Bike Shops
Coaches
Fitters
Race Calendar
Running Stores
Store
Stack & Reach
Training Log
Triathlon Clubs
We Noticed
MAIN INDEX
RULES & LEGEND
LOG IN
Slowtwitch Forums
:
Triathlon Forum
:
Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners?
1
2
View All
Tri
Classifieds
Lavender
Jobs
Womens
Notices
Print Thread
ndrfnnut
Apr 8, 12 5:24
Post #1 of 38
(2588 views)
Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners?
Quote
|
Reply
__________________________________________________
I wake up in the morning and piss excellence. --Ricky Bobby
Dreadnought
Apr 8, 12 8:12
Post #2 of 38
(2535 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [ndrfnnut]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
ndrfnnut wrote:
Our YMCA had a Woodway, but it broke down, and they were not very enthusiastic about fixing or replacing it.
Having said that, i don't know if there are other treadmills that can match their cushioning.
Rappstar
Apr 8, 12 9:02
Post #3 of 38
(2496 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [ndrfnnut]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
IME and in talking to others, there is Woodway, then there is everything else way, way, way down the list. Go into any high performance facility. The treadmills are Woodways. I'd never heard of them, but then after Simon W. got one in preparation for Beijing, I started seeing them all over the place, usually in places that you could tell put a lot of thought into their equipment, such as the Athlete's Performance facility in Tempe.
"Non est ad astra mollis e terris via." - Seneca |
rappstar.com
|
Facebook - Rappstar Racing
Ask me about:
Specialized
|
Zoot
|
Compex
20% OFF - RAPPSTAR20 |
SpiderTech
10% OFF - SPIDERJORDAN |
Zipp
|
1st Endurance
|
Normatec
15% OFF - RAPP12 |
Quarq
|
SRAM
|
ZICO
|
Smith Optics
|
Mauna Lani Bay
|
Cobb Cycling
Dreadnought
Apr 8, 12 10:10
Post #4 of 38
(2452 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [Rappstar]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
Rappstar wrote:
IME and in talking to others, there is Woodway, then there is everything else way, way, way down the list. Go into any high performance facility. The treadmills are Woodways. I'd never heard of them, but then after Simon W. got one in preparation for Beijing, I started seeing them all over the place,
usually in places that you could tell put a lot of thought into their equipment
, such as the Athlete's Performance facility in Tempe.
How can we encourage our local gyms to stock them?
knobjob
Apr 8, 12 10:14
Post #5 of 38
(2443 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [ndrfnnut]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
Woodway is a different animal and in a separate class. For a really good home use treadmill though, I'd look at the Landice L8. It's pretty bomb-proof in its own right. American made with a great warranty and excellent platform. Not dirt cheap but relatively affordable compared to the cheapest Woodway.
btmoney
Apr 8, 12 10:31
Post #6 of 38
(2430 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [Dreadnought]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
Unlikely that your local Bobs Gym will carry them. The price of a used one is the same as buying other "inferior" brands new. Not saying they aren't worth it though.
____________________________
Khai
Apr 8, 12 11:40
Post #7 of 38
(2386 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [Dreadnought]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
Dreadnought wrote:
How can we encourage our local gyms to stock them?
I had a new (still being built) gym that was trying to drum up new business through my company calling me several times. I asked what kind of treadmills they'd have and the gal told me "
several brands, but only the best
". I asked "
Will you bring in Woodway? If you can guarantee Woodway I'll sign right now
". Her response was "
Oh, I'm sure you'll be happy with them - we only buy the best
" I told her "
Go talk to your buyers and call me back with written confirmation that you'll have Woodway treadmills. If you can do that I'll sign
".
She never did call me back, but that was sort of a win anyhow... :p
<If you're gonna be dumb, you gotta be tough>
Get Fitter!
Proud member of the Smartasscrew, MONSTER CLUB
Get your FIX today?
Woodway
Apr 8, 12 12:53
Post #8 of 38
(2338 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [Dreadnought]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
You can always call or email woodway and we can tell you what local club or training facility has a woodway for you to train on based on where you live.
