Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Prev Next
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [Old Hickory] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Old Hickory wrote:
veganerd wrote:
Old Hickory wrote:
j p o wrote:
Old Hickory wrote:
veganerd wrote:
Duffy wrote:
veganerd wrote:
obama tried to get congressional approval to strike syria. so, yeah. he would have. and tried to.


No. He would have done it just like Trump. No congressional approval needed.

Didn't you read the article?


no. i didnt yet.


You don't need any more information to fire off a stupid remark. Do you?

Oh man. You are special.


To be fair, Vegen had precisely as much information as the OP did before he said that Obama was behind the statement.


That's a low bar. I'm sure vegan appreciates that vote of confidence.


do i need to read an article to comment on duffys remark? is duffys remark quoted in the article?

we already know what obama would have done, because he tried. that is all we need to know to refute duffys comment.

You don't need anything or anyone. You are the smartest guy in the room. And you prove it often.


your capitulation is noted.

who's smarter than you're? i'm!
Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [spot] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
spot wrote:
veganerd wrote:
j p o wrote:
Old Hickory wrote:
veganerd wrote:
Duffy wrote:
veganerd wrote:
obama tried to get congressional approval to strike syria. so, yeah. he would have. and tried to.


No. He would have done it just like Trump. No congressional approval needed.

Didn't you read the article?


no. i didnt yet.


You don't need any more information to fire off a stupid remark. Do you?

Oh man. You are special.


To be fair, Vegen had precisely as much information as the OP did before he said that Obama was behind the statement.



also, i dont need to read the article to know what happened when obama was president. he tried to get congressional approval, was shot down, and now people are acting as if he wouldnt have done it. its nonsense.

But Obama never really needed Congressional approval in the first place. The War Powers Act is pretty vague on stuff like this, and retaliatory strikes have been ordered by Presidents without consulting Congress. Case in point: Obama never sought nor got Congressional approval for the Libya operation, which was of far greater scope and extent than what would have likely been the case for a Syria strike. Obama painted himself into a corner with going to Congress in the first place. My guess is that he thought it was a done deal, but was stymied when he couldn't even count on support in the Senate, which was controlled by the Democrats at the time.

maybe so, but for whatever reason, he felt like he needed approval. all im arguing is that its dishonest to say that obama would not have striked syria. he wouldn't have gone to congress if he was against it.

who's smarter than you're? i'm!
Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [spot] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
But Obama never really needed Congressional approval in the first place. The War Powers Act is pretty vague on stuff like this, and retaliatory strikes have been ordered by Presidents without consulting Congress.

If Obama had acted on his own and bypassed Congress again to strike Syria, the outrage would have been for the abuse of Executive power. If he doesn't act at all, he is seen as weak. If he did go to Congress, he knew that the Republicans and some Democrats would defeat him.

It seems to me that he was in a bit of a box.

Case in point: Obama never sought nor got Congressional approval for the Libya operation, which was of far greater scope and extent than what would have likely been the case for a Syria strike.

I think going into Libya was a mistake and not going after Assad was a mistake but in both cases, they were not simple decisions. Trump will be judged down the road and he too will find out that hindsight is always 20/20, particularly when you are on the other side.

Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [veganerd] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote:
its dishonest to say that obama would not have striked syria.

Well, he didn't do it.

All I can go on is that it's being said that he would have done it (like Trump did) but the fact is he didn't.

But, but, he tried!!!!

Civilize the mind, but make savage the body.

- Chinese proverb
Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [Sanuk] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sanuk wrote:
But Obama never really needed Congressional approval in the first place. The War Powers Act is pretty vague on stuff like this, and retaliatory strikes have been ordered by Presidents without consulting Congress.

If Obama had acted on his own and bypassed Congress again to strike Syria, the outrage would have been for the abuse of Executive power. If he doesn't act at all, he is seen as weak. If he did go to Congress, he knew that the Republicans and some Democrats would defeat him.

It seems to me that he was in a bit of a box.

Case in point: Obama never sought nor got Congressional approval for the Libya operation, which was of far greater scope and extent than what would have likely been the case for a Syria strike.

I think going into Libya was a mistake and not going after Assad was a mistake but in both cases, they were not simple decisions. Trump will be judged down the road and he too will find out that hindsight is always 20/20, particularly when you are on the other side.

Nah, the media would've had his back.
Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [Duffy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Duffy wrote:
Quote:
its dishonest to say that obama would not have striked syria.

Well, he didn't do it.

All I can go on is that it's being said that he would have done it (like Trump did) but the fact is he didn't.

