Dilbert wrote:
Yep SR22 is fantastic. Another aircraft I'd love to own is a Diamond DA40. It has by far the best safety record in general aviation. You can stall it, engine idle and nose up, and it will drop slower than an SR22 with
CAPS deployed. Yeah. You can stall and crash the DA40, and walk away from it. Lower cruise speed though about 150 knots vs about 180 knots for the SR22.
Sounds like you have been talking to the Diamond sales guy... ;-P I'll give you two thoughts to mull over from a guy that has landed out in gliders at least 25-30 times in competitions. 'Landed out' means, '...didn't make it to an airport.' Anyway, it's not so much the potential energy that is the problem in a forced landing, it's the
kinetic energy. Although the DA40 may be descending more slowly than an SR22, it is also moving horizontally at about 55-60 kts. to someplace that isn't intended for landing an airplane with a 40' wingspan. Also, an SR20 or SR22 has the same option to glide into a field with essentially the same risk plus the added option of a parachute. And, do you know how poorly the typical power pilot is at doing a spot landing with minimum energy into a field with a dead engine for the first time? I'll tell you, they suck. With all due respect, I'll take the parachute option EVERY time,
unless I have an airport within gliding range. And I have landed in more fields than anybody I know.
Second consideration. You can put this into the anecdotal n=3 category if you'd like. I have known two DA40 owners. One sold it to buy a TTX and the other sold it to join our partnership. Neither of them had much positive to say about the DA40. Last, the US Air Force bought some as primary trainers and later replaced all of them with SR20s. Diamond had a rocky time financially about 10-15 years ago and a lack of faith in the company probably didn't help their sales much either. They spent a lot of time and energy trying to push a diesel engined version that just wasn't well received by the US market.
All in all, I wouldn't say it's a BAD airplane. I just think there are better choices.
Greg
If you are a Canuck that engages in gratuitous bashing of the US, you are probably on my Iggy List. So, save your self a bunch of typing a response unless you also feel the need to gratuitously bash me. If so, have fun.
"Don't underestimate Joe's ability to f___ things up" - Barack Obama, 2020