Eric W - Woodway USA
lightheir
Apr 8, 12 14:18
Post #9 of 38
(2284 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [ndrfnnut]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
I'm sure Woodway's great and all, but seriously, what's wrong with a midrange TM like a Sole F80? Sure, it might not have the ultraprecision of a Woodway in pace, and damping of impact's not quite as good (but still vastly better than road), but for private, single use which doesn't need to stand up to multiuser commercial situations, I can't think of any problems that would limit training in any way with a $1500 TM like a Sole, or similar.
-Mike-
Apr 8, 12 17:49
Post #10 of 38
(2211 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [ndrfnnut]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
I do quite a bit of treadmill running at Lifetime Fitness and they have woodway and life fitness, i wish i knew what life fitness model they carry (all of their gyms tend to be the same model) as it is quite good...over 12mph, good wide and long track, great controlls, and feels great.
knobjob
Apr 8, 12 19:46
Post #11 of 38
(2154 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [lightheir]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
Quality of materials. I can get in the same workout on a sole or a Landice. But the Landice feels way more solid during the experience. A mazda and a BMW will both get me from point a to b. but I'll take the latter every time and pay the premium because for me it's about the result and the experience.
lightheir
Apr 8, 12 19:49
Post #12 of 38
(2151 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [knobjob]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
knobjob wrote:
Quality of materials. I can get in the same workout on a sole or a Landice. But the Landice feels way more solid during the experience. A mazda and a BMW will both get me from point a to b. but I'll take the latter every time and pay the premium because for me it's about the result and the experience.
True, but a BMW only costs about 2-3x more than a Mazda, if even that.
A Woodway, however, costs 8x more than a $1500 Sole F80, and over double a Landice premium TM.
For commercial users, and possibly pros who really use the heck out of it, I could understand, but for a single amateur AGer? That's big wallet stuff right there, even for someone earning 6-figs.
AwesomePossum
Apr 8, 12 20:09
Post #13 of 38
(2123 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [lightheir]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
lightheir wrote:
knobjob wrote:
Quality of materials. I can get in the same workout on a sole or a Landice. But the Landice feels way more solid during the experience. A mazda and a BMW will both get me from point a to b. but I'll take the latter every time and pay the premium because for me it's about the result and the experience.
True, but a BMW only costs about 2-3x more than a Mazda, if even that.
A Woodway, however, costs 8x more than a $1500 Sole F80, and over double a Landice premium TM.
For commercial users, and possibly pros who really use the heck out of it, I could understand, but for a single amateur AGer? That's big wallet stuff right there, even for someone earning 6-figs.
You can get a used Woodway off of Craigslist for $3000. If I was in the market for a treadmill, I'd consider that option instead of spending $1500 on a treadmill I wouldn't enjoy using, thereby making it the more expensive option per run since I'd probably use it much less.
knobjob
Apr 8, 12 20:48
Post #14 of 38
(2100 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [lightheir]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
You missed my main point about the experience. It's not about arithmetic. It's about owning something that I'd want to use.
lightheir
Apr 8, 12 20:51
Post #15 of 38
(2099 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [knobjob]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
knobjob wrote:
You missed my main point about the experience. It's not about arithmetic. It's about owning something that I'd want to use.
Ummm, if you NEED a Woodway just to get going on a TM, I don't think a TM is something you should even own. It's not like running on a $1500 is particularly painful or difficult - the TM experience in itself can be , well, boring, at times, but that's totally separate from the TM itself.
avagoyamug
Apr 9, 12 6:01
Post #16 of 38
(2022 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [ndrfnnut]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
I don't know why everyone raves about the 'shock dampening' as a sales point. It just trains the body to not to worry about doing the shock absorbing for itself which will increase the chance of injury and decrease performance when running on the road, which is where the running that counts occurs.
I'm interested in a treadmill that is as close as possible to running on cement.
Anyone know which one that is?
