Only one you need to consider.

Alas, if twas still open.

Lake monroe, cartop recreation area. Its a no wake area that has little traffic

ahh, memories of stupid shit I have done

Ha, that would be great.

Thanks Craig.

You can get to the quarries if you try hard enough. They just aren't accessible by car.

Lake Lemon, which is North of town, is also a good option. It's a little bit smaller and less congested than Lake Monroe.

All the old Hoosiers, and Cutters, too, thank you for posting this.