I'm sure it's out there somewhere but what is actually lost with a round bottle on the down tube?
Triathlon Forum
Login required to started new threads
Login required to post replies
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [Fishbum]
[ In reply to ]
2.98756567325734 watts
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [Fishbum]
[ In reply to ]
All credibility.
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [BryanD]
[ In reply to ]
BryanD wrote:
2.98756567325734 wattsAnd here I thought it was something like (19/20) * pi
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [nickwhite]
[ In reply to ]
nickwhite wrote:
All credibility.Perfect response.
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [Fishbum]
[ In reply to ]
it depends
Sometimes, it's less aerodynamic (although, like anything, until you test it on your bike with you on it, how much is throwing darts blindfolded. Maybe nothing)
on the flip side, at least for triathletes (long course specifically) you gain a bit. Being able to have a spot that's easy (and almost certainly the most practiced of most cyclists) to reach and that basically every bottle you'll pick up at an aid station will fit "correctly" (I remember having a torpedo setup when I did long course, and without fail every bottle I picked up at an aid station had the top broken on and just poured water/sport drink on the front end, or I shoved it in my jersey and eliminated the "gain" of using a torpedo)
Are there safer (aerodynamically) places to put a bottle... pretty much, yeah. But sometimes just going with simple and reliable is worth some amount.
ymmv of course. Coming from a now TT'er only that doesn't carry any bottles (or an aero bottle on the frame for "show")
My Blog - http://leegoocrap.blogspot.com
Sometimes, it's less aerodynamic (although, like anything, until you test it on your bike with you on it, how much is throwing darts blindfolded. Maybe nothing)
on the flip side, at least for triathletes (long course specifically) you gain a bit. Being able to have a spot that's easy (and almost certainly the most practiced of most cyclists) to reach and that basically every bottle you'll pick up at an aid station will fit "correctly" (I remember having a torpedo setup when I did long course, and without fail every bottle I picked up at an aid station had the top broken on and just poured water/sport drink on the front end, or I shoved it in my jersey and eliminated the "gain" of using a torpedo)
Are there safer (aerodynamically) places to put a bottle... pretty much, yeah. But sometimes just going with simple and reliable is worth some amount.
ymmv of course. Coming from a now TT'er only that doesn't carry any bottles (or an aero bottle on the frame for "show")
My Blog - http://leegoocrap.blogspot.com
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [Morelock]
[ In reply to ]
What I also heard is (next to incompatibility) aerobottles do not hold firmly in their cages. And for example the elite crono contains only 500 ml. All not very favourable on a long distance.
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [Morelock]
[ In reply to ]
This question is specific to an upcoming 70.3. my current bottle setup is to bottle launchers behind the seat and one of those Elite Chrono Arrow bottles on the down tube that I was considering swapping out for traditional bottle. I sweat like a whore in Church and would like to carry as much Gatorade with me from the start as possible because they will only have water at the bottle exchanges. I apologize for any spelling errors this is being done via talk to text.
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [Fishbum]
[ In reply to ]
If I hadn't tested specifically and knew for a fact it was costing me a considerable amount of time, I think I'd likely run a round cage these day, at least if I was on a "traditional" non-integrated hydration frame that was easy to refill. (Take that with a grain of salt as when I was actually doing long course stuff I did the exact opposite, but I think maybe have gotten slightly wiser with age...maybe...probably not...)
At some point, things can and do go wrong over 56 miles... usually it's not a catastrophe. At Aquabike Nats (the last "long course" race I did) I had a torhans aero30 that I had practiced the sh*t out of refilling before racing (with an aero bottle w/nutrition on the dt) yet at the aid station halfway I dropped the bottle while trying to pour it into the TH. That was bad. I might have dropped it anyways with a round cage, but I think it's certainly less likely I did. I would have lost some time with a slower setup most likely, but not as much time as I lost because I had nothing to drink for an important section.
Again, it all depends. Lots of people rock the most aero setup possible and do just fine and will say you just practice it and it's all good. I would have argued for that exact thing a year or two ago. I just think my perception on just how good I am at making 0 mistakes during a race has changed over the years, but again, ymmv
My Blog - http://leegoocrap.blogspot.com
At some point, things can and do go wrong over 56 miles... usually it's not a catastrophe. At Aquabike Nats (the last "long course" race I did) I had a torhans aero30 that I had practiced the sh*t out of refilling before racing (with an aero bottle w/nutrition on the dt) yet at the aid station halfway I dropped the bottle while trying to pour it into the TH. That was bad. I might have dropped it anyways with a round cage, but I think it's certainly less likely I did. I would have lost some time with a slower setup most likely, but not as much time as I lost because I had nothing to drink for an important section.