But, but, he tried!!!!


i wanted to buy a house.
i put in an offer that was rejected.
someone else bought it.

did i want the house?
did i try?
was the person who bought it the only one willing to?

i asked a girl out on a date.
she said no
she dated someone else

did i want to date her?
did i try?
was i the only one who wanted to?


it would seem incredibly silly to come back later and try to refute or malign the idea that i would have bought the house or dated the girl.

who's smarter than you're? i'm!
Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [Sanuk] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sanuk wrote:
But Obama never really needed Congressional approval in the first place. The War Powers Act is pretty vague on stuff like this, and retaliatory strikes have been ordered by Presidents without consulting Congress.

If Obama had acted on his own and bypassed Congress again to strike Syria, the outrage would have been for the abuse of Executive power. If he doesn't act at all, he is seen as weak. If he did go to Congress, he knew that the Republicans and some Democrats would defeat him.

It seems to me that he was in a bit of a box.

Case in point: Obama never sought nor got Congressional approval for the Libya operation, which was of far greater scope and extent than what would have likely been the case for a Syria strike.

I think going into Libya was a mistake and not going after Assad was a mistake but in both cases, they were not simple decisions. Trump will be judged down the road and he too will find out that hindsight is always 20/20, particularly when you are on the other side.

Obama had already done that with Libya, so I don't understand why that would have hindered him WRT to Syria. And, numerous other Presidents have conducted such strikes without prior consultation or approval. There was plenty of precedent for Obama to act unilaterally. As for the Libya decision, Obama and team did have the 20-20 hindsight of what happened in Iraq after taking down a dictator. How they could then fail to predict what would happen in Libya is baffling.

___________________________________________________
Taco cat spelled backwards is....taco cat.
Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [spot] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Did Obama show an effort to strike Syria?

who's smarter than you're? i'm!
Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [veganerd] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
veganerd wrote:
Did Obama show an effort to strike Syria?

He drew a line...

Civilize the mind, but make savage the body.

- Chinese proverb
Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [Duffy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Duffy wrote:
veganerd wrote:
Did Obama show an effort to strike Syria?

He drew a line...

did he ask congess for premission to strike them?

who's smarter than you're? i'm!
Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [veganerd] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
veganerd wrote:
Duffy wrote:
veganerd wrote:
Did Obama show an effort to strike Syria?

He drew a line...

did he ask congess for premission to strike them?

Did Trump?

Civilize the mind, but make savage the body.

- Chinese proverb
Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [spot] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
As for the Libya decision, Obama and team did have the 20-20 hindsight of what happened in Iraq after taking down a dictator. How they could then fail to predict what would happen in Libya is baffling.

Yes, it is baffling to me too. Obama was always worried about going into the Middle East and repeatedly questioned going into Iraq without planning for what comes next. I don't get it either.

Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [Duffy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Duffy wrote:
veganerd wrote:
Duffy wrote:
veganerd wrote:
Did Obama show an effort to strike Syria?

He drew a line...

did he ask congess for premission to strike them?

Did Trump?

if you didnt think im right, you would probably just answer the question instead of dancing around it.

who's smarter than you're? i'm!
Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [veganerd] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
veganerd wrote:
Duffy wrote:
veganerd wrote:
Duffy wrote:
veganerd wrote:
Did Obama show an effort to strike Syria?

He drew a line...

did he ask congess for premission to strike them?

Did Trump?

if you didnt think im right, you would probably just answer the question instead of dancing around it.

The guy in the article says obama would have done the same thing as trump. Well, obama was president for 8 years and did not do what trump did.

Those are the facts. They are not in dispute.

Civilize the mind, but make savage the body.

- Chinese proverb
Quote Reply
Re: Me too! Me too! I would have done it too!!!!!! (Obama related)... [Sanuk] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sanuk wrote:
But Obama never really needed Congressional approval in the first place. The War Powers Act is pretty vague on stuff like this, and retaliatory strikes have been ordered by Presidents without consulting Congress.

If Obama had acted on his own and bypassed Congress again to strike Syria, the outrage would have been for the abuse of Executive power. If he doesn't act at all, he is seen as weak. If he did go to Congress, he knew that the Republicans and some Democrats would defeat him.

It seems to me that he was in a bit of a box.

Case in point: Obama never sought nor got Congressional approval for the Libya operation, which was of far greater scope and extent than what would have likely been the case for a Syria strike.

I think going into Libya was a mistake and not going after Assad was a mistake but in both cases, they were not simple decisions. Trump will be judged down the road and he too will find out that hindsight is always 20/20, particularly when you are on the other side.
-
My take is that Obama used congress the same way that congress uses the power they have happily ceded to the POTUS. Basically he did not want to hit Syria, and put it to congress hoping they would not give approval...instant cover; "I wanted to but couldn't". Congress is good with the POTUS doing things like Trump did (and Obama in Libya) simply because they do not have to take what may become a politically costly position. BTW, Obama was never going to attack Assad, again because he needed to keep Putin happy so he could get his Iran deal.
Quote Reply

Prev Next