Its actually going very well to the dismay of many on the left. Put aside the politics and listen to what the military leadership says in their entirety not 30 second clips saying there is only one Iraqi battalion combat ready. As you said the BEST reports are from the muddy boots guys and as been reported here by soldiers like Steve Hawley things are going extreemly well. Also Generals Abizaid and Casey feel things are going well too. Specific point to be made by General Casey is this is going to take a long time. For those who think you support the troops but not the war need to understand this. Commanders on the ground are concerned about the lack of committment from the American people. Why is it if those on the ground doing the work feel its worth the fight can't the American people support their efforts?
Commander Still Eyes Iraq Troop Reduction
In this photo provided by ABC News, Gen. George W. Casey, the commanding general of U.S forces in Iraq, appears during an interview on This Week with George Stephanopoulos, Sunday, Oct. LINDA SPILLERS October 02, 2005 1:11 PM EDT
WASHINGTON - Senior military commanders said Sunday that Iraqi security forces are improving significantly as U.S. officials stood by earlier assessments that some U.S. forces could return home early next year.
The generals played down the fact that the number of top-level battalions of Iraqi soldiers - those ready to go to war without U.S. assistance - has fallen from three to one since June.
More important to the mission of training Iraqis is the growing number of Iraqi security forces at all levels, including those able to lead operations with U.S. backing, said Gen. George W. Casey, the commander of multinational forces in Iraq.
"The development of the Iraqi security forces is very much on track," Casey told ABC's "This Week.
He said the goal is to develop Iraqi forces that can operate without U.S. assistance. "You don't build an army to that level overnight ... it's going to be some time for them to get there," Casey said.
Both Casey and Gen. John P. Abizaid, who heads the U.S. Central Command and has overall responsibility for military aspects of the global fight against terrorism, have said U.S. troop levels could decrease in the spring if political and security conditions in Iraq were favorable.
That assessment appeared in question last week when Abizaid and Casey told a Senate committee about the reduction in top-level Iraqi battalions. Some lawmakers expressed concern about the pace and overall success of the training mission.
On Sunday, Abizaid said more Iraqis are in the field at various levels of training and are participating in security operations than before. Field commanders, both U.S. and Iraqi, are confident and remain optimistic that progress is being made, he said.
Iraqi forces already are leading the fight in some areas of the country, Abizaid said, citing parts of downtown Baghdad and southern Iraq as examples. He did not say how long it might take to train enough fully combat-ready Iraqis to replace U.S. troops.
Abizaid also said he was optimistic that the political goals for Iraq would be met. Voting is scheduled for Oct. 15 on a draft constitution, with elections for a new government set for December.
"As long as politics continues to move in the direction that it appears to be moving, and the Iraqi security forces continue to move in the direction that they're moving, the insurgency doesn't have a chance for victory," Abizaid said on NBC's "Meet the Press."
If a legitimate government emerges from elections and represents all of Iraq's political factions, Abizaid said, "there's no reason to suppose that we can't bring force levels down in the spring."
Casey would not set a specific date for a drawdown of U.S. troops, now numbering nearly 150,000. He said a reduction was part of the overall strategy and would be based on conditions in Iraq.
"It will happen progressively around the country as Iraqi security forces step forward," Casey told CNN's "Late Edition."
Abizaid discounted the potential fallout from a rejection of the constitution. He said it was important to see whether minority Sunni Arabs, who oppose the draft constitution, participate in the political process.
"Whether or not the constitution fails in the referendum should not necessarily concern us," he said on CBS' "Face the Nation."
"As long as politics is legitimate in Iraq, with all groups participating, whether it's in the constitutional referendum or the elections for a new government, we'll be just fine," he said.
Casey said commanders are concerned the war could lose the support of the American public. Recent polls indicate that only one-third of Americans approve of President Bush's handling of the war.
"I think it's important for the American people to understand that we should not be afraid of this fight. This is a tough fight," Casey said. "This is worth it, and we have a plan and a strategy in place that will allow us and our Iraqi colleagues to prevail."
Asked if he worries that the U.S. troops who have died in Iraq - a number approaching 2,000 - may have given their lives in vain, Casey said: "No, I don't worry about that. Not yet - we're not there yet."
After the talk shows, Sen. Jack Reed, a member of the Senate Armed Services Committee, said the idea that training Iraqi forces may take years rather than months is not the message the Bush administration wants to get out because it presumes huge costs and a long U.S. involvement.
"The administration is desperate to try to reverse the popular impression that the situation is deteriorating rapidly," Reed, D-R.I., told reporters in a conference call that his office organized.