Post the whole email conversation if you're going to call them out, no paraphrasing. Don't we have some Dimond guys on the forum? Maybe they'll chime in. What happens if you break the seatpost/beam and aren't the original owner, do you scrap the bike? Some stuff might help folks in the future looking for a secondhand bike.
My Blog - http://leegoocrap.blogspot.com
Podium Sports Racing - http://www.podiumsportsmed.com/team/