Again, it all depends. Lots of people rock the most aero setup possible and do just fine and will say you just practice it and it's all good. I would have argued for that exact thing a year or two ago. I just think my perception on just how good I am at making 0 mistakes during a race has changed over the years, but again, ymmv
My Blog - http://leegoocrap.blogspot.com
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [Morelock]
[ In reply to ]
Morelock wrote:
At some point, things can and do go wrong over 56 miles...
I just think my perception on just how good I am at making 0 mistakes during a race has changed over the years
What you wanna say is ok to me.
I also run a round bottle on my down tube (I used to fool around with these profile design bottles with straws). I do not do flying mounts anymore (did it, but found out I'm too clumsy for that). I do not grab bottles behind the saddle (I tried, but I decided again I'm too clumsy especially in race stress). I'm over 55, what can I say?
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [Fishbum]
[ In reply to ]
Close to nil for me. Racing draft legal...
#swimmingmatters
Laugh hard. Run fast. Be kind.
The Doctor (#12)
#swimmingmatters
Laugh hard. Run fast. Be kind.
The Doctor (#12)
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [BryanD]
[ In reply to ]
Quote:
2.98756567325734 wattsUnless it's faster!!!!!!!
Brian Stover USAT LII
Accelerate3 Coaching
Insta
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [desert dude]
[ In reply to ]
Any particular frames where it's faster?
Unless it's faster!!!!!!!
desert dude wrote:
Quote:
2.98756567325734 wattsUnless it's faster!!!!!!!
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [Fishbum]
[ In reply to ]
Fishbum wrote:
I'm sure it's out there somewhere but what is actually lost with a round bottle on the down tube?~50-55 grams of drag, half that for an aero bottle in the same spot.
Save: $50 on Speed Hound Recovery Boots | $20 on Air Relax| $100 on Normatec| 15% on Most Absorbable Magnesium
Blogs: Best CHEAP Zwift / Bike Trainer Desk | Theragun G3 vs $140 Bivi Percussive Massager | Normatec Pulse 2.0 vs Normatec Pulse | Speed Hound vs Normatec | Air Relax vs Normatec | Q1 2018 Blood Test Results | | Why HED JET+ Is The BEST value wheelset
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [sp1ke]
[ In reply to ]
yes there are and but they are all the smaller/est size frames. there are a few where it's neutral on the medium size frames
Brian Stover USAT LII
Accelerate3 Coaching
Insta
Brian Stover USAT LII
Accelerate3 Coaching
Insta
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [longtrousers]
[ In reply to ]
longtrousers wrote:
I do not grab bottles behind the saddle (I tried, but I decided again I'm too clumsy especially in race stress). I'm over 55, what can I say?I'm 31 and have trouble with this, haha. I can do it, but I have to take care and probably lose any time from aero gains. Most training rides, I just swap the rear bottle with the BTA while at a light. Current plan for my first 70.3 is keeping nutrition bottle back there for use every 30 minutes. But toying with the idea of doing the unthinkable and putting a bottle in the triangle. I've spent too much money on gadgets to not do that, haha.
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [Fishbum]
[ In reply to ]
Fishbum wrote:
I'm sure it's out there somewhere but what is actually lost with a round bottle on the down tube?
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [Fishbum]
[ In reply to ]
Re: Round Bottle on down tube. [WD Pro]
[ In reply to ]
Your best bet is to remove all bottles on down tube.
KG6 wrote:
longtrousers wrote:
I do not grab bottles behind the saddle (I tried, but I decided again I'm too clumsy especially in race stress). I'm over 55, what can I say?I'm 31 and have trouble with this, haha. I can do it, but I have to take care and probably lose any time from aero gains. Most training rides, I just swap the rear bottle with the BTA while at a light. Current plan for my first 70.3 is keeping nutrition bottle back there for use every 30 minutes. But toying with the idea of doing the unthinkable and putting a bottle in the triangle. I've spent too much money on gadgets to not do that, haha.
Me 2. I'm deff running a aero bottle in the triangle. Maybe even a round one.