RPMacDonald
Apr 9, 12 6:10
Post #17 of 38
(2015 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [ndrfnnut]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
I ran a university fitness center that carried both Woodway and Life Fitness models. And I've put hundreds of hours on both. To be honest, the difference between the 2 is very negligible... You're turning down going to a facility because they don't have woodway? Come on man! Unless you're an elite runner (like Simon), the difference between the 2 isn't going to impact your run. Sometimes I actually wasn't a fan of the woodway's belt because of the slats, however that was simply annoying a times.
_____________________
MSc, CSCS
Team Running Free
"We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit."
wannabefaster
Apr 9, 12 6:28
Post #18 of 38
(1992 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [ndrfnnut]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
I have over 1000 miles on my Landice L7 that is just over two years old. I love the thing. It is comfortable, relatively quiet and reliable and does everything I need a treadmill to do. Price was very reasonable as well. Its calibration is slighly off. 9 mph on my Landice is really more like 9.2-3 mph but I guess that just means when I am running at that pace I am getting a better workout.
I am 5' 7" tall so I did not need the slightly longer/wider belt of the L8 + the warranty is actually better (I think) for the L7 because it is sold for home, not health club, use.
----------------------------
None of the secrets of success will work unless you do.
Powered by Dark Horse Multisport Coaching
http://darkhorsemultisport.blogspot.com/
(This post was
edited
by wannabefaster on Apr 12, 12 22:07)
knobjob
Apr 9, 12 8:59
Post #19 of 38
(1938 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [lightheir]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
Ummm, when did I ever say I needed a Woodway?
And the boring and mundane nature of treadmill running is not automatically separate from the quality of the product. Treadmill running sucks to begin with. Anything that further detracts from the experience isn't going to help.
Some of you guys must be running slow as hell on these treadmills. A $1500 machine ain't particularly stable or fun at 12 mph.
As to whether or not I should own a treadmill, it's to accommodate my running when the weather or time of night makes it impractical. Investing in a decent machine is just to help moderate the hell of running on one of those satanic devices. For the record, I have a Landice L8, not a Woodway. Its built like a brick house.
lightheir
Apr 9, 12 9:36
Post #20 of 38
(1915 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [knobjob]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
knobjob wrote:
Ummm, when did I ever say I needed a Woodway?
And the boring and mundane nature of treadmill running is not automatically separate from the quality of the product. Treadmill running sucks to begin with. Anything that further detracts from the experience isn't going to help.
Some of you guys must be running slow as hell on these treadmills. A $1500 machine ain't particularly stable or fun at 12 mph.
As to whether or not I should own a treadmill, it's to accommodate my running when the weather or time of night makes it impractical. Investing in a decent machine is just to help moderate the hell of running on one of those satanic devices. For the record, I have a Landice L8, not a Woodway. Its built like a brick house.
I own a Sole F80 ($1400 when I bought it), and it's rock solid. It weighs friggin' 300 pounds, so it's not going anywhere.
And FYI - I do intervals on it at 5:30/mi pace on a weekly basis (it goes down to 5min/mile) no problem. No weird shaking or extra sounds, although I'll admit that the footsteps get pretty loud when I'm running that hard on it, but that occurs on pretty much every TM.
I don't think its accurate at all to claim that you can't run fast on $1500 TMs - you can run no problemo at 5-6 min/mile on these things. In fact, my SoleF80 is better to do fast work for me than the pricey Landice(older models, probably) TMs at the local gym, as there's less weirdo noises from loose bolts and parts that probably got slightly overlooked with the constant use, despite the fact that the Landice is a bigger TM than the Sole.
I've got zero complaints with my Sole. (I've owned two other TMs in the past which I sold due to big moves x-country, Vision Fitness, and a Pacemaster, between $2000 and $1500, and honestly, there's like no difference for me between them all.)
Khai
Apr 9, 12 12:17
Post #21 of 38
(1851 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [avagoyamug]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
avagoyamug wrote:
I don't know why everyone raves about the 'shock dampening' as a sales point. It just trains the body to not to worry about doing the shock absorbing for itself which will increase the chance of injury and decrease performance when running on the road, which is where the running that counts occurs.
