] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

Is it possible to have your arms stretched out forward like that and not require additional muscle recruitment? Is strengthening the shoulders to be able to push backwards a requirement so you don't keep sliding forward? If you had really flexible shoulders/back and no arm muscle it might be a little easier to hold them out there, but I think that is a pretty tough position to hold for an hour.


SeasonsChange

Jun 9, 11 10:11

Post #20 of 75 (8200 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Ryon] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

a semi superman actually helps me breathe since my elbows are narrow and is a lot more aero


BSUdude

Jun 9, 11 10:13

Post #21 of 75 (8185 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Ryon] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

I was/am more amazed at how ugly those pinarello TT bikes are and how un-aero they look.


Landyachtz

Jun 9, 11 10:24

Post #22 of 75 (8129 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [BSUdude] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

 

BSUdude wrote:
I was/am more amazed at how ugly those pinarello TT bikes are and how un-aero they look.

Yeah I had to laugh yesterday when Bob roll said that Wiggins was much better at equipment selection than vinokourov. The cable routing on that pinarello is atrocious, while vino is on a Shiv. Not saying in other aspects Bob roll isn't right, but I just found that funny.

Also if I hear Bob roll over-pronounce one more damn name I might shoot myself. I finds his commentary extremely annoying. Everyone and their mother knows how to pronounce zabriskie's last name, but to Bob roll its always zabreeeeski.

________________________________________________________________
When you try to be good at too many things at the same time, you usually end up average in all of them. Heck, a triathlete should be well aware of that ;-) -Tom A.


Old Albion

Jun 9, 11 10:25

Post #23 of 75 (8122 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Carl Spackler] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

Carl Spackler wrote:
I was watching the TT yesterday and with those socks hiked up high, all I could think is that he looks like a stork. "Lanky Scottsman" is an understatement, but damn, he tore up that TT..

Actually, he's English (not a Scot) but you're right he does look super lean. Interesting also that he was so cautious on the decsent when he is known to be a very good descender.


triarcher

Jun 9, 11 11:25

Post #24 of 75 (7982 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [Ryon] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

Is it just me or does it seem to be a bit of an optical illusion because of the different seatpost angles??? Maybe the two positions shown are not that far removed due to the geometry of the Graal vs the DA?? On the DA his elbows are over the stem but the Graal looks like the Head tube has more rake?? The back is obviously flatter on the Graal.


jackmott

Jun 9, 11 11:29

Post #25 of 75 (7956 views)
Re: Bradley Wiggins's position... how does he breathe?!? [triarcher] [In reply to] Quote | Reply

I got a $ says the position are identical just in different states of scooted forwardness on the saddle at different times.


Local running hero Liz Shelton gets her first TT bike and reports on Jack's Generic Triathlon
Aeroweenie.com -Compendium of Aero Data and Knowledge
Freelance sports & outdoors writer Kathryn Hunter

First page Previous page 1 2 3 Next page Last page  View All  
 
 
 



New Product Intros
Is there a specific event you most closely associate with new product coverage and intros?
Sea Otter
Eurobike
Interbike
Hawaiian Ironman
I'm oblivious