After having it confirmed that no way was a 52 the right size, I called the bike shop back and spoke with the owner. He agreed that something was not right and had me work with one of his more experienced bike fitters. This guy was great. We worked together and came up with a pretty aggresive position that I'm happy with.

We looked at either a 55 or 58, and but wound up going with a 55. Thanks everyone for your input and help

One happy Cervelo owner!