I'm interested in a treadmill that is as close as possible to running on cement.
Anyone know which one that is?
You must be in an AG that starts with a 1 or really hate your body...
<If you're gonna be dumb, you gotta be tough>
Get Fitter!
Proud member of the Smartasscrew, MONSTER CLUB
Get your FIX today?
majrim
Apr 12, 12 6:34
Post #22 of 38
(1747 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [avagoyamug]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
I have good experience with the Katana (
www.lode.nl
) looks a bit like the Woodway with those slats. The feeling is totally different on this one it's like running on an athletics track, feels great. Their other running belts are good as well, more traditional but extreme good in quality. That Katana is expensive but so strong and no problems with service! I do believe you can get them in the States because I have seen them at the ACSM in Denver last year.
mcmetal
Apr 12, 12 12:25
Post #23 of 38
(1695 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [lightheir]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
lightheir wrote:
knobjob wrote:
Ummm, when did I ever say I needed a Woodway?
And the boring and mundane nature of treadmill running is not automatically separate from the quality of the product. Treadmill running sucks to begin with. Anything that further detracts from the experience isn't going to help.
Some of you guys must be running slow as hell on these treadmills. A $1500 machine ain't particularly stable or fun at 12 mph.
As to whether or not I should own a treadmill, it's to accommodate my running when the weather or time of night makes it impractical. Investing in a decent machine is just to help moderate the hell of running on one of those satanic devices. For the record, I have a Landice L8, not a Woodway. Its built like a brick house.
I own a Sole F80 ($1400 when I bought it), and it's rock solid. It weighs friggin' 300 pounds, so it's not going anywhere.
And FYI - I do intervals on it at 5:30/mi pace on a weekly basis (it goes down to 5min/mile) no problem. No weird shaking or extra sounds, although I'll admit that the footsteps get pretty loud when I'm running that hard on it, but that occurs on pretty much every TM.
I don't think its accurate at all to claim that you can't run fast on $1500 TMs - you can run no problemo at 5-6 min/mile on these things. In fact, my SoleF80 is better to do fast work for me than the pricey Landice(older models, probably) TMs at the local gym, as there's less weirdo noises from loose bolts and parts that probably got slightly overlooked with the constant use, despite the fact that the Landice is a bigger TM than the Sole.
I've got zero complaints with my Sole. (I've owned two other TMs in the past which I sold due to big moves x-country, Vision Fitness, and a Pacemaster, between $2000 and $1500, and honestly, there's like no difference for me between them all.)
I agree about the Sole F80. I have run on many expensive treadmills and for $1500 the Sole is pretty darn close and I have done plenty of 12mph runs on it no problem.
AJHull
Apr 12, 12 14:19
Post #24 of 38
(1646 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [Khai]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
It's posts like this that confirm for me how elitist and needy triathletes are. ;)
_____
Adrian in Vancouver
_____
Dreadnought
Apr 12, 12 16:17
Post #25 of 38
(1600 views)
Re: Besides Woodway, who makes a good treadmill for runners? [avagoyamug]
[
In reply to
]
Quote
|
Reply
avagoyamug wrote:
It just trains the body to not to worry about doing the shock absorbing for itself which will increase the chance of injury and decrease performance when running on the road, which is where the running that counts occurs.
I'm interested in a treadmill that is as close as possible to running on cement.
Are you also a proponent of minimalist running shoes?
1
2
View All
Print Thread
this forum
this category
all forums
All words
Any words
Whole Phrase
Market Influence
What influences your swim/bike/run product buying decisions most? The use of products by, or comments made by or in:
Pro cyclists?
Pro triathletes?
My non-Slowtwitcher friends?
Forum members and other Slowtwitchers?
Slowtwitch tech articles and forum moderators?
Other magazines?
Manufacturers?
My LBS?
Ratings/comments on other websites?
Other