klehner wrote:
AlanShearer wrote:
I think the solution to this is to throw the entire team out of the tournament.
I generally feel this way about all tournaments. It should be a condition for entering to commit to fair play and to compete in good faith throughout, regardless of who the opponent might be. If a team or competitor isn't willing to make this commitment, they should be excluded from the tournament.
So absent some internal Iranian policy change, this would apply to Iranian athletes if there's a chance that they might face an Israeli in the tournament.
The same applies to that Christian school a few years ago that forfeit a high school playoff baseball game because the other team had a couple girls on it.
I think it also applies to teams that refuse to play on Sunday or some other religious day, with the exception for situations where the team can be placed in a bracket that has no scheduled Sunday games.
How many countries should be tossed from the soccer World Cup because Israel is in the European zone?
I think you can make a distinction between qualifying rounds and the finals.
So none for 2018, as Israel didn't qualify. I'm not aware of any team in UEFA that refuses to play with Israel, so it's not an issue in qualifiers. There are teams in the AFC and perhaps the CAF that won't play against Israel, but it doesn't become an issue unless and until they qualified for a finals in which Israel also qualifies.
The only time Israel qualified for the finals was 1970. In that tournament, they were placed in a different group than Morocco for the group stages because Morocco had threatened not to participate if they would have had to play against Israel. I don't think different groups are a reasonable solution, as there's still would have been a chance of them playing each other if both had progressed to the knockout stages. To Morocco's credit, they at least threatened to pull out of the tournament rather than compete and then forfeit a game. I think they should have been taken up on their threat with a replacement team instead..