slowguy wrote:
veganerd wrote:
MJuric wrote:
Exactly. Mental health workers do it all the time. Cops in other countries do it all the time. Some cops do it here. But somehow we can't expect all cops here do do this? I think that's bullshit. They deal with a lot of mentally ill people so they should be properly trained. Yet we have people here dismissing the idea that cops should be trained in this.
How do the police know whether the person is an aggressive criminal or mentally ill?
I tend to think that in many cases the approach for the mentally ill works on both but it won't in cases where the perp is a violent criminal and is simply looking to get away. In that case the cop ends up dead or injured.
I definitely think we need a rethinking of police training, tactics and especially laws, but also tend to think there is no panacea and that no matter what we do we will have cases of people getting shot that maybe shouldn't have.
~Matt
Of course we can't fix all the peoblems. But we can certainly do better. A lot better.
How many mentally ill people are engaged incorrectly by the police, resulting in their injury or death? Much like the conversation on black deaths by cop, it's probably important to establish if this is really a significant problem, or if it's just an issue of having seen a handful of videos that may not be representative of what usually happens.
Incorrectly? Hard to say. Not only are people here adamant that the cops don't make mistakes, the cops are even more so. Which makes it real hard to track.
At least 125 people with signs of mental illness have died in police encounters in the U.S. so far this year, according to the
latest accounting from The Washington Post. "Unless the families identified the deceased as somebody who was mentally ill or the police department identified them as mentally ill, we did not — even if it may on the surface of things [have] appeared as if they might be," she tells NPR's Eric Westervelt. "So it's a conservative number — but even with it being conservative, it was a quarter of the killings."
http://www.npr.org/...ice-are-mentally-ill
I'm beginning to think that we are much more fucked than